Buy or bye!!! My honest Mascara Review!!!

2024/9/17 Edited to

... Read moreIn the world of beauty, mascara is a crucial product that can instantly enhance your look. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one for your needs. In this review, I explore various popular mascaras and share my personal experiences with them. Starting with the L'Oreal Telescopic, I found it offers lengthening effects but can leave lashes looking clumpy. If you have straight lashes, the Elf Lash It Loud may not be the best option for you, as I experienced some discomfort while using it. On the brighter side, the Elf Lash n Roll received a high score of 11/10 for its ability to create fuller and longer lashes, making it a favorite for many. Essence's Lash Princess is well-known for its false lash effect; however, it may smudge and dry out quickly, which is something to consider. Maybelline Great Lash remains iconic and effective, although it can be tricky to remove after use. Ultimately, whether you should buy or say 'bye' to these products depends on your individual preferences and lash type. I've thoroughly reviewed each product, including their pros and cons, to provide you with valuable insights to inform your purchasing decisions. Don't let the mascara aisle intimidate you—read on to find your perfect match!

28 comments

ripples's images
ripples

Tartelette tubing mascara gave me a severe allergic reaction. I’ve never had any issues with any eye makeup previously.

See more comments

Related posts

HONEST Mascara Buy or Bye 💌
Products 🥥🌵 Cover Girl Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara 🥥 ↣ gives length, stays curled ☆ BUY ∘ $ 13 E.L.F. Big Mood Waterproof Mascara 🌵 ↣ so affordable, doesn’t run for the most part in water! ☆ BUY ∘ $ 8 Babe Lash Volumizing Mascara 🥥 ↣ doesn’t do anything for my lashes, no volume
Nat🎀

Nat🎀

3746 likes

Buy or bye?? 👀🤨
Honest drug store makeup review: buy or bye BUY Covergirl Outlast Lip Stain -$8 -Super long lasting -So pigmented, but blendable if you work quick. Last all day and are perfect with as a liner with gloss. BYE NYX Duck Plump -$12.99 -Agressive plumping and shine -The consistency is nice
Hannah Robinson

Hannah Robinson

1952 likes

🫧🌷BUY OR BYE🌷🫧
#Lemon8Box #buyorbye 💰Some great deals I get online that are worth the price! 🛍1:Carolina Herrera ⭐️Overall rating: 10/10 🛍2:Carolina Herrera ⭐️Overall rating: 4/10 🛍3:bath & body works ⭐️Overall rating: 10/10 🛍4:bath & body works⭐️Overall rating: 10/10 🛍5:bath & body works
Eileen lopez🫶🏽

Eileen lopez🫶🏽

1691 likes

Honest Review of Sabrina Carpenter’s Perfumes
I love my little collection, I am obsessed with them! Plus the bottles are so cute, but warning 2 of them did come with two different shades of the top and bottom of the perfume. Luckily it is barley noticeable unless you search for it! #perfumereview #sabrinacarpentersweettooth #sabrina p
eye-luh 👼🏻 🤍

eye-luh 👼🏻 🤍

15.1K likes

Honest mascara buy or bye 💌
💌 Brand: GLOSSIER ⭐️Overall rating: 8/10 I LOVE this mascara, it’s a really good formula and it makes my lashes stay curled and long all day. 💌 Brand:MILK ⭐️Overall rating: 4/10 I don’t like mascara, the wand it massive and it’s hard to get a clean application. Very clumpy 💌 Brand:CLIN
kir<3

kir<3

125 likes

BUY or BYE
buy or bye 🍋 honest review of drugstore makeup products ❤️ #drugtoremakeup #ratebeauty #beautyfinds #byeorbuy #Lemon8 #lemon8challenge #BuyOrBye #ByeOrBuy makeup challenge Maybelinne Fit Me Powder : buy very affordable and turns oily to matte Maybelline Superstay Viynl Lip
olivia

olivia

853 likes

🌟 BYOMA Buy or Pass: My Honest Review! 🌟
Hey beauties! Ready for some BYOMA product reviews? Let’s dive into these skincare gems and see which ones are worth your hard-earned cash! 💸 1. BYOMA De-Puff and Brightening Eye Gel × PASS (This was a tough one!!) 😣 2. BYOMA Moisturizing Rich Cream × BUY! ($15.99) 🛍️💧 3. BYOMA Gel Cream Moist
Lola

Lola

21 likes

Buy or BYE: Walmart’s Skincare Products✨
🤩 Rating skincare products at Walmart with a Yes or No ( & reasoning! ) 👇🏼 ❌ St Ives Scrub: absolutely not! This is way too abrasive, there are better exfoliants! ✅ Peach Slices Snail Rescue Toner: anything by peach slices is amazing, this toner included! ❌ Clean & Clear Morning B
irianna

irianna

11.9K likes

BUY or BYE - E.L.F Edition
I love Elf but some products didn’t really work for me! Daily Song: ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5: Today’s song is “The 30th” by Billie Eilish. This song is about a car accident that someone close to Billie got into. It hits hard. Did you know that Billie Eilish is releasing her new album “Hit Me Har
n

n

1259 likes

BUY OR BYE ✨💵
Should you spend your money on these products? Let’s break it down product by product Item: e.l.f. JELLYPOP DEW PRIMER I don’t know how I did my makeup without this. Makes my makeup go on so smoothly, the only bad thing about this product is that it’s limited edition. It has a light watermelon
Darrah🎀✨

Darrah🎀✨

2043 likes

Buy or Bye? 🤔 my honest thoughts on my jewelry! ⛓️💎
i have bought quite a few necklaces from a few different brands now, all supposedly “surgical grade stainless steel”. i am very sensitive to some metals so its very important that i get pure stainless steel or silver or gold! here is what i think of all of the brands i’ve purchased from! vit
mash

mash

24 likes

Buy or Bye? Review ✨🌊
I recently bought a bunch of popular makeup products to up my makeup game and this is my honest review of them. Most of the products were good and this is all MY OPINION, which I am entitled to. 💄🛍️ Viral Tiktok Makeup Bag 🦋 I absolutely love this bag. It is so cute and compatible. Hold brushes
Alana Podgorski

Alana Podgorski

475 likes

Buy or Bye : Mascara Edition
Here’s my buy or bye on mascaras!! Can’t recommend the ilia and elf mascaras enough! Whats your fav mascara? #byeorbuy #lemon8challenge #beautyfinds #beautyreview #makeuprecommendations #lemon8beautycrew #lemon8beautycoupon #Lemon8Box
dani :)

dani :)

187 likes

Buy or Bye? | The Ocean Healed My Eczema Cream 🌊
I had a severe discoid eczema patch on the back of my neck months ago and now it’s fully gone and has been itch free thanks to The Ocean Healed my Eczema Soothing Cream! I was super skeptical at first seeing all its mixed reviews on TikTok but I figured why not give it a try 🤷🏻‍♀️ I am always
Shannon-Nicole

Shannon-Nicole

459 likes

buy or bye : mascara edition
This is my take on the “buy or bye” trend. Hope you liked. - Charlotte 🐚🥥🌺
Charlotte 🐚🥥🌺

Charlotte 🐚🥥🌺

288 likes

Buy ✅ or Bye ❌e.l.f. edition
Hi everyone!!! Today I'm reviewing everything i have from e.l.f. cosmetics!!! Here's a little review of all the products and their prices! 💌 Brand: e.l.f. elf setting powder: I have this in the pink shade and love it! works super well and does not look chalky 💵 Price: $8.00 ⭐️Overall r
Cordelia

Cordelia

1504 likes

Honest Review: Eos Crème De Pistachio Lotion
Honest Review – EOS Crème de Pistachio 🍨✨ I absolutely LOVE the scent of this! The very first thing that hits my nose is a rich, sweet vanilla toffee—warm, cozy, and dessert-like in the best way. The pistachio note is definitely there, but it’s soft and subtle—don’t expect a strong nutty or gree
HeyItsAshleyK1

HeyItsAshleyK1

244 likes

buy 🛍️ or bye 👋 | rating lippies 💋
Honestly rating & reviewing trending lip products💋 I will always be honest when I’m sharing my opinion especially when it comes to the “trendy” stuff. I never want someone to spend money on something that isn’t worth it!! I hate reading reviews & realizing the product is nothing like ppl
skylar

skylar

216 likes

my honest mascara review
SINCE WHEN CAN WE ONLY HAVE FIVE HASHTAGS?! #theyre real mascara #honest mascara & lash primer #well people mascara #some vegan mascara #better than sex mascara
gracie

gracie

8 likes

💅 Mascara💅
Since people were asking 😇 here are my #buyorbye for Mascaras @Jana I hope this helps ❤️😇 What else would you guys have me do ❤️ Comment down below 💖🤗 #viralmascara #mascararecommendations #makeup #mascaratips #mascararecommendation #mascararoutine @Lemon8 Beauty #Pat
Aaliyahj.makeup

Aaliyahj.makeup

76 likes

BUY OR BYE ✨💵
Should you spend your money on these products? Let’s break it down product by product Item: The Ordinary GLYCOLIC ACID This product has quickly become a staple in my night routine. It has so many different uses and truly is like an all in one product. I have a super flaky scalp and these helps
Darrah🎀✨

Darrah🎀✨

625 likes

BUY OR BYE? : HONEST REVIEW 🛍️ or 👋🏾
BUY OR BYE? : HONEST REVIEW 🛍️ or 👋🏾 In this post I feature six products and give an honest review on if they are worth buying or not. These are some of my favorite products 🌟but are they really worth buying? 🤔 All of these products can be found at Target or your local Walmart. You can also go to
Ashley Willis.

Ashley Willis.

323 likes

COSMIC BY KYLIE HONEST REVIEW: BUY OR BYE?🛍️👋🏼
This is my honest review, it is one of my favorite fragrances EVER! It lasts for hours and I’ve already gotten so many compliments on it. It smells very luxurious but not overpowering where it’s nauseating. This is a work of art tbh🥲 NOTES- opening: star jasmine and blood orange heart: golden
Rianna Pepe

Rianna Pepe

42 likes

Honest review of Sky High Mascara
💌 Brand: Maybelline 💵 Price:$10 👍Pros : Makes eyelashes have more volume! Purchased from: Walmart ⭐️Overall rating: /10:10 Additional Tips: I honestly like to get a paper towel and get some of the mascara off the brush before applying so it’s not too thick looking on eyelashes! #skyh
Carissa Juhl

Carissa Juhl

134 likes

Billie Eilish Perfume..honest review💭
⭐️Overall rating: 3.5/5 💰Price: 3oz/$72 I’ve heard all the girls rave about this so when I saw that #ulta had it on sale during there “21 days of beauty” I had to grab it. I was able to get this 3.5oz for only $34 which is a steal b/c the 1oz runs for $52 @ regular price! #ultahaul #perfum
Khalisa 🫶🏾

Khalisa 🫶🏾

513 likes

BUY or BYE? honest opinion
after purchasing and testing our hundreds of mascaras, i have decided on my final top 3! 1. THRIVE Cosmetics Liquid Lash Mascara 2. Clinique Mascara 3. Lash Sensational Mascara #beautyroutine #lemon8challenge #mascara #buyorbyemakeup #lashes
nails

nails

35 likes

honest new product review 💕✨🌸🎀
Quick Smash or Pass 🎀🫶🏼✨>> Ordinary - pass Caudalie - smash Too Faced - smash Milk - pass Summer Fridays- pass (on this flavor) I love trying new products! I’ve been trying to cut back buying all the new & “trendy” makeup in 2024 but I’m just a girl 👸🏼💕 #deinfluencing
skylar

skylar

770 likes

BYE or BUY (TESLA)
#verifiedonlemon8 #honestreview #morphe 💌 Brand: Tesla Model 3 💵 Price: around 20,000 👍Pros : ??? 🤔Cons: ??? ⭐️Overall rating: /10: 7 What is your opinion on Teslas?
🤍

🤍

3 likes

Buy or Bye: Body Glaze by Canvas Beauty ??
This is my 2nd time purchasing any of the body glaze products and I want to give my honest review! The first time I purchased the full sized ‘Drunken Peach’ and ‘Strawberry Shortcake’ and to me it had a faint smell BUT everyone around me smelled it from a few feet away and LOVED IT! At first I
Elyssia 🩷

Elyssia 🩷

107 likes

BRUTALLY HONEST REVIEW MASCARAS
#brutallyhonest #honestreview #makeupreview #mascararecommendations #mascarareview
KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

KAYLA🤎🧸✨🐆

502 likes

NEST Santa Barbara Strawberry- Honest Review
🍓This question might be better suited for millennials and older lol… You know those red strawberry candies with the ancient white dust looking film on it- the ones with the red and green plastic around it? Your grandma sometimes asked you if you wanted a piece of candy, you would say yes and then s
Court.Charisse

Court.Charisse

195 likes

HONEST PUMPKIN SPICE PERFUME REVIEW 🎃🍂✨
I just bought Pumpkin Epicee by Le Monde Gourmand hair and body mist and here's the rundown: PRICE: $28 NOTES: Pumpkin Spice, Nutmeg & Frothed Milk, Musk & Sandalwood MY REVIEW 👇👇 SMELL: 10000/10, it smells delicious! I was so excited when I smelled it! LASTING POWER: 7/10,
Lushie Club 💖

Lushie Club 💖

258 likes

Honest Review of the Loveshackfancy x Stanley
I do love it but I wish it had the straw… it is sort of an awkward shape just in that when you have the lid off you can’t fill it up all the way and you have to make sure you screw it all back on so it doesn’t leak. Did anyone buy this? What are your thoughts? #LOVESHACKFANCY #waterbottle
molly

molly

359 likes

Buy or Bye
I say… BUY !! I have used my ipad for everything!! I am a music education major at college and i use my ipad and apple pencil for EVERYTHING. 💌 Brand: Apple Purchased from: Apple Store 🌹Pros : - read music for concert band - read textbooks - write notes - use as second screen for
Tori

Tori

209 likes

Honest review buy or bye
I finally got my hands on the milk makeup bronzer in the shade toasted 💰Price: 24:00 👍Pros: The color is gorgeous easy to use blends like butter lovely finish natural look #milkbronzer #naturallook #honestreview #easytoblend #buyorbye #honestbeautyreview #Lemon8Diary #lemon8challeng
Natybenvecer22

Natybenvecer22

8 likes

Buy 👍🏽or bye 👋🏽 (curly hair edition👩🏽‍🦱)
I’m reviewing The Doux Bananas Gel, and let me tell you—it’s amazing! I didn’t even need a base gel or mousse on top because the hold is THAT good. Plus, no flaking like the Bee Girl Custard! If you’re thinking about trying it, don’t walk—RUN (or better yet, teleport!) to the store and grab one!
Beauty NM

Beauty NM

171 likes

An honest review
I’m back with another honest review from someone who’s not trying to sell you some thing 🩵 Today’s focus is #skincare specifically …SKINFIX. Now right off the bat this is a very expensive brand …. caught myself looking at it for a couple months trying to talk myself away from it because to be
With Love, Kirsten

With Love, Kirsten

65 likes

Is this mascara worth it??
Honest thoughts, I like it and I would buy it again this is the essence mascara. Price $4 #lemon8partner #makeupreview #makeuprecommendations #makeuptutorial #mascarareview #makeup
Katelynn 💗

Katelynn 💗

189 likes

💖 Honest Dollar Tree Skincare Review 💖
✨ L.A. Colors Lip Oil - 10/10: Smells amazing (like coconuts?), not sticky, and leaves lips looking juicy! Great by itself or on top of another product. 😬 L.A. Colors Lip Gloss : -000/10: Oh no, soooo sticky and tacky! It was tough to get off, left my lips feeling weird, and doesn’t look good al
Jayyy Fayyy

Jayyy Fayyy

447 likes

BUY OR BYE? 💞
Honest review ‼️‼️‼️ Here are some products you need to know about! 🙌 I've tested them all, and it's time to reveal which ones you should BUY and which ones deserve a big BYE. Check out their textures, packaging, and more. Sometimes, the hype is just fake and lie, but I'm here to spil
Eto Tsindeliani

Eto Tsindeliani

466 likes

Buy or bye
This is an honest review on all these products not on the packaging or how popular they are. The brands are: 🛍Brand: Essence 🛍Brand: E.L.F 🛍Brand: Sol De Janeiro 🛍Brand: Covergirl 🛍Brand:Almay 🛍Brand:Mario Badecu 🛍Brand: Touchland These are in order ⚠️These are my opinion’s please
Sky

Sky

14 likes

my honest review on e.l.f. products i own
product review 🛍Brand: e.l.f. Cosmetics ! #elfcosmetics #makeup #productreview #beautyfinds #elf blush #elf putty blush #elfmakeup #elf halo glow
bee✨

bee✨

310 likes

Buy Or Bye 👋
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge This is my buy or bye challenge! ✅I love Rare Beauty blush! Pros ——- •Creamy •pigmented •beautiful color! •lasts long —————————- Cons❌ ———— •Can get a little messy Drunk elephant jelly cleanser🐘🌷 Pros🫶 ——- •Washes nice •feels good after ——————-
Nat

Nat

11 likes

Buy or Bye (Mascara Edition)
❌Bye: Essence “I 🖤 EXTREME VOLUME” Mascara 📈Rating: 1/10 👎Cons: Too wet and the wand is awful 💵 Price: $4.99 ❌Bye: Maybelline Falsies Push-up Angel 📈Rating: 7/10 👎Cons: Not a fan of the wand, didn’t lift my lashes 💵 Price: $11.99 ✅Buy: L’Oreal Paris Telescopic Mascara 📈Rating: 10/10
torie belnavis

torie belnavis

146 likes

Brutally Honest Review
The packaging is stunning. that’s why I wanted to try because it looked really interesting and really pretty but I didn’t necessarily like the product. I was very disappointed because one of my favorite mascaras is from Lancome. It’s the Lash Idôle Lash-Lifting & Volumizing Mascara 💰Price: $3
Katelynn 💗

Katelynn 💗

30 likes

brutally honest review!💋
These are all my honest reviews over the viral makeup products I’ve tried!✨ Products: 💛Saie Super Glowy Gel This is my HOLY GRAIL. It looks amazing under makeup or can wear by itself. Makes your skin look so glowy. I use the shade Sunglow so it gives me natural looking tan! 💛LYS Bronzer This
ash💖

ash💖

77 likes

Buy Or Bye Mascara Edition 💅🏻
✅ Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara Mini I truly enjoy this Mascara, it is my go to because of how buildable it is and easy to remove, it doesn’t feel heavy on your lashes and it’s very long lasting and affordable. ⭐️Overall rating: 5/5 💰Price: $20 Full Size and $11 Mini Size ❌
RVhomecooking

RVhomecooking

58 likes

Forvr Mood Fragrances Honest Review
Ms. Jackie , Ms. Jackie you put your foot in these perfumes! As someone one who is a sweet vanilla scent girl , I’m going to rank the fragrances. There’s been alot of talk but here’s the real because I don’t get paid for this lol. 1) “Hard to get” is my absolute favorite!! I actually went ahead an
Glam dolls Si

Glam dolls Si

38 likes

Buy or bye
#buyorbye #lemon8challenge Elf product review (my honest opinion) Elf lip oil- super moisturizing and glossy love the colors and the feel of them on my my lips tastes like peppermint and not sticky! Elf clear mascara- flaky when it dries and not that much product Elf blush and bru
🎄•Stella•🎄

🎄•Stella•🎄

6 likes

Too Faced Mascara Honest Review 🩷
🤎 Better Than Sex - Brown This brown mascara is my fav!! Anytime I use it, it looks like it’s my my natural lashes but just a little more thicker. I love using this when I’m trying to go for a more subtle everyday look. 🩵 Better Than Sex - Waterproof the only waterproof mascara that actuall
Julianna ♡

Julianna ♡

55 likes

Buy or Bye - Glossier review 🌸
I ordered a buncha stuff from Glossier and here’s what I think is worth the purchase and what you should pass on: 1. Cloud Paint: BUY ✅ - the cutest package design - blends well and fun to mix shades 2. Skin Tint & Concealer: BUY ✅ - literally melts into your skin - such a natural
Lauren.e.albury

Lauren.e.albury

80 likes

REFY mascara review✨
REFY lash sculpt mascara in brown is amazing #rare beauty mascara #refybeauty #mascara #mascarareview
Luca Sofia 🧸

Luca Sofia 🧸

14 likes

Buy or Bye! mascara edition
Milani mascara:this mascara is amazing. gives the most beautiful long whispy lash look. give me a lot of length and makes my eyelashes look full. it is also a tubing mascara so it doesn't smudge and comes off very easily. Maybelline sky high: VERY runny, was hard to apply. after multiple coa
Payton Conzo

Payton Conzo

12 likes

My honest review of Korean products
I don't find it appropriate to recommend products without using them for a long time, so here is a real product review from your girl with dry skin 👌🏻💕 Purchased from: YesStyle #skincare #koreanskincareproducts #koreanproducts #beautyfinds #koreanskincarehaul
sseraykaraca

sseraykaraca

4 likes

See more