Try this Reese’s Cup

Peanut butter, strawberry Reese’s cup. It was very thick. But it wasn’t too bad. It reminded me of raspberry instead of strawberry. It was only a dollar so I had to try it. I will rate it 2 out of 10. If it was regular like not double stuff then I would buy it again. I personally wouldn’t buy it again

2025/6/29 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so you've heard about the Reese's PB&J Strawberry Big Cup, right? I know I had! As a huge Reese's fan, I was absolutely buzzing to get my hands on this unique twist. The idea of peanut butter and strawberry jelly in a chocolate cup? Sounded like a dream. But sometimes, dreams are just... dreams. When I finally unwrapped this "STRAWBERRY BIG CUP," the packaging itself was pretty eye-catching – that familiar orange with a pop of pink promising something different. It definitely lives up to the "Big Cup" name; it's a hefty treat, and the cross-section after I took that first bite was certainly impressive: a thick layer of chocolate, that classic creamy peanut butter, and then a distinct red, fruit-flavored filling. It looked exactly like the pictures, a real layered masterpiece. Visually, it was a winner. Now, for the taste. This is where things got interesting for me. The initial bite was definitely sweet, and the distinct fruit flavor came through immediately. The original article mentioned it felt "very thick," and I completely agree. This isn't just a hint of strawberry; it's a substantial, almost jam-like filling that adds a significant density to the cup. It really fills out the "chocolate, peanut butter, and a red strawberry-flavored filling" description. My main takeaway, similar to the original author, was that the strawberry flavor tasted surprisingly... raspberry-like. It wasn't a fresh, juicy strawberry taste; it was more akin to a slightly artificial, tangy raspberry jam. This wasn't necessarily bad, but it wasn't what I was expecting from a product explicitly labeled "STRAWBERRY." It created this interesting, almost conflicting sensation with the rich peanut butter and milk chocolate. The sweetness level was also quite high, which, combined with the thickness of the filling, made it feel quite indulgent, almost overwhelmingly so for me. Compared to a classic Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, which balances salty peanut butter with sweet chocolate perfectly, the PB&J Strawberry Big Cup felt a bit off-kilter. The fruit filling, while unique, tended to dominate the peanut butter rather than complementing it in the way a good PB&J sandwich does. It felt like the strawberry was trying too hard to be the star, overshadowing the harmonious duo of chocolate and peanut butter that we all love. Considering it was only a dollar, I thought, "Why not give it a try?" But after experiencing it, I understood the 2 out of 10 rating. If you're someone who absolutely loves very sweet, fruit-forward candies and enjoys an adventurous flavor profile, you might find something to like here. However, if you're a purist who adores the classic Reese's balance, or if you're expecting a genuine, fresh strawberry note, this might not be for you. For me, it was a one-and-done experience. I'd rather stick to the original or perhaps a seasonal variant that doesn't mess with the core flavors quite so dramatically. It’s definitely a unique treat, and at 190 calories per package, it's a significant indulgence, but for my taste buds, it missed the mark. If they ever made a version that wasn't "double stuff" with the fruit filling, maybe, just maybe, I'd give it another go, but as it stands, it’s not hitting my repurchase list.

17 comments

šŸ¤ŽšŸŸ¤ ReneePlusSize's images
šŸ¤ŽšŸŸ¤ ReneePlusSize

they have a hit and miss with some stuff.. like some of it is overwhelmingly sweet..

See more(3)
Taylor's images
Taylor

I agree I did not like this. Not enough jelly to on ratio and the jelly was like a paste not jelly

See more(1)

Related posts

REESE’S PEANUT BUTTER PROTEIN BALLS: šŸ«
These 4 ingredient Reese’s Peanut Butter Protein Balls are packed with 9 grams of protein per ball and only take a couple minutes to make! I love making these as a sweet treat throughout the day or even a pre workout snack! You have to try these asap! šŸ«Tag me if you make these Reese’s Protein Ba
DayamifromMiami

DayamifromMiami

2491 likes

Reese’s cup at home šŸ˜
HOMEMADE REESE’s PEANUT BUTTER CUPS šŸ«šŸ„œ This was fun dessert/snack to try. These peanut butter cups came out 10x better than the ones in the store. The perfect sweetness & creaminess. I used all organic brands when making these. And these required very few ingredients. Ingredients use
Kendall

Kendall

296 likes

New Reese’s Cup
Have y’all tried them yet !?
Ursula Lawal

Ursula Lawal

420 likes

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Chili
Ingredients ½ pound bacon, cut into ½ inch pieces 1 pound ground beef 1 pound ground pork or sausage 4 cloves garlic, mined 1 whole onion, diced 2 teaspoons Chipotle chili powder 1 tablespoon Chilli powder 2 tablepoons Better than Bouillon, Beef Flavored 28 ounces crushed tomatoes 14.5 ou
✨Ruth|Easterday✨

✨Ruth|Easterday✨

164 likes

Cookies Turning Out Like A Reese’s Cup!
You gotta try this cookie recipe! #cooking #food #foodie #recipes
Cluelesscooking101

Cluelesscooking101

1 like

3 ingredient Reese’s
Yes please! #quickeasydinner #easysweettreat #sweettreat #easysnack
Sarah Williams, MS, RDN

Sarah Williams, MS, RDN

11.3K likes

Reese’s Pieces Peanut Butter Chip Cookies
Freshly baked and bursting with Reese’s Pieces and peanut butter chips! šŸ«šŸ„œ These White Chocolate Reese’s Pieces Peanut Butter Chip Cookies are the ultimate sweet & salty treat! šŸ˜‹šŸŖ Ingredients: 2 and 1/2 cups all-purpose flour 1 teaspoon baking soda 1/2 teaspoon salt 2 sticks (8 ounces
Karen Renee

Karen Renee

1004 likes

Reese’s delight
They say you can’t buy happiness, but you can buy Reese’s Delight… and that’s pretty much the same thing šŸ¤ÆšŸ¤¤šŸ„¹šŸ¤—šŸ„° #cookiesrecipe #cookies #reesescup #cookies #peanutbutter
SALTIE AND SWEET COOKIES

SALTIE AND SWEET COOKIES

1127 likes

Reese’s Cup Coffee!
So, I went to the store to stock back up on some things for my coffee and stumbled upon Reese’s creamer! 😱 I was surprised how much this tasted like peanut butter cups! šŸ’• Might be my new favorite coffee šŸ˜ Here is everything I used: 1. NescafĆ© espresso blonde instant coffee ā˜•ļø 2. Torani
Brittany’s Channel

Brittany’s Channel

151 likes

Reese’s Ice Cream
Homemade Reese’s Cup ice cream šŸ«šŸ„œ So easy, so creamy—you NEED to try this! #icecream #shorts
bentley.bbq

bentley.bbq

874 likes

Reese’s, Made Healthier!
Craving that classic peanut butter and chocolate combo? This 5-ingredient recipe is ridiculously easy to make — and tastes just like the real deal! Made with simple, wholesome ingredients and fewer preservatives, it’s a sweet treat your body and tastebuds will love. Keep a batch in the fridge
bloomwithlina

bloomwithlina

462 likes

High Protein Giant Reese’s Cup
#highprotein #sweettreats #healthjourney #weightloss
Melissa

Melissa

2728 likes

Reese's Cup Iced Latte
Reese’s Cup Coffee Syrup Ingredients: -½ cup water -¼ cup granulated sugar -2 tablespoons peanut butter -2 tablespoons chocolate syrup -½ tsp vanilla extract Directions: 1. Whisk the water and sugar over medium heat until the sugar dissolves. 2. Add the peanut butter, chocolate
A Date Night In

A Date Night In

77 likes

Trying Only Reese’s Snacks! šŸ„œšŸ«
What’s your favorite Reese’s snack? #reeses #snackhaul #peanutbutter #reesescup #groceryhaul
Morgan Chomps

Morgan Chomps

1176 likes

Two blended beverages in clear cups, featuring layers of light and dark brown liquid. Each drink is topped with whipped cream, chocolate syrup drizzle, and pieces of chocolate candy and crushed toppings. The cups have a green and white circular logo.
šŸ„œšŸ« Reese’s Peanut Butter FrappšŸ«šŸ„œ Recipe Belowā¤ļø
šŸ„œšŸ« Reese’s Peanut Butter Frappuccino 🌟 Ingredients: For the Frappuccino: 1 cup whole milk (or your preferred milk) 2 tablespoons creamy peanut butter 2 tablespoons chocolate syrup 1/4 cup brewed coffee (chilled) 2 tablespoons cocoa powder 2 tablespoons granulated sugar (or sweet
Dior Deesse

Dior Deesse

3244 likes

18g Protein Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Want a sweet treat but still hit your protein goals, try these high protein Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups!!! They have 18g of protein and taste amazing! ~ Recipe: • 1 cup of crushed granola • 2 1/2 tablespoons of peanut butter • Mix it together, then shape them however you’d like. • Freeze t
Rylee_M

Rylee_M

88 likes

Spring Reeses!!!
Thought I would give this a try not much of a difference like adding a slight crunch oddly enough giving this a 8/10 since the add sprinkles actually help with eating the big cup in one try #reesespeanutbuttercup #eatorpass
Mallymall

Mallymall

21 likes

A hand holds a green and purple Reese's PB&J King Size White Chocolate Mint Cup package. The package displays a cross-section image of the candy, revealing a white chocolate cup with a white filling and a green jelly-like center. It weighs 2.8 oz (79g).
Now Reese šŸ˜’ UPDATE : Yes it’s šŸ¤–
Now let’s talk about if you’ll eat it or notā€¼ļø 4th Reese snack I disagree with šŸ˜‚
C.hazzzel

C.hazzzel

319 likes

Reese’s is my weakness
Reese’s peanut butter cup
Chris Lilly

Chris Lilly

2924 likes

Reese's cup
The perfect addition.
upstateartist

upstateartist

8 likes

Reese's Chocolate Chip Cookies
Reese’s Chocolate Chip Cookies Ingredients: -12 tablespoons butter, softened -¾ cup brown sugar -½ cup granulated sugar -1 egg AND 1 egg yolk -2 tsp vanilla extract -2 ¼ cups all purpose flour -½ tsp salt -1 tsp baking soda -1 ½ tsps cornstarch -1 ½ cups mini chocolate chips
A Date Night In

A Date Night In

375 likes

A black tray holds several square-cut Reese's Peanut Butter Brownies. They are topped with colorful Reese's Pieces, miniature Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, and drizzled with peanut butter. The image has text overlays "Reese's PeanutButter Brownies" and "Lemon8 @ashleyheavey".
Reese’s PeanutButterBrownies
Reese’s peanut butter brownies. Peanut butter brownie topped with Reese’s pieces and Reese’s peanut butter cups. Drizzled with peanut butter! #brownies #reesespeanutbuttercup #peanutbutter #fallvibesšŸ‚ #potamuspastries
PotamusPastries

PotamusPastries

244 likes

Reeses Brownies šŸ¤ŒšŸ‹
The secret is crushed graham crackers in the peanut butter! For the brownie bottom I used this recipe: ​1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted butter, melted ​1 cup granulated sugar ​1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder ​2 large eggs ​1 teaspoon vanilla extract ​3/4 cup all-purpose flour ​1/4
MrsJeanDymond

MrsJeanDymond

1548 likes

🄜 šŸŖā¬‡ļø REESE’S CUP PROTEIN PAZOOKIE
Who says you can’t crush your fitness goals eating ā€œoff-limitsā€ food? This high-protein, macro-friendly pazookie is packed with 64g of protein—so you can enjoy every delicious bite while staying on track in your fitness journey. šŸ”„ Save this recipe for your next sweet tooth craving & share wi
Clark Hill

Clark Hill

37 likes

Reese cup blizzard (in the ninja creami)
So dang good! #ninjacreami #ninjacreamirecipes #Recipe #icecream #reeses
Jenny Rae

Jenny Rae

129 likes

A single package of Mrs. Freshley's Deluxe Reese's Peanut Butter Flavored Cupcakes, featuring a chocolate cupcake with peanut butter icing, chocolate drizzle, and sprinkles. The package highlights 480 calories and a net weight of 4.5 oz (128g), with a best-by date of 04/07/25.
Reese’s Cup cakes 😳
Omg! Found this at dollar tree! I seen this and grabbed one. I loooove Reese’s cups. Would you try this? #letschat #foodie #dollartreefinds #cupcakes #reeses
Curated by š“š“®ā„›š“®š’® ź«

Curated by š“š“®ā„›š“®š’® ź«

172 likes

Reese's peanut butter cup cheesecake
#reesespeanutbuttercup #cheesecake #smallbusiness #placeyourorders
JesuisSloane

JesuisSloane

14 likes

A round chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting, chocolate ganache drips, and Reese's Pieces decorating the sides. The top is adorned with peanut butter frosting swirls, half Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, and more Reese's Pieces.
A top-down view of the chocolate cake, showcasing the arrangement of peanut butter frosting swirls, half Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, and Reese's Pieces on the chocolate ganache top. The center features a circular pattern of orange, brown, and yellow candies.
A slice of the chocolate cake on a paper plate, revealing multiple layers of chocolate cake and peanut butter frosting. The top of the slice is decorated with chocolate ganache, a half Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, peanut butter frosting, and Reese's Pieces.
Reese’s Chocolate Cake
Three later chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting. Topped with chocolate ganache, Reese’s cups and Reese’s pieces! #reesespeanutbuttercup #peanut butter #chocolatecake #potamuspastries
PotamusPastries

PotamusPastries

190 likes

Reese’s Dessert
1 cup whip 2 tbsp PB2 2 tbsp Reese’s chips #dessert #dessertrecipe #healthyfood
Teresa | Weightloss Mentor

Teresa | Weightloss Mentor

163 likes

A hand with light pink nails holds a clear cup of iced coffee with foam and ice. The drink is a Reese's Protein Latte, as indicated by the orange text overlay. The background is blurred.
Reese’s Protein Latte
šŸ« Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Protein Iced Coffee Ingredients: • 1 cup chilled coffee (or 1–2 shots espresso) • 1 Chocolate Premier Protein • 1 pump Skinny Syrup Peanut Butter Cup (or Peanut Butter if that’s what you have) • 1 pump Skinny Syrup Chocolate Car
Charrae Tenece

Charrae Tenece

191 likes

See more