My double heaven pudding 😮‍💨

🍌🤎 DOUBLE HEAVEN BANANA PUDDING

Two sides. Two cookie experiences. One homemade pudding.

Baby, let me tell y’all about THIS dessert! 😘

Introducing my Double Heaven Banana Pudding homemade from scratch, because we are NOT opening pudding boxes over here! 😂👩🏽‍🍳

And when I say double heaven, I mean TWO different sides of banana pudding heaven in ONE pan!

🍌 SIDE ONE: THE CLASSIC

For my classic banana pudding lovers! Homemade banana pudding layered with vanilla wafers in the middle, giving that familiar, nostalgic Southern banana pudding experience. Simple, classic, and made with love. 🤎

🍪 SIDE TWO: THE COOKIE BUTTER DREAM

Now THIS side is for my cookie butter lovers! We’re talking homemade banana pudding infused with Biscoff cookie butter, Chessmen butter cookies in the middle layer , and Biscoff cookies on top and bottom layers . That rich, buttery cookie flavor takes this side to another level! 😮‍💨

👩🏽‍🍳 THE SECRET?

The pudding itself is homemade from scratch. No boxed pudding mixes, baby! 😘 The cookie butter is incorporated right into the pudding, so the flavor goes beyond just adding cookies on top.

✨ Two sides.

✨ Two different cookie layers.

✨ Homemade pudding from scratch.

✨ One pan of DOUBLE HEAVEN!

Which side are you choosing: CLASSIC VANILLA WAFER 🍌 or COOKIE BUTTER BISCOFF 🤎?

Me? I’m making room for BOTH!

#DoubleHeavenBananaPudding #HomemadeBananaPudding #FromScratchBaking #CookieButterLovers #BiscoffDesserts #ChessmanCookies #SouthernDesserts #Lemon8Food #FoodieDiary #HomemadeWithLove

10/20 Edited to

... Read moreIf you love banana pudding but crave variety, making this Double Heaven Banana Pudding at home is a game-changer. From my experience, crafting each side from scratch truly brings out the freshness and deeper flavors you just can’t get from boxed mixes. The classic vanilla wafer side delivers that comforting, nostalgic Southern taste, perfect for sharing with family on a cozy afternoon. But the real showstopper is the cookie butter-infused side. Incorporating Biscoff cookie butter directly into the pudding base, paired with crunchy Chessmen butter cookies, adds an irresistible caramelized, spiced sweetness that complements the bananas beautifully. The layering of cookies throughout is essential—it gives textural contrast and elevates the dessert beyond standard banana pudding. One tip I’ve learned is to chill the pudding overnight. This allows the flavors to meld, the cookies to soften just right, and results in a luscious, creamy texture that’s pure indulgence. Also, using ripe but firm bananas helps maintain freshness without turning mushy. Creating this dual-sided dessert is fun because you get the best of both worlds in one pan—ideal for gatherings where guests have different preferences. Whether you prefer the traditional route or want to experiment with trending cookie butter flavors, this homemade Double Heaven Banana Pudding never disappoints. Trust me, the effort is worth it when everyone’s asking for seconds!

1 comment

𝑴𝒂𝒍𝒊𝒚𝒂𝒉🍓's images
𝑴𝒂𝒍𝒊𝒚𝒂𝒉🍓

❤️

Related posts

The BEST chia seed pudding
High protein chia seed pudding recipe 👇🏻 what you need: 2 tbsp chia seeds 1/2 cup milk 1/2 cup plain or vanilla Greek yogurt Splash vanilla extract Few dashes cinnamon 2 tsp - 1 tbsp maple syrup #chiaseedpudding #healthyfood #breakfastideas #chiapudding
Christine

Christine

27.3K likes

Raspberry Chia Pudding Parfaits 💕
Raspberry Chia Pudding Parfaits 💕 Chia Pudding Ingredients: 1 cup oat milk ¼ cup yogurt vanilla ¼ cup chia seeds 1 cup raspberries Parfait Ingredients: ½ cup chia pudding ½ cup yogurt ¼ cup fresh berries Instructions: 1. Combine the oat milk and raspberries in a blender. Blend for
Kelsey Riley

Kelsey Riley

10.9K likes

Biscoff Banana Pudding 🧡
#bananapuddingtrifle #biscoffbananapudding #dessertrecipe #trifle #bananapuddingcakerecipe Whisk 2 small packages of instant french vanilla pudding with 4 cups cold milk until thick. Put the pudding in fridge while whipping up 3 cups of heavy cream until you have very stiff peaks (Add
Melisa

Melisa

13K likes

Chia Coconut Pudding with Peaches 🥥🍑
Ingredients: chia seeds coconut milk maple syrup or honey (optional) vanilla extract peaches (fresh or canned) Mix chia seeds with coconut milk, a touch of vanilla, and a bit of sweetener if you like. Stir well and let it rest for 10 minutes, then stir again to break up any clumps. Cover an
Aesthetics & Recipes

Aesthetics & Recipes

8146 likes

Dragon fruit chia seed pudding
Dragon fruit chia pudding 💕 Ingredients: 1 cup oat milk ½ cup dragon fruit (fresh or frozen) ¼ cup chia seeds ¼ cup vanilla yogurt Instructions: 1. Blend the dragon fruit and oat milk for 5-10 seconds. 2. Combine all ingredients in a jar or container and mix well. 3. Wait about 3 minut
Kelsey Riley

Kelsey Riley

6467 likes

My chia pudding meal ✨
Ingredients: - 2 tbs chia seeds - 1/2 cup milk of your choice - teaspoon of vanilla extract (optional) - honey - 2 tbs yogurt - add fruit and granola of your choice #chiaseedpudding #chiaseedpuddingrecipe #mealprep #breakfastmealprep #fyp #breakfastmeals #lowcalorierec
Novay Goddess

Novay Goddess

13.3K likes

🍌Healthy Banana Pudding
Healthier Banana Pudding that is SO good! Ingredients 1 Single Serve Non Fat Yogurt 1 TBS SF banana pudding mix 1 Generous TBS SF cool whip Sliced Banana 10-12 mini nilla wafers Instructions Mix yogurt, pudding mix , and cool whip Layer nilla wafers, yogurt mixture, and banana slice
Sarah 💕

Sarah 💕

5314 likes

PEACH PUDDING!!!
I’m always trying something so yessssss go make it!!! #peaches #peach slices #pudding #dessertrecipe #dessertideas #dessertviral #holidayfinds #sweettooth #peachdessert #unfiltered
luvstaste💅🏽

luvstaste💅🏽

1967 likes

Strawberry Banana Pudding
Strawberry Banana Pudding is a layered dessert, combining fresh fruit, strawberry glaze, pudding, and a mix of cookies and vanilla wafers. Perfect for the Holiday's, Valentine's Day or ANY special occasion! This treat gets more indulgent with each creamy spoonful. (Tap the link in my profi
Tamara J

Tamara J

41.7K likes

Not Paula Deen’s Banana Pudding 🍌🤭
•5 bananas •1 - 8oz tub of whipped topping •1 - 3.4 oz pack instant vanilla pudding •1/2 pack of 5.1 oz banana instant pudding (this is where I had to change Paulas recipe. I was out of vanilla pudding and only had the big pack of banana 🤷‍♀️) •1/2 can La Lechera dulce de leche (extra additio
Melisa

Melisa

3899 likes

Mango Chia Pudding with 4 ingredients💛🥭
This snack is not only tasty, but also packed with fiber, healthy fats, and essential nutrients👇🏻 Ingredients: • 1/4 cup chia seeds • 1 cup coconut milk or milk of your preference • 1 mango • 2 tbsp honey Instructions: 1. In a mixing bowl, combine the chia seeds and milk. Mix well.
Gabriela🤍

Gabriela🤍

5738 likes

mango coconut pudding
i made a super easy mango pudding with all the mangos i had sitting in my fridge and it was sooo refreshing! 😊🥭 save this recipe to make your own delicious mango pudding (it can even be made vegan) and don’t forget to follow for more cute and easy dessert recipes! ♡ recipe below! ~ mango cocon
bethany 🐻🍓

bethany 🐻🍓

4414 likes

A clear rectangular dish filled with banana pudding, topped with crumbled vanilla wafers. The image has text overlay that reads "Marry Me BANANA PUDDING".
An overhead shot of all the ingredients for banana pudding, including vanilla wafers, Cool Whip, sweetened condensed milk, vanilla pudding mix, almond milk, bananas, and lemon juice.
A white bowl containing whisked vanilla pudding mix and milk, with a box of vanilla wafers and a can of condensed milk in the background.
Marry Me Banana Pudding
This is the recipe my great-grandmother would use for her banana pudding. Ingredients: • Vanilla wafers, 11oz • Cool whip, 8oz • Sweetened condensed milk, 14oz (specifically Eagle Brand) • Large vanilla pudding mix, approximately 5oz • Milk (I only had vanilla almond milk, any type will
Abby

Abby

13.2K likes

Mini Flan | caramel Pudding and Soft Cake
#softcake #flan #caramelpudding #dessert #recipe Recipe on u-taste.com Ingredients Caramel 55 g granulated sugar (1/3 cup) 15 g water 25 g water (hot) Pudding 2 eggs 1 egg yolk 30 g granulated sugar (3 tbsps) 240 g milk (1 cup) 60 g heavy cream (1/4 cup) 1 tbsp vanill
Jessica | soft cake & u-taste

Jessica | soft cake & u-taste

2825 likes

Delicious Red Velvet Banana Pudding
Red Velvet Banana Pudding – A Southern Remix with a Creamy Twist! I put a decadent spin on banana pudding by layering it with soft red velvet cake, creamy banana pudding made with a hint of cream cheese, and fluffy homemade whipped cream. It’s rich, nostalgic, and melts in your mouth! Here’s
Kooking Kayla 👩🏾‍🍳

Kooking Kayla 👩🏾‍🍳

2437 likes

Banana Pudding???
Protein Banana Pudding > 🍌 Sweet tooth and want a quick snack? Try it out. Super quick, healthier alternative and so gooood 😋 Ingredients ⬇️ 💎 Plain Greek Yogurt @oikos 💎 Banana Cream Flavor @jello 💎 Bananas 💎 Mini Nilla Wafers How to make⬇️ 💎 Add your Plain Greek Yogurt t
Jazmyhn Catlin

Jazmyhn Catlin

2985 likes

Banana Pudding Rice Krispie Treats 🍌
Banana pudding just got a crispy, gooey twist! 🍌✨ These Banana Pudding Rice Krispie Treats are made with browned butter, vanilla wafers, and banana crème pudding – they’re the perfect sweet bite. Who’s ready to dig in? #BananaPudding #RiceKrispieTreats #DessertIdeas #SweetTreats #Ba
EricaOnTheEats

EricaOnTheEats

3170 likes

Chia seed pudding 4 ways!
Not only is chia seed pudding super easy to make (it takes 5 minutes to prepare!), but it's also delicious and great for preparing ahead of time. One of my favorite things about these recipes is that you can make such a wide variety of tasty combinations that are delicious, filling, & very
BalancedLife

BalancedLife

5694 likes

A rectangular pan holds a strawberry banana pudding cheesecake dessert. It features a pink crumbly base topped with round Nilla Wafers and square Chessman butter cookies, garnished with a fresh strawberry in the center.
A rectangular pan holds a strawberry banana pudding cheesecake dessert. It features a pink crumbly base topped with round Nilla Wafers and square Chessman butter cookies, garnished with a fresh strawberry in the center. A Nilla Wafers box is visible in the background.
A rectangular pan holds a strawberry banana pudding cheesecake dessert. It features a pink crumbly base topped with round Nilla Wafers and square Chessman butter cookies, garnished with a fresh strawberry in the center. A Nilla Wafers box is visible in the background.
Strawberry Banana Pudding Cheescake🩷
Ingredients: 1 Box Strawberry Cake Mix 1 Box Cheesecake Pudding Mix 1 Box Banana Cream Pudding Mix 8 oz Whipped Cream Cheese 1 can condensed milk 1 tsp Vanilla Extract 1 tsp Cinnamon 8 oz Cool Whip Strawberries 🍓 Bananas 🍌 Bananas Nilla Wafers Chessman Butter Cookies 🍪 Che
k3ndall

k3ndall

1952 likes

A close-up of Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding served in a foil container. It features creamy pudding, strawberry sauce, fresh whole strawberries, sliced bananas, and a generous topping of golden-brown crunch, showcasing the dessert's vibrant layers and textures.
Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding Recipe 🍓🍌

#cozyrecipes #lemon8challenge Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding 🍓🍌 Ingredients:🔥🔥 For the Banana Pudding:🚨 2 cups whole milk 1/2 cup granulated sugar 1/3 cup cornstarch 1/4 tsp salt 1 tsp vanilla extract 3 large bananas, sliced 1 cup whipped topping (like Cool Whip) For the
Jakari Lashika

Jakari Lashika

2087 likes

A banana pudding cupcake in a white liner, topped with piped white frosting, fresh banana slices, a golden drizzle, and crushed vanilla wafers. Another cupcake is visible in the background on a white serving dish.
🍌🧁 Banana Pudding Cupcakes Heaven! 🧁🍌
📝 **Ingredients:** Banana Cupcakes: - 1 ¼ cups all-purpose flour - 1 tsp baking powder - ½ tsp baking soda - ¼ tsp salt - ½ cup unsalted butter, softened - ½ cup granulated sugar - ¼ cup brown sugar - 2 ripe bananas, mashed - 2 large eggs - 1 tsp vanilla extract - ¼ cup sour cream or
Angelinaaaaa

Angelinaaaaa

2402 likes

➡️My favorite kind of #chiapudding
➡️My favorite kind of #chiapudding - coconut cream;🥥 -chia seeds; -banana; -berrys; -coconut flakes Seattle
Liubov

Liubov

722 likes

STRAWBERRY CRUNCH BANANA PUDDING 🍓🍌
Pudding: 3oz box banana cream instant pudding 2 cups whole milk 8oz cream cheese (room temp) 14oz can condensed milk 3-4 bananas sliced 1 cup sliced strawberries 1 1/4 cup heavy whipping cream 1/2 box Nilla wafers (I used mini) Topping: 1/2 cup all purpose flour divided 1/2 cup ro
Shalean Ghitis

Shalean Ghitis

24K likes

Three glass containers hold mango chia seed pudding, topped with vibrant diced mango pieces. The image features text overlays 'mango chia seed pudding recipe' and 'SWIPE', indicating a recipe post.
mango chia seed pudding recipe 🥭🥥
craving a yummy but healthy treat?! ingredients: 1 cup organic greek yogurt 1 cup unsweetened coconut milk 1/3 cup chia seeds 3 tablespoons vanilla extract (or to taste) mango (chopped to add on top) optional toppings: coconut flakes cacao nibs sliced almonds this is totally option
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

1207 likes

Dumbledore lemon drop pudding
recipe—200 g granulated sugar 55 g butter, softened 85 g all-purpose/plain flour 3 large eggs, separated 340 ml milk Confectioners/icing sugar, for dusting #pudding #lemon #harrypotter #
Belle

Belle

1199 likes

✨Banana Pudding Cheesecake Heaven 🤤
📒Notes: Vanilla wafers crust ✔️ Two whole bananas baked in it ✔️ Homemade whip cream ✔️ Vanilla pudding ✔️ Caramel ✔️ #banana #bananapuddingremix #bananapudding #dessert #dessertideas
Ale 💞

Ale 💞

2336 likes

Chia Seed Pudding Parfaits 🌱✨💕
Chia Seed Parfait Recipe 🌱✨💕 Chia pudding ingredients: 1 cup oat milk ¼ cup yogurt vanilla ¼ cup chia seeds Parfaits ½ cup chia pudding ½ cup yogurt ¼ teaspoon superfood powder ¼ cup fresh fruit Head to my website for the full recipe 🩵 #healthylifestyle2024 #mealprep #mealprepi
Kelsey Riley

Kelsey Riley

11.6K likes

A finished banana pudding in a clear glass dish, topped with whole and crushed vanilla wafers and banana slices. The text overlay reads "Marry Me BANANA PUDDING," with fresh bananas visible in the background.
Various ingredients for banana pudding are displayed on a kitchen counter, including milk, vanilla wafers, whipped topping, sweetened condensed milk, pudding mix, and bananas. The text overlay says "ingredients."
A clear glass bowl contains the prepared vanilla pudding mixture. The text overlay indicates "1. Prepare the pudding."
viral banana pudding recipe
This is the best banana pudding recipe I’ve ever tried, and I’m happy to share it with you! Ingredients: • Vanilla wafers, 11oz • Cool whip, 8oz • Sweetened condensed milk, 14oz • Large vanilla pudding mix • Milk • Lemon juice for bananas • Bananas (1-2 minimum) 1. Add the recommende
irianna

irianna

6847 likes

Dairy Free Banana Pudding | Vegan
My updated Vegan Banana Pudding recipe is here, just in time for the holidays! Give it a try, and let me know what you think! #lemon8diarychallenge #KaySoPlantBased #KaySoGrand #holidayrecipes #bananapudding
Kay Brittany

Kay Brittany

6661 likes

Banana pudding recipe
Quick and easy banana pudding recipe 👩🏽‍🍳 #bananapuddingrecipe #bananapudding #homemade🍌 pudding #homemadebananapudding
TopTierCook

TopTierCook

5122 likes

Banana Pudding
https://cookerofdeliciousness.com/the-best-banana-pudding/ #foodoflemon8 #bananapudding #easyrecipe #dessertideas
CODofficial

CODofficial

14.1K likes

The BEST Banana Pudding Cookies 🍌
This is a loved cookie in this household! They are so delicious and taste just like banana pudding! 💛🫶🏻 Ingredients: 12 tablespoons butter ¾ cup light brown sugar ¼ cup white sugar 3.4 ounces instant banana cream pudding dry mix only 2 large eggs 1 teaspoon vanilla 1 teaspoon baking soda
Meghz 🥑

Meghz 🥑

3766 likes

Many Flavors Of Banana Pudding 😋
Get Into My Five Flavors Of Banana Pudding ⬇️ Regular Banana Pudding Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding Oreo Banana Pudding Strawberry Banana Pudding Peach Cobbler Mmmmm Mmmmm Good ! This Is Some Of The Best Banana Pudding You Could Ever Get Your Hands On ! Follow My Business Page On
Kei

Kei

1331 likes

A hand holds a black rectangular container filled with strawberry banana protein pudding. The dessert features a light base, topped with whipped cream, crushed graham crackers, and a generous scattering of diced strawberries and banana pieces.
Strawberry Banana Protein Pudding 🍓🍌
These protein puddings are one thing that has satisfied my cravings while still adding nutritional value into my diet! If you like this one, check out the Oreo one on my profile! 🫶🏻 Ingredients: 1 bottle of FairLife Core Protein Shake - make sure it’s the 42g of protein one (Can use Strawberry
Megs 🖤🗡️📚

Megs 🖤🗡️📚

6412 likes

healthy banana pudding
will you try this?
sarah rankin

sarah rankin

3467 likes

A close-up shot of several banana pudding cookies, topped with a white drizzle and crushed vanilla wafers. The image features text overlays "BANANA PUDDING cookies" and "LOVE IT!", along with Lemon8 branding.
Easy & Tasty Banana Pudding Cookies 🍌🍪
Fun fact: A huge dream of mine is to open my own cafe! I plan to have a lot of home made sweet treats there soI thought to myself, why not begin practicing now while also making a name for myself in town! I sell these amongst other cookies at work & they’re a favorite of my coworkers so I thoug
Bri 🐝🫶🏾

Bri 🐝🫶🏾

2244 likes

Strawberry banana pudding ❤️
Here’s how I make my pudding Follow the measurements on the pudding & just add As much whip cream and the condensed milk as you want! - Bananna cream jello mix - Vanilla pudding jello mix - wafer cookies - chessman cookies - cool whip - used 4 bannnas - about 8 strawberries #h
Amber_Lovee

Amber_Lovee

3267 likes

✨Banana Pudding Cookies🍌✨
These banana pudding cookies are dangerously good 😩✨ Soft, sweet, and loaded with banana flavor — plus that creamy drizzle? Game over. 🍌🍪 #BananaPuddingCookies #SoftCookies #SouthernDesserts #BakingTok #Lemon8Kitchen
kyla.symone

kyla.symone

3399 likes

Banana Pudding No bananas❗️😍✨
Banana Pudding cookie overload 😍 #bananapudding #cookiebutter #cookierecipes #bananapuddingcakerecipe #dessertrecipes try at home !
Autumn Saioré 🌹

Autumn Saioré 🌹

877 likes

A close-up of Magnolia Bakery style banana pudding, topped with whole vanilla wafers and crushed crumbs, with a red spoon partially visible. The text overlay reads 'MAGNOLIA BAKERY STYLE BANANA PUDDING'.
Sweetened condensed milk is being poured from a can into a clear glass bowl, with a text overlay indicating '7oz can of sweetened condensed milk'.
Water is being poured into a clear glass bowl containing sweetened condensed milk, with a text overlay stating 'Add 3 cups of water'.
✨Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Recipe at Home 😋🤍☀️
Magnolia Bakery - Grand Central #NY #baking #foodie #dessert #Lemon8Diary #home #pudding #bananas #vanillascent
E N E S S A

E N E S S A

8174 likes

A banana pudding cake viewed from above, topped with vanilla wafers, whipped cream swirls, and a square cookie featuring a crown design, set against a floral background.
A side view of a banana pudding cake, decorated with vanilla wafers and square cookies with crown designs around its white frosted sides, with whipped cream visible on top.
A close-up side view of a banana pudding cake, adorned with vanilla wafers and square cookies featuring crown designs on its white frosted exterior, with whipped cream on top.
Banana Pudding Cake 🍌🤤
This banana pudding cake is as delicious as it looks! This is by far a bestseller for my business. Someone gets one of these at least 2-3 a week lol 😂 #terinstreats #bananapuddingcake #bananas #banana #bananacake #bananapudding #cakeideas #yummycake #yummycakes #deliciouscake
Terin Chambers

Terin Chambers

2484 likes

Ina Garten’s Brownie Pudding
This brownie pudding is on a whole different level… so moist, so rich, and honestly it tastes just like a giant lava cake. Every bite is pure chocolate heaven. I found this recipe on the @Food Network website from @inagwrten and tweaked it just a bit. #browniepudding #brownies #dessertlov
Emanskitchen

Emanskitchen

344 likes

BANANA CHEESECAKE PUDDING
This is not your mamas banana pudding recipe it’s wayyy better!!!! FAMILY SIZE BOX OF NILLA WAFERS 2 BLOCKS OF ROOM TEMP CREAM CHEESE BOX OF VANILLA INSTANT PUDDING BOX OF BANANA INSTANT PUDDING 5 RIPE BANANAS 2 TSP VANILLA EXTRACT BIG TUB OF COOL WHIP 4 CUPS COLD MILK 2 CANS CONDENSED
Niz Sousa

Niz Sousa

1724 likes

Banana Pudding Rice Krispy Treats
Banana Pudding Rice Krispy Treats are absolutely delicious!!! Im obsessed! Original recipe comes from Treated Royal. #bananapudding #ricekrispietreats #combo #easydessert
Bugsy&Company

Bugsy&Company

2178 likes

Banana Pudding cheesecake
Banana Pudding Cheesecake with Salted Caramel Ingredients: For the Crust: 1 ½ cups Nilla Wafer crumbs ¼ cup granulated sugar ½ cup unsalted butter, melted For the Cheesecake Layers: 24 oz cream cheese, softened 1 cup granulated sugar 3 large eggs 1 cup sour cream ¼
ItsJusssGi

ItsJusssGi

5412 likes

See more