These two look a little different if you search them side by side but when you put them on and blend they look identical! The only thing I’ve noticed that’s a tiny bit different is the finish of the Haus Labs one, it looks a little bit wet if that makes sense but color wise they are so similar! Perfect dark(ish) shades for fall too 🍂
... Read moreOkay, so I've been on the hunt for the perfect fall blush, and when I first heard whispers about a potential dupe for Rhode's Toasted Teddy, my ears perked up! I absolutely adore the rich, warm reddish-brown shade of Toasted Teddy, but sometimes a girl needs options, or a more budget-friendly alternative. That's where Haus Labs Glassy Cayenne came into play, and I just had to put them to the ultimate test.
Initially, just swatching them side-by-side, you might notice subtle differences. The Rhode one, often in its sleek light brown container, feels incredibly creamy and blends like a dream. The Haus Labs, housed in its chic silver container, also has a beautiful texture, but as I mentioned, it seems to have a slightly more 'wet' or dewy finish. On my hand, the swatches of the reddish-brown shade looked incredibly close, almost indistinguishable once blended out.
But how do they perform on the cheeks? That's the real question! I've been wearing one on each cheek to truly compare. Both give that gorgeous, sun-kissed, slightly flushed look that's perfect for autumn. The Toasted Teddy gives a soft, natural flush that lasts all day without fading. The Glassy Cayenne, with its dewy finish, gives a similar color payoff but with an added luminous glow, which I actually love for brightening up my complexion on duller days. For me, they both wear beautifully for hours, easily passing the workday test. If you prefer a more satin finish, Rhode might edge out slightly, but if you love a healthy glow, Haus Labs is fantastic.
Now, let's talk about some specific queries many of you have, like using Rhode Toasted Teddy on lips. While both are technically blushes, I've seen people experiment with Toasted Teddy as a lip color, and honestly, it can look stunning! It gives this beautiful, muted reddish-brown stain that's very on-trend. Just be aware that it’s formulated for cheeks, so it might not have the same longevity or hydrating properties as a dedicated lip product. I like to dab a tiny bit on my lips and then top it with a clear gloss for a cohesive look. It’s a great way to extend the use of your beloved blush!
Another common question is about Rhode Toasted Teddy on fair skin. As someone with a lighter complexion myself, I can confidently say it *works*! The key is to apply it with a light hand. This reddish-brown shade can be quite pigmented, so a little goes a long way. Start with a tiny dot and blend it outwards for a sheer wash of color. You can always build it up if you want more intensity. It gives a beautiful, natural warmth without looking muddy or overwhelming. It’s actually one of my go-to shades because it mimics a natural flush so well, making it a versatile addition to any makeup bag.
Ultimately, whether you pick up Rhode Toasted Teddy or Haus Labs Glassy Cayenne, you're getting a stunning, versatile shade that will elevate your fall makeup game. If you're looking for an almost identical color match with a slightly different finish, Glassy Cayenne is definitely a strong contender as a dupe. Both are incredible products in their own right, and honestly, you can't go wrong with either for achieving that perfect autumnal glow!