Review for Heart Bones by Colleen Hoover

There was nothing in particular that was wrong with this book. But I have to be honest, while I was reading it I couldn't quite believe this is something Colleen Hoover wrote. At one point I checked the cover just to make sure her name was actually on it. I know her last few books have sort of detoured from the usual romantic genre she has written in. And while this one had some romance, it fell a little flat for me.

The rest of this review (sort of) contains spoilers, so read with caution.

Basically, the plot of the book was:

Beyah is a sad person.

Beyah meets Samson, who is sad person.

We know why Beyah is sad, but we don't really know why Samson is sad (I mean if you squint your eyes and really try, you can probably guess why).

Beyah and Samson are sad together and like to make out while being sad.

Predictable plot twist occurs.

"My mom died, lol" - Beyah to her dad.

Vague, then sort of cute ending.

The end.

So while this didn't really live up to my expectations,

- no memorable characters, no distinctive humorous scenes, really no tension at all - it was still a pretty decent read. Definitely not up there with my favorites

#lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #BookReview #readersoflemon8

2024/5/9 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so you've heard about Colleen Hoover's 'Heart Bones,' and maybe you're wondering what it's all about, especially after reading my initial thoughts. As someone who's read quite a few of CoHo's books, I wanted to dive a bit deeper into what makes 'Heart Bones' tick, covering some of the aspects I know many of you search for – like the characters, a proper summary, and what to expect from the ending. First off, let's talk about the Heart Bones characters. At its core, we have Beyah Grim, a young woman who's had a really tough life, growing up in poverty with a neglectful mother. She's fiercely independent and guarded. Then there's Samson, a seemingly privileged guy from a wealthy family, but he carries his own heavy burdens and secrets. Their paths cross during a summer in Texas, and it's their shared sense of loneliness and sadness that initially draws them together. What makes them compelling, despite my earlier skepticism, is the quiet intensity of their connection and how they slowly peel back layers of their pasts to find solace in each other. For those looking for a Heart Bones summary without giving away every single beat, here's the gist: Beyah is forced to move in with her estranged father and his new family for the summer after a tragic event. She expects a quiet, transient existence before heading off to college. Instead, she meets Samson, her wealthy neighbor. Their relationship isn't a whirlwind romance; it's a slow burn built on mutual understanding, unspoken pain, and a unique 'summer only' arrangement. They both harbor significant secrets, and a big part of the book is about these secrets gradually coming to light and how they impact their fragile bond. It's a story steeped in themes of grief, socioeconomic disparity, first love, and the pursuit of healing. Now, about the Heart Bones ending – without giving away the final twist, I can say that it aims for a bittersweet, hopeful resolution. Like many of Colleen Hoover's books, there's often a significant reveal or challenge that the characters must overcome. In 'Heart Bones,' the ending ties up the loose ends surrounding Samson's mysterious past and Beyah's future, leaving readers with a sense of closure while still acknowledging the complexities of their journey. It's an ending that tries to offer a glimmer of light after a somewhat darker, more emotionally charged narrative. And for those curious about the Heart Bones book cover, it typically features a simple yet evocative design, often with minimalistic elements or symbolic imagery that hints at the story's emotional depth. It definitely sets a certain mood even before you dive in. Reflecting on my overall 'reading experience' with 'Heart Bones,' if I were to rate it on a scale of 1 to 5, it probably landed around a 3.2 for me – a solid, if not groundbreaking, read. While it might not be my absolute favorite CoHo, it definitely offers a unique reading journey for those who appreciate stories about overcoming adversity and finding unexpected connections. It's a reminder that sometimes, even when things feel a little off the usual path, there's still value in the journey.

Related posts

A woman smiles while holding a phone, with text overlay "COLLEEN HOOVER BOOKS I'VE READ FAVORITE TO LEAST FAVORITE" indicating a ranking of her books.
A hand holds the book "Heart Bones" by Colleen Hoover, rated 10/10, described as the best book with a huge plot twist that made the reader cry.
A hand holds the book "November 9" by Colleen Hoover, rated 10/10, with the comment that the reader cried and the plot is different.
Colleen Hoover Books Favorite To Least Favorite
I’ve never read a bad book by her! Next read is Too Late! :)
madison marie ⚡️🦆🖤

madison marie ⚡️🦆🖤

418 likes

Heart Bones by Colleen Hoover
Omg i loved loved this book. 10/10. It's honestly my favorite book of hers. Beautifully written #bookwormsoflemon8 #colleenhoover #lemon8challenge #Lemon8Diary
Alexis Hoke

Alexis Hoke

4 likes

A person holds Colleen Hoover's 'Heart Bones' book on a boat, overlooking a lake and mountains. A pink note with three stars states 'EXPLORES THE BEAUTIFUL COMPLEXITIES OF LOVE AND LOSS'. 'BOOK REVIEW' is overlaid.
Book Review: Heart Bones 💝
📚 Genre: Romance 💭 My Thoughts: The storyline is captivating, the collision of such different worlds allows for some beautiful intimate moments. As the character makes difficult decisions she learns about friendship, sisterhood, and romance - truly hard to put down. ⭐ Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Brittney

Brittney

17 likes

A stack of Colleen Hoover books including Verity, Maybe Not, and Reminders of Him, with an overlay text 'Rating Colleen Hoover Books' and decorative pink and blue elements.
The book cover for Colleen Hoover's 'Verity' with a rating of 6.5/10 displayed on a banner. The cover features a figure made of golden threads.
The book cover for Colleen Hoover's 'Ugly Love' featuring blue text and water bubbles, with a rating of 8/10 on a banner.
Rating Colleen Hoover Books ✨
-verity: overhyped, predictable, not too bad, just didn’t get the hype, lots of plot twists though 🩶 -ugly love: great story, sad, made me cry 🩷 -reminders of him: made me SOB, just took really long to get to the end, ending was rushed I feel like, and took too long to get there, but very goo
Mel Santiago

Mel Santiago

6 likes

📖 BOOK BLOG | Heart Bones by Colleen Hoover
“People can’t always be who you want them to be.” 💔 Genre: New Adult, Romance, Coming-of-Age 📚 Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5) 🌊 Vibes: Summer sunsets, hidden pain, found family, emotional slow burn 🩵 My Thoughts: This book wrecked me in the most beautiful way. Heart Bones isn’t your typical romance
Patty🌷

Patty🌷

8 likes

A hand holds Colleen Hoover's 'Too Late' book, featuring a dark cover with distressed orange text, against a soft, light-colored blanket. A 'BOOK REVIEW' graphic is overlaid, along with a heart outline and Lemon8 branding.
Review for Too Late by Colleen Hoover
⭐️:4.2 🌶️:3 this book is very confronting. I can do almost anything - and when I saw the trigger warning at the start I rolled my eyes thinking "it's Colleen Hoover... it can't be that triggering" WOAH was I wrong Imao. This was so full on, yet so captivating. Some parts were
Hope Wilhelmina

Hope Wilhelmina

5 likes

why I don’t support Colleen Hoover
A lot of people on my YouTube have been asking and commenting why I don’t support Colleen Hoover, so here’s why! do you support Colleen Hoover? #lemon8bookchallenge #lemon8bookclub #spiciestbooks #booktok #bookrecs
Readers.archive

Readers.archive

2474 likes

My Favorite collen hoover books ratings
⭐️Overall rating: /10/10 for all these books
(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

(☆Boo𝙺diaries(☆

201 likes

A bookstore display features multiple stacks of Colleen Hoover books, including 'Confess,' 'Reminders of Him,' 'Without Merit,' 'All Your Perfects,' 'Ugly Love,' 'Verity,' and 'Maybe Someday.' A promotional poster with a silhouetted couple is in the background. Text overlays ask for 'Thoughts on Colleen Hoover?' and mention 'Lemon8 bookclub'.
thoughts on Colleen Hoover ?
i've always been told not to read her books but i've never gotten a reason why tiktok was just so influencing on hating what's everyone thoughts or opinions on her books? ✨Please let me know✨ #colleenhooverreview #colleenhoover #colleenhooverbooks #booktok #BookRevie
senora ��💛

senora 💛

227 likes

Colleen Hoover Review
My honest reviews of the Colleen Hoover books I’ve read. She got me started into reading, but I have since moved on for obvious reasons. #lemon8bookclub #colleenhoover #books #BookReview
Nat Rose

Nat Rose

336 likes

Honest Review - It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover
Rating- (-5)/5⭐️( potential spoilers) Move over, Girlboss, Gatekeep, Gaslight—get ready for Love Bomb, Impregnate, Abuse. Ugh, I don’t know why I keep doing this to myself. 😂 I’m just not a Colleen Hoover fan after reading several of her books (no hate to those who are—she’s just not my cup of te
Torre

Torre

9 likes

Guide to Colleen Hoover books!
All the books in this post are Young Adult (14+) by Colleen Hoover 1) Without Merit 2) Regretting You 3) Heart Bones 4) Never Never Series: 1) Slammed 2) Point of Retreat 3) This Girl
Mansehaj_K

Mansehaj_K

10 likes

A hand holds Colleen Hoover's book 'Confess' with 'CURRENTLY READING' text overlay. The book cover displays 'CONFESS a novel COLLEEN HOOVER #1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLING AUTHOR'. The setting is outdoors on a sunny day with green grass and a resort in the background.
CONFESS BY COLLEEN HOOVER
Colleen Hoover is an amazing author if your are interested in romance novels. I USED TO HATE READING AND NOW I LOVE IT! Reading has never been more fun for me thanks to her! I just started reading confess and the love language has me hooked! If you like a good mystery about what is going to hap
Mollyyreyess

Mollyyreyess

12 likes

Finding Perfect by Colleen Hoover. 🎀
So I was looking for books that had to do with Thanksgiving season and this book had the word Thanksgiving on the back. It’s a very small book which is refreshing so I decided to grab it. Come to find out it’s a conclusion to the hopeless series by Colleen Hoover so I read the ending before the res
Brook

Brook

23 likes

A special collector's edition of Colleen Hoover's book "Verity" stands upright on a wooden surface. The cover features abstract, tangled lines forming a figure and its reflection, with the title "Verity" and author's name prominently displayed. An overlay reads "BOOK REVIEW" with a pin icon, and a Lemon8 watermark is in the corner.
BOOK REVIEW #2 VERITY BY COLLEEN HOOVER
Lowen Ashleigh is a struggling writer on the brink of financial ruin when she accepts the job offer of a lifetime. Jeremy Crawford, husband of bestselling author Verity Crawford, has hired Lowen to complete the remaining books in a successful series his injured wife is unable to finish. Little Does
briana

briana

9 likes

It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover
🌶️🌶️ 😭😭😭😭😭 I been putting it off and putting it off but it was finally time especially with the movie coming out next month. I wasn’t ready for the emotional damage that I was about to receive. It was not the first and certainly won’t be the last she has done this to me but it was worth it. I cou
Bookedbykirsten

Bookedbykirsten

5 likes

Heart Bones
Annotating for the first time. Picked Heart Bones by Colleen Hoover because it’s my absolute favorite CoHo book! I’m having so much fun so far! #colleenhoover #heart bones by colleen hoover #annotating #bookaesthetic #bookwormsoflemon8
Abigail Gleaves

Abigail Gleaves

0 likes

A hand holds the book 'Heart Bones' by Colleen Hoover, featuring a cover with two skull outlines and colorful floral designs. Overlaid text indicates '3.8 Jordann's Score' and '4.2 Good Reads', along with review tags like 'Romance w.o being over the top', 'Subtle Plot Twist', and 'Beating the Odds'.
Heart Bones ~ Honest Book Review!
Book Name: Heart Bones 💔 🦴 Author: Colleen Hoover Genre: Romance I am not sure how I found this book but I thought it was going to be more of a mystery than a romance - so I was genuinely surprised that it kept my attention. SN: This is my first romance novel I read! It was a qui
Jordann

Jordann

3 likes

Honest Review: Without Merit by Colleen Hoover
Genre: Contemporary romance, Psychological Fiction, Domestic Fiction Intro: The Voss family is anything but normal. They live in a repurposed church, newly baptized Dollar Voss. The once cancer-stricken mother lives in the basement, the father is married to the mother’s former nurse, the little ha
CourtneyAMadison

CourtneyAMadison

5 likes

The book cover for Colleen Hoover's "It Starts With Us," a #1 New York Times Bestseller and Exclusive Collector's Edition. The light blue cover features dark blue text, a yellow daffodil illustration, and small speckles, resting on a gray textured surface. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.
Book Review: It Starts With Us by Colleen Hoover
Title: It Starts With Us Author: Colleen Hoover Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (5/5 stars) I never read the first book and only watched It Ends With Us on Netflix, but it definitely left me needing more. Thankfully, It Starts With Us delivered. It continues Lily and Atlas’s story, focusing on healing, sec
Leilani

Leilani

4 likes

📖 Book Review: It Ends With Us By: Colleen Hoover
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 Favorite Quote: “If you ever find yourself in a position to fall in love again, fall in love with me.” - Atlas Corrigan 📒— This book is the book that has gotten a lot of readers back into reading & I see why! There’s a lot of hate surrounding this author. Some say she “
MarisolMelendez

MarisolMelendez

18 likes

Book Review
It Starts With Us by Colleen Hoover
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️ 😭😭😭😭 I totally agree that it ends with us could of been a standalone and completed as is. But I also think that it starts with us was just as perfect. I loved it. I loved hearing Atlas’s side of the story. I loved seeing the challenges of Lily and Riles coparenting. I feel we n
Bookedbykirsten

Bookedbykirsten

10 likes

A hand holds Colleen Hoover's book 'Verity', which has a dark cover with golden, abstract, tangled lines forming a figure. Overlays read 'Best book hands down' and 'Colleen Hoover'. The image also features decorative sparkles, a lemon emoji, and 'Lemon8 @autumn_beecroft' branding.
Verity by Colleen Hoover
Best book hands down that I’ve read so far. I finished this book in 8 hours because I could not put it down for the life of me. The suspense this book has, it’s romantic, thriller, and all around an amazing book. I’ve seen this come up as recommendations and I would have to agree 10/10 recommend.
Autumn | SAHM

Autumn | SAHM

6 likes

Heart Bones by Colleen Hoover 🫀
One thing I didn't expect this book to do was tug at my own heart bones 😭 I can honestly relate to Beyah in so many ways, starting with the disconnect between her & her parents. She blossomed so beautifully throughout the progression of this novel, though. I'm glad she never gave up on
softgirljuju🩷

softgirljuju🩷

0 likes

See more