THEN SHE WAS GONE…

Book Review Time!!

ā­ļøOverall rating: 4/5

šŸ“šGood Reads Rating: 4.5/5

Ellie Mack was the perfect daughter. She had perfect hair, perfect grades, even the perfect boyfriend. Her mother, Laurel Mack adored her. Her sister, Hannah, wanted to be her. They both vied for her attention.

Then one day Ellie was gone. Nobody saw her walking down the street to the library across the road from her odd tutor, Noelle Donnelly’s home. No one saw her go inside Noelle’s house. No one ever saw her again.

That is, until Floyd comes into Laurel’s life, ten years later. He’s the perfect charmer. He’s the kind of guy she needs. He has a young daughter named Poppy.. who looks just like Ellie Mack.

This book was.. heart palpitation inducing.

I had a hard time with the main character, Laurel Mack at first. Then the book went on and I began to understand her more.

Lisa Jewell does a fantastic job of writing an antagonist character. When we see into the mind of them, you truly feel so much resentment and anger. It’s amazing that (Jewell) was able to invoke such emotion!

The amount of twists and turns this story takes us down, will leave you dizzy and confused at times. But know that it ALL comes together in the end. I really enjoyed this book and I can’t recommend this enough. You will be shocked!!

#lemon8bookclub #bookstagram #readeroflemon8 #BookReviews #readingrecommendations

2025/4/23 Edited to

... Read moreIn 'Then She Was Gone,' readers are taken on a gripping suspense-filled journey that reveals deeper psychological themes surrounding family dynamics and unresolved trauma. The story intricately weaves the past and present, forcing the protagonist, Laurel Mack, to confront her heart-wrenching loss. Lisa Jewell masterfully portrays the anguish of a mother whose life was turned upside down by tragedy. The introduction of Floyd and his daughter Poppy serves as a poignant reflection of the unresolved grief Laurel carries, igniting both hope and doubt in her heart. This novel stands out not just for its plot twists but also for its exploration of complex emotions and relationships. The characterization is rich, particularly the antagonist, who elicits profound feelings of empathy alongside resentment, showcasing Jewell's skill in crafting multidimensional characters. As Laurel navigates her tangled feelings, readers will find themselves questioning the nature of truth, love, and healing. 'Then She Was Gone' is more than just a thriller; it’s a profound exploration of human connection, loss, and the unpredictable paths to healing.

12 comments

QuandrielšŸŽ€šŸ’–šŸ’'s images
QuandrielšŸŽ€šŸ’–šŸ’

I have this on my audible wishlist ā¤ļø

See more(1)

Related posts

Then She Was Gone-let’s talk about it
Honestly I have no words for how insane this book was. Definitely not what I was expecting but I also cannot stop talking about it. It’s a mix between romance and true crime when a 15 year old girl goes missing and 10 years later her family starts getting answers but none of the answers they receiv
Brooke Drew

Brooke Drew

471 likes

Then She Was Gone šŸ‰šŸ¤šŸ‘’
book review | Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell 🌸 my rating: ā­ļøā­ļøā­ļø Setting: London šŸ‡¬šŸ‡§ No one ever just disappears. Laurel Mack’s daughter, Ellie Mack, suddenly disappeared one day. She was only fifteen. Never to be heard from or seen again. Eventually the case goes cold. Now, 10 years
chelsea

chelsea

56 likes

Then She Was Gone Book Review
Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell Genre: Thriller, Mystery, Psychological thriller, Suspense My Rating: ā­ļøā­ļøā­ļøā­ļø/5 My Thoughts: Wow. Ok, so...I had a lot of mixed feelings about this book. It started off super slow, and the majority of the writing seemed unimportant, kinda just like rambl
Mel

Mel

19 likes

Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell
3.5 star read. I received this book as part of a blind date with a book package. Usually, thrillers aren’t my go-to genre, but I was optimistic about this one. To be honest, the first 150 pages felt like a chore; I found myself pushing through the narrative. However, once I crossed that threshold,
kenzšŸ’œšŸ“ššŸˆ

kenzšŸ’œšŸ“ššŸˆ

9 likes

She rewrites her own ending
What if the person you lost never really left? #lisajewell #thenshewasgone #emotional #twist #suspense Concord
BookishBloomMel

BookishBloomMel

1 like

BOOK REVIEW: THEN SHE WAS GONE
Earlier this week, I finished reading Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell. This one came as a recommendation I've had from friends & I see tons of hype about it online. Honestly y'all for me it wasn't the best 😬 I found that it had a slow start & the writing style wasn't my fav
Sarah

Sarah

6 likes

Then She Was Gone
A great suspense story that keeps you curious and asking questions. I would read this book again. It would be a great book to read in October around Halloween. I’d definitely recommend this book! I hope you enjoy this book as much as I did. ā˜ŗļø #suspensebooks #thrillerbookrecommendations #lemon
Kristynas_bookadventure

Kristynas_bookadventure

8 likes

Then she was gone
#thrillerbooks #bookwormsoflemon8 #booksoflemon8 #bookrecommendations
Mari_books

Mari_books

7 likes

Then She Was Gone Book Review
ā­ļøOverall rating: 4/5 ā­ļø It took me a while to get into the book because of the format and style of it. It felt like it was for teens in high school. Also the story was just dragging a bit. I wanted to dislike it at first, maybe I’m just impatient I know they have to build up the backstory and e
Jadeā¤ļø

Jadeā¤ļø

25 likes

Your next read - Then She Was Gone
It’s August which means it’s practically already spooky season. If you want an easy read and a page turning mystery with a bit of a spooky vibe, this is a good one! #spookyreads #bookrecommendations #booktok #bookrecs #reading
Krystal

Krystal

8 likes

THEN SHE WAS GONE ~ Lisa Jewell
An absolute fast paced page turner!!! Loved this book. The type you can't put down. It got a little predictable for me about the ending however the writing is amazing; a lot of different POVs. Packed with drama and suspense. #lemon8challenge #lemon8bookclub #booktok #bookreviewsoflemon8
Anjali Jha

Anjali Jha

13 likes

BOOK REVIEW! THEN SHE WAS GONE
Oh boy do I have a lot to say about this one. 🫧I recently posted that I was reading this and how it drew me in. I just finished it so time to review! I must preface this by saying I’m a harsh rater and it takes a lot for me to rate something 5 stars haha šŸ“šSynopsis ā€œThen She Was Goneā€ is
nikki

nikki

14 likes

Then She Was Gone | Book Review 🤨
šŸ“š Book Review šŸ“– Book name: Then She Was Gone āœšŸ» Author: Lisa Jewel 🤨 Genre: Thriller 🌟 My rating: 3.75 🌟 šŸ’­ My review: I give this book a 3.75 🌟 because the first half is very slow and kinda boring. In hindsight, there was a reason for it but could have been a bit better. The last half was bett
Laken

Laken

7 likes

Then She Was Gone: Book Review šŸ“•šŸ“–
ā€œThen She Was Goneā€ by Lisa Jewell presents an intriguing premise but ultimately fails to deliver a satisfying narrative. The pacing is uneven, with sections dragging on without much development, leaving the reader disengaged. While some characters are well-developed, others feel superficial and la
šŸ‚šŸŒµShantelšŸŒæšŸ„

šŸ‚šŸŒµShantelšŸŒæšŸ„

5 likes

Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell
#bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8challenge
kailynnšŸ¤Ž

kailynnšŸ¤Ž

1 like

she’s gone now
#relateable #charlylandry #Lemon8Diary #viral #foryou #thevampirediaries #slay #girlboss #foryoupage #fyp
ā™”ļøŽ

ā™”ļøŽ

720 likes

SHE VANISHED AFTER ..
HER HUSBAND WROTE A BOOK ABOUT DISSOLVING A BODY IN ACID 🚨 Memphis, Tennessee | February 2007 šŸ”„ Ricarda Tillman-Lockett was only 22 years old when she disappeared. She was born on the Winnebago Indian Reservation, spent her childhood in Sioux City, South Dakota, and moved to Memphis when she t
Missing People in America

Missing People in America

612 likes

She was thrilled he's gone. Can't blame her.
ThatAbsurdDad

ThatAbsurdDad

2 likes

He though she was gone 🄺
#bookrecommendations #whydoyoureadsomuch #itsjustabook #hesnotreal #arrangedmarriage #booktok #yemeni #arabbooktok #muslimgirl #blowthisup #couple #disney #explorepage #foryou #goviral #highschool #wattpadtiktok #wattpadforyou
Rima

Rima

1 like

Then she was gone book reviewšŸ“–
Secret hobby of mine is I love to read! šŸ“– I might have taken me a while to get into this book but once I hit part 4 I was hooked! And finished the rest of the book in one day! Definitely a must read! Had me hooked an saying WTF 😳 #BookReview #book #readreadread ā­ļøOverall rating: 7/10
CountryBar_Bā¤ļø

CountryBar_Bā¤ļø

3 likes

She left me.. the one I loved most..gone…
For context I’m now single. And looking for a new partner. Reason being is because My gf broke up with me…… She said it was just a prank… So all the kisses. Hugs. Presents. All the Love I gave her… was for nothing?? She played with my heart. And did It knowing what it would do. She is a ho
Vonn_

Vonn_

1 like

She was so depressed…
How he dare to? #husbandandwifešŸ’• #momsupportingmoms #motheranddaughter #transformation #cheatingboyfriends
Hannah Travel

Hannah Travel

0 likes

Poof, then shes gone. šŸ’Ø
#valorant #Gaming #gamergirl
Miss_Midnight03TTV

Miss_Midnight03TTV

1 like

This was INSANE 😭 Gone before we could blink!
#mha #Anime
SierraNovaa | Anime & Beyond

SierraNovaa | Anime & Beyond

4 likes

And RIp to my cousin she gone to soonšŸ˜‡šŸ™ƒ
prettygirlboss_31_bossqeen_ac

prettygirlboss_31_bossqeen_ac

0 likes

Gone From my Sight
Henry Van Dyke
ShannenW37

ShannenW37

1 like

Was I wrong for yelling at her???
We had a few friends over at our place, including one of my husband’s female friends. Everyone was relaxed, talking, sitting around the living room. At some point I stepped away briefly to do something in the other room. I was gone for only a few minutes. When I came back, I stopped in my trac
Natrol

Natrol

349 likes

She Didn’t Ask—She Told Us to Wear These Hats
Easter Hat Chaos: Brought to You by My Mom So I went digging through the garage looking for my mom’s Easter yard decorations… found nothing but dust and frustration. But THEN—boom—I uncovered this legendary Easter hat she decorated AND these iconic photos from 2018 when she forced all of us into
GrievingGracefully | šŸ’Ž4life

GrievingGracefully | šŸ’Ž4life

8 likes

She said my Amazon package was a ā€œgiftā€ and refuse
So my Amazon package worth around $150 got delivered to a completely different apartment building. The delivery photo showed the wrong complex, so I drove there myself to try and sort it out. A woman answered the door and basically told me she thought the package was a gift for her (like serious
Mary

Mary

357 likes

Then shes gone#eyelashes #mayhug #fluffy #3D#catey
MayHug Lashes

MayHug Lashes

4 likes

She got so big while I was gone!🌸
#farmlife #babysheep #lamb #growing #babyanimals
Ann.s.mooney

Ann.s.mooney

0 likes

She is gone on Christmas to🤧
šŸ‘»GhostenašŸ‘»

šŸ‘»GhostenašŸ‘»

0 likes

She put her Trust In HIM
Maya sat alone in her living room, the last remnants of a dinner gone cold untouched on the table. Her gaze drifted to the empty armchair by the fireplace, where her husband, James, had spent countless evenings with her, sharing stories, laughter, and dreams. He was her rock, her faith, her everyth
Seize it

Seize it

9 likes

Would Anyone Miss Me When I’m Gone
Would anyone notice the silence, when my laughter fades from the air? Would footsteps echo differently, without my shadow there? Would the wind still call my name, softly through the trees at dawn? Or would the world keep breathing on, as if I’d never gone? Would someone
Islandlover šŸŒˆšŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆ

Islandlover šŸŒˆšŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆ

0 likes

SHEIN HAUL GONE WRONG 😩🤯
#bookwormsoflemon8 #shein #vongotti #healthcareworker #jewelrystack Tampa
Vongotti

Vongotti

4 likes

Gone But Not Forgotten: Etta James
On January 25, 1938, a baby girl named Jamesetta Hawkins was born in Los Angeles. The world didn’t know it yet, but a storm of gospel, blues, and soul had just been delivered into its hands. She was a child of hardship, raised mostly in foster care and surrounded by instability—but her voice? Her v
LataraSpeaksTruth

LataraSpeaksTruth

45 likes

Harley Quinn’s Final Circle… Gone Wrong [FORNITE]
It was the last fight. The circle was closing. Harley Quinn had the high ground, the weapons, the style… …and then she handed the win to the other player. šŸ’€ Sometimes chaos isn’t a plan — it’s a fail. Even villains have off days — and this one was a disaster. šŸŽ® Streaming on Twitch — com
RoyalQueenAnndy

RoyalQueenAnndy

3 likes

Hall and Oates Shes Gone
#70s #80s #90s #1970s #1980s #1990s #70smusic #80smusic #90smusic #yachtrock #rb #soul #disco #funk #90scountry #easttncountrygirl #tnvols #blacksoul #black #genex #genx #countrygirl #Tennessee #exjw
The Cabbage Roses

The Cabbage Roses

1 like

See more