Top 14 slices in NYC, ranked

2/20 Edited to

... Read moreHaving explored many of the top-ranked pizza spots in NYC, I can attest that each slice offers a unique taste experience that reflects the city's vibrant pizza culture. For example, L&B Spumoni Gardens is famous for its Sicilian slice, known for its thick crust and rich tomato sauce topped with cheese that perfectly balances freshness and indulgence. Meanwhile, Fini Pizza's Grandma slice, often praised for its thin, crispy crust and aromatic long hot shallots, offers a delightful twist on traditional white pizza. From personal experience, the Burrata slice at Cello's Pizzeria stands out with its creamy cheese and spicy jalapeño-pepperoni combo — a bold choice for those who love flavor complexity. The Vodka slice at Lucia Pizza is another highlight, with its smooth, tangy vodka sauce complementing the pepperoni and fresh mozzarella, creating a truly memorable slice. What I appreciate most about this ranking is how it showcases the diversity of pizza styles in NYC, from classic cheese to innovative toppings. Whether you're a fan of the classic sausage pizza from Rite 14 Amore or prefer the more refined cacio e pepe slice from F & F Pizza Vibe, there's something here for everyone. For anyone visiting or living in the city, this list acts as a practical roadmap to discovering hidden gems and local favorites. By sampling slices from this curated selection, you get a rich snapshot of NYC's pizza scene — a blend of tradition, creativity, and irresistible taste. So grab a slice (or several), and immerse yourself in the quintessential New York pizza experience!

2 comments

Related posts

A close-up of a perfectly cooked, sliced steak with a fork, displaying a pink interior. Overlay text reads 'top 14 nyc STEAKHOUSES ranked'.
A map of New York City showing various locations marked with numerical ratings, indicating steakhouse rankings. Text states 'based on over 100 million rankings on Beli'.
A collage of six dishes from Lucky's Soho, including bone-in ribeye, lobster mac, mac and cheese, and a cocktail, representing the 14th ranked steakhouse.
Top 14 steakhouses in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. Let us know what you think should’ve made the list! #nycsteakhouse #steakhouse #nycfoodie #steakdinner #nyceats
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

21 likes

A dessert with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and mint leaves, with text overlay "top 14 Mexican restaurants in NYC, ranked" and "lemon8 @beli_eats".
A map of NYC showing numerous green circles with ratings, indicating restaurant locations, with text "based on over 95 million ratings on Beli".
A collage of four images featuring various dishes from Taqueria Tlaxcalli, including burritos (carnitas, vegetarian) and steak nachos.
Top 14 Mexican Restaurants in NYC
The top-rated Mexican restaurants in NYC, based on over 95 million rankings on Beli. Let us know what you think should have made the list! 1. Quique Crudo 2. Cocina Consuelo 3. Cuerno 4. Oxomoco 5. Mariscos El Submarino 6. Taqueria Ramirez 7. Cosme 8. Dolores 9. Corima 10. Hell
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

1 like

A close-up of a dessert, likely tiramisu, topped with whipped cream and cocoa powder, on a white plate. The image has a text overlay that reads 'top 14 ITALIAN RESTAURANTS in NYC, ranked'.
A map of New York City showing numerous green circular pins with numerical ratings, indicating restaurant locations and scores. A text overlay states 'based on over 100 million rankings on Beli'.
A collage of six dishes from Campagnola, including penne vodka, chicken special with mushrooms, shrimp, 'little apps' with bread and charcuterie, and another chicken dish. The text '14. Campagnola' is overlaid.
Top 14 Italian restaurants in NYC, ranked
#nycfood #italiancuisine #nycfoodie #nyceats #nycitalianfood
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

2 likes

Top 10 bagel shops in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full top 15 bagel list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #nycbagels #bagel #nycbagel #nycfood #nycfoodie
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

2 likes

A close-up of a burger with melted cheese, thick bacon, and a fried egg, introducing the "top 5 BURGERS in NYC, ranked" based on Beli member ratings.
A map of New York City showing numerous restaurant ratings, indicating that the burger rankings are based on over 100 million ratings on Beli.
A collage of six images showcasing various burgers from "5. One White Street," including cheeseburgers and regular burgers, some served with pickles.
Top 5 burgers in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full top 10 nyc burger list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #nycfood #nycfoodie #nyceats #burgerlovers #nycburger
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

1 like

A close-up cross-section of a sandwich filled with meat and onions, with text indicating it's about the top 5 sandwich shops in NYC, ranked by Beli members.
A map of New York City showing numerous locations marked with fork and knife icons and ratings, indicating sandwich shops, based on over 100 million ratings on Beli.
A collage of six images showcasing various sandwiches from Salty Lunch Lady's, including tuna crunch, marinated broccoli, and smashed chicken sandwiches.
Top 5 sandwich shops in NYC, ranked
The top 5 sandwich shops in NYC, based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full top 10 list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #nycsandwich #sandwichshop #nycfoodie #nycfoodspots #nycfood
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

1 like

Top 5 Korean BBQ restaurants in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full NYC Korean BBQ list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #nycfoodie #kbbq #koreanbbq #nycfoodspots #nyceats
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

1 like

Top 14 Indian restaurants in NYC, ranked
#nycfood #indiancuisine #nycfoodies #nyceats #nycindianfood
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

0 likes

biggest pizza slices I’ve ever had in NYC✨
East Village Pizza is one of the most popular pizza spot you can find in NYC! We had their double stacked pizza 🍕 with pepperoni and I have to say we had to share even one piece among the two of us. It was that big 🤩 Location:📍East Village #lemon8partner #nycpizza #nycrecs #wheret
eat.feast.repeat

eat.feast.repeat

634 likes

A vibrant iced matcha latte in a glass, showing distinct green and creamy layers. Text indicates it's the cover for 'Top 10 Matcha Spots in NYC, ranked' based on over 100 million ratings.
A collage showcasing various matcha lattes from '9. PARK at KIMS'. Images include iced and hot matcha drinks in different cups and glasses, highlighting the cafe's offerings.
A collage of lavender peaflower drinks from '8. Land to Sea'. The images display layered beverages with blue/purple and green hues, some iced, in clear cups.
Top 10 Matcha Spots in NYC, ranked
Matcha lovers assemble 🍵 Check out the full list on Beli! Let us know what you think should’ve made the list 👀 #matchalatte #matchalove #nyccafe #nyccafes #matchalovers
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

6 likes

A close-up of pancakes topped with blueberries, a berry sauce, and a dollop of cream or butter. Text overlay reads "top 5 PANCAKES in NYC, ranked" and "as ranked by Beli members."
A map of New York City showing numerous green fork and knife icons with numerical ratings, indicating restaurant locations and scores. Text overlay states "based on over 100 million ratings on beli."
A collage of six images, each showing a stack of banana pancakes with syrup. A central text box identifies them as "5. Croft Alley Banana pancakes."
Top 5 pancakes in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full top 10 pancake list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #pancake #nycfoodies #pancakelover #nyceats #nycfoodie
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

2 likes

A delicious chopped cheese sandwich, filled with melted cheese, seasoned ground beef, shredded lettuce, and sliced tomatoes, served on a toasted hero roll. The image highlights the "NYC Bodega Classic" recipe.
Ground beef and diced yellow onions are sizzling in a black skillet on a gas stove, forming the base for the chopped cheese sandwich. The beef is browned and mixed with the softened onions.
A mouth-watering chopped cheese sandwich, cut in half, revealing gooey melted cheese stretching between the two halves, along with seasoned beef, lettuce, and tomato on a toasted roll. It emphasizes the "Melty Perfection."
Chop Cheese Recipe: NYC Bodega Classic at Home
Inspired by NYC Bronx & Harlem bodegas,this sandwich hits with serious flavor. Perfect for late-night cravings or game day fuel. Want to level it up? Add jalapeños or hot sauce. A Juicy, Melty, Grilled Masterpiece You Can Make in 15 Minutes 🛒 Ingredients: • 1 lb ground beef (80/20 prefe
Iamshariflack

Iamshariflack

974 likes

Two pizza slices on paper plates, one with burrata and basil, the other with shredded cheese and basil, on a wooden table. The image has a text overlay that reads "NYC SLICES i can't get enough of."
A square Sicilian-style pizza from Emily, topped with red sauce, burrata cheese, fresh basil leaves, and spicy red pepper flakes, on a metal cooling rack.
A square Sicilian-style pizza from Emily, topped with crispy pepperoni and sliced green peppers, on a metal cooling rack.
NYC slices 🍕 that I can’t get enough of
hot, cheesy NYC pizza slices that I can't get enough of (all of these are 10/10): - Emily: West Village (Luca pizza $22, colony pizza $24): this is PERFECT for a group dinner, do not pass on the burger either - Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza (large plain pizza ($24): best thin crust! - R
chef.slick

chef.slick

164 likes

NYC BUCKET LIST | $1 Pizza slices top list
✨ I think the planets are aligned: Conde Nast Traveller says is the most coveted destination for 2025 and Bad bunny said you just need one summer there, but you only have $1 dollar to eat Im sure you didn’t know that there are two weeks out of the year in New York when everything is much muc
More Legs Room

More Legs Room

16 likes

Sliced roasted duck with crispy skin, served on a green leaf garnish on a white plate, introducing a ranking of top Chinese restaurants in Chinatown.
A map of Chinatown showing various restaurants marked with green circles containing numerical ratings, indicating rankings based on over 90 million reviews on Beli.
A collage showcasing various views of pineapple pork buns, some held in hands, highlighting Mei Lai Wah as restaurant number 14 on the list.
Top 14 Chinese restaurants in Chinatown, ranked
#chinesefood #nycchinatown #nycfoodies #chinatownnyc #nycfood
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

44 likes

Top 14 restaurants in Brooklyn, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. Let us know what you think should’ve made the list! #brooklyn #brooklynfood #brooklynrestaurants #nyceats #nycfoodies
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

0 likes

A close-up of a pepperoni and basil pizza with the text "top 10 PIZZA in NYC, ranked" and "as ranked by Beli members" overlaid, indicating a pizza ranking.
A map of New York City showing numerous green pizza slice icons with ratings, illustrating pizza locations and their scores based on over 100 million Beli ratings.
A collage of six 'Tie dye pizza' images from Rubirosa, featuring pizzas with swirled sauce patterns, highlighting the 10th ranked pizzeria.
Top 10 pizzerias in NYC, ranked
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full top 15 nyc pizza list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #nycpizza #pizzalove #nycfood #nycfoodies #nycbucketlist
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

0 likes

NYC Pizzeria Since 1967… Is It Still Worth It? 🍕
New Yorkers have been going to this Brooklyn pizzeria since 1967, so I had to see why it’s still so popular. I tried 4 slices: ⭐ Original Square — 10/10 Thick cut with a soft, pillowy center and crispy bottom. ⭐ 13 Ave — 9.7/10 Toasted sesame crust with a bold nutty crunch… still thinking abou
WanderandDinee | Trend Tester

WanderandDinee | Trend Tester

57 likes

5 Sips & Bites in NYC While Walking My Puppy 🐶🍕☕️🧋
This week’s agenda: walk the pup, eat good food, repeat. Here are 5 spots we strolled to: 1️⃣ FIFTYLAN Koreatown - Ice cream milk tea with golden boba ($9). I’m still dreaming about this drink 2️⃣ Chip City - Lucky Charms and classic chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the oven ($11 for 2)
chef.slick

chef.slick

37 likes

CHOCOLATE COVERED APPLE SLICES🍫🍏
These are much easier to make than caramel apples and they are customizable. You can add your favorite toppings for a perfect easy sweet treat! Not to mention. Super easy!! What you’ll need: 2 apples, sliced about ¼” thick (Honeycrisp, Granny Smith, Fuji, etc) Lemon juice 8 oz Essential Ever
LetsBeBestieBoos

LetsBeBestieBoos

17.9K likes

A woman smiles behind a tall, colorful layered birthday cake topped with sprinkles and a sparkler, representing NYC desserts. The background shows bottles on shelves.
A metal bowl holds a sundae with ice cream, chocolate sauce, colorful sprinkles, and a mint leaf, being drizzled with more chocolate, highlighting The American Bar's build-your-own sundae experience.
An elaborate chocolate milkshake from Diner 24, topped with whipped cream, marshmallows, sprinkles, chocolate syrup, and two blue straws, with a cookie stick and ice cream bar.
NYC desserts you must put on your bucket list🎂🍰🍪
1️⃣ The American Bar 🍨✨building my own sundae was so much fun. I love how they gave us a checklist with all the flavors and toppings and let us go through them and check them off. The sundae was unreal. 2️⃣ Diner 24 🍔🥤 their milkshakes were some of the craziest I’ve ever seen. We got the s’mores
Travel With Linds

Travel With Linds

22 likes

must-try food spots on your nyc trip
if you’re visiting nyc and don’t know where to start—these are my go-to food spots that are always worth the hype: 1. l’industrie pizzeria - hands down one of the best slices in nyc. their burrata slice is a must—crispy base, sweet tomato sauce, and creamy burrata on top. ($5.50) L’industrie Pi
nessie

nessie

102 likes

Western Cookie Cake slices!
#westerncookies #cowboycookies #cow #cowgirl #cookiecake
Rachel Ann

Rachel Ann

1122 likes

Watermelon Jello Slices
These are so cute and fun to make for the summer time and bring to the pool party 🌊☀️🌴 #watermelonjelly #watermelon #jello #summersnacks
Jennifer

Jennifer

10.7K likes

places to visit in nyc! ✨🎀
#placestovisit #lemon8challenge Central Park – Start your NYC adventure in the serene beauty of Central Park, where you can escape the city hustle for a moment of calm. Stroll through winding paths, marvel at iconic landmarks like Bethesda Terrace, or find a quiet bench to people-watch and
maddie schultz

maddie schultz

16 likes

A close-up of the Chestnut Mont Blanc dessert from Hojokban, featuring a creamy chestnut swirl, powdered sugar, a whole chestnut on top, and a spoon digging into the dessert, with text overlays.
A plate of Hojok Galbi, showing sliced beef short ribs with bones, topped with chopped peanuts, red and green chili slices, and a side of green onion salad.
A close-up of the Hojok Galbi, with tongs lifting a piece of sliced beef short rib, showcasing the meat, peanuts, and chili slices.
4.8-Star Korean Spot you must try in NYC!!
This place is straight 🔥 in Seoul, and now it’s here in NYC! After my Korean friends told me I had to try Hojokban, I finally went—and wow, it lives up to the hype. Even Google agrees with its 4.8-star rating! Here’s what I had: 🌟 Hojok Galbi Their signature dish! Everyone orders this, and for
YOYO TV in NYC

YOYO TV in NYC

384 likes

BEST RAMEN under $25 in NYC ✨
🍜 ramen local hidden gem in NYC👇🏼 💖 follow @cass • nyc food for more food recs in nyc! 🔖 save this and share with someone you want to bring to here 😋 it’s getting cold so you know what that means… soup seasonnnn 🥰 and what better way to kick off autumn than with a big bowl of ramen? Kam
cass • nyc food

cass • nyc food

227 likes

Cuts & Slices 🍕
We got .. Sweet chili salmon ( or chicken can’t remember) Galic parm shrimp Bbq chicken Jerk Chicken black truffle Alfredo ✨Fried shrimp and lobster black truffle 10/10 Brown Stew oxtail Cuts & Slices We requested to cut the slices in half so we can share ☺️ it was all good,
Destyni ᥫ᭡

Destyni ᥫ᭡

743 likes

Cheese zucchini slices
Cheese zucchini a healthy sweet idea. 💡 #zucchini #zucchinirecipe #Lemon8Diary #healthyrecipes #food
tayliss_bookdragon

tayliss_bookdragon

503 likes

Save this for your next NYC bakery crawl
Based on over 100 million ratings on Beli. See the full top 20 list on Beli and let us know what you think should have made the list! #nycbakery #croissant #nycfoodguide #bakeries #nyceats
Beli App | Restaurant Lists

Beli App | Restaurant Lists

4 likes

Three personal-sized pizzas are on a wooden table, with hands reaching for slices. One hand holds a slice of Hawaiian pizza. A shaker of red pepper flakes is visible, and a text overlay is present on the image.
Three personal-sized pizzas and a soda bottle are arranged on a wooden table. The pizzas include a plain cheese, a Hawaiian, and one with various toppings like peppers, olives, and mushrooms.
A top-down view shows three personal-sized pizzas on a wooden table. They consist of a plain cheese pizza, a Hawaiian pizza, and a pizza topped with assorted vegetables and meat.
🍕 $8 PIZZA in NYC?! Hidden Gem You Need to Try
My boyfriend took me to his childhood favorite pizza spot in Queens and… I’m OBSESSED. Legit one of the best budget eats I’ve had in NYC. 📍Singas Famous Pizza Singas Famous Pizza We went to the Forest Hills location — apparently the Flushing one got burned down recently (RIP🥲). It’s super low
TableForWei

TableForWei

36 likes

A vibrant spread of Korean BBQ dishes on a table, featuring various cuts of raw beef, a grill with cooking meat, side dishes, corn cheese, and uni rice, all under the text 'Antoya Korean BBQ'.
A close-up of pan-fried Strip Loin Yook-joen, garnished with green onions and sesame seeds, with chopsticks lifting a piece. Corn cheese is visible in the background.
Thinly sliced Korean Style Carpaccio, a raw beef dish, arranged on a white plate with microgreens, sesame seeds, and a side of pickled onions and wasabi.
Korean BBQ Meets Creative Bites✨ in NYC
Antoya is back with some amazing new Korean-inspired snacks, and they’re all must-tries! Here’s what we loved this time: ➡️ Korean Style Carpaccio Lightly seared beef slices that release a smoky aroma while staying tender inside. Wrap them with veggies and sauce for a fresh, crisp bite! ➡️ S
YiweiinNY🤯

YiweiinNY🤯

47 likes

My Top 3 Pizza Recommendations in Rome 🍕
Seu Pizza Illuminati 🍕 Ranked the #6th Best Pizza in the World ‼️ Seu Pizza Illuminati, ranked the 6th best in the world, is a must-visit in Rome. Chef Pier Daniele Seu, known for his inventive pizzas, crafts the "Pizza Margherita Gialla" with yellow tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, and
Aubrey Seat

Aubrey Seat

5 likes

TOP 5 NYC Cheesiest Pizza’s
Top 5 Pizzas Nyc 1. Negril Village - Caribbean spin on a classic wood fire pizza. Very filling and cheesy for a good price . 2. Max Brenners - Classic cheese pizza brick oven style and a lot of bang for your buck. 3. Farmers Pizza - Original neighborhood pizza spot always a good slice every ti
JewelMakana

JewelMakana

23 likes

A clear container holds various chocolate-dipped apple slices with toppings like butterfinger, chocolate peanut butter, chocolate pretzels, nutter butter, strawberry crunch, cookies n cream, and fruity pebbles.
A white tray contains apple slices coated in a dark, crumbly topping, resembling cookies and cream, arranged neatly.
A clear container holds four chocolate-covered apple slices, drizzled with chocolate and topped with nuts, with a Snickers wrapper on top.
Chocolate Apple Slices
Here Are A Few different apple slices I I’ve made recently 🤩🍏🍂🍫🤎 I like to either cut the whole apple and dip the slices or just dip the whole apple and cut them into slices 🙂‍↔️ #appleslices #caramelapple #treatmaker
Fe

Fe

4158 likes

CHOCOLATE-COVERED CARAMEL APPLE SLICES
#chocolateapples #deliciouschoices #Lemon8Diary #snack ideas #kidsnacks #delicioussnacks #lemon8challenge #yummyrecipes
Savyyy

Savyyy

431 likes

See more