Who-dunnit mystery & Romance 💕

Title: The Matchmaker

By: Aisha Saeed

Overall I really liked the concept of this book, I’m just a bit let down by the execution. Let me explain…

When I started this book, I was excited to dive into it and get a good who-dunnit mystery led romance done in a good-ole South Asian fashion. I did love the constant homage to our beautiful desi culture & all the hidden struggles that come with it. The reason I gave it a lower rating is because the pace of the plot was just toooo slowwww! I love how they set up some of the plot twists, however, ALL the twists came in the very end couple chapters. It just took way too much time to get me hooked and barely at that. The only reasons I finished the book is because I really like to support South Asian Authors & I hate to DNF a book.

Maybe if you’re a faster reader than I am- you will like this book but for all those reasons I have to give it 3/5 stars. To be fair I bumped it .5 more stars because the final plot reveal was worth the sleuthing I was doing, however I don’t feel like the author tied up all the strings at the end.

2025/7/11 Edited to

... Read moreSet in a vibrant South Asian backdrop, 'The Matchmaker' offers readers a unique blend of romance and mystery, reflecting the complexities of cultural identity. The author's portrayal of desi culture provides a rich context to the story, celebrating its beauty alongside the challenges faced by characters. This novel, while engaging, has been critiqued for its pacing—a common issue in mystery genres where intricate plotting takes precedence. Readers often expect a steady build-up leading to a climactic finish, and in this case, the slow reveal of plot twists can dampen the excitement initially stirred by the book's premise. Understanding that not all readers absorb narratives at the same pace can be crucial; therefore, it's important to approach this book with an open mind, acknowledging that what may not resonate with one reader could perfectly suit another. The capacity for plot twists to surprise and delight at the story’s climax is commendable, yet an evenly paced narrative could significantly enhance the reader’s experience. Additionally, the representation of South Asian authors in the literary marketplace is vital, as it enriches the diversity of voices and perspectives available to readers. Recommendations for readers include considering a balance between cultural storytelling and the anticipation of mystery, ensuring both elements coexist harmoniously for maximum engagement.

Related posts

underrated spicy dark romance books
have you read any of these? these dark romances deserve so much more love! if you’re looking for something new, give these a try. definitely check the content warnings before reading these. #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #booktok #darkromance #bookrecommendations
romance books

romance books

3020 likes

spicy age gap romance books
how many of these have you read? if you loved the first set, here are more spicy age gap romances to add to your tbr! make sure you check out part one if you haven’t already. #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #booktok #darkromance #bookrecommendations
romance books

romance books

1973 likes

Who Dunnit? Murder Mystery Book Recommendations
Who Dunnit? Let’s Read and Find Out in these Murder Mysteries I love a good whodunnit and trying to solve the case as I read. Remember: Nothing Is As It Seems & Everybody Is A Suspect!!!! 📚Agatha Christie And Then There Were None A Haunting In Venice Death On The Nile 📚Grady Hendri
DOMSSPACEINTIME

DOMSSPACEINTIME

2 likes

steamy romance to read next!
i am a simple girl. i like cutsie rom-coms. and i like books with cutsie covers that LOOK like romcoms but will leave you blushing. SUE ME obvii i'm part of the spicy book renaissance and i am just as addicted to them as everyone else so here are some steamy reads to freshen up your tbr! per
readinromance

readinromance

1876 likes

Heartbreaking Paranormal Mystery and BL Romance
📖 Name of the Book: Sanctify Volume 3 📄 Plot: Gil and Lance find the final remaining survivor of the original Corrupted gang from the orphanage crime. Gil reveals his secrets and Lance is faced with not only the knowledge of his past life but also the lies that threaten to tear apart Lance and
Cozywulfe | BL Reading Diary

Cozywulfe | BL Reading Diary

45 likes

Haunting Crime Mystery with Dark BL Romance
📖 Name of the Book: Sanctify Volume 1 📄 Plot: Lance Hunter is an exorcist who'd rather live his life as a dog-walker. But the world doesn't work that way because the world can't live without evil so there must always be someone good. Lance gets brought on a police investigation for a
Cozywulfe | BL Reading Diary

Cozywulfe | BL Reading Diary

73 likes

Closed-Door Romance Recs!
Some closed door adult romance for the girlies who don’t like “spicy” books 🥰 ✨Books by Sarah Adams ✨The Bodyguard by Katherine Center Tropes: She’s the Bodyguard, Fake Dating ✨My Phony Valentine by Courtney Walsh Tropes: Fake Dating, Hockey Romance ✨My Lucky Charm by Courtney Walsh
Hannah 🧡

Hannah 🧡

252 likes

YA beach read! Small town, mystery, and romance 🌴
Meet Piper Davenport! She's the new girl in Coral Sands who lives in the cottage that no one dares purchase... Now she's wrapped up in a 50 year old mystery, and someone is out to stop her from finding out the truth. At least, she has the cute boy next door to keep her sane... right? Th
YA Beach Reads

YA Beach Reads

8 likes

Dark Paranormal Romance Full of Chills
Back again with some spooky dark romance with enough spice to burn your tongue. Though the spice levels vary in these books so there’s something for everyone❤️‍🔥👻🥀 #darkromance #paranormalromance #booktok #lemon8bookclub #bookwormsoflemon8
JustaBookBaddie

JustaBookBaddie

1186 likes

Who-dunnit Book Recs
New finds onto my TBR #kindlegirlie #lemon8challenge #lemon8bookclub #bookrecommendations #summer
Khannu💛

Khannu💛

32 likes

Who Dunnit??
Talk about your red herrings, both books will keep you guessing; even if you think you know who did what the how will amaze you. The FMC is definitely not someone you wanna cross because she’s a master at serving up revenge. You almost feel bad for those caught up in her plans but then you rememb
BustyBabe023

BustyBabe023

1 like

Kowloon Generic Romance 💖
Title: Kowloong Generic Romance (vol. 2) Creator: Jun Mayuzuki 📄 Plot: Reiko has discovered the secret photo in Hajime's desk of an engagement she can't remember and doesn't know how to feel about it, or how to approach the subject with him. She seeks comfort in a friend, gets Haj
Mel3ficent

Mel3ficent

7 likes

Romance Anime Getting Another Season
Romance anime fans, we WON 😭💗 These romance stories are officially getting another season, and I couldn’t be happier! The Apothecary Diaries – Wit, mystery, and subtle romance at its finest. Maomao’s sharp mind and her intriguing dynamic with Jinshi make this one of the most satisfying slow bur
jaylinny2

jaylinny2

99 likes

Romance and mystery. TMDR has it all.
Track Marks and Diamond Rings A romance with an occult twist. #newreads #newbooks #mystery #mysterybooks #ebook
daniel_j_gordon_books

daniel_j_gordon_books

0 likes

Fabulous mix of cozy mystery, romance and fantasy!
I am officially in my historical romance era so I jumped at the chance to read The Gentleman and His Vowsmith by Rebecca Ide! A locked-room mystery with magic and romance in a historical setting that is full of humor, angst and pining? Immediately yes!! ✨ Magic 🔍 Sleuthing 💀 Mystery 💖 Romanc
Tara Kat

Tara Kat

11 likes

Romance and mystery
Stepping into a world of mystery, romance, and adventure in the King Louis room! ✨♥️ This isn’t just a getaway—it’s a love story wrapped in an escape room challenge. Who knew date night could be this thrilling? #RomanticEscape #DateNightGoals #RomanticGetaway #EscapeRoomDate #CouplesAd
Brittany Vacca

Brittany Vacca

2 likes

Dark YA Romance Rec
“The Night I Spent with Aubrey Fisher” is a dark, upper-YA coming-of-age romance with mystery elements. It’s about two people who need to get lost in order to find each other. It has tropes of: ✨ healing journey ✨ redemption ✨ broken in some way ✨ dude in distress ✨ emotional scars ✨ dark s
Christopher M. Tantillo

Christopher M. Tantillo

2 likes

Classic Mystery Box✨
Classic Mystery Box in the mood of Dark Romance — for Jessica 💌 #MysteryBox #UnboxingTime #SmallBusinessLove #GiftIdeas #DarkRomance
🎀MimiLand🎀

🎀MimiLand🎀

382 likes

Classic Mystery Box Dark Romance
#mysterybox #stationarysupplies
🎀MimiLand🎀

🎀MimiLand🎀

7 likes

Hands tied in romance dark...
⊱ ੈI have a previous list of dark romance in my profile, so i took the time to listen more and put together a second list that could be approached again to the environment that belongs to this genre #darkromancebooks #Lemon8 #musicrecommendations #darkmafiaromance 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖺 𝗌𝗉𝖾𝖼𝗂𝖺𝗅 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗌
𝐄𝐯𝐞䆯㗵

𝐄𝐯𝐞䆯㗵

4 likes

🌸 Must See Romance Anime’s 😮‍💨
Romance Anime’s are top tier😮‍💨 As an avid anime watcher, there’s levels to this! I love a good Shojo and Shonen romcom series 🥰 and don’t get me started on the men 😌 Here are some of my top romance anime recs: Horimiya ⭐️Overall rating: 7/10: The male lead is fine ASF 🥵 but I wasn’t a fa
Nyah Misfit

Nyah Misfit

35 likes

New Romance Animes to Add to Your Watchlist!
Fall romance anime season is officially here, and I’ve got some fresh and dreamy recommendations for you! 🍂💞 From magical love stories to heartfelt slice-of-life romances, this lineup is filled with charm and emotion. Here are the must-watch new releases this season: Mechanical Marie – This roma
jaylinny2

jaylinny2

281 likes

YA beach romance + small town mystery! 🌴
A new town, a new mystery, and a boy who could change everything. #youngadultbooks #summer romance #beachyvibes #mysterybooks #yacontemporary
YA Beach Reads

YA Beach Reads

1 like

Mystery, romance, and suspense all rolled in one❤️
This story will haunt me for years to come. I followed the recommendation to go in blind, and I'm not sorry that I did. Wonderful characters, Fabulous story! Read Responsibly 🍷 📚 Series 📚: stand alone Book 1 📖: Pen Pal Author ✍️: J. T. Geissinger #lemon8bookworm #lemon8bookclub
LilReadBookWyrm

LilReadBookWyrm

2 likes

Wonderful Mystery Romance for fall!
I loved this book! First time reading Nora (I know, I can’t believe it either) and I’ll be back for more! I hope I can find another of her books with these same feels! It’s about a lawyer turned carpenter who leaves the big city to buy a dilapidated mansion in New Orleans. He gets more than he barg
Kendall Blake

Kendall Blake

7 likes

Your Ultimate Guide to Romance, Magic & Mayhem
Ready to binge-read your next obsession? 📚✨ Whether you’re craving fairy tale vibes, slow-burn passion, or dark mystery with a side of vengeance, this ultimate romance trilogy guide has got your bookish back. Warning: spice levels vary from “sweet tea” to “holy fire alarm,” so buckle up and prepare
✨Literary📚Hangover✨

✨Literary📚Hangover✨

682 likes

Romantic murder mystery
#murdermystery #romance #booktok #goodreads
Carolyn Bowen

Carolyn Bowen

4 likes

Horror | Mystery | Thriller | Slasher | Crime
Book Recommendations for my Horror, Mystery, Thriller, Slasher and Crime, Guys and Gals! ———————————————————————————- You’re Not Supposed to Die Tonight By Kalynn Bayron At Camp Mirror Lake, terror is the name of the game... but can you survive the night? This heart-pounding slasher by N
W

W

30 likes

Classic Mystery Box Dark Romance 🖤💖 for Lisa 🥰
🎀MimiLand🎀

🎀MimiLand🎀

23 likes

three romance books i’m reading ❤️‍🔥
I never read more than one book at a time but each of these books have me so excited to bust these pages open that im just going to read multiple!! My plan is to read several chapters a day for each book. I’ll give an update within the next day or two! #currentlyreading #lemon8challeng
ᥲrιᥱ❦

ᥲrιᥱ❦

162 likes

Small town romance ✨
Who doesn't want a book thats romance and spooky all mixed into one? Happy Medium by Sarah Adler is that perfect combination! It's such a cute love story that has a few twists and turns. Definitely recommend it for the people with the love of ghosts and love stories! 🖤 - small town romance
Aunt Mel ✨

Aunt Mel ✨

4 likes

Thiller& Mystery Books🩸🔪
If you’re into scary and mystery books here are some book recommendations for you to put on your TBR list!!! #mysterythriller #mysterybookrecs #mystery & thriller #mysteries and thrillers #thrillerbookrecommendations #book recommendations #thrillermystery
iAmSammy✨🌸

iAmSammy✨🌸

548 likes

New to vampire romance? Start here
Okay, so, lemme tell ya, I've fallen head over heels for vampire romance lately! 🧛‍♀️❤️ It's like, the ultimate escape into a world of forbidden love, dark secrets, and just a hint of danger. And honestly, I've been devouring these books like they're going out of style. 😂 If you&
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

103 likes

Gothic Romance Book Recs🖤✨💀
Gothic romance is one of my all time favorite genres, especially during the summer time oddly enough! Here’s a few of my favorites that I’ve read. 💀The Isle of Sin and Shadows: A southern gothic romance based in Louisiana. It’s a spooky mystery with romance as a main plot point and the ending
linds

linds

29 likes

YA Beach Mystery + Romance 🌴
The Summer of Lost Wishes // Nikki Chartier 🌺Boy next door 🌴New girl in town 🌺Summer cottage renovation 🌴Small beach town 🌺Unraveling local mystery 🌴Secret letters in the wall 🌺Coming of age 🌴"Someone's watching us" 🌺Off-limits romance #youngadultbooks #yamysterybooks
YA Beach Reads

YA Beach Reads

3 likes

🥀Gothic Romance🥀
Looking for haunted houses, brooding heroes, atmospheric suspense, and romances that burn through the dark? These books deliver everything you could want in a gothic romance… atmosphere, angst, and forbidden love. 🏰 Master of Salt and Bones | Keri Lake A castle of bones, a scarred recluse, and
ellebee reads

ellebee reads

492 likes

A MUST read Small Town Romance Series
A Must Read Small Town Romance Books Series! The Eden’s Series by Devney Perry Indigo Ridge - Cowboy Romance Juniper Hill - Single Mom Garnet Flats - Second Chance Jasper Vale - Fake Dating Crimson River - Mystery Sable Peak - Single Dad #romancerecommendations #cowboyromance #th
EmalooReads

EmalooReads

9 likes

Lighter Dark Romance Book Recs for Beginners
If you want to get into Dark Romance but don’t want to traumatize yourself right off the bet, these are my recommendations lol #spicybookrecommendations🔥 #darkromancebookrec #dark romance #darkromancerecommendations #darksmut
🌛𝔰𝔞𝔪🌜

🌛𝔰𝔞𝔪🌜

505 likes

i need a good who dunnit rec!!
so i just finished school spirits and a good girl's guide to murder (both incredible shows!!) and i now know that i love a good who dunnit, any and all recommendations are welcome, books, movies, anything #schoolspirits #Netflix #agoodgirlsguidetomurder #mystery #murder mystery #sum
nkxma

nkxma

6 likes

Beach town, romance, mystery, and more 🌸🌊
The Summer of Lost Wishes // Nikki Chartier 🌺Boy next door 🌴New girl in town 🌺Summer cottage renovation 🌴Small beach town 🌺Unraveling local mystery 🌴Secret letters in the wall 🌺Coming of age 🌴"Someone's watching us" 🌺Off-limits romance #youngadultbooks #yamysterybooks
YA Beach Reads

YA Beach Reads

0 likes

📖 today is dark romance stuff your kindle day! ༘⋆
today is dark romance day! 📖🙂‍↕️ reminders for: @Jordan Sumler @Ririri🎀 @Jessica Inniss dark romance - july 20th website -> darkmodebooks.substack.com contemporary romance - july 23rd website -> romancebooklovers.com cozy mystery - july 25th website -> cozymysterybook
ciara janaé ꨄ︎

ciara janaé ꨄ︎

17 likes

Romance/Thriller Books to Read This Fall
Fall season is upon us! Here are some fall books that are great if you want something cozy, thrilling, or romantic. If any of these books stand out to you, I highly recommend you adding them to your fall tbr :) Genres: ROMANCE: - Bride: a paranormal romance with a werewolf and vampire.
Hannah Pilgrim

Hannah Pilgrim

305 likes

Convincing you to read a dark academia romance 🤍
One of my top reads of 2025 is Nightshade by Autumn Woods ✨ You’ve got - Hate to love - Thriller/murder mystery - Swimmer fmc x Rugby player mmc - University set in Scotland - Dark academia vibes If you love any of those ⬆️ tropes this is THE book for you! It’s moody and atmosphe
em ✨

em ✨

8 likes

Who Dunnit? Pinball
🚨New Release Review Alert🚨Who Dunnit from Williams Pack 9 is now available on the Legends4K Pinball machine. One of my favorite releases for 2025 thus far! #legends4kpinball #atgames #zenstudios #whodunnit #digitalpinball
Mr. Legends

Mr. Legends

0 likes

Slavic Inspired Fantasy Murder Mystery
Balkan folk-inspired fantasy with a murder mystery twist? Yes, please! This book was really entertaining. It read like a young adult book but wasn't marketed that way. I found the world building breezy but excellent and there is a little slow-burn romance in there as well. Moving on to book
ScienceintheFiction📚🔬✍️

ScienceintheFiction📚🔬✍️

1 like

Fall 2025 Romance Anime Recommendations
Cozy vibes, warm colors, and heart-fluttering stories; fall 2025 is packed with must-watch romance anime. From slow-burn school love to fantasy, these new titles are perfect for curling up with a blanket and diving into autumn feels. Here are my top picks for your fall watchlist! #lemon8partner
Lina 🪷

Lina 🪷

378 likes

Dark romance “Gothikana” thoughts ✨
“𝒢𝑜𝓉𝒽𝒾𝓀𝒶𝓃𝒶” 𝒷𝓎 𝑅𝓊𝒩𝓎𝓍 ★彡[ꜱᴘᴏɪʟᴇʀ ꜰʀᴇᴇ ʀᴇᴠɪᴇᴡ]彡★ Gothikana is a dark academia romance that follows 21 year old Corvina, who is eager for a fresh start at the mysterious university of Verenmore after receiving an admission letter. The school has a haunting past and many dark secrets of its own
Jessica Claire

Jessica Claire

41 likes

Small town mystery, beach vibes, & romance! 🌊
I came up with the idea for this book during the year my sister and I lived in Florida. It's set in a small beach town with a big mystery that's about to be unraveled! If you love small beach towns, old mysteries, and a cute boy next door, you'll love The Summer of Lost Wishes! S
YA Beach Reads

YA Beach Reads

3 likes

Romance Mystery Book Haul
I got the mystery book bag at Vstock. 20 books all for $14.99! Honestly I would recommend this because I got books I wouldn't have even looked at otherwise. I'm planning on doing a YouTube series dedicated to reading these as soon as I move so please tell me which one looks like the most
Clara

Clara

6 likes

Looking for a Sapphic Sports/Mystery romance?
💓Hearts and Stars on KU! tropes: 💓bisexual romance 💓secret identities 💓ex-cheer captain 💓football player 💓sapphic romance 💓queer rebel 💓mafia conflict #bookish #characterart #sportsromance #sportsromancebooks #sportsromancenovels #lgbtbooks #bisexualbooks #bisexualroma
Phoenix Kathryn 👀 Author

Phoenix Kathryn 👀 Author

4 likes

See more