2/14 Edited to

... Read moreBaking NYC bakery style cookies at home is such a rewarding experience, especially if you love that perfect balance between a soft center and slightly crisp edges. One tip I’ve found really helpful is to chill your cookie dough for at least 24 hours before baking. This step allows the flavors to deepen and the texture to improve, giving you cookies that truly taste like they came from a New York bakery. Another trick is to use a combination of brown and white sugar; brown sugar adds moisture and chewiness, while white sugar contributes to the cookie’s crispness. Also, don’t skimp on the quality of your vanilla extract—it really makes a difference in flavor. When shaping your cookies, aim for larger, slightly flattened rounds to replicate that classic bakery style. Baking at a slightly lower temperature than usual helps the cookies cook evenly, staying soft in the middle but lightly golden on the outside. Finally, be sure to let your cookies cool on the baking sheet for a few minutes before transferring them to a wire rack—this helps them set perfectly. Happy baking, and trust me, once you try these techniques, your homemade NYC bakery style cookies will become a family favorite!

Related posts

NYC thin and Gooey cookies! 🍪🤎
Chocolate chip is my go-to! What’s your favorite cookie? Let me know down below!🤎 Recipe and more below⇩ ••• 2 cups all-purpose flour ½ teaspoon baking soda 1 teaspoon cornstarch ¾ teaspoon salt 1 cup unsalted butter ¾ cups granulated sugar ¾ cup packed brown sugar 1 large egg 1 larg
𝐚𝐛𝐛𝐞𝐲🤎🧺🌾

𝐚𝐛𝐛𝐞𝐲🤎🧺🌾

2979 likes

A collage of various pastries, including spiral buns, a croissant with pistachio and rose, and a pastry in a box, with the text 'NYC BAKERIES TO TRY' overlaid.
The exterior of Radio Bakery, a brick building with a dark awning and large windows, with the text 'RADIO BAKERY' overlaid.
An interior view of Radio Bakery, showing a display counter filled with numerous spiral-shaped pastries and croissants, with text indicating long lines.
hottest nyc bakeries you must try
nyc bakeries are truly elite and these are some bakeries you must try in nyc: 1. librae - bakery known for their middle eastern flavours. one of their popular items, the rose pistachio croissant ($8.50) is definitely worth getting with a crunchy roasted pistachio crust and a creamy pistachio fil
nessie

nessie

1044 likes

A bakery display case filled with various cute, Asian-inspired desserts, including small pastries with faces, tarts, and other sweet treats, some with price labels.
A bakery display case showcasing cloud-shaped cakes, pink round cakes, creme brulees, and small pastries resembling dumplings, alongside packaged sandwiches and madeleines.
A bakery display featuring rows of cream puffs with different toppings, and packaged character-shaped macarons, including Totoro and alpaca designs.
the cutest asian inspired baked goods
Bibble & Sip is a small asian bakery in midtown with the cutest baked goods and cakes. Their baked goods boasts of unique asian inspired flavours that tastes amazinggg!! Their most popular item is their cream puffs ($3.90). We’ve tried almost all the flavours (matcha, milk tea, earl gray) a
nessie

nessie

3595 likes

A collage showcasing various pastries and bakery scenes from NYC, including canelés, croissants, focaccia, and a matcha chocolate croissant, with the text 'NYC BAKERY GEMS VOL.4' overlaid.
An interior view of a modern bakery, likely La Cabra, with baristas working behind a counter and customers in the background, featuring sleek lighting and minimalist decor.
A close-up of two canelés, a croissant, and a cardamom bun on plates, accompanied by an iced coffee, all arranged on a wooden table at La Cabra Bakery.
✨NYC Bakery Gems Vol.4 🥐
Craving something sweet & savory? I found some exceptional bakeries that are redefining the pastry scene in NYC🥨🥐🍞🥖 La Cabra Bakery – A minimalist aesthetic Scandinavian import 🍮 Canelé – Their signature no.1 🌿 Cardamom Bun – Their signature no.2 🍞 Sourdough ☕ Hand Brew: La Roca, Cost
jessiesfwang

jessiesfwang

168 likes

NEW YORK Places I didn’t regret visiting ✨
• Remi43 Flower & Coffee 💕 This place is all about the atmosphere. It feels so refreshing to be surrounded by plants and birds! Yes, birds be flying there so if you’re scared of birds this is not the right place for you 🤪 • Funny Face Bakery 🧁 Such a beautiful bakery! The staff is
KK 💕

KK 💕

2895 likes

Is this the best croissant in NYC?
Pistachio croissants are my favorite in the world. This croissant was super high quality and the flake and butter on this was insane. French butter is truly the best in the world world and you can taste the quality! Definitely need to come back and try the other 🥐 Although I did love this croiss
Jaylynn Cardona

Jaylynn Cardona

363 likes

A hand holds a freshly baked chocolate chip cookie broken in half, revealing its melted, gooey chocolate center. Several other whole chocolate chip cookies are visible in the background, some resting in a wire cooling basket.
NYC Style Chocolate Chip Cookies 😋
Ingredients: 2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour 1 tsp baking soda 1 tsp salt 1 cup unsalted butter, softened 3/4 cup granulated sugar 3/4 cup packed light brown sugar 1 tsp vanilla extract 2 large eggs 2 cups semisweet chocolate chips Instructions: Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). In a med
Tiffany 💕✨

Tiffany 💕✨

9006 likes

An overhead shot of various desserts and iced lattes from ANDO patisserie, including Salted Egg Yolk Taro Puffs, Black Sesame Towel Roll, Taro Box, Basque Cheesecake, Jasmine Iced Latte, Peanut Iced Latte, and Jasmine Flower Pudding.
A flat lay showcasing a selection of desserts and iced lattes from ANDO patisserie, featuring Salted Egg Yolk Taro Puffs, Black Sesame Towel Roll, Taro Box, Basque Cheesecake, Red Tea Chestnut Roll, Jasmine Iced Latte, Peanut Iced Latte, and Jasmine Flower Pudding.
A close-up of a slice of Basque Cheesecake from ANDO patisserie, topped with whipped cream and delicate purple and yellow flower petals, presented in a white box.
NYC Dessert Haven with Fragrant Coffees✨
I’ve had my eye on this dessert spot for a while, and I finally got the chance to visit while in downtown. It didn’t disappoint at all—the flavors were perfectly balanced, and none of the treats felt overly sweet. Plus, the coffee was a highlight for me! Here’s what I tried: ☕️ Coffee: 1.
YiweiinNY🤯

YiweiinNY🤯

165 likes

GIANT NYC style pumpkin chocolate chip cookies 🍪 This is the cookie if you want a lottttttt of chocolate WITH your cookie (because let’s be honest chocolate is always the main character) 🤭🤭 This is a sky high pumpkin cookie stuffed with chocolate chips! It is the perfect fall twist on a cooki
Mallory Harr

Mallory Harr

100 likes

The Best Vegan Bakery in NYC
I love this bakery! The pastries are so good & fresh.I’m not vegan, but I love finding a great vegan restaurant or bakery. I don’t eat a lot of dairy & I used to be non-dairy for 6 years, so this is one of my go-to spots. Even if you are not vegan, you will love this place! The pastries
Safeezygal

Safeezygal

172 likes

The #1 croissant in NYC is worth the hype
Lafayette Grand Café & Bakery Okay, so let me introduce you to the Suprême—*the* pastry you need to try at Lafayette Grand Café & Bakery in NYC. It’s this super indulgent, cream-filled croissant that’s been getting a ton of buzz, and honestly, it’s totally worth the hype. it takes
Safeezygal

Safeezygal

2448 likes

NY cookies
Grand Island Sígueme en Instagram para tips y recetas🥰 en mi perfil está el link #nystylecookies #nycookies #galletas #bakery #cake
Roxy’s Bakery

Roxy’s Bakery

35 likes

THE CUTEST BAKERY IN NYC
this bakery has been on my mind all summer 🍰 it’s so cute and they also make breakfast sandwiches which are huge and $3.50. take me back 😩 I had they’re bacon egg and cheese on a croissant and next time im def gonna try their strawberry cake 🎂 im always looking for new recommendations, es
celeste ☆

celeste ☆

13 likes

Have you tried this before?
#bakery #newyorkcity
ItsYaBoyMike

ItsYaBoyMike

34 likes

🌟Fav bakery for every sweet tooth
Red Gate Bakery aims to blend nostalgia and comfort (think “childhood baked-good memories”) with modern, creative twists. and it does very well 🫶🏻 i have tried many of their cinnamon buns. each flavor is rotating weekly with seasonal flavor once in a while. so far i have tried and loved— 🍞 st
Ticha U.

Ticha U.

18 likes

cute Turkish cafe in nyc 🇹🇷✨
The Ivy Coffee & Tea & Bakery is a turkish owned cafe in nyc✨ They had turkish chocolates as well! Definitely keep this on your summer/fall drinks list! We loved their pumpkin latte! Location:📍East Village #lemon8partner #wheretoeatnyc #nycrecs #nycguide #nycfoodreview
eat.feast.repeat

eat.feast.repeat

133 likes

A vibrant array of intricate French pastries, topped with various fruits and garnishes, displayed on a tray, with the title "Where to Get the Best Dessert in NYC" overlaid.
A display window at Sweet Rehab featuring numerous small, intricate French pastries, two bottles of champagne, and a large pastry under a glass cloche. Pastries range from $10-$25.
Two gourmet ice cream sundaes from Caffé Panna, generously topped with sauces, cookies, and other treats, with one being drizzled from above. Scoops start at $7 and pints are $13.
BEST DESSERT SPOTS IN THE CITY 🍰🍪🍦
Sweet Rehab: Chic dessert and champagne bar serving intricate French pastries, teas, and caviar. Caffé Panna: Italian inspired gourmet ice cream spot with daily changing flavors and specials. Mah-Ze-Dahr: Bakery with 3 locations across Manhattan with highly acclaimed and luxurious treats, hot
Lex in the City

Lex in the City

385 likes

We made Shipping
#cookies #nystylecookies #dominicancake #bakehomemade 💵 Price:$8.00
Pinkcakery

Pinkcakery

9 likes

A display case filled with various crepe cakes, including a purple yam cake dusted with powdered sugar, and other flavors like matcha and chocolate, highlighting scrumptious desserts in NYC.
Two slices of Lady M crepe cake, one with green matcha and chocolate layers, and another with purple layers, showcasing the neat and clean layers of these famous desserts.
A Dominique Ansel cronut with white icing on a plate, alongside a dessert featuring watermelon, chocolate chips, and red swirled topping, representing iconic NYC treats.
scrumptious desserts in nyc 🍰 🥐
this list is for my sweet-tooth peeps. i have been to each of these places more than once. so, it’s a guarantee that they will not fail you 🫶🏻 Lady M Cake Boutique - New York City • the best crepe cake in the world. • the layers is so neat and clean. • cream / crepe layers are so perfect
Ticha U.

Ticha U.

101 likes

A vibrant kitchen with disco balls and a neon sign, featuring stand mixers on a counter. The image introduces "Unique NYC Experiences: FOODIE EDITION."
A close-up shows hands piping filling onto green macaron shells, illustrating a macaron/croissant baking class at Mille-Feuille Bakery in Greenwich Village, taught by a French chef.
This image displays various cheeses, crackers, and dough on a floured surface, with a hand holding a piece of dough. It highlights Murray's Cheese classes in West Village.
FUN NYC ACTIVITIES FOR FOODIES 🥐🧁🍕
🥐 Macaron or Croissant Making Mille-Feuille Bakery in Greenwich Village offers 2 hour pastry baking classes on Saturdays and Sundays led by a French born chef. You can choose a macaron class or croissant class which includes the preparation, baking, and learning the history and theory of pastri
Lex in the City

Lex in the City

924 likes

The #1 Must-Try Croissant in NYC
This croissant is definitely worth the hype! Lafayette Grand Café & Bakery Okay, so let me introduce you to the Suprême—*the* pastry you need to try at Lafayette Grand Café & Bakery in NYC. It’s this super indulgent, cream-filled croissant that’s been getting a ton of buzz, and hone
Safeezygal

Safeezygal

51 likes

✨ NYC Bakery Gems Vol.4 🧁🍩
Happy Saturday Everyone!! 🥳 Time for the hunt for that perfect pastry moment🧁🍰🍮 Here’s a list of bakeries serving up from viral buns to hidden seasonal gems—all worth the carbs! 🛎️ Seoul Sweets – Korean-inspired aesthetic gem 🍫 Dubai Chocolate Latte – Seasonal & limited, don’t miss it! 🌑
jessiesfwang

jessiesfwang

25 likes

New York style cookies 🍪
#lemon8diarychallenge #cookies🍪 #chocolate #chocolatechipcookies #Lemon8 #lemom8creator #lemom8diary #lemon8food
Lasmith24

Lasmith24

27 likes

A collage displays a matcha ice cream donut, cut to reveal green ice cream and cake, alongside a whole donut. Text identifies it as the "Wonder Wheel Matcha Ice Cream Donut."
A close-up shows a matcha ice cream donut, cut in half, revealing its vibrant green matcha ice cream and cake layers, nestled in patterned wrapping.
A whole green matcha donut, wrapped in paper, is shown with a "Doughnut Plant New York City" branded paper bag and an iced beverage in the background.
NYC: Must-Try Matcha Ice Cream Donut 🍩🍦
Finally tried the Matcha Ice Cream Donut at Doughnut Plant in BK, and it did NOT disappoint! 😍 I was in the area after a late Koi Omakase dinner (half-price deal, yes please!), so I decided to stop by and check out this donut shop I’ve heard so much about. • I went around 6 PM, and they were a
YiweiinNY🤯

YiweiinNY🤯

913 likes

Trying Minuto Bauli - Just Opened In NYC 🍰😋
Just found my new favorite sweet treat—Minuto Bauli just opened in Union Square! It’s an Italian bakery from Verona that’s been around for 100+ years, and this is their first U.S. spot. They only make one thing: the Minuto Bauli. It’s a warm, fluffy pastry baked fresh and filled with whatever yo
Savannah Vinson

Savannah Vinson

564 likes

This is one of the most hyped cafes in NYC
I went to SALSWEE to check out some of their pastries. The pastries are beautiful, but I wasn’t as impressed as I hoped to be. The interior is very fancy, and wide spaced. There is a good amount of seating, esp for NYC. I ordered the strawberry croissant, which was good. However, the actual c
Safeezygal

Safeezygal

563 likes

Love this Everything Focaccia
the best bakery in NYC!? #bakery #nycfood #focaccia #foodiespotlight @Lemon8 Food #lemon8food
jeremyj

jeremyj

247 likes

The best bakery in NYC?
This place is less than a 5 minute walk from my office so this is dangerous! But this might be the best pistachio croissant I’ve had in NYC 🥐 the chocolate was a bit much for me but I love pistachio so much! Reminded me of the same taste & quality as the croissants I had in Europe! I w
Jaylynn Cardona

Jaylynn Cardona

92 likes

Replying to @CULerkin Sofia & Grace Cookie Company in Bed Stuy was sooo good! They had a wide variety of things from cookies, empanadas, paninis and coffee. Definitely try them the next time you’re looking for a bakery in Brooklyn. @Sofia and Grace Cookie Co #nycfood #nycbakery #coffeeshop #
Tania🗽 | NYC LIFESTYLE

Tania🗽 | NYC LIFESTYLE

19 likes

Levain bakery copycat chocolate chip cookies
Creamy chocolate flavor always makes great cookies. This NYC Levain bakery copycat is actually so easy! SAVE THIS RECIPE 👇🏻 (6-8 cookie dough) 1 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature 1 cup powdered sugar 1 egg 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour 1 teaspoon baking soda 1 cup chocolate chips
Aila Lin

Aila Lin

133 likes

New York
#newyork #newyorkcity
Peepers

Peepers

965 likes

cool new NYC coffee & dessert cafe ☕️
SALSWEE $$$ this is hands down the most delicious, aesthetically pleasing nyc bakery with fake fruit deserts, almond croissants and the most insane matcha and coffee. its equally adorable too. the pastries are expensive, but they have every right to be. seriously i felt like i was eating a piece
jadeglam

jadeglam

78 likes

A little Paris in the middle of NYC 🇫🇷☕️
Popped into Le Pain Quotidien for a quiet coffee break and discovered two hidden gems: 🥐 Scone – Golden, crumbly, with that perfect butter-rich bite. Slightly sweet with a crisp top… made even better with a swipe of jam or a pat of butter. British soul, French flair. 🍮 Canelé – Caramelized sh
YiweiinNY🤯

YiweiinNY🤯

26 likes

Omg Korean Salt Bread!
please bring this to NYC #koreanfood #nyc #foodies #lemon8food
jeremyj

jeremyj

820 likes

NYC Style Red Velvet Cookies 🍪🍪
Red velvet isn’t just a flavor — it’s a whole mood. 💋🍪 #nyccookies #homebaking #redvelvetcookies #gbbo #relaxingatmosphere
The Kitchen Palette🍪

The Kitchen Palette🍪

7 likes

one single street, some of the best pastries in NYC, so worth rhe walk 🥐☕️💫 bundle up, hop on the L and stroll down Driggs Ave for these gems! KIJITORA - high quality Matcha with a menu of seasonal flavors - went viral (rightfully so) for their strawberry Matcha latte this summer La Bi
delaney

delaney

72 likes

See more