Having spent quite a bit of time playing with both the Needoh Gumdrop and the dollar store dupe, I've gathered some personal insights that might help you choose the right squishy toy for your collection. The first thing I noticed is that the authentic Needoh is significantly smaller and has a firm, almost hard squish due to its sugary substance inside. This makes it perfect for those who enjoy a satisfying resistance when squeezing, as it slowly regains its original shape. On the other hand, the dollar store version is noticeably bigger and softer, providing a much easier and gentler squish. If you prefer a more subtle tactile experience that doesn’t put much pressure on your hands, this dupe might be the ideal pick. However, this softness also makes it less durable over time, especially if you like to squish frequently. One fun aspect is the gumdrop shape that both toys share, giving them an appealing and cute look. While the original Needoh has a solid build, the dollar store alternative can sometimes feel a bit too pliable, which can influence how satisfying the toy feels during play. Another tip: you can actually try to soften the original Needoh slightly by warming it up in your hands before squishing, which might balance out the firmness and provide a new experience. Similarly, if the dollar store dupe feels too soft, you might experiment with slightly chilling it to add a bit of firmness. Overall, while the real Needoh is becoming harder to find, the dollar store dupe is a great budget-friendly alternative that still offers a neat squishy experience. Your choice ultimately depends on whether you prefer a firm, tactile resistance or a soft, easy-to-squish toy. Both have their charm, and trying out each can be a fun way to understand your personal preference better!