Was Carbone Actually Worth the Hype?

Getting a reservation at Carbone is no small feat—it’s one of those restaurants where demand seems to far exceed availability. I even tried using Amex’s concierge service to snag a table, but no luck. After countless failed attempts, I set a reminder on Resy and got a weekday lunch time reservation when the competition was a little less fierce. Here’s how it went and what i thought of the food:

🍞 Bread with Cheese and Prosciutto: The unexpected star of the meal—warm, crusty bread paired with creamy mozzarella and prosciutto. Simple yet absolutely unforgettable. If I were to go back, this would be 60% of the reason.

🍝 Spicy Rigatoni Vodka: Absolutely lived up to the hype—creamy, rich, and perfectly balanced, it’s no wonder it’s the star of the menu. However, I have to say I am biased to this dish as Rigatoni is my favorite type of pasta.

🍅 Veal Parmesan: Another standout, with its golden, crispy crust and tender, flavorful meat smothered in a bold tomato sauce. One slice was already very filling.

🦞 Lobster Ravioli: Creamier than I had hoped for, which made it feel a bit heavy, but the flavors were still delicate and well-balanced.

🐚 Assorted Baked Clams: While flavorful, they leaned on the salty side, which made them a bit overpowering compared to the other dishes. I would not order this again.

Carbone New York

📍 Location: 181 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012

💲 Price Point: $$$

For an alternative that’s just as good (and much easier to get into), try Emilio’s Ballato (55 E Houston St, New York, NY 10012). Head there around 5pm for a walk-in and enjoy classic Italian dishes without the stress.

#lemon8partner #nycfoodreview #nycrestaurantreviews #nycitalian #carbone

Carbone New York
2025/1/24 Edited to

... Read moreCarbone, located at 181 Thompson St, New York, is renowned for its Italian cuisine and vibrant atmosphere. Reservations can be tough to secure, as demand is high. Alongside the celebrated Spicy Rigatoni Vodka, the Lobster Ravioli is a dish that captivates many diners, offering creaminess with delicate flavors. The Veal Parmesan is also noteworthy for its crispy crust and rich tomato sauce. For those considering alternatives, Emilio’s Ballato nearby offers a fantastic dining experience without the reservation hassle. Other dishes like Assorted Baked Clams may not appeal to every palate, as some find them a bit too salty. Overall, Carbone is a quintessential NYC dining spot that showcases classic Italian flavors, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts. Whether you're a local or a visitor, indulging in its offerings will surely contribute to your culinary journey in the city.

12 comments

Maxine 💫's images
Maxine 💫

girl go make money being a restaurant critic i beg you!!!!

See more(1)

Related posts

supplements that are worth the hype
finding the right supplements can feel like a maze, but these picks from whole foods are actually worth the hype. 🌿 💊 trace minerals – your body needs these essential nutrients for everything from energy to immune function, and these high-quality drops make it easy to replenish what you’re missin
radiatewithcait

radiatewithcait

1596 likes

Not everything was worth the hype… but these were 👏
#ApartmentFavorites #6MonthsLater #WorthIt #HomeEssentials #selenasincerely #SoftLifeStyle
selenasincerely

selenasincerely

1575 likes

A Sephora store aisle displaying various fragrance bottles. A hand with long nails points towards the displays, with text indicating a selection of popular fragrances that are worth the hype.
A hand holds a clear, faceted perfume bottle with a silver cap, described as having a warm floral scent that receives many compliments.
A hand holds a gold-colored perfume bottle with a clear top, described as smelling like cherries.
These are ACTUALLY worth the HYPE!💕
Ngl I’m the type of person who doesn’t believe a lot of overhyped products on the internet. So as Sephora employee I made it my duty to see if they were worth it or not and give my unbiased opinion and these are so far my favs! Let me know if you guys want a lil Sephora series where I test viral p
Keekee☁️

Keekee☁️

4833 likes

French skincare meets TikTok hype, worth the hype?
Morning: Start with their gentle cleanser (smells like fresh roses!), then the vitamin C serum. My my dull skin instantly lit up with a radiant glow. Top with their SPF 30 moisturizer, just dewy protection. Night: Their balm cleanser melts off mascara like magic, even waterproof! Then the retino
Milaalim

Milaalim

3230 likes

A flat lay shows five different concealer products lined up, with text indicating they are top recommendations. The products vary in bottle shape and color, suggesting a range of options.
Two bottles of a skincare serum and concealer product are displayed, one new and one used, highlighting its medium coverage. Both bottles have a pump dispenser and light pink caps.
A concealer product with a sponge-tip applicator is shown next to its cap, indicating it offers medium coverage. The clear bottle has a red and white label.
Concealers that are ACTUALLY worth the hype 🎀✨
products: 🫐Nyx Bare With Me Concealer Serum ∘ Skincare serum + concealer in one! (tremella mushroom, cica, and green tea) ∘ A little goes a long way so it lasted a good while for me! ∘ Buildable coverage ⋆ $12 🍒Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circle Treatment Concealer ∘ I’ve b
Nat🎀

Nat🎀

1088 likes

supplements that are actually worth the hype✨
@Whole Foods is having a huuuuge supplement sale rn so here’s all the supplements that are actually worth the hype #wholefoodshaul #healthyhabits #supplements #wholefoods #fitnessjourney
radiatewithcait

radiatewithcait

1679 likes

A collection of various skincare products, including tubes and jars, displayed on a light surface. The image features text indicating a ranking of Korean skincare products, focusing on a specific edition.
A tube of eye serum is shown with a rating of 8.5/10. Text highlights its lightweight yet hydrating nature and suitability for use under makeup.
A tube of sunscreen with SPF 50 is displayed, rated 7/10. Features mentioned include being lightweight, glowy, no white cast, but having a slight sunscreen scent.
Korean skincare that’s worth the hype✨🤍
I wanted to share my honest ranking of the Beauty of Joseon products I've tried after using them consistently in my routine. These ratings are based on texture, performance, and how often I actually reach for each product. The Glow Serum is an absolute favorite for me - it gives the best glow w
Ashlee 🌸

Ashlee 🌸

845 likes

📍NASHVILLE RECAP: What’s worth the hype
Spent a few days soaking up all the Nashville vibes — music, murals, hats, donuts, and more. Here’s everything I did + my honest ratings (because not everything’s a 10/10 y’all 👀). If you’re planning a trip soon, SAVE THIS so you don’t miss out! 🚜 Nashville Tractor 💕 White Limozeen 🍩 Five Daug
Liz 🫶🏻✨

Liz 🫶🏻✨

103 likes

A hand holds a brown jar of a dietary supplement. Overlay text reads "Supplements That are Worth the Hype! (in my opinion)" with a white arrow pointing right. The bottom left corner has a logo and username.
A hand holds a brown jar of a dietary supplement. Overlay text presents a disclaimer: "This is my personal opinion... NOT to be taken as medical advice." A logo and username are in the bottom left.
A hand holds a brown jar of a dietary supplement powder. Text highlights it promotes relaxation, contains 3 forms of magnesium, and promotes restful sleep. It also notes that most people are deficient in magnesium.
Supplements Worth the Hype: what I buy on repeat 🔁
Again, please be sure you are listening to your own body’s needs and consulting with your physician to ensure you are being safe when trying supplements. Everyone is different and just because something works for me, doesn’t mean it may be the best option for you so please listen to your body 🫶🏼
Holly Faye

Holly Faye

523 likes

An open Owlcrate box containing the 'Heartless Hunter' book by Kristen Ciccarelli, an exclusive edition with a dark cover featuring a red rose and a key. Text overlays ask, 'Worth the hype or just pretty vibes?'
The 'Heartless Hunter' book cover, dark with a red rose and key design. Text bubbles highlight key elements: 'Dark academia,' 'Enemies to lovers,' 'Secret magic and danger,' and 'Tension you can cut with a dagger.'
An illustration depicting a man in a suit and a woman in a white gown at a ball. Text bubbles indicate 'visual, cinematic world,' 'morally gray characters,' and 'slow burn that actually delivers.'
Heartless hunter, worth the hype?
My honest thoughts on the hottest new release: heartless hunter 🔥📚 I saw Heartless Hunter by Kristen Ciccarelli blowing up all over the New York Times lists and BookTok and obviously, my FOMO kicked in 📖👀 Was I expecting an enemies-to-lovers, dark magic, morally gray love interest masterpiece??
Meredith Jao

Meredith Jao

18 likes

makeup products that are worth the hype!
here’s some makeup products that i 100% think are worth the hype and i would recommend to anyone! i have oily skin, so keep that in mind :) • e.l.f. power grip primer this is one of the only primer that i have consistently rebought. it’s super tacky and makes my makeup stay all day! it’s also s
lillian!

lillian!

1986 likes

Are these worth the hype? 🩷
These are all in my opinion! Now I need to do a post where all the books are books that I didn’t actually like lol #booktok #lemon8bookclub #books #reading #books 🫶🏼
cassidy valee 🎀

cassidy valee 🎀

50 likes

Luxury makeup that’s worth the hype👀😳
I love to splurge on products that actually perform well! Some products that I love to spurge on is base products! Here are some of my favorite products that I couldn’t live without or rebought multiple times 😂😅 Let me know what products you think are worth the hype?👀😍 #lemon8partner #mak
Prettythingswithjess

Prettythingswithjess

131 likes

A collage showcasing various dishes like truffle omelette, steak au poivre, bluefin tuna, and squash salad, alongside a glimpse of the restaurant's elegant interior with a large painting and plush seating, highlighting a new French restaurant in an UES townhouse.
A close-up of a truffle mushroom omelette, generously topped with shaved black truffles and chives, presented on a white plate, described as a delicious dinner option.
A close-up of a steak au poivre, featuring a thick cut of steak covered in a creamy, peppercorn sauce, presented on a white plate.
French UES townhouse spot worth the hype
Chez Fifi $$$ That new french spot located in a swanky Upper Eastside townhouse that's been all over your feed is actually worth the hype and its price tag. trust me - as a native new yorker and self-described foodie, the food is fresh, tasty, and its aesthetically pleasing decor isn't t
jadeglam

jadeglam

22 likes

Dollar Tree Baby Products WORTH THE HYPE😍
Hello👋🏼 if you’re new here, there’s something you need to know… I’m a dollar tree addict😂 I seriously cannot stay out of that store. Even when I don’t actually need anything, I still like to stop in just to see what new stuff they put out 😂 anybody else? These are some new products I spotted
Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

Dania Toddler Mom & UGC

57 likes

Is IV Therapy is actually worth the hype? 💧✨
💊While oral supplements are a great daily habit, they have to navigate your digestive system before reaching your bloodstream. 💉IV therapy takes a different route by delivering essential vitamins, minerals, and hydration directly into your circulation for 100% absorption and immediate impact!
Dr. Yuri Choi

Dr. Yuri Choi

41 likes

Two popular Japanese hair products, a gold jar and a pink bottle, are displayed against a tiled background, with text asking if viral haircare is worth the money.
A hand holds an open blue hair styling stick, revealing the solid product inside, used for smoothing flyaways and baby hairs.
A pink bottle of a hair treatment, featuring a cartoon character, is shown against a tiled background.
Japan’s Viral Haircare Is Worth the Hype 🇯🇵✨
I picked these up while I was in Japan after seeing them everywhere on TikTok, and they’ve genuinely replaced so many other items in my hair care routine. If you’re planning a Japan trip (or shopping online), these are the products I’d 100% recommend to you 💛 Products Details: (+ approximate pri
Venus 🇹🇭

Venus 🇹🇭

19 likes

A hand holds a box of Built Puff protein bars, featuring Brownie Batter and Cookie Dough Chunk flavors. The box highlights protein, collagen, and calorie information for each flavor, with text overlay 'RATING BUILT PUFF PROTEIN BARS'.
Two individual Built Puff protein bar wrappers, Brownie Batter (brown) and Cookie Dough Chunk (teal), are held in a hand. Text overlays indicate 'BROWNIE BATTER: 9/10' and 'COOKIE DOUGH: 10/10' ratings.
A Built Puff protein bar, unwrapped and bitten in half, reveals its soft, marshmallow-like interior. A hand holds the bar, with text overlays 'PUFFY MARSHMELLOW-Y TEXTURE + DELICIOUS TASTE!' and 'LOVE IT! 😊'.
Built Puffs Review: Are They Worth the Hype?🍪🍫
Rating Built Puffs Protein Bars ⭐️🍫 I finally tried the Built Puffs and had to share my thoughts! 🤎✨ These protein bars are SO different from the usual chalky, hard-to-eat ones. They have a soft, marshmallow-like inside and a yummy chocolatey coating—honestly, they feel more like a treat than a
Anna🫶🏼

Anna🫶🏼

65 likes

A light pink perfume bottle is centered on a pink fuzzy background. Overlays include 'I NOMINATE,' 'LEMON8 HOLY GRAIL,' a 'VERIFIED ON LEMON8' stamp for user reviews, and five gold stars, indicating a positive review. The bottle has text on its front.
Is Burberry Her Actually Worth The Hype? 🍓✨
I finally tried Burberry Her after seeing it everywhere, and here’s my honest take. It opens super sweet and fruity with strawberry and raspberry notes that feel really fresh and a little addictive. As it dries down, it turns softer and more floral, then settles into that warm musky base that ma
Alexandria❣️

Alexandria❣️

13 likes

A hand holds a bottle of shimmering body oil labeled 'SALT WATER VANILLA SHIMMERING BODY OIL' by Salta. The bottle is on a marble bathroom counter with a lit candle and jewelry in a dish. Text overlays read 'worth the hype' and 'shimmering body oil'.
This shimmer body oil is actually worth the hype ✨
Okay I get it now. This gives that glowy “your skin just naturally looks expensive” look without being sticky or over the top. The shimmer is super fine so it catches the light in the prettiest way, especially on shoulders, collarbones, and legs. Also smells SO good. Like clean summer vacation e
whatmarnieloves2

whatmarnieloves2

0 likes

A TV screen displays the HBO Original series "Welcome to Derry" with episode details and a "Watch S1 E2" button. A Pennywise-like figure holding a red balloon is superimposed. Text above the screen reads "IT *worth the hype!!* WELCOME TO DERRY".
this new show is worth the hype! 🎈💥
Okay but… Welcome to Derry on HBO Max actually shocked me 😳 I wasn’t expecting it to be this scary! I’ve never been scared by the “It” movies, but I wanted something spooky for Halloween and this show did not disappoint 👻 I’ve only seen one episode so far because my husband and I are saving the res
Myra 💞

Myra 💞

198 likes

is the biscoff cheesecake hack worth the hype?
Last week I tried the Oreo version of this and unfortunately… became obsessed. So obviously, it was only right that I moved on to Biscoff next. I had some leftover Trader Joe’s yogurt sitting in my fridge, so this felt like fate. All you need are Biscoff cookies (I snagged these for $3.50 at Ra
jess ݁ ˖Ი𐑼⋆

jess ݁ ˖Ი𐑼⋆

5 likes

A cozy bed styled with layered neutral bedding, including a knit throw blanket, with a nightstand and lamp beside it. The image introduces bedding brands that are worth the hype.
A bed featuring layered neutral bedding, including a prominent knit throw blanket and an olive green duvet. The text highlights the versatility of the knit throw blanket from Casaluna.
A bed styled with layered neutral bedding, including a knit throw blanket and a dark brown duvet. The text promotes the quality and color options of linen bedding from Quince.
bedding brands that are worth the hype
bedding brands that are actually worth the hype!! casaluna from target has the best knit throw blanket - it looks so good layered with just about any bedding & instantly makes the bed feel styled. quince is my go to for high quality linen at a more affordable price & I love that it comes in
saleaoneill

saleaoneill

318 likes

WELLNESS “TRENDS” THAT ARE ACTUALLY WORTH THE HYPE
I lovee a good wellness trend🤌🏼 which is why i literally try every single one i hear about😂 it’s simply for ✨experimental purposes✨ After trying all of the wellness trends that i have, these are the ones i personally believe are worth the most time and energy because they ACTUALLY work✨ Have you
Cassidy

Cassidy

288 likes

A light gray, spherical container with "rhode" branding, nominated as a "Holy Grail" caffeine mask. Overlaid text highlights it as verified, user-reviewed, and not sponsored, with a five-star rating.
rhode caffeine mask is WORTH THE HYPE! ✨
I’ll be the first to admit I was a little nervous about the price tag at first. $38 for a mask felt like a splurge, but after using the rhode caffeine mask, I can officially say it’s worth every single penny. I’m already planning on buying it over and over again. It has honestly become my favori
Myra 💞

Myra 💞

30 likes

Three cans of Ryl tea in Green Apple, Rocket Pop, and Blue Raspberry flavors are displayed on a wooden surface, with text indicating a tasting and ranking review.
A hand holds a blue Ryl tea can, featuring Jolly Rancher Blue Raspberry flavor, 5 calories, and a 5/10 rating. The text notes a lingering aftertaste and lack of distinct Jolly Rancher flavor.
A hand holds a green Ryl tea can, featuring Jolly Rancher Green Apple flavor, 0 calories, and a 7/10 rating. The text describes it as the best of the three, with an accurate candy-like taste but still an aftertaste.
ryl tea taste test! is it worth the hype? 🤔
I love finding new fun, low calorie drinks to try, so I had high hopes for these. Sadly, I wasn’t a huge fan. The initial flavor profiles are actually pretty accurate! The green apple literally smells and tastes exactly like the candy, and the rocket pop hits you with that classic summer popsicl
Myra 💞

Myra 💞

16 likes

A vanity table filled with various makeup products, a lighted mirror, and a laptop displaying a video. The image features text overlay about makeup that is worth the hype.
A pink tube of lip balm with a product swatch, highlighted as a highly-rated lip butter balm for hydration and shine, and featuring a beauty award.
A white and gold bottle of makeup setting spray, presented with a high rating for its flawless finish.
Makeup thats ACTUALLY worth the hype 🤧
#lemon8diarychallenge #makeup #makeuptips #makeupideas #makeupforbeginner #makeupdupes #sephora #onesizebeauty #rarebeauty #fyp
natalyy

natalyy

31 likes

A blue box and a small blue bottle of eye gel are displayed on a textured surface. The box highlights benefits like reducing dark circles and eye bags, with key ingredients such as caffeine and hyaluronic acid.
A hand holds a small blue bottle of eye gel. The bottle's label mentions it visibly reduces dark circles and eye bags, and is dermatologically tested with ingredients like caffeine and hyaluronic acid.
Two versions of the eye gel are shown: a small sample size pump bottle and a full-size bottle with a ceramic tip applicator. Text indicates the ceramic tip provides a cooling sensation.
belif aqua bomb eye gel is worth the hype! 🩵
I was able to try out a sample of the belif aqua bomb eye gel & let me tell you... it's worth the hype! 🩵 This k-beauty undereye gem retails for $32 full-size! 💸 📍: ulta beauty, sephora, khols, amazon. Key benefits ➡️ 🩵 deeply hydrates the undereye 🩵 depuffs 🩵 plumps fine
yariibabyy

yariibabyy

15 likes

is raspberry leaf tea worth the hype?!?
hello ◡̈ There are so many claims that raspberry leaf tea helped support labor but is there any real scientific evidence? Unfortunately no there’s not. Researching on pregnant women is actually incredibly hard. Every situation is so different so the lack of research is simply because of how diffi
mom | sierra ◡̈

mom | sierra ◡̈

46 likes

Velvet Lasso: Worth the Hype? ☕️
📍Address: 3254 Navajo St Suite 100, Denver, CO 80211 This coffee shop is definitely more of a latte lovers spot. It’s not on the level of being Starbucks sweet, but it’s a good middle ground between a hint of sweetness and actually being able to taste the coffee. 💰 Price: I paid $14 plus ta
poparoundtown365

poparoundtown365

6 likes

A hand holds a white and pink nutrition supplement container with 'WORTH THE HYPE?' overlaid. The container features a watermelon slush graphic and text indicating benefits like bloating, immunity, energy, and digestion. It also states 'MY REPURCHASE PRODUCT'.
WORTH the hype?
⭐️Kiala Nutrition Watermelon Slush⭐️ If you’ve been on Tik Tok then you’ve probably gotten a million ads for this like I have 😅 I caved in and bought it after reading the reviews and let me tell you… it’s worth it! The taste is way better than other green brands I’ve tried that taste like chalk
Amalee Perozo

Amalee Perozo

138 likes

A hand holds two hair products, a smaller bottle with a yellow cap and a taller white spray can. The image questions if the haircare was worth the cost.
A hand holds a small bottle of hair oil with a yellow dropper cap. Text highlights that a few drops resulted in smoother, softer hair with less frizz and glossy shine.
A hand holds a white dry shampoo spray bottle with a blue band. Text describes the product as a non-aerosol mist that felt damp but extended time between washes by two days.
I Spent $100+ on K18 Haircare… Was It Actually Worth It? 💸👀
I spent over $100 on two K18 products, so obviously I needed to know whether I had purchased life changing haircare or simply very pretty bottles 😭💸 After actually using the K18 AirWash Dry Shampoo and K18 Molecular Repair Hair Oil, my honest answer is this: They are expensive, but both earne
mads 👏🏻

mads 👏🏻

12 likes

A collage featuring various dishes like pasta, a burger with fries, and appetizers, alongside an illuminated restaurant interior. The text "4 Viral NYC Restaurants worth your & the hype" is prominently displayed.
A close-up of a plate of spicy rigatoni pasta with red sauce on a decorative plate. Text identifies it as "Carbone celeb fave spot serving family style known for its spicy rigatoni."
A black plate holds several pieces of fried chicken nuggets generously topped with green caviar. Text identifies it as "fancy Korean fried chicken known for its nugget topped w caviar Coqodaq."
4 Viral NYC spots worth your 💸& the hype
Carbone New York $$$ one of the hardest reservations in nyc - seriously you better set your alarm to 10am every 21 days - does live up to the hype and primarily for its family size portions and spicy rigatoni. the sauce truly is to die for and it never quite tastes the same when I make it at hom
jadeglam

jadeglam

55 likes

The book cover for 'Icebreaker' by Hannah Grace, featuring an ice skater and a hockey player, is displayed with text asking 'Is it worth the hype?' and 'ICEBREAKER REVIEW.' A tablet, blue color palette, and a blue drink are also visible.
A flat lay features the 'Icebreaker' and 'Wildfire' books by Hannah Grace, a white book with red line art, two blue vinyl records, and a tablet showing ice skating images, all arranged on a white background.
An open copy of 'Icebreaker' shows highlighted passages discussing emotional understanding and communication, with a white book featuring red line art in the background. The page displays 'Chapter Thirty Six' and 'NATHAN'.
Icebreaker... Was it worth the hype? 🥰✨
Icebreaker - Hannah Grace 4.5 stars I absolutely adored this read. Especially because I loved how the storyline intertwined with major themes of mental health. I also loved how this book was diverse but in a way where it was naturally written and not trying to force anyone to be anywhere. The s
Mariam Damlakhi

Mariam Damlakhi

8 likes

Trendy makeup that’s worth the hype?
What viral makeup products do you think are ACTUALLY worth the hype? Let us know in the comments! Credit 💌: @Julia #letschat #viralmakeup #ViralBeauty #worththesplurge
Lemon8 Beauty

Lemon8 Beauty

216 likes

Two open takeout containers hold bagels from Brick Street Bagels in Boston. One bagel features lox, red onion, and dill, while the other has sliced tomato, cucumber, and dill, asking if it's worth the hype.
A line of customers waits outside the Brick Street Bagels storefront in Boston. The text notes that a line is normal but moves quickly due to efficient service inside the establishment.
A hand holds a 'Mother's Garden' bagel topped with garlic and herb cream cheese, sliced cucumber, tomato, dill, capers, and olive oil, presented in bright sunlight.
Brick Street Bagels, worth the hype??
my favorite bagel spot is now OPEN in Southie with a storefront!! why is it my fav? likely because it’s local and small biz and that’s where I’d rather put my money towards BUT ALSO because they’re actually very good got the Classic Lox and Mother’s Garden for the haul. the only con is that they
Vivian!

Vivian!

10 likes

See more