Frog it or finish? I can’t decide!

I’ve learned over the years that if I’m not fully loving the result I’m getting, it’s better to just start over or to frog it to the point where I do like it again and try another way. But there’s been a few projects that I’ve ignored this advice and still kept trying anyways! Then I end up with bins of projects that I don’t like, taking up space.

Help me finish these projects! I need fresh eyes and a different perspective. What would you do with these fails?

#crochetaddiction #crochetproject #crochethelp @Lemon8 US #crochetcommunity #crochetideas

2025/10/23 Edited to

... Read moreCrochet projects can often lead to unexpected challenges, especially when the original design doesn't turn out as planned. Many crafters face the dilemma of whether to frog (undo) a project or push through to finish it, even if the result isn’t initially satisfying. From star scarves losing their shape to clouds that may not be pretty enough for pillows, there are simple ways to rescue these fails. One effective approach is repurposing parts of a failed project. For example, if the star-shaped motifs won’t hold their form, consider using them as decorative appliqués on bags or cushions instead of assembling them into a scarf. This repurposing not only saves your work but also adds unique elements to other crafts. When it comes to animal shapes like a dinosaur or a bear that aren’t meeting expectations, simplifying details can give them a charming, quirky look. Adding faces or playful features may transform an 'ugly mess' into a lovable toy. Alternatively, these pieces could be turned into keychains or ornaments if the larger project feels overwhelming. For textured pieces like towels aimed at a 'cute messy' look but end up messy in an unintended way, finishing techniques like weaving in ends neatly or adding a border could elevate the aesthetics. Sometimes, subtle finishing touches make a big difference in overall appeal. Trying new stitch patterns or combining colors differently in partially completed blankets or pillows may also revive the project. Taking a step back and assessing the possibilities with fresh eyes often reveals innovative fixes. Lastly, embracing experimentation and knowing when to frog projects ultimately saves space and energy, preventing bins filled with half-loved creations. Sharing these experiences with the crochet community can provide new insights and encouragement, turning challenges into inspiring creative journeys.

53 comments

LuridAcord's images
LuridAcord

Making these would be so cute!

See more(10)
Pretzel's images
Pretzel

Turn the cloud upside down and make it a skull pillow for Halloween

See more(1)

See more comments

Related posts

Should I Finish This Crochet Shrug or Start Over?
🧶 Still working on this crochet shrug and I can’t decide… should I keep going or frog it and try a different stitch pattern? 🤔 I’m using this gorgeous ombré yarn and loving how the colors are pooling into the squares, but I’m torn if I should finish it as a shrug or turn it into something else. Wh
Tasha Crafty Creations

Tasha Crafty Creations

11 likes

Can’t decide 🤷🏾‍♀️
I can’t decide whether I truly enjoy Alani & reap any benefits or simply just like this aesthetic. Is it a placebo? #alaninutrition #fitness #protein
Sassy

Sassy

539 likes

Can’t decide if I wanna go back blonde lol
Bella Noelle

Bella Noelle

2966 likes

Book Tattoo I can’t decide
#tattooideas #bookgirlie
💜 Samantha  )•¥|\|€R 💜

💜 Samantha )•¥|\|€R 💜

76 likes

9 Productivity Hacks: Finish What You Started
There are many techniques that help you finish your coursework, home chores, or just normal life tasks. Sometimes they can pile up and become overwhelming. Here are 9 productivity hacks that help me finish things, like this blog 😊: EAT THE FROG The “frog” is considered your most important and d
Jau 🤎

Jau 🤎

2964 likes

Help decide or give advice 🫶🏼
Hi so I’m trying to decide if I want to start Affiliate marketing or if I should do Day trading. Does anyone have any experiences to share or just helpful advice? Thanks in advance ✨✨
Lin🏵️

Lin🏵️

6 likes

Today I used the Eisenhower Matrix to prioritize my day 📝 It’s mid-terms season and I am busy busy busy. I added in the “eat the frog” concept by doing the item from the urgent/important category that I was looking forward to the least so that it would just be done. I was able to finish everything
Nikki

Nikki

0 likes

Why can’t I decide? 😅
I’m supposed to be starting school at the end of next month. I’m currently signed up to get my bachelors in business management, and had hopes of opening an all woman’s gym one day along with being a personal trainer. Lately though I’ve been really looking into radiography. I’m not sure why it’s in
Lexi Peterson

Lexi Peterson

30 likes

Can’t decide what I love more: dance or fitness!
#dancerlifestyle #healthylifestyle2024 #dancerforlife #fitnesslifestyle #fitnessgirls
Sasha.dance

Sasha.dance

11 likes

Braid Ideas “I can’t decide” HELP🥹
Wassup you guys I’ll be getting my hair braided soon and I am stuck in between these options. I absolutely love the the flower but It look so intimidating and idk who would know how to do it. Can you guys help me decide on a hairstyle? #letschat #options #braidingideas
Alexis DeShoun

Alexis DeShoun

8 likes

It’s fall time cozy up with a book or two
If you decide to cozy up with a book, incorporate a few of these into the mix to feed your self development and business development soul. I’ll drop some good story based books later. #bookworm #booktok #bookrecommendations
Koldestlife

Koldestlife

70 likes

Capone or Caselli? My Heart Can’t Decide 😌🔥
The 3-part Capone series had me hooked from start to finish. Erin and Capone Delgado’s story pulled me in so deep, I didn’t want to come up for air. I honestly don’t know who I love more—Capo or Menace Caselli. They both have that dangerous edge, but when it comes to their women, their soft side me
Mimi

Mimi

3 likes

help me pick which WIP should i finish this week 🧶
Happy WIP Wednesday! 🤗🧶 if you don’t know, WIP stands for “work in-progress”! I always seems to have probably 3-4 ongoing projects at once ALL THE TIME! and i can never decide what to prioritize and what to leave for future me. so please help me decide what project i should finish up this wee
ayersellie

ayersellie

23 likes

Using ChatGPT To Help Decide Your College Major!!
💡 Use ChatGPT to help you decide your college major!! Just type in a prompt, answer a few questions about your interests, and get a personalized recommendation for your major. It even provides detailed explanations on why a certain field fits you best 🎯. Whether you're into tech, arts, or scien
CompSkyy

CompSkyy

122 likes

can’t decide if it’s better blank or not!
#lemon8diarychallenge #opinion #homedecor #question #helpmedecorate
jules

jules

124 likes

Long or short? I can’t decide 🥺
I’ve been debating chopping it off again but I can’t make my mind up for sure 😅
Sav

Sav

1 like

Can y’all help me decide a thumbnail quick????
Hey guys I’m posting a video tmr!! And I need help fast on deciding my thumbnail! I don’t know if I should change my channels aesthetic with number 2 or keep the aesthetic with 1. Idk if changing my aesthetic might not go well with my viewers. I’m also a small creator btw, if you’re interested
Danielia Ro

Danielia Ro

20 likes

Please help! I can’t decide😭
#fortnite #fortnitecommunity #helpmechoose
Lyssa

Lyssa

3 likes

Why Should Your Tastebuds Decide for Your Skin?
Let’s take a moment to reflect on this. Most skincare products are filled with a cocktail of chemicals that your body would instinctively reject if they had to pass the test of your taste buds. They slip past your tongue unnoticed, yet your skin—your largest organ—is a highly receptive surface, abs
MrLifeNow

MrLifeNow

184 likes

Are these cute I can’t decide
I feel like I would really like to own one of these but I want your guys opinions are these cute?
Elynn Drury

Elynn Drury

6 likes

I can’t decide ⊹₊ ⋆✿
So you guys I’m getting my license this summer and I need help picking my VERY FIRST CAR!!! I’m between these two. I think they’re very adorable and small enough for me since I’m a beginner driver. I’m also open to different suggestions because I know nothing about cars. Before I decided that n
𝐋𝐢𝐲𝐚𝐡˚ʚ♡ɞ˚

𝐋𝐢𝐲𝐚𝐡˚ʚ♡ɞ˚

1287 likes

I can’t decide 💭👻
Snapchat+ has so many premium features to choose from to design your chat page, change your icon to many more perks. I finally decided to pick a green icon since we are right around the corner from #stpatricksday #springbreak #Lemon8Diary #shareyourthoughts #helpmechoose #livephoto #Le
Ms_Daisy

Ms_Daisy

12 likes

I can’t decide! Which one should I get? 🤔
I've been struggling to choose a new bag lately, so I've listed all the most popular styles in the US market (see picture). They all seem like classics, and it's really hard to choose! The picture is just the tip of the iceberg; I also have a complete comparison chart of the entire s
Canal Street Factory 💞

Canal Street Factory 💞

15 likes

Keep, frog or just throw away
I have about 5 projects going rn and am not going to finish most of them because I've started them all within a week of each other and got excited to start something else but these are making me fill burnt out. So I'm getting rid of them. Mini fire octo- I have lost my place in the patter
Crocheting with Carolynn

Crocheting with Carolynn

5 likes

Can Never Decide How to Style the Awkward Corner🤔
Do you have a kitchen corner? 🫣It’s always so awkward to style it up but here’s a few things I’ve tried that all look good! +knife block, bowl of fruit, mini lamp - I have it like this now +recipe book with stand, plant - simple yet useful when following recipes +air fryer, plant - so conve
Yasmin

Yasmin

233 likes

I can't decide if...
I should dye my locs or not! I want a deep deep ginger but I love black. Even black girl blonde? Help! 🤣 #microlocs #microlocjourney #microlocinspiration #microlocks #shortlocs #shortlocstyles #shortlocs #locs #locstyles #locstylesforwomen
Jayachanel

Jayachanel

21 likes

I couldn't decide.. so I bought all 4 💗🩷🤍
I felt like it was time to switch it up a bit with the tumblers.. you know, give the ones that start with the letter "S" a break .. lol 🤭 I went to Dunkin today & just had to have them all because they all are so cute to me! I will keep one for myself ( can't decide which one) &a
𝐔𝐧𝐢𝐪𝐮𝐞𝐥𝐲_𝐆𝐢𝐚 ♡

𝐔𝐧𝐢𝐪𝐮𝐞𝐥𝐲_𝐆𝐢𝐚 ♡

134 likes

I can’t decide!!
ItsAnne<3

ItsAnne<3

11 likes

Help! I can’t Decide What Color To Buy
Help me choose my new mixer color! My old KitchenAid mixer that I had for YEARS finally but the dust and it needs to be replaced. Now I have been waiting since 2019 for the copper mixer to get restocked. It has exactly once and it sold out in under a minute. So I’m pivoting now that I actua
Bgarnett

Bgarnett

23 likes

Can't decide whether to loc your toddler?
1. Hair volume: My child has a lot of hair and it is thick in density. This is it blown out with just a blow dryer so you can see the full texture and coarseness of it. It soaks up water and product like a sponge. Detangling was a nightmare. Wash days could take anywhere from 3-5 hours which was AL
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

2030 likes

Don’t stew, don’t fight. Decide, finish, move on.
Jen glenn

Jen glenn

6 likes

🥲 I can never decide what to do
🤭 ready for spring time.. I think it’s time to go back to the light side completely #hairstyles #hairlemon8
nicolelcarpio

nicolelcarpio

21 likes

when you can't decide
why settle for one when you can have both. both are awesome some days I enjoy the coffee and on a rainy day like today I would reach for the og khamrah that cinnamon and spices #Lemon8Diary #hellolemon8 #smellgoodfeelgood #lattafakhamrah #fyp #beautyfinds
ffrobin

ffrobin

3 likes

30 Day Doodle Challenge: Day 2
Day 2: Frogs 🐸 Had guests over and my younger cousin helped decide how to draw the frog. This took 2 hours and 24 minutes to finish up. I re-did this drawing a few times, because I wasn't sure how to go about it. I think it looks decent enough though. Drew a cute frog and some tadpoles.
🐟Luna🐟

🐟Luna🐟

40 likes

Your Fresh Start Begins When You Decide
It’s never too late to hit the reset button on your life, your goals, or your dreams. Starting over doesn’t require perfect timing or the “right” day of the week—it only requires a moment of courage and a decision to move forward. Whether it’s Monday morning, Wednesday afternoon, or any random mome
J

J

128 likes

can’t decide scent help me choose
Hi, guys! I've been confused about which scent I should choose because these are among the best scents I've found when searching online. I'm having a hard time deciding. Can you help me? Which one do you think is better? #AskLemon8
Chariz

Chariz

2 likes

I can’t decide- HELP😣💈
What color fits me best?
Kelsie Smith

Kelsie Smith

84 likes

when you can't decide which book to read...
sometimes I struggle to decide which book to read first, so I just read both of them at the same time! #lemon8bookclub #Lemon8Diary #lemon8diarychallenge
Erin

Erin

4 likes

See more