Which one should I read

2024/7/30 Edited to

... Read moreOh my gosh, I totally get where you're coming from! Being in a book slump is the absolute worst, especially when you have two amazing series like Harry Potter and Twilight staring at you, practically begging to be read. It’s even tougher when you’ve seen the movies first, because you already know the big plot points, but trust me, the books are a whole different experience! Let's dive into this ultimate book battle. You're trying to figure out which fantasy world to immerse yourself in, and it's a tough call because they offer such different vibes. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (or Philosopher's Stone, depending on where you are!) is the gateway to a classic, epic fantasy adventure. It's all about magic, friendship, courage, and a boy who discovers he’s a wizard, complete with flying on a broomstick and facing dark forces. The world-building is just incredible, and you grow up with the characters. If you love intricate plots, a sense of wonder, and a rich, detailed magical society, then Harry Potter is a fantastic journey. It's truly one of the great fantasy books of our time, setting a high bar for the genre. Then there’s Twilight, a series that really redefined paranormal romance for a generation. It centers around a human girl, Bella, who moves to a rainy town and falls in love with a mysterious vampire. The iconic image of hands holding a red apple perfectly encapsulates the forbidden fruit aspect of their relationship. While it's also a fantasy in its own right, with vampires and werewolves, it leans much more into the romance and character-driven drama. If you're looking for intense emotional connections, a bit of supernatural mystery, and a story that pulls you into its unique love triangle, then Twilight could be your perfect escape. And to directly answer a common query – no, Twilight isn't a Harry Potter fanfiction; they're wildly different universes, though both captivated young adult readers with their own brand of magic and intrigue. So, how do you decide? Think about what you're craving right now. Do you want to be whisked away to a grand school of witchcraft and wizardry, solving mysteries and battling evil, building deep friendships like Harry, Ron, and Hermione? Or are you in the mood for a more personal, intense story of supernatural romance, yearning, and loyalty, like Bella and Edward's saga? If you finish one and are looking for what books are similar to Harry Potter, you might enjoy series like 'Percy Jackson & The Olympians' by Rick Riordan, which also features a young hero discovering a hidden world, or 'The Chronicles of Narnia' by C.S. Lewis for classic fantasy. For those who enjoy the paranormal romance aspect of Twilight, you could explore 'The Vampire Diaries' series by L.J. Smith or even 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' by Sarah J. Maas for a more adult fantasy romance. Breaking a book slump can sometimes mean trying something completely new, but revisiting beloved stories through their original book forms is also a fantastic strategy. Sometimes, just having a different format, like an audiobook, can reignite that spark. My personal advice? Flip a coin, or read the first chapter of both! See which one grabs you more. Either way, you're in for a treat, and you'll be out of that slump in no time. Let us know what you pick!

80 comments

Britneyf07's images
Britneyf07

I would do twilight first since it’s not as long as Harry Potter

See more comments

Related posts

An open book rests on a white textured surface, with the title overlay "BOOKS EVERY WOMAN SHOULD READ" and subtitle "FEMININE EMBODIMENT & HEALTH," introducing a selection of recommended readings.
The book "Women Who Run With the Wolves" by Clarissa Pinkola Estés is displayed, highlighted as a guide for women to unleash their inner wild woman through amazing storytelling.
The book "Pussy: A Reclamation" by Regina Thomashauer is shown, described as providing feminine embodiment tools to celebrate sensuality and reclaim personal power.
BOOKS EVERY WOMAN SHOULD READ
Feminine embodiment & women’s health books that I truly believe every woman NEED to read. These books changed my life and I promise they will change yours too, if you allow them to open your mind and shake everything you’ve ever been told by society. WOMEN WHO RUN WITH THE WOLVES by Clarissa
August Rhianna

August Rhianna

4579 likes

A flat lay of various MXTX novels, including Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation and Heaven Official's Blessing, with the overlay text "Which MXTX Series Should You Read First?".
A person holding "The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System" novel, with green text boxes listing its characteristics like "Isekai," "Comedy," "Satire," and "Shizun X Disciple."
A person holding "Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation" novel, with blue text boxes highlighting features such as "Rivals to Lovers," "Political Intrigue," "Murder Mystery," and "Reincarnation."
Which MXTX series should you read first??
MXTX is an Chinese author that writes danmei (Chinese M/M romance) novels. She has three separate series that can be read in any order! I recommend starting with Grandmaster of Demonic Cultivation 💕 #grandmasterofdemoniccultivation #mdzs #heavenofficialsblessing #tgcf #scumvillainsselfsavin
Alex Tsatsos

Alex Tsatsos

390 likes

Help me pick what I should read next..
This will be my first read of the year.. which one should I read? Have you read any of them? #reading #lemon8bookclub #books #readersoflemon8 #Lemon8Diary
Chareese

Chareese

60 likes

5 Books that you SHOULD read 🥰🍋
- save this post 🤍- Do you want to level-up this year? Of course you do, so here are five books I have read that offer powerful insights into self-improvement, emotional resilience, and personal transformation. Each of these books offers practical wisdom for anyone looking to make meaningful chang
Miah 💕

Miah 💕

86 likes

Two books by Darcy Coates are displayed: "House of Shadows" with a gothic house and crow, and "The Whispering Dead" (Gravekeeper #1) with a dark tree, gravestones, and a shadowy figure against a red background. Both are by a USA Today Bestselling Author.
What book should I read?
I have loads of her books and I'm trying ti pick which one I should read first. These two are series. What would you read first? #lemon8diarychallenge #books
Juno Lucita

Juno Lucita

6 likes

Two books, 'The Housemaid' by Freida McFadden and 'Flock' by Kate Stewart, are displayed on a fluffy blanket. An overlay asks 'Which should I Read first,' with decorative stickers of books and a coffee cup.
Which book should I read first?
Help me pick! If you’ve read these, tell me which is better! 👏🏼 #readingrecommendations #books #booktok #romancebooks #reading
Kaitlyn 🤍

Kaitlyn 🤍

19 likes

BOOKS YOU SHOULD READ
More recommendations for your book shelf! 🫶🏽 ⬇️ Don’t forget to SAVE the post for later! ⬇️ • The Subtle Art of Not Giving A F**K | 100/10 ⭐️ • Maps of the Modern World | 10/10 ⭐️ • Honey & Spice | Partial read. Started but haven’t finished. I’m loving what I’ve read so far and love
everythingtrin 🫦

everythingtrin 🫦

219 likes

Two books, 'None of This Is True' by Lisa Jewell and 'The Seven Year Slip' by Ashley Poston, are displayed on a wooden surface with the text overlay "It's time to Read."
A hand holds the thriller novel 'None of This Is True' by Lisa Jewell, featuring a dark cover with houses and a quote from Lucy Foley. The text overlay reads "Thriller, Suspense vibes."
A hand holds the romance novel 'The Seven Year Slip' by Ashley Poston, which has a bright yellow cover with stylized text and figures. The text overlay reads "Romance, good feel book."
Help! Which one should I read next?
Looking for a new book to read. Would love some suggestions in the comments below or of the ones pictured above. Thank you, Lemon8 family! #Lemon8PhotoStudio #Lemon8Diary #books #reading #read #barnesandnoble #book #shopping #shareyourthoughts #storytime
Callie

Callie

9 likes

Two books by Freida McFadden, 'The Housemaid' (blue cover) and 'The Housemaid's Secret' (red cover), are displayed side-by-side. Both covers feature an eye looking through a keyhole. The image asks, 'WHICH BOOK SHOULD I READ FIRST?'. Both books have 20% off stickers.
Which Book Should I Read First ?
I want to read both, but do not know which one I should read first! Help
adriana g

adriana g

3 likes

A stack of four books from The Hunger Games series, including 'The Hunger Games,' 'Catching Fire,' 'Mockingjay,' and 'The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes,' with text overlay 'DYSTOPIAN SERIES YOU SHOULD READ'.
A stack of five books from The Maze Runner series by James Dashner, including 'The Maze Runner,' 'The Scorch Trials,' 'The Death Cure,' 'The Kill Order,' and 'The Fever Code.'
The book 'Selection' by Kiera Cass, featuring a woman in a large blue gown on the cover, placed on a white tray next to a candle and pearl bracelet.
Dystopian Series You Should Read
The Maze Runner The Selection Stung The Lunar Chronicles The 100 Have you read these? Which is your favorite? #books #reading #recommendations
Kaitlin Graham

Kaitlin Graham

39 likes

A dark image featuring a skull surrounded by black roses, with the white text "MY JANUARY TBR HOPEFULS" prominently displayed, indicating a list of books to read.
The book cover for "Voice Like a Hyacinth" by Mallory Pearson, featuring a black background with vibrant floral arrangements and a dark animal's face.
The book cover for "One Dark Window" by Rachel Gillig, depicting a dark fantasy scene with a figure in red on a bridge between two castle towers.
WHICH ONE SHOULD I READ FIRST?
Which one of these have you read? Which one should I read first? NO SPOILER PLEASE 🖤 #tbrlist #bookstoread #readwithlemon8 #booklover
Murder & Manuscripts

Murder & Manuscripts

1 like

Which one should I read next?
Melanie Wall

Melanie Wall

3 likes

Which one should I read next?
Need your help!! I’ve been reading dark romances with murder and suspense, and I just need a good old fashion romcom!! I need cheesy, funny, light hearted, and sweet romance! I got these two at my favorite local bookstore today and just need some suggestions on which one to read first.🥰 The rom-co
CatOsborn29

CatOsborn29

3 likes

Which book should I Read?
#Lemon8Diary #lemon8diarychallenge Finished up one this morning and trying to decide what to read next! #books #lemon8partner #lemon8bookclub #lemon8book
Kimmie ᨒ↟

Kimmie ᨒ↟

6 likes

A notebook titled "Bible Study For Beginners" lists Bible books for different needs: James for spiritual growth, Psalms for encouragement, John for deepening relationship with Jesus, Proverbs for wisdom, and Job for faith in tough times. An open Bible shows text from James.
Which Book of the Bible Should You Read? 📖✨
I’m starting a new Bible study and wasn’t sure what book to read next. 🤔 If you’ve ever felt the same, here’s a list based on different needs! ✨ I was going to finish Psalms, but wanted to go deeper in my spiritual growth, so I’m diving into James. 💡 What book of the Bible are you readi
Char

Char

30 likes

which one do I need to read?
I am not usually one to leave things unfinished, but with these books that’s exactly what I’ve done. And I’m not sure I will ever go back to them… but I need your help to decide. Are these books worth my time? Should I throw in the towel? I hate being a quitter but I don’t want to get into a readin
emmalouisebooks

emmalouisebooks

43 likes

A collection of self-help and personal development books, including titles like 'The ABCs of Self Love,' 'Good Anxiety,' 'Woman Evolve,' 'Better Than Before,' and 'Shadow Work Journal,' are displayed on a textured surface, suggesting a focus on self-improvement and wellness.
Which one should I pick
#Bookgirl #selfimprovementjourney #lovereading
Reese219

Reese219

18 likes

Which book should I read in the Bible?
Struggling to find a chapter to study in your Bible? Here’s how I start my study sessions! 1️⃣ First, pick a book that speaks to where you are—whether it’s dealing with anxiety, growing in your friendships, or diving deeper into knowing Jesus. Not sure where to start? Just grab a Bible, flip thr
ModistyAmethyst

ModistyAmethyst

38 likes

Two stacks of books on a carpeted floor, featuring various titles for a '2024 TBR List,' with the hashtag #LemonLit at the top right and a social media handle at the bottom left.
Which book should I read next?
List of books from top left to bottom right Secrets of Blackthorn Hall - Cassandra Clare Chain of Thorns -Cassandra Clare Chain of Iron -Cassandra Clare The Southern Bookclubs Guide to Vampire Hunting - Grady Hendrix The Water Dancer - Ta-Nehisi Coates Cursed - Frank Miller Cut to the B
Torre

Torre

6 likes

which book should i read next ? 🩵📖
hi friends! i have multiple books that are on my tbr! which one should i read next? (swipe for ALL the options) & give me your honest opinions! if there are any books you don’t see, please leave more recommendations! :) i just finished reading two books this week! - therapy by sebastian
emily

emily

7 likes

Which one should I read next? 🤔
I don’t know where to start 😩😩 Currently reading A Little Life by Hanya Yanagihara #reading📖 #books 🫶🏼 #currentread
Mercadies Dawn

Mercadies Dawn

1 like

Which should I read next?
Just got two new books! Tell me which I should read first BUT I’m going to read both! #reading 📖 #books 🫶🏼 #loves to read 📚
LauraLyeLoves

LauraLyeLoves

5 likes

A young woman in a black dress stands in a school hallway, asking "which book should i read next?". Overlaid decorations include a smiley face, sparkles, and a daisy, suggesting a request for book recommendations.
The book cover for "The Deal Off-Campus 1" by Elle Kennedy is displayed on a textured background. The cover features a person in a sweatshirt and shorts with a whistle. The Good Reads rating is 4.23.
The book cover for "We Were Liars" by E. Lockhart is shown on a white textured surface. The cover depicts people in water. The Good Reads rating for this book is 3.67.
which book should i read next ?
My friends all recommended me these books and i wanna know what you guys think i should read next !! #books 🫶🏼 #reading📖
Madie Paige

Madie Paige

15 likes

Which book should I read
I am in a reading slump :(
Lexy Jean

Lexy Jean

8 likes

Which book should I read next?
Stuck between the two of these, I just can’t make a decision on which one to read first haha! If i start reading “a good girl’s guide to murder” then i’d have to read the rest of the books in the series right after! & if i start reading “if only i had told her” then i’d have to read “if
Addy 💛

Addy 💛

10 likes

A white bookshelf displays various books, including "May A Divine Awaken" and "This Land Is Our Land." The shelf also features a green crocheted dinosaur and a LEGO-style dinosaur figure, adding a playful touch to the book collection.
A hand holds the book "This Land Is Our Land," featuring a cover with a person looking at a glowing sky. An overlay describes the plot: tensions over immigration, a white supremacist path, and real aliens invading. Sunflowers are visible in the background.
A hand holds the book "May A Divine Awaken," depicting a young person with vitiligo in a uniform on the cover. An overlay explains the story: a soldier with vitiligo discovers hidden powers and uncovers family secrets. Sunflowers are in the background.
underhyped books you should read!
i went through my goodreads and picked out a couple of books that somehow have fewer than 200 ratings!! you all need to pick them up and fall in love with them, because they deserve to have more eyes on their pages. which one intrigues you more? #lemon8partner #lemon8bookclub #under
Steph 📚💫

Steph 📚💫

27 likes

Which should I read first ???
Tanya Oleski

Tanya Oleski

1 like

A hand holds several books, one with a yellow spine, on a gray blanket. Text asks, "What book should I read next?" and states "In my fantasy era," with a crown icon and Lemon8 branding.
The book "The Atlas Six" by Olivie Blake lies on a gray blanket. Overlay text describes the plot: six magicians fight for a place among the Alexandrians, gaining wealth, power, and prestige.
The book "The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue" by V.E. Schwab is on a gray blanket. Overlay text describes a girl making a deal for immortality, but no one remembers her until 300 years later.
What book should I read next?
1. The atlas six - olivie Blake 2. The invisible life of Addie larue - v.e. Schwab 3. Fourth wing - Rebecca yarros 4. Sanctuary of the shadow - Aurora ascher 5. Lightlark - Alex aster 6. The cruel prince - holly black If any of you have read any of these and enjoyed them please let me kno
saighey

saighey

42 likes

A flat lay of various romantasy books including Powerless, A Court of Thorns and Roses series, Fourth Wing, Iron Flame, Caraval, and One Dark Window, on a white bedspread, with the text 'SHOULD I READ...' overlaid.
A close-up of four books from the A Court of Thorns and Roses series by Sarah J. Maas, featuring colorful covers like green, orange, blue, and pink, fanned out on a white textured surface.
The books Fourth Wing and Iron Flame by Rebecca Yarros, both with gold and dark covers, are displayed side-by-side on a white textured surface, representing popular fantasy reads.
WHAT SHOULD I READ NEXT??!
i’m currently reading the powerless series by lauren roberts after not really being a fantasy fan (besides percy jackson and harry potter) and i’m absolutely deVOURING it. i need moreeee story lines like this!! the enemies to lovers!!! the magical (but still angsty) feeling it gives!!! I NEED ROMAN
savannah :)

savannah :)

254 likes

See more