Frog it or finish? I can’t decide!

I’ve learned over the years that if I’m not fully loving the result I’m getting, it’s better to just start over or to frog it to the point where I do like it again and try another way. But there’s been a few projects that I’ve ignored this advice and still kept trying anyways! Then I end up with bins of projects that I don’t like, taking up space.

Help me finish these projects! I need fresh eyes and a different perspective. What would you do with these fails?

#crochetaddiction #crochetproject #crochethelp @Lemon8 US #crochetcommunity #crochetideas

2025/10/23 Edited to

... Read moreCrochet projects can often lead to unexpected challenges, especially when the original design doesn't turn out as planned. Many crafters face the dilemma of whether to frog (undo) a project or push through to finish it, even if the result isn’t initially satisfying. From star scarves losing their shape to clouds that may not be pretty enough for pillows, there are simple ways to rescue these fails. One effective approach is repurposing parts of a failed project. For example, if the star-shaped motifs won’t hold their form, consider using them as decorative appliqués on bags or cushions instead of assembling them into a scarf. This repurposing not only saves your work but also adds unique elements to other crafts. When it comes to animal shapes like a dinosaur or a bear that aren’t meeting expectations, simplifying details can give them a charming, quirky look. Adding faces or playful features may transform an 'ugly mess' into a lovable toy. Alternatively, these pieces could be turned into keychains or ornaments if the larger project feels overwhelming. For textured pieces like towels aimed at a 'cute messy' look but end up messy in an unintended way, finishing techniques like weaving in ends neatly or adding a border could elevate the aesthetics. Sometimes, subtle finishing touches make a big difference in overall appeal. Trying new stitch patterns or combining colors differently in partially completed blankets or pillows may also revive the project. Taking a step back and assessing the possibilities with fresh eyes often reveals innovative fixes. Lastly, embracing experimentation and knowing when to frog projects ultimately saves space and energy, preventing bins filled with half-loved creations. Sharing these experiences with the crochet community can provide new insights and encouragement, turning challenges into inspiring creative journeys.

53 comments

LuridAcord's images
LuridAcord

Making these would be so cute!

See more(10)
Pretzel's images
Pretzel

Turn the cloud upside down and make it a skull pillow for Halloween

See more(1)

See more comments

Related posts

Should I Finish This Crochet Shrug or Start Over?
🧶 Still working on this crochet shrug and I can’t decide… should I keep going or frog it and try a different stitch pattern? 🤔 I’m using this gorgeous ombré yarn and loving how the colors are pooling into the squares, but I’m torn if I should finish it as a shrug or turn it into something else. Wh
Tasha Crafty Creations

Tasha Crafty Creations

14 likes

This image shows the title slide for an article on "PRODUCTIVITY HACKS How to Get Sh*t Done!", featuring bold text over a background of a desk with handwritten notes, sticky notes, and a planner, setting the stage for productivity tips.
A hand holds a green sticky note illustrating the "EAT THE FROG" productivity hack. It features a drawing of a frog and text advising to "Do your most challenging task at the start of your day," aligning with the article's explanation.
A hand holds a green sticky note detailing the "KANBAN BOARD" method. The note displays a diagram with "To Do," "Working On," and "Complete" columns, illustrating how to categorize tasks into three groups as described in the article.
9 Productivity Hacks: Finish What You Started
There are many techniques that help you finish your coursework, home chores, or just normal life tasks. Sometimes they can pile up and become overwhelming. Here are 9 productivity hacks that help me finish things, like this blog 😊: EAT THE FROG The “frog” is considered your most important and d
Jau 🤎

Jau 🤎

3021 likes

A hand holds a small, light green crocheted frog with a white belly and a pink flower on its head. The image has text overlays: "Cute Frog Pattern," "free pattern," and "and crochet contest."
A text slide titled "LILYFROGGY PATTERN" introduces a new, beginner-friendly, free pattern for a lilypad froggy, encouraging users to scroll for contest details and warning against copying the pattern.
A text slide lists the "MATERIALS" required for the crochet project, including yarn, a crochet hook, scissors, stuffing, and optional safety eyes. It also defines common "ABBREVIATIONS" used in crochet patterns.
Cute Frog Pattern✨
Don't forget to save this pattern to your profile! This pattern is by little.rocsa on Instagram! #lemon8diarychallenge #amigurumi #crochetforbeginners #crochet #frog
Desirae

Desirae

182 likes

can't decide if I look better happy or serious lol
#PhotoDump
Milan Trinity

Milan Trinity

19 likes

Can’t decide 🤷🏾‍♀️
I can’t decide whether I truly enjoy Alani & reap any benefits or simply just like this aesthetic. Is it a placebo? #alaninutrition #fitness #protein
Sassy

Sassy

542 likes

✨Cute Frog Pattern✨
Don't forget to save this to your profile! This pattern is by cuteville_toys on Instagram ❤️ #lemon8diarychallenge #crochet #amigurumi #freepattern
Desirae

Desirae

146 likes

A detailed black and white full sleeve tattoo on a person's arm, featuring a tall stack of books intertwined with large floral designs, set against a blurred background of bookshelves.
A black and white tattoo on an arm depicting a raven perched atop a stack of books, with a lit candle casting light beside the books.
A vibrant, colorful tattoo on a thigh showing a winding staircase made of books, leading up a path through a lush forest with tall pine trees and autumn foliage.
Book Tattoo I can’t decide
#tattooideas #bookgirlie
💜 Samantha  )•¥|\|€R 💜

💜 Samantha )•¥|\|€R 💜

78 likes

if you can’t decide on your digital product…
If you keep going back and forth on what to create, this is exactly why nothing’s getting done. This digital planner gives you a simple step-by-step plan, daily tasks, and a clear path so you can finally choose one idea and finish it. Link in bio 💛 #digitalproducts #makemoneyonline
teisa🌺

teisa🌺

0 likes

A hand holds a tall stack of self-development and business books, including "Atomic Habits," "The Psychology of Money," "The Courage to Be Disliked," "Talk Like TED," and "Make Your Bed," against an outdoor, sunny background.
It’s fall time cozy up with a book or two
If you decide to cozy up with a book, incorporate a few of these into the mix to feed your self development and business development soul. I’ll drop some good story based books later. #bookworm #booktok #bookrecommendations
Koldestlife

Koldestlife

70 likes

Your Fresh Start Begins When You Decide
It’s never too late to hit the reset button on your life, your goals, or your dreams. Starting over doesn’t require perfect timing or the “right” day of the week—it only requires a moment of courage and a decision to move forward. Whether it’s Monday morning, Wednesday afternoon, or any random mome
J

J

128 likes

Today I used the Eisenhower Matrix to prioritize my day 📝 It’s mid-terms season and I am busy busy busy. I added in the “eat the frog” concept by doing the item from the urgent/important category that I was looking forward to the least so that it would just be done. I was able to finish everything
Nikki

Nikki

0 likes

Don’t stew, don’t fight. Decide, finish, move on.
Jen glenn

Jen glenn

8 likes

Do it girl, Decide now. You, or him!
Dark Siren Ebook in bio. (only for powerful women) #powerfulwomen #womenoflemon8 #booktok
𝔇𝔞𝔯𝔨 𝔖𝔦𝔯𝔢𝔫𝔞 🌑🥀

𝔇𝔞𝔯𝔨 𝔖𝔦𝔯𝔢𝔫𝔞 🌑🥀

89 likes

Q4 Planning: 7 Steps to Finish the Year Strong
As we enter the final quarter of the year, it’s time to take stock of your goals and make a solid plan to end the year on a high note.... Quarter 4 is the perfect opportunity to reflect, refocus, and push toward your ambitions. Here are 7 steps to help you plan for a successful and productive Q
Belle Grubb

Belle Grubb

23 likes

It’s been three days… I cannot decide. Help 🥹
Okay… swipe to see our options here…. Leave a comment and I’ll seriously dig through these. I’ve been staring at a screen for so long I can’t even tell which one I like anymore. It’s all a blur now 🥲 Follow for themes and fun content. Thanks lemon8 friends! 🙂‍↔️✨ #ipadplanner #ipadaesthe
✨Screenary✨

✨Screenary✨

21 likes

A serene landscape features a solitary evergreen tree in a field with patches of snow, backed by a forest and hills under an overcast sky. Overlaid text reads: "When things are falling apart, they may actually be falling into place." The image conveys a message of hope and perspective during challenging times.
Falling apart? Or falling into place? You decide
Sometimes, it feels like everything is crumbling around you. But what if those breakdowns are breakthroughs in disguise? Remember, just because it feels like things are falling apart doesn’t mean they aren’t falling into place. Trust the process. Let the universe rearrange things in your favor, eve
Soulphoria

Soulphoria

51 likes

I can’t decide?!?!!
Are you a kindle girlie or a physical books girlie? I want a kindle but every time I try to e-read I go back to my physical book. There’s just something about having a book as a trophy 🏆😂 #looking into getting a kindle #kindlebookclub #lemon8bookclub #book
Krazylife<3

Krazylife<3

3 likes

You need the rage to start… but the obsession to finish. I heard that the other
You need the rage to start… but the obsession to finish. I heard that the other day and it stuck with me. The rage is real. It’s the frustration, the pain, the moment you decide enough is enough. That’s what gets you moving. But rage doesn’t last. What actually changes your life is the
Randy Orchen

Randy Orchen

0 likes

I can’t decide 💭👻
Snapchat+ has so many premium features to choose from to design your chat page, change your icon to many more perks. I finally decided to pick a green icon since we are right around the corner from #stpatricksday #springbreak #Lemon8Diary #shareyourthoughts #helpmechoose #livephoto #Le
Ms_Daisy

Ms_Daisy

14 likes

A hand wearing a leather finger protector holds a light green needle-felted frog with black eyes. Text overlays read "NEEDLE FELTING MR. FROG" and "no thoughts just vibes." A thought bubble icon is above the frog, and a needle felting tool and wool roving are visible on a wooden surface.
mr. frog progress
I have big plans for little frog, currently trying to finish sewing his fishing waders 🎣 #needlefelting #handmade #handmade #knittedfrog
Sugar + Crumb

Sugar + Crumb

23 likes

A small dog wearing a red vest sits on a wooden staircase, with a wall sconce and framed picture in the background. Overlay text asks about affiliate marketing or stocks trading, seeking help, with a Lemon8 watermark.
Help decide or give advice 🫶🏼
Hi so I’m trying to decide if I want to start Affiliate marketing or if I should do Day trading. Does anyone have any experiences to share or just helpful advice? Thanks in advance ✨✨
Lin🏵️

Lin🏵️

6 likes

Braid Ideas “I can’t decide” HELP🥹
Wassup you guys I’ll be getting my hair braided soon and I am stuck in between these options. I absolutely love the the flower but It look so intimidating and idk who would know how to do it. Can you guys help me decide on a hairstyle? #letschat #options #braidingideas
Alexis DeShoun

Alexis DeShoun

8 likes

What shoes should I wear. I’m 🤰🏾and can’t decide
Help please
Alisha Drake

Alisha Drake

2 likes

Prom Dresses I Can’t Decide On
Little Foody

Little Foody

164 likes

A close-up of a multi-colored crocheted fabric, possibly a blanket, with text overlay asking 'which WORK IN PROGRESS crochet project should i finish?'. The fabric features shades of grey, white, and green.
A hand holds an orange crocheted pumpkin with a dark green stem, indicating it's a work in progress that needs stems added. The pumpkin has a textured, open-weave design.
A hand holds a pink and grey crocheted hand warmer with visible loose loops, indicating it needs mending as some loops have popped out. Arrows highlight the unraveling sections.
help me pick which WIP should i finish this week 🧶
Happy WIP Wednesday! 🤗🧶 if you don’t know, WIP stands for “work in-progress”! I always seems to have probably 3-4 ongoing projects at once ALL THE TIME! and i can never decide what to prioritize and what to leave for future me. so please help me decide what project i should finish up this wee
ayersellie

ayersellie

22 likes

I can’t decide which one I want to use!
Which would you use? #journalpageideas #journalideas #journalingideas #digitaljournaling #digitaljournal
Kels

Kels

6 likes

Help me decide 🤍🤍
I’ve been wanting to get into the healthcare field for a while now and I found 3 great options but I can’t decide on which one to do. They all interest me and if I could I would do all of them 😅. Please help a girl out 🙏🏻🤎 #healthcareworker #radiologytech 🩻 #pharmacytechnician 💊 #phlebotomist 💉🩸
bailey 🪩💘🛼💐✨

bailey 🪩💘🛼💐✨

1648 likes

A detailed LEGO-built greenhouse or house structure with small animal figures and plants, featuring text overlays asking "What does my room need?" and "Swipe."
A cluttered desk featuring a heart-shaped mirror, a pink jewelry box, pens, a ring light, a Nintendo Switch Lite, books, and various containers.
A single bed with purple and yellow bedding, positioned against a wall adorned with a colorful sun-themed tapestry, with a text overlay "Second bed."
I can’t decide
#letschat #lemon8constest
Ginny🌀

Ginny🌀

3 likes

A living room corner with a white sectional sofa, a light wood coffee table, and a large blank white wall. A woven basket with a plush toy sits in the corner, next to a window with blinds. The user asks for decor advice for the wall.
Another view of the living room, showing a large black TV mounted above a black media console with a faux fireplace. A tall black shelf lamp stands beside it, and the woven basket with a plush toy is visible in the background.
A wider shot of the living room, featuring a white sectional sofa, a light wood coffee table, and a prominent blank white wall. The TV, media console, and basket are also visible, asking for opinions on the decor.
can’t decide if it’s better blank or not!
#lemon8diarychallenge #opinion #homedecor #question #helpmedecorate
jules

jules

124 likes

A colored Christmas-themed illustration features a dog on a staircase holding garland, and a cat standing by presents next to a decorated Christmas tree. The background behind the staircase and tree is a light, neutral color.
Can’t decide
Which background looks better? #coloringbooktherapy #coloringbookforadults #coloring
Life with Love

Life with Love

7 likes

A black Christmas tree is decorated with orange lights, various pumpkin and jack-o'-lantern ornaments, and orange striped ribbons, creating a festive Halloween theme. The tree is topped with a cluster of small orange berries and pumpkins.
A black Christmas tree is adorned with white lights, purple and white spherical ornaments, striped bows, and Jack Skellington-themed decorations. The base is surrounded by black and white striped gift boxes, suggesting a 'Nightmare Before Christmas' theme.
A black Christmas tree is elaborately decorated with red, white, and black ornaments, including candy canes, lollipops, snowflakes, and skull figures. A large Jack Skellington head wearing a Santa hat serves as the tree topper, emphasizing a 'Nightmare Before Christmas' theme.
I can’t decide !
So I wanted to decorate my black Christmas tree I have buuuuuttt I can’t decide the theme 😵‍💫 #christmas #christmastree #christmasideas #decoratingfortheholidays🎄 #lemon8diarychallenge
Jesohaia

Jesohaia

10 likes

A green frog painting on white paper with punched holes at the top. The frog has two dark eyes and a simple, rounded shape. The image includes a Lemon8 watermark and username in the bottom left corner.
What do you guys think of my frog?
This painting took me well over 12 hours and I’m glad I have the courage and resilience to finish it. Hope you guys like it! #frogart #i love painting #frog #paintings #summerbod #embracevulnerability #unfiltered #lemon8diarychallenge Your Mom's House Denver
Eliana

Eliana

11 likes

A book cover for "CAPONE III" by JAHQUEL J. features a man with a beard and chain from the back, with the tagline "I just may steal your heart." The background shows an urban scene with palm trees.
Capone or Caselli? My Heart Can’t Decide 😌🔥
The 3-part Capone series had me hooked from start to finish. Erin and Capone Delgado’s story pulled me in so deep, I didn’t want to come up for air. I honestly don’t know who I love more—Capo or Menace Caselli. They both have that dangerous edge, but when it comes to their women, their soft side me
Mimi

Mimi

3 likes

A hand holds a green crocheted frog keychain with large eyes and dangling legs, set against a blurred Starbucks cafe background. Text overlays announce a "FREE Crochet Pattern" and "Slow Tutorial is Up by Sprout."
A hand holds a green crocheted frog keychain. The image displays the "Hanging-Leg Frog Crochet Pattern" details, including yarn, hook size, abbreviations, and step-by-step instructions for crocheting the frog's head (R1-R18).
A hand holds a green crocheted frog keychain. The image provides instructions for crocheting the frog's body and two methods for creating the hanging hands and feet: a bead version and an easy version, with credit to Sprout.
Hanging-Leg Frog 🐸 | FREE Crochet Photo Pattern
Here’s the FREE photo pattern for my hanging-leg frog 🐸✨ This post is the step-by-step photo guide, so you can crochet along without getting stuck. 🎥 The slow, detailed 19-minute video tutorial is also up (perfect to follow stitch by stitch). If any basic stitches feel confusing, check my prev
Sprout

Sprout

30 likes

What show should I watch/finish??
#show #helpmechoose #anime #watch #finish
Ku~ 🥮🍫🩷

Ku~ 🥮🍫🩷

4 likes

A collage of various career scenes including ultrasound, animal photography, farming, pharmacy, zookeeping, and midwifery, with text 'I don't know what career to pick CAN'T DECIDE', reflecting career indecision.
A collage depicting an ultrasound technician performing scans, monitors displaying fetal ultrasounds, and a technician in scrubs, illustrating the daily tasks of this profession.
A collage showcasing animal photographers in various settings, using long lenses to capture wildlife, including a small animal resting on a camera lens.
Can’t decide which to pick
I’m way too indecisive to pick only one career. #careeradvice
Valeryria8

Valeryria8

1 like

Two fantasy novels, 'Tress of the Emerald Sea' by Brandon Sanderson and 'Heir of Fire' by Sarah J. Maas, lie on a patterned fabric with strawberries and musical notes. An overlay reads, 'when you can't decide which book to read... so you just read them both!'
when you can't decide which book to read...
sometimes I struggle to decide which book to read first, so I just read both of them at the same time! #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #lemon8diarychallenge
Erin

Erin

4 likes

See more