Mike’s Pizza

1/7 Edited to

... Read moreIf you’re a fan of classic, mouth-watering pizza, Mike’s Pizza in Amityville, Long Island is definitely worth visiting. As someone who has explored many pizzerias across the NYC metropolitan area, I can say that Mike’s Pizza offers an authentic slice that resonates with both locals and visitors. The charm lies not just in their crispy crusts and flavorful toppings but in the welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit enjoyable. One thing I especially appreciate about Mike’s Pizza is their dedication to quality ingredients. From freshly shredded mozzarella to rich tomato sauce, every bite tells a story of craftsmanship. They cater to diverse tastes, offering everything from traditional cheese and pepperoni pizzas to unique specialty pies that cater to adventurous eaters. Located in Amityville, a town known for its vibrant food scene on Long Island, Mike’s Pizza adds a personal touch that sets it apart from the bustling NYC pizzerias. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie to share, it’s the perfect spot to satisfy your pizza cravings. For foodies and pizza enthusiasts looking for that quintessential New York taste outside the city, Mike’s Pizza is a hidden gem. It’s ideal for family dinners, casual hangouts with friends, or even solo indulgence. If you happen to be in Long Island, adding Mike’s Pizza to your food itinerary will not disappoint. Don’t forget to explore other local eatery options in Amityville to enjoy a full gastronomic experience in this charming town.

Related posts

Mountain Mikes Pizza
Henderson, say hello to your new pizza obsession! Mountain Mike's is serving up irresistibly cheesy, crispy-crusted perfection, and every bite is loaded with flavor. That signature curly pepperoni? Absolute game-changer. Get ready to grab a slice (or the whole pie) at their brand-new location!
Bigbitesvegas

Bigbitesvegas

24 likes

A large salad-style meal in a rectangular container, featuring various deli meats including pepperoni, cheese, and vegetables, drizzled with dressing. A bag of cheese-flavored tortilla chips is in the background.
A close-up view of a hearty salad in a rectangular container, showcasing a mix of sliced meats, pepperoni, cheese, and fresh vegetables, topped with dressing.
A hand holds a forkful of the salad, showing a mix of shredded lettuce, sliced tomatoes, onions, pepperoni, and deli meats, with the container blurred in the background.
Viral Tiktok: Jersey Mike's Sub in a tub
This was sooo good + fresh! I added pepperoni's + French dressing (from home) and let me just say...it was 🔥 10/10! Have you tried it yet? The lost of the ingredients in the comments. #Lemon8 #jerseymikes #food #foodie #lemon8food
QTPie Vibez

QTPie Vibez

1098 likes

Exterior view of Mike's Pizza restaurant at night, featuring a brightly lit "Mike's PIZZA" sign. Cars are parked in front of the brick building under a dark sky.
A detailed close-up of a receipt from Mikes Pizza, showing a pick-up order for a 14-inch pizza with cheese, sausage, onions, pepperoni, black olive, green pepper, bacon, and giardiniera, totaling $14.60.
A top-down view of a large, fully loaded pizza from Mike's Pizza, featuring a variety of toppings including cheese, black olives, green peppers, and meats, presented in a cardboard box with a pizza saver.
MIKE’S PIZZA
Mikes pizza is definitely a Northern IL hidden gem ALWAYS 10/10 #pizzareviews #pizzarestaurants #illinois #foodie #explore #fyp
TRESHAUN

TRESHAUN

4 likes

A close-up of a golden-brown pizza grilled cheese sandwich, cut in half, with abundant melted mozzarella cheese stretching. The toasted bread is seasoned. Text overlay lists ingredients: 6 ounces of pepperoni, 8 slices of bread, and 12 slices of mozzarella for the recipe.
Pizza Grilled Cheese
Super simple easy recipe on a budget! If you wanna get fancy add some garlic butter to the sides of the bread if you wanna get fancy or even some pizza sauce. - 1/2 cup of butter - 2 cloves of minced garlic - 2 teaspoons of parsley 🤤 #pizzalovers #grilledcheese #pizza #pizzarecipe
Alex Caster

Alex Caster

4184 likes

Pizza Skulls💀🍕
Pizza + Skull baking pan = a really fun Halloween snack!🍕 Simply use Pillsbury pizza crust dough and press it into your skull baking pan (I found mine on Amazon). Load it with pizza toppings and seal it up, then bake in the oven. So so simple and so much fun!💀😋 #fallfood #lemon8challenge @L
Katherine Salom

Katherine Salom

4373 likes

Mexican pizza
#fastfood #tacobell #pizza #easyrecipes #restaurant
Holliewould

Holliewould

1320 likes

Pizza Roll-Ups🍕
Elevate your snack game these irresistible pizza roll-ups!🍕 Using Pillsbury crescent dough sheets, I layer on rich pizza sauce, a couple of different cheeses, and savory pepperoni. Roll them up, slice, and bake to perfection for a crispy, cheesy treat that's perfect for any occasion. ✨Watch the
Katherine Salom

Katherine Salom

7726 likes

EASY DINNER AFTER WORK: Flatbread Pizza
this garlic bread style pizza was so good! I made extras for our lunches tomorrow 🥰 #pizzarecipes #dinnerideas #easyrecipes #cooking #budgetfriendly
Madison ✨

Madison ✨

548 likes

🍕Pizza Silent Mukbang 🍕
#pizza #pizza🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🖤 #foodtok #mukbang
Ashloreats

Ashloreats

11 likes

A high-protein homemade pizza, topped with pepperoni and sausage, cut into four slices on a black plate. Text overlay indicates it contains 48 grams of protein.
Various ingredient packages for a high-protein pizza, including marinara sauce, chicken sausage, pita bread, mozzarella cheese, and turkey pepperoni, displayed over a blurred pizza background.
A high-protein homemade pizza, topped with pepperoni and sausage, cut into four slices on a black plate. Text overlay displays its nutritional macros: 610 kcals, 48 grams protein, 47 grams carbs, and 30 grams fats.
PIZZA 48G PROTEIN RECIPE 🍕
MY HIGH PROTEIN HOMEMADE PIZZA RECIPE 🧀 Macros 🍽️ Protein: 48 grams Carbs: 47 grams Fats: 30 grams Calories: 610 kcals Ingredients: 1 (80g) ➡️ Pita (BRAND: White Greek Style Pita) 70 grams ➡️ Marinara (BRAND: Prego - Fresh Mushroom) 30 grams ➡️ Pepperoni (BRAND: Great Valu
Yvannia

Yvannia

779 likes

Sweet Potato Pizza
One of my most viral video of 2024 with 7.9 mil views ⤵️🍠 Sweet Potato Pizza Crust 🍕!! It is 10/10 idea by @_food_love_life_ I def would do this again but with bbq chicken!! Toppings 1 sweet potato (1/3 pound) 1/3 cup cottage cheese 2 ounces Chorizo 1/4 cup Red onions 2 tablespoons Jal
🇵🇦JOYCE the HUNGRY🇸🇻

🇵🇦JOYCE the HUNGRY🇸🇻

6177 likes

Chicken fajitas pizza
MÍA brand for pizza crust ( you can find it at your local Walmart) #pizza #food #foryoupage
Chefsly👩‍🍳

Chefsly👩‍🍳

2782 likes

If nobody has told you; you deserve to be happy 🫶
#blessed #embracevulnerability #kindness #love #summer @Lemon8 US @Lemon8 Food
Pizza Mike & Kennedy Dog

Pizza Mike & Kennedy Dog

600 likes

Dustin,Lucas,will,Mike, me!
#strangerthings
⋆.𐙚 ̊ ꒰ 𝓜𝓲𝓪 ꒱ 🤍

⋆.𐙚 ̊ ꒰ 𝓜𝓲𝓪 ꒱ 🤍

29 likes

pizza casserole 🤌🍕
this is so so good and lasts me and my bf multiple days!! feel free to ask me any questions you may have! to reheat you can use the microwave or put in the oven covered with foil until warm. #pizzacasserole #yummy #Recipe #pasta #fyp #cooking ingredients: - 1 lbs ground beef or sau
Anna

Anna

560 likes

Two freshly baked pizza subs with melted mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, and a garlic-herb buttered crust, resting on parchment paper.
A clear measuring cup containing melted butter mixed with minced garlic, oregano, and Italian seasoning, stirred with a spoon.
A jar of pizza sauce, a package of mozzarella cheese, and a package of pepperoni, laid out as ingredients for pizza subs.
Pizza Subs 🍕
What I Used * Rustic sub buns * Mozzarella cheese * Pepperoni * Classico Pizza Sauce * 4 tbsp butter * Minced garlic, spoonful * Oregano * Italian seasoning Toasted each sub on 375F for maybe 15-17 minutes until cheese is melted. Measurements and toppings vary to your liking on amou
Zeetheintrovert

Zeetheintrovert

11.6K likes

A hand holds a golden-brown puff pastry pizza bite topped with pepperoni, cheese, hot honey, parmesan, and basil, with other bites blurred in the background.
Various ingredients for puff pastry pizza bites are displayed on a counter, including puff pastry sheets, pepperoni, cheese, pizza seasoning, hot honey, and pizza sauce.
Step 1 shows groups of 3-4 pepperoni slices arranged on parchment paper on a baking sheet.
Game Day Pizza Appetizer’s
Recipe from: The Boozie Foodie IG: iamashleybreannn What you'll need: •1 sheet puff pastry, thawed •pepperoni (about 4 per pastry) •1 cup freshly shredded mozzarella (or 6 small chunks of fresh mozzarella) • your favorite pizza sauce •1 egg, beaten (for egg wash) • pizza seasoning
Sallam 💕

Sallam 💕

435 likes

A Jersey Mike's healthy option bowl, featuring sliced turkey and provolone cheese topped with banana peppers, jalapeños, tomatoes, onions, lettuce, and oregano. Ordering instructions and ingredients are overlaid, with a bag of Miss Vick's chips in the background, all within a car interior.
Jersey Mikes ⬇️
On the go? Need something healthy? Order this, you will thank me later! This is so delicious without the bread and olive oil!! #healthy #jerseymikes #louisiana #onthego
Ⓣ

1012 likes

A bag of Totino's Pepperoni Pizza Rolls and a container of Garlic Parmesan & Basil Butter are displayed on a kitchen counter, representing the ingredients for viral pizza rolls. The image has a 'Viral Pizza Rolls' text overlay.
Viral Pizza Rolls ✨🤌💋
Have yall tried the viral pizza rolls from TikTok? ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨ I used Pepperoni Pizza Rolls Garlic butter from Walmart Parmesan Parsley Ranch or Marinara Sauce Y’all give it a try and tell me what you think! 385* 8 mins #viralpizzarolls #foryoupage #foodreview #lemon8challange
ErinCole

ErinCole

2572 likes

Magic Mike’s Pizza Express
📍Magic Mike’s Pizza Express in Cypress, CA #magic #magicmike #pizza #wings #smallbusiness
borderlinecook

borderlinecook

4 likes

Pizza Egg Rolls 🍕
Woman vs Kitchen ❤️‍🔥

Woman vs Kitchen ❤️‍🔥

3430 likes

Crab Rangoon Pizza🦀🥢
Ingredients: 16oz fresh dough Mozzarella cheese - about 2 cups Wonton wraps - about 5-6 wraps Oil for frying - about 1/3 cup your choice Green onion - sliced (preference amount) Parmesan cheese - sprinkle to taste Cream cheese base: 8 oz of cream cheese 1/2 tsp sugar 1/2 tsp garlic po
Mike Obermeyer

Mike Obermeyer

239 likes

Pizza Stuffed Garlic Knots in 10 Minutes! 🍕🧄
Pizza stuffed garlic knots! 🤤 These are amazing and come together in less than 10 minutes! All you need is garlic knots, cheese, pepperoni, and marinara sauce. Slice the garlic knots, stuff them with cheese and pepperoni, then pop them in the air fryer at 375°F for 6 minutes. Heat up some marinara
🌺 JILIENNE 🌴

🌺 JILIENNE 🌴

4309 likes

Chicken Crust Pizza 👀
#healthyrecipes #healthymealideas #healthymeals #highprotein #highproteinmeals
Tayler Ayralee

Tayler Ayralee

3100 likes

Super Easy Weightloss Pizza Hack
I've sampled various flavors of these delicious Mission tortilla wraps, but these ones were a game changer! Last night, I made the most delicious pizzas. I started by browning each side of the wrap in a little oil in the frying pan. Then, I layered it with Rao's pizza sauce, a sprinkle of I
Donshelle

Donshelle

646 likes

#fyp #funny #80s #pizza #comedy
Mike Honcho

Mike Honcho

2 likes

Fruit Pizza Recipe
I've been daydreaming about this fruit pizza for weeks 🤤 ingredients: - 2 rolls Pillsbury Ready to Bake Sugar Cookie Dough - whatever fruit you like! - 2 boxes cream cheese - sugar - vanilla extract Instructions: 1. Spread & flatten cookie dough onto a pan & cook based o
Carissa C

Carissa C

492 likes

Wild Mikes Pizza
#gettoknowme
UnHXLYOneBlaccZXMBIIE666

UnHXLYOneBlaccZXMBIIE666

0 likes

Vito’s Gourtmet Pizza in Coral Springs, Florida
Delicious Delights: Exploring Vito's Gourmet Pizza in Coral Springs, Florida! #TheSoFloDuo #SoFloGem #SoFlo #vitospizza #pizza #goldenpizza #cheese #crustlover #chickenparm #italiansub
Codie N Drew

Codie N Drew

227 likes

The BEST French Bread Pizza 🍕🔥
🍕🔥 Say hello to the best French Bread Pizza! Crispy, cheesy, and loaded with my favorite toppings, this quick and easy recipe is a game-changer. Perfect for any night of the week!😋 @Lemon8 Food #lemon8food #Lemon8Diary #Recipe #recipeideas #recipesimple #easyrecipe #easyrecipes
Katherine Salom

Katherine Salom

3128 likes

Pickle pizza!!!
The best combo ever ever ever. This pizza is fun to make and absolutely delicious. Higher in protein too! Crust: 2 cups Flour 1 cup Greek yogurt nonfat 1.5 tsp Baking powder 1 tsp Salt 2 Eggs 1 tsp Garlic powder 1/2 tsp Pepper 1 tsp Dried Dill Toppings: 1 cup fat free mozzarella che
Jacklin

Jacklin

601 likes

Keith Lee was just at this pizza spot 😔
The Keith Lee effect is real! It was amazing to see the whole community come together to come say their last hurrah to mikes pizza! All the locals were waiting telling me their stories on how they’ve been coming here for years and how sad they were to see this go. Gentrification is a huge is
Jaylynn Cardona

Jaylynn Cardona

100 likes

A close-up shows several golden-brown pizza bombs, topped with melted cheese and herbs. One bomb is lifted with a fork, revealing a pepperoni slice and stretchy mozzarella cheese, indicating a warm, cheesy filling ready to be served.
Pizza Bombs🍕
Pizza Bombs Ingredients : for 16 balls 3 tablespoons butter, for greasing the pan 16 ½ oz can of biscuit dough(465 g), 1 can marinara sauce sliced pepperoni 8 oz ball of mozzarella cheese(225 g), cut into cubes butter, melted 2 cloves garlic, minced salt, to taste pepper, to taste 1
🩷Mihav ميهاف

🩷Mihav ميهاف

1924 likes

Wild Mike's Pizza
#foodie #food #foodaddict #yum #delicious #homecooked #foodaholic #foodporn #foodgasm #foodstagram #instafood #foodphoto #foodblogger
Joni Russell Kennedy

Joni Russell Kennedy

2 likes

WWWWW FunnyMike WWWWW Londyn 🙏❤️‍🩹
#funnymike #2xrakai #rakai
QuenchClips

QuenchClips

7429 likes

Magic Mike’s Pizza Express
📍Magic Mike’s Pizza Express in Cypress, CA #pizza #affordable #oc #oceats #wings
borderlinecook

borderlinecook

1 like

Pizza Bombs🍕
So good!! #food #viral #fyp #fypシ゚viral #momsoflemon8 #sahm
Natalee Chacon

Natalee Chacon

1531 likes

Homemade Bagel Pizza
#pizzaathome #bagelpizza #quickandeasyrecipes
_cookingwithtamiaa_

_cookingwithtamiaa_

2672 likes

Easy Classic Pizza Bake
This recipe never lasts long around here lol * 2 containers of Original Flaky Layers Biscuits (8 count) cut into 8 pieces- or any biscuit brand that you like * 1/4 c melted garlic butter (store-bought or homemade- I use salted butter, melt it then add a clove of minced garlic) * 1/2# sausage,
Taryn Camp

Taryn Camp

3062 likes

High Protein Pizza Bowls
Ingredients: -12oz ground turkey sausage or beef -Pepperoni -pizza mix cheese -cottage cheese or plain Greek yogurt -marinara of choice -12oz pasta -salt, pepper, Italian seasoning, garlic powder Steps: -cook pasta according to package -while pasta is cooking brown your sausage or beef
Shayla

Shayla

871 likes

Healthy Pizza🍕
Pizza is one of my all-time favorites, but let’s be honest—it doesn’t always leave you feeling great afterward.That’s why I’ve been loving this better-for-you version! Ingredients: For the crust: • 1 1/4 cups of oat flour @bobsredmill • 1/2 cup of Greek yogurt • 2-3 tbsp of water (or
Gabriela🤍

Gabriela🤍

6577 likes

#GodIsGreat #Blessed #Kindness #Dogs #Love
Pizza Mike & Kennedy Dog

Pizza Mike & Kennedy Dog

18 likes

Easy snack idea - Pepperoni French bread pizza 🍕
Smothered in garlic butter and drizzled with hot honey. Midnight snack, appetizer, game day food, girl dinner, whatever the occasion this is so yum. ✨RECIPE:✨ Into a bowl add 1 stick softened butter, 8 cloves minced garlic, 1/3 cup grated Parmesan, 1/2 teaspoon red pepper flakes (or more if y
Mallory Austin

Mallory Austin

889 likes

Red Robins New Mikes Hot Honey Collab!
#foodie #pizza #burgers #redrobin #foodreview
Jas & Kam Food Reviews

Jas & Kam Food Reviews

736 likes

🍕This recipe will ruin takeout pizza forever
72-Hour Dough - Like a spa day for gluten San Marzano Tomatoes - The Beyoncé of ingredients Burnt Cheese Crown - Not a mistake, ~aesthetic~ #PizzaTherapy #CarbFairyTales #DoughsAnyone #CheeseEmergency So many people have been asking me about the potato recipe from my last post, a
Eve

Eve

2460 likes

Magic Mike’s Pizza Express
📍Magic Mike’s Pizza Express in Cypress, CA #pizza #wings #takeout #oc #smallbusiness
borderlinecook

borderlinecook

0 likes

Six golden-brown, skull-shaped pizza rolls are arranged on a green plate around a small bowl of marinara sauce. The image features a text overlay that reads "PIZZA SKULLS" with a pizza slice and skull emoji, highlighting this Halloween-themed recipe.
Pizza Skulls Recipe 🍕
PIZZA SKULLS RECIPE 👇🏼🎃 1 Cup Bread Flour 1 1/2 Cups All Purpose Flour (+ more as needed) 2 Tsp Active Dry Yeast 1 Tsp Sugar 1 1/2 Tsp Salt 2 1/2 Tbsp Olive Oil + more for Spraying Cheese Pepperoni Marinara Sauce *Bake at 370 for 22-25 minutes* #pizzaskulls #halloween #recipe
Daisy Campuzano

Daisy Campuzano

8788 likes

😍 pizza
Wife of Neymar ♥️🌹🩷

Wife of Neymar ♥️🌹🩷

2 likes

Pizza Pepper Poppers
2-BITE PIZZA PEPPER POPPERS 🍕 🌶 5 mini peppers, sliced in half 1/2 cup marinara 1/2 cup mozzarella, shredded Mini pepperoni Drizzle peppers with olive oil. Stuff with sauce, cheese and pepperoni! Pop these babies in a 350 degree oven for 12 to 15 minutes! Enjoy! #pizza #lunchideas #app
JadeCalistaLee

JadeCalistaLee

3624 likes

This school pizza is 🔥 and easy to make!
#cookingathome #cookwithme #pizzarecipes
chefbriccababy

chefbriccababy

4347 likes

A baking pan with pizza dough, shredded lettuce, and two bottles of sauce are on a countertop, ready for making taco pizza.
A baking pan with pizza dough, shredded lettuce, and two bottles of sauce are on a countertop, with a text overlay indicating the next step.
Pizza dough in a pan is covered with a layer of yellow cheese sauce, with a text overlay instructing to add meat next.
Taco Pizza🌮🍕✨
#tacopizza #dinner #dinnerideas #easyrecipe #kidfriendlyrecipes #momsoflemon8 #sahm #bluecollarwife #realisticlifestyle
dakota lewis

dakota lewis

563 likes

See more