2025/7/17 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, fellow Summer I Turned Pretty fans, let's be real. The internet is absolutely buzzing with the eternal 'Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah' debate, and honestly, some days I just cannot with certain characters! That's why when I stumbled upon (or maybe created, let's not get into specifics 😉) this 'Goodnight to everyone except if you're Team Jeremiah' meme, I knew I had to share it. It perfectly encapsulates that playful, sometimes exasperated, feeling many of us have. This iconic sentiment – 'Goodnight to everyone, except if your team Jeremiah' – truly highlights the passionate rivalry within 'THE SUMMER I TURNED PRETTY' fandom. It’s more than just a funny image; it’s a rallying cry for those of us who are firmly rooted in Team Conrad. For me, it's about the undeniable connection Belly shares with Conrad, the history, the longing stares, and those moments that just make your heart ache in the best way. Jeremiah is sweet, don't get me wrong, but sometimes his actions just make me want to throw my remote at the TV! Who's with me? I mean, think about it: the shared childhood memories, the quiet understanding, the way Conrad always seems to get Belly even when she doesn't understand herself. That's the stuff of epic romance, right? When I watch their scenes, especially from the earlier seasons of 'THE SUMMER I TURNED PRETTY', I'm just constantly rooting for them. So, when Jeremiah does something that puts a wrench in their story, it's hard not to feel a bit frustrated. This meme is my playful way of channeling that frustration and finding solidarity with other fans who feel the same. These kinds of fan-made memes are such a huge part of the whole SITP experience. They let us express our opinions, vent our feelings, and connect with a community of people who are just as invested in Cousins Beach as we are. Whether you’re sharing them on Instagram, TikTok, or here on Lemon8, they create a space for us to laugh, commiserate, and celebrate our favorite (or least favorite!) characters and storylines. You know, that feeling of seeing a meme and thinking, 'YES! Someone finally gets it!' — that's what this 'Goodnight Team Jeremiah' meme is all about for me. So, if you're like me and find yourself constantly replaying Conrad and Belly's best moments, or perhaps sighing dramatically at Jeremiah's choices, then this meme is for you. It's all in good fun, of course, but it’s also a little nod to where my heart truly lies in this complicated love triangle. What team are you on? Let me know in the comments – I'm always up for a friendly debate!

487 comments

pearl's images
pearl

guess i’m not sleeping then

See more(20)
Channing Claire's images
Channing Claire

Jokes on you Jeremiah wins in the end 😛😛😛

See more(27)

See more comments

Related posts

WELLNESS PRODUCTS I CANNOT LIVE WITHOUT🙌
just some wellness gadgets i’ve been absolutely LOVINGGGG (that actually work)🥰 each of these products serve their own unique purpose and have improved my life in a way that was worth way ymore the price i paid for them! and of courseeee i have all the goodies from my girl Lauryn from The Skinny Co
Cassidy

Cassidy

962 likes

husband wants to divorce because I cannot parkcar
#car #cartips #carskills #parking #automobile
Chequanxiaoqiao

Chequanxiaoqiao

708 likes

I hate that feeling I’m stressed so I cannot study
But without study, I get more stressed. Wish my life would be easier #studymotivation #studywithme #studygram #studygoals #motivation #study #collegelife
studywithemmane

studywithemmane

2446 likes

An open Bible, specifically to the Book of Isaiah, with a pink pen resting on its pages. A text overlay reads "Let's Start More Bible Journaling in 2025," set against a background of a blanket outdoors.
A handwritten journal page titled "Trust In God," outlining its meaning, relevant Bible verses, questions for self-reflection on trust, and practical ways to trust God, including Luke 22:42.
A journal page titled "God's timeline," emphasizing that no season is wasted, God prepares rather than delays, and He will reveal reasons for waiting, referencing Deuteronomy 31:8-9.
Bible Journaling: Ways to Connect with God 🫶🏼✨
Elevate your quiet time with fresh Bible journaling ideas for 2025. Blend creativity and faith through meaningful verse mapping, aesthetic layouts, and reflective practices. Let your journal be as beautiful as your journey with God. ✨📖 #BibleJournaling #VerseMapping #QuietTime #BibleStudy
The Crafty Couponer 🤑✨

The Crafty Couponer 🤑✨

2645 likes

we CANNOT be friends if…
#grwm #getreadywithme #wecantbefriends #grwmmakeup
KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

650 likes

I cannot put this book down 🤩
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: A Love Letter to Whiskey 📖 Genre: Romance ⭐ Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ #books 🫶🏼 #romancebooks #bookrecommendations #blackgirlsreadbooks #bookwormsoflemon8
Sydney Nicole

Sydney Nicole

1714 likes

Bible journaling ideas I’ve done
I’m a beginner and this is what I’ve done recently! More are from inspo I found on Pinterest! #biblejournaling #biblestudy #journalbible #healthylifestyle2024
Lexi Brianne 🪼

Lexi Brianne 🪼

1080 likes

Things I CAN control vs things I CANNOT!
What do y’all think? Thanks to this Tiktok creator for having this in my screenshots
Hawa

Hawa

372 likes

A tabby cat with its tongue out, surrounded by yellow stars and pink hearts, with text overlay 'Human foods your cat... CAN & CANNOT eat'.
A dark brown cat in a fluffy bed, with text listing foods it CAN eat: cooked lean meats, carrots, peas, cooked fish, scrambled or hard-boiled eggs, cucumbers, and steamed broccoli.
A white cat sitting on a table, with text listing more foods it CAN eat: bananas, apples, oatmeal, blueberries, watermelon, rice, and spinach.
CAN & CANNOT feed your cat!😻✅✨
‼️Disclaimer‼️ - cats have finicky digestive systems which can develop diabetes if fed food that are high in sugar. There are several human food that are safe for your cat to eat as an OCCASIONAL TREAT. COOKED LEAN MEAT &FISH 🥩🐟 stick to lean, cooked meat. raw meat can cause foodborne ill
𝑲𝒂𝒔𝒔💖

𝑲𝒂𝒔𝒔💖

2783 likes

Cannot believe I never had this before!!!
A complete lifesaver!! LINK: https://liketk.it/50ITU #wonderfold #w4luxe
j e s s i e 🎀✨🪩⚡️

j e s s i e 🎀✨🪩⚡️

3226 likes

A hand holds a stack of three puzzle books, with a smaller floral-patterned book on top. The image has text overlayed that reads "PUZZLE BOOKS I can't live without."
A hand holds a small, vibrant pink book with a floral pattern. The text overlay reads "Logic puzzles!".
An open small puzzle book displays two logic puzzles: "Country Weddings" and "Suguru". A hand holds the book open.
PUZZLE BOOKS I cannot live without
Do any of you also love challenging your brain with puzzle books? When I don’t feel like reading a book at night, I tend do to puzzles to wind down from the day! I love challenging my brain with these fun books! What’s your favorite puzzle to do? #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #rea
anniemurphy

anniemurphy

941 likes

Cheap FIRST Apartment Finds you CANNOT miss
Im moving into my FIRST apartment on 04/29 and have PREPARED myself😚 💗I got my Queen sized Mattress for 100$! From FBM 💗 I also got a ring camera from target for 54.99! It was on sale 💗 i got my couch and bed frame on amazon Using my student discount/ prime!! Dont sleep on finding things that
Meir Maree

Meir Maree

362 likes

A meaningful arm tattoo features a pocket watch, two orange butterflies, and a broken face with tears. The text 'Time Heals What Lessons Cannot' is integrated into the design. A 'Meaningful Tattoo' sticker is on the right.
Meaningful Tats , Time Heals What Lessons Cannot
neshamichelle

neshamichelle

1034 likes

I cannot wait to get married.
Me and my boyfriend plan to get married 4/5 years from now and I just know it’s gonna be perfect !!! This is how I want it I need this day to be perfect 😩. #WeddingInspo #embracevulnerability #springbreak #travelwithme2024 #Lemon8Diary #fashionfinds
Mookiana 💕 .

Mookiana 💕 .

685 likes

You Cannot Learn a Language in 30 Days
I see endless videos on YouTube titled “how I learned X in 7 days…” – I call B.S.!!! If you are just starting to learn a language, especially one very different than your native language, you will realize that vocabulary, grammar, sentence structure, even down to the way your mouth moves to pron
Anaïs D’Ottavio

Anaïs D’Ottavio

447 likes

A hand holds four books spine-up, with the text overlay "BOOKS THAT I WILL NEVER MOVE ON FROM *with quotes" against a white and green blanket background. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible.
The book "BABEL AN ARCANE HISTORY" by R. F. Kuang, featuring a tower on its cover, rests on a blanket. A quote about translation and betrayal is overlaid on the image.
The book "THE WOMEN A Novel" by Kristin Hannah, with a helicopter and palm trees on its cover, is displayed on a blanket. A quote about belief, war, and societal division is overlaid.
Books I simply cannot move on from
I either sobbed or stared at a wall… there is no in between. #books #bestbooks #fantasybookrecs #bookquotes
Allie 📚💙

Allie 📚💙

635 likes

Time with God thus AM!!!!🌸🌸🌸
Rose  Davenport

Rose Davenport

21 likes

you cannot tell me these aren’t the cutest🥰
#engagementphotos #gettingmarried
Kaylee

Kaylee

5268 likes

PERSONALLY Cannot Live Without
My FTM (First Time Mom) MUST HAVES!!! note: these are my PERSONAL ‘cannot live without’s what works for my baby and me, may not work for you and yours! And that’s okay 🖤 1) Frida Baby - Windi the Gaspasser 2) mommy’s BLISS - baby probiotic drops 3) Frida Baby - NoseFrida Saline Mist
🫒

🫒

2016 likes

I cannot wait to get my hands on one of these 😩
#summer #lemon8challenge #lemon8partner #Lemon8Diary #redbull
MommaBear🐻

MommaBear🐻

1406 likes

A person holds a mint green Nintendo Switch displaying 'Upcoming Releases' and 'Switch Games I'm Excited For' against a bookshelf background.
A person holds a mint green Nintendo Switch displaying the title screen for 'Garden Witch Life' on a white blanket.
A person holds a mint green Nintendo Switch displaying the title screen for 'Fabledom', featuring a colorful fantasy city, on a white blanket.
I cannot wait to play these!
Garden Witch Life - September 19, 2024 Fabledom - September 12, 2024 Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom - September 26, 2024 Tales of the Shire - 2024 (no set date) September is going to be a fun month for new Switch games! Which ones are you excited for? #cozygaming #switchgames #nintendo
Keeks 📖🏹

Keeks 📖🏹

208 likes

Jeremiyah, Love at the NFL combine along with Jason Love his father gave me all the thrills and feels as we head into this year’s NFL draft! Jeremiah love is the number one talent in this draft and everyone now knows it! #jeremiyahlove #nflcombine #nfldraft #tiktoksportscommentarycontest
Dee Loves Sports

Dee Loves Sports

3 likes

Things I do to help show my BF that I love him
I feel like everyone shows there emotions differently especially love, but these are just a few small things I do to help remind my BF that I love him. 1. Letters- ever since the start of our relationship I have written my bf love letters. Sometimes it’s hard to put how I feel into words but whe
Heav

Heav

208 likes

An aisle in a beauty store, likely Ulta, with shelves filled with various beauty and personal care products. Overlay text states the theme: "THINGS AT ULTA YOU CANNOT CONVINCE ME TO BUY."
A display of small, portable hand sanitizers in pink and orange packaging on a store shelf. Overlay text questions the perceived high cost of the item.
A retail display featuring numerous body care products, including shave sets and body butters. Overlay text expresses concern about the high price and effectiveness of these items.
Things at Ulta you cannot convince me to buy
Here are some products at Ulta that I absolutely cannot be convinced or influenced to buy!! Way too overpriced & here a few of these have no benefit anyway. Not pictured: the dyson air wrap🫣 If I got it as a gift or something, of course I’d be grateful. But I would never voluntarily spend my ow
dani :)

dani :)

4475 likes

you cannot cope with the future!
I’ve been dealing with a lot of anxiety lately and this is something i talk about consistently on my social media platforms. i always say: anxiety is the chaos without the presence of danger. it’s all an illusion. this part of the book sums it up perfectly!! a must read 🪴 #Lemon8Diary #Lemon8
Karlamary

Karlamary

40 likes

I CANNOT BELIEVE I DID IT! 🙌
🤩🤣🙌When you realize that you have spent double the amount on groceries than what you’ve invested into your business 💡 Message YES if you want more info on what I do! #thetravelboss #affiliate #travelagent #thetravelbossfromseattle #mompreneur
Karolina Legkun

Karolina Legkun

3 likes

I cannot believe I got to see them 🤯
I’m so late on my Norway content - this was actually like a month ago but I got super lucky that my first attempt was a high activity night! I went northern lights hunting with Greenlander Tours in Tromso, who did not give up despite initially cloudy conditions and we eventually found a spot wi
Marisa • Travel

Marisa • Travel

77 likes

You Cannot Manifest for Others. LAW OF ATTRACTION
You Cannot Manifest for Others. THE LAW OF ATTRACTION works perfectly everytime. It is universal and ultra powerful. The law of attraction states that like attracts like, that wherever your attention goes energy flows, and you attract more of that into your life, whether you like it or not. Y
Manifest

Manifest

7 likes

A pink handbag with various daily essentials, including a black wallet, watch, phone, perfume, earbuds, compact, tablet, stylus, and lipstick, laid out on a green blanket, with the text "I cannot go out without" overlaid.
A flat lay of daily essentials on a green blanket, featuring a pink handbag, Coach wallet, Omega watch, iPhone with floral case, Pacific Regatta perfume, AirPods, Clinique compact, pink tablet with Apple Pencil, and NYX Lingerie XXL lipstick.
A close-up of an Omega Tachymetre watch and an iPhone with a floral case and a pink lotus pop socket, resting on a green blanket.
My humble “I cannot go out without” ✨
I saw post about “what’s in my bag” and here’s my version, the “I cannot go out without” cuz my day won’t be the same as it was without these — and yes, I love black & pink palette ❤️ P.s: My perfume is Philippines brand called Regatta — I wanted to put a link but it’s not avail in the US. I
Nichole

Nichole

473 likes

I cannot believe this happened!
Pinch me I can’t believe I got to see them! 🐳 Whale watching has always been on my bucket list so I jumped when I was visiting Olympic National Park and saw they give whale watching tours out of Port Angeles! This was honestly such a wonderful tour! The captain was very knowledgeable and I le
Marisa • Travel

Marisa • Travel

15 likes

You cannot heal where you were hurt.
You cannot heal in the same environment that hurt you. Remove yourself from any environment that you do not feel loved, celebrated or appreciated. When a flower does not grow, you change the environment, not the flower. You are the flower, you deserve to bloom! 🌸 #healinglifestyle #healyourse
Xo Mikayla✨

Xo Mikayla✨

33 likes

Makeup products I CANNOT do my routine without!
As a makeup lover I am constantly trying new products and switching things in and out of my routine, but these are the products that I cannot do my routine without because they are THAT GOOD: Elf Power Grip Primer - the best sticky primer One Size on ‘til dawn mattifying waterproof setting sp
Sophia Giuffré

Sophia Giuffré

74 likes

7 Things i cannot live without rhode kit edition!!
💌 Brand: Rhode 💵 Price: $142 Items: Pineapple refresh cleanser Glazing milk Peptide Glazing Fluid Barrier restore cream x3 peptide lip treatments - Salted Caramel, Original, & Strawberry
Teejay Newsome

Teejay Newsome

2 likes

I Cannot Make This Up🤎
1️⃣Digital Products: Channel your knowledge and passion into creating a course or even a PDF. You don't need to be an expert in the field; you just need to know how to be a reporter. Utilize software like ChatGPT and Canva to assist you. I crafted my initial digital products and made $1300 in t
Mya Chanell

Mya Chanell

179 likes

See more