Trying the Protein Poptart

(Not sponsored) I don’t typically eat protein bars or protein desserts. I find most of them nasty, but I was surprised with this one!

I microwaved this for 10 seconds (recommended on the packaging)

Taste:

I like the flavor. I don’t think there’s too strong of a protein powder flavor that I typically have noticed in other desserts. The interior chocolate tastes good.

Texture:

This is where I think most people will struggle with it. It’s a dense and chewy dessert. It is thicker than a real poptart and a bit dry where there isn’t any interior fudge. I don’t mind it too much, but if you’re expecting an exact copycat to real poptarts, you’ll be disappointed.

Overall thoughts: I like this and think it’s a good healthier dessert alternative. I’m always craving chocolate. I would eat these again or try some of their other flavors

@Lemon8 Food #lemon8food #foodreview #healthydessert #proteinrecipes #proteinsnacks

2024/12/23 Edited to

... Read moreAfter trying the Legendary Protein Poptart, I definitely dove into the nutrition label, especially since many of you ask 'how much protein in pop tarts?' This one packs a serious punch with 22g of protein per pastry, which is fantastic for a dessert! It also comes in at 200 calories and has 5g net carbs, making it a surprisingly macro-friendly option. When you compare it to a traditional Pop-Tart, the protein content is a game-changer, helping me feel fuller and avoid that sugar crash. I always check the 'protein bar wrapper nutrition label' on new products, and this one holds up well for a 'healthy dessert alternative.' It's not just empty calories; it actually contributes to my daily protein goals. So, 'are protein pop tarts healthy'? Based on my experience, yes, they can be a healthier choice than many other desserts. While it's still a treat, the high protein and lower net carbs (5g!) mean it doesn't spike my blood sugar the way a sugary pastry would. Plus, for someone who's always craving chocolate, this 'chocolate protein poptart' really hits the spot without derailing my diet. It's about moderation, of course, but it's a great tool to satisfy cravings while getting in some essential protein. One thing I noticed, which the original review also highlighted, is the texture. It can be 'dense and chewy' and a bit 'dry where there isn’t any interior fudge.' My tip? Don't skip the microwave! The packaging recommends 'microwave instructions for 10 seconds,' and trust me, that's crucial. Heating it up makes the 'gooey chocolate filling' truly gooey and softens the pastry considerably. I've even tried it with a dollop of sugar-free whipped cream or a side of berries to add some moisture and freshness, turning it into a more complete 'healthy dessert' experience. If you find the texture still not quite to your liking, refrigerating it for a super-chewy, almost brownie-like texture is another way to enjoy it, though I prefer it warm. For those of you searching for 'protein poptart recipe' or 'legendary bars' alternatives, while this review is about a pre-made product, it inspires me to think about homemade options! If you love the idea of a high-protein pastry but want to control every ingredient, there are fantastic recipes online for DIY protein pop tarts using protein powder, oat flour, and sugar-free glazes. It's a fun project if you have the time! Or, if you're exploring other 'legendary bars' or similar 'proteinsnacks,' I've found their other flavors, like strawberry or cinnamon roll, offer a slightly different texture and taste profile, making them worth exploring if chocolate isn't your absolute favorite. Having tried a few 'protein pop tarts' brands, Legendary Foods definitely stands out for its flavor balance, even with the texture nuances. Overall, this Legendary Protein Poptart is a solid win for me. It's a convenient, high-protein snack that genuinely helps curb my chocolate cravings. Don't go into it expecting a sugary, flaky Pop-Tart, but embrace it for what it is: a much 'healthier dessert alternative' that delivers on protein and a surprisingly good chocolate flavor. I'll definitely be keeping these in my pantry!

25 comments

AmeliaC's images
AmeliaC

I don’t mind them plain but they are ten times better when microwaved

See more(1)
peaceonelove85's images
peaceonelove85

Blueberry is yummy too! They also have cinnamon rolls!

See more(1)

See more comments

Related posts

Trying The Viral Poptart Ice Cream!
#poptarticecream #poptart #icecream #foodie #fyp
Jas & Kam Food Reviews

Jas & Kam Food Reviews

12.8K likes

Healthy strawberry pop tart 😌✨
This was so good and great for breakfast if you have a sweet tooth in the morning, it has protein and no sugar 😇🥰 calories- 161 per pastry 🍓 Try it and let me know what you think 🤔 #bodytransformation #healthylifestyle #strawberry #poptarts #proteinbreakfast #proteinsweets
Chey Marie

Chey Marie

1180 likes

A baked strawberry poptart cobbler in a glass dish, topped with white glaze and colorful sprinkles, ready to be served. A rolling pin and a red candle are in the background.
Ingredients for the cobbler: two cans of strawberry pie filling, a container of fresh strawberries, a bottle of milk, a container of sprinkles, and two packages of ready-to-bake pie crusts.
Fresh strawberries are shown diced on a white cutting board, with an empty strawberry container and a red candle in the background.
🍓✨Strawberry Poptart Cobbler ✨🍓
Craving something sweet, summery, & oh so delicioussss? I gotchu girl 🙌🏻 This Strawberry Pop Tart Cobbler is the dessert you didn't know you needed. & hey, if you're feeling a little blue, switch to blueberries!🫐 Ingredients 🍓1 large container of strawberries 🍓2 cans of stra
Dasha Coffey

Dasha Coffey

3509 likes

A baked blueberry cobbler in a glass dish, topped with white glaze and colorful sprinkles, with a wooden rolling pin beside it. The image is titled "Blueberry Poptart Cobbler" with blueberry illustrations.
Various ingredients for blueberry cobbler are displayed: cans of blueberry pie filling, fresh blueberries, milk, powdered sugar, sprinkles, a lemon, and a box of pie crusts.
A blue and white bowl contains a dark red blueberry and pie filling mixture, being stirred with a blue and wooden spatula. The text indicates to "Mix blueberries & Pie filling."
🫐✨Blueberry Poptart Cobbler✨🫐
Craving something sweet and summery? This Blueberry Pop Tart Cobbler is the dessert you didn’t know you needed!!✨ Ingredients 🫐1 large container of blueberries 🫐2 cans of blueberry filling 🫐1package of roll & bake pie crust 🫐1 cup Powdered sugar 🫐3 tbsp milk 🫐sprinkles 🫐 1 1/2 tbsp o
Dasha Coffey

Dasha Coffey

3000 likes

Giant Pumpkin Poptart 🎃🍁
Giant Pumpkin Poptart 😍 recipe below a must for fall!! Ingredients: Filling: - 1 ¼ cups pumpkin puree - 1 cup brown sugar - 1 teaspoon pumpkin spice - 1 teaspoon vanilla extract - 2 tablespoons cornstarch Pop-tart: - 2 sheets puff pastry (about 9 ½ x 11 ¾ inches each) PS I used gluten
Jessica 🌱

Jessica 🌱

4363 likes

cinnamon roll ally but will never glaze a protein product 🙂‍↔️⛹🏻‍♀️✨ #proteinpoptarts #proteinpastries #legendaryfoods #proteincinnamonroll #proteinsweets #swolesweets
BuffUnicorn

BuffUnicorn

4499 likes

easy homemade poptarts 🫶
#homemadepoptarts #poptartrecipe #poptarts
stasha | runner + sahm 🫶

stasha | runner + sahm 🫶

1004 likes

Homemade Poptarts 🍓🩵
My first attempt at homemade pop tarts ! I had these in Nashville and immediately wanted to learn how to recreate them at home ! Ingredients - 2 boxes of pie crust 1 jar of strawberry jam - or whatever kind you like 1 egg for egg wash on top (optional) For the frosting - Powdered sugar
MollyMcLaughlin

MollyMcLaughlin

8386 likes

How I hit 50g protein without really trying! 🍳🤍
Not every breakfast has to be complicated 😭🍳✨ I’ve been so tired recently, but I love cooking my meals versus ordering out so let’s make it lazy today lol. Simple comforting meals like this have honestly been making me feel a little more put together again 🤍 So this is my current high pro
Florida Georgia Girl Eats

Florida Georgia Girl Eats

514 likes

A large, round, homemade strawberry pop-tart, cut into slices, with one slice being lifted. It features a white glaze, colorful sprinkles, and a visible strawberry jam filling, showcasing the finished dessert.
A list of ingredients for making a giant strawberry pop-tart, including pie crusts, strawberry jam, butter or egg wash, powdered sugar, milk, optional food coloring or jam for glaze, and sprinkles.
The first section of the method for preparing a giant strawberry pop-tart, detailing steps 1 through 5, which cover preheating the oven, preparing the crusts, spreading jam, sealing, and making steam vents.
🍓Giant Strawberry Poptart🍓
#yummy #lovepoptarts #homeade
whatalife64

whatalife64

913 likes

HEALTHY POPTART RECIPE
These are such a soft and cozy treat with a delicious sweet filling and glaze! Poptarts made healthy, yes please 🤗 All of the details are on my food instagram @lexasnoms ! Each poptart has 8g of protein and less than 200 calories, let me know if you try them and what you think 🎉 #healthydess
alexa n

alexa n

288 likes

We got Strawberry Poptarts at home!!
These are way better than the store! Just in time for the end of strawberry season. Overall rating: 10/10. Here’s the pe: Ingredients: Dough • 2.5 cups of Flour • 1 cup of Unsalted Butter; chilled & cubed • 2 tsp of Salt • 4 tsp of Sugar • 0.5 cups of Water; cold Filling • 1 16oz
Lil Bitty Jazzy

Lil Bitty Jazzy

384 likes

Mini Poptart ❤️
#crochet #amigurumi #plushies #cute #poptart
Little Bean Crochet

Little Bean Crochet

7310 likes

Homemade Poptarts! ✨🥰🍓🧁
These are so good! they are quick and toddler friendly. #homemadepoptarts #homemade #recipeideas #bakingfromscratch #toddlerfriendly
keeks

keeks

3696 likes

A stack of golden-brown cottage cheese protein pancakes, topped with fresh strawberries and syrup, with a bite taken out of the top pancake.
Oats are shown in a clear glass bowl, ready to be blended into oat flour, with a blender visible in the background.
Wet ingredients like eggs are in a blender cup, ready to be blended until smooth for the pancake batter.
These cottage cheese pancakes hit 30–40g protein without trying
If you’re trying to get more protein in the morning without overthinking it, this single‑serve pancake stack is perfect. It’s hearty, filling, and keeps me full straight through my lunch break Ingredients: 1/2 cup oat flour 1/2 cup cottage cheese 2 eggs 1 tsp baking powder 1/2 tsp vanilla
Sienna Paige

Sienna Paige

76 likes

A plate of homemade heart-shaped pop tarts, decorated with pink and purple frosting, some with sprinkles and chocolate drizzle. The image has overlaid text "POP TARTS HEARTS EDITION" and a Lemon8 watermark.
Eight baked heart-shaped pop tarts with crimped edges are cooling on a black wire rack. The pastries are golden brown, and a small orange heart emoji is overlaid on the left.
Several unbaked heart-shaped pastries with crimped edges are arranged on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. An orange wavy arrow points to one of the pastries, which appears to have an egg wash.
Heart Poptarts!!
Yes these are homemade and let me tell you these are amaaazing! The dough I used was a little bit of a challenge to work with but absolutely worth it. I used a Pate Sucree pastry dough instead of using phyllo. It was super easy to make. I whipped it up in the stand mixer and let it sit in the fridg
Oveja Kitchen

Oveja Kitchen

2523 likes

Homemade Raspberry Protein Pop-Tarts!
Gluten free, protein rich, naturally flavored & better for you and paleo friendly pop tarts! You'll need almond flour Tapioca flour Vanilla protein powder coconut sugar Grass fed butter egg Raspberries (or berries of choice) Chia seeds (for chia jam option) powdered monkf
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

164 likes

sourdough poptarts
dough: 280g all purpose flour 50g sugar 5g salt 4 sticks butter, grated 285g sourdough discard icing: 1/2 cup powdered sugar 1-2 tbsp milk #sourdough #poptarts #diy #homemade
erika | sourdough & diy

erika | sourdough & diy

20 likes

PoptartHomemade✨🤍🍓
Who Loves PopTarts?✨🤍 #poptart #homemade #strawberries #fyp #popular
🖤🍒ʟᴀʟʏ🍒🖤

🖤🍒ʟᴀʟʏ🍒🖤

30 likes

GIANT POPTART
This GIANT Pop-Tart is everything your inner child (and your grown-up sweet tooth) needs. Just a few ingredients, endless filling options, and it brings all the big kid energy. Watch it happen in under a minute in the step-by-step video and then save to make this later, or make it today!
Holley in the Kitchen

Holley in the Kitchen

20 likes

If you’re trying to hit your protein goals... make these 💪
High-protein homemade bars 25g protein per bar and way better than the expensive shop ones. Easy to make and perfect for snacks or post-gym. Save this tor later 25g protein | 325 calories - per bar Tip: Everyone's goals are different! Cut the bars into 8 instead of 6 if the cal
Yasuan Vega

Yasuan Vega

24 likes

A protein drink hack featuring a glass of light-colored beverage, a mango-flavored protein drink bottle, a can of pineapple chunks in juice, and a red beverage can. Text overlays indicate "Hawaiian shaved ice," "mango," "Pineapple juice," and "Calories: 200 Protein: 23g Rate: 9/10."
Trying protein drink hacks:
Definitely liked the Alani drink better. It had better protein to calories ratio and tasted better! #proteinrecipes #proteindrinks #alani #sweettreats #protein
JessRox

JessRox

426 likes

Home Made Poptarts 👌
Homemade Brown Sugar Poptarts 2 pieces pie crust 1 tbsp melted butter Filling 1/2 cup brown sugar 1 tbsp flour 1 tbsp cinnamon 1/4 tsp salt Icing 1 cup powdered sugar 1 tsp vanilla extract 1 tbsp cinnamon 2-3 tbsps milk Steps -Preheat oven to 375* -in mixing bowl add all fi
Tessa❤️🥰

Tessa❤️🥰

287 likes

Thoughts on #poptart protein? Not a healthy breakfast item or snack IMO! 😬😬😬 #glp1community #proteinsnack
Nicole | Fashion & GLP-1 girly

Nicole | Fashion & GLP-1 girly

1 like

Frosted cookie dough pop tart cookie bars!
Gluten free, refined sugar free, and with a protein boost! These pop tart cookie bars have a shortbread pop tart base, and a cookie dough filling, baked to soft goodness, then topped with a dreamy cookie dough frosting! #poptarts #cookiedough #proteindessert #glutenfreedairyfree #hea
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

1304 likes

grinchmas poptarts 💚❤️
Recipe: raspberry filling 1 small container of fresh raspberries cooked down on stove top with 1/4 c of water and 1/4 c of sugar mix 1 tbsp of corn starch and 2 tablespoons of raspberry juices to make a slurry then pour slurry back into the pan with the rest of the raspberries dou
bramble 🍦

bramble 🍦

977 likes

Cookies n creme poptart ice cream sandwiches 🥶🍦
#icecream #dessert #poptarts #kookingwithki
KookingWithKi

KookingWithKi

1333 likes

Poptart or nothing 🫶✨
What’s your fav #flavor ?!? Ima smores girly #popgirlies #fyplemon8 #Lemon8
Danidoodles143

Danidoodles143

7 likes

Easy Fall Sweet Potato Poptart
Have you ever had a sweet potato Poptart? What you need Brown sugar Cinnamon Nutmeg Vanilla extract Alittle water for a smoother texture Pie crust 1 egg Sweet potato Frosting Powdered sugar Any milk - I used almond milk Cinnamon for topping I put my sweet potatoe in t
Gourmetlashay

Gourmetlashay

539 likes

Honest Protein Pastry Review
These are the four flavors I’ve found in-store to try and I don’t regret any of my purchases. My number one favorite was the chocolate until I discovered the blueberry… why do they have to be so expensive 😩. I recommend microwaving them for 10-20 seconds before you enjoy, it makes them so gooey! Al
.

.

406 likes

Healthy homemade Pop Tarts!
Gluten free, refined sugar free, and easily dairy free homemade pop tarts!! So far I've made Hot fudge sundae Peanut butter and jelly Raspberry frosted brown sugar cinnamon And triple fudge! What's your favorite pop tart flavor?! #poptarts #glutenfreedesserts #healthie
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

2311 likes

Homemade Poptarts
These are so addicting! I wanted to find more options for my kids breakfast and this will definitely be in rotation! The best part is they are so customizable, sugar content, shapes, icing amount. It’s all up to you! Give them a try and let me know how they turn out! Ingredients: - Pie dough, I
Kenna🐓

Kenna🐓

228 likes

diy felt poptart pouch!
#sewing #feltprojects
gigi

gigi

1101 likes

Poptart Magnets
Painting my Poptart magnets. I used paper clay to make these. I love using paper clay because it's more durable in my opinion. #clayartist #crafts #art #paintingideas
Britney Walker

Britney Walker

72 likes

A box of Pop-Tarts Frosted Apple Cinnamon Flavor (Apple Jacks) with a text overlay asking, 'WHICH ONES YOU TASTING?'. This flavor is listed in the article's desired lineup.
A box of Pop-Tarts Frosted Strawberry Milkshake flavor, featuring a pink frosted Pop-Tart with sprinkles. A text overlay reads, 'Light strawberry vibe??'.
A box of Pop-Tarts Unfrosted Blueberry flavor, showing a Pop-Tart with blueberry filling. A text overlay states, 'I was shocked to see these!', matching the article's mention.
Poptarts Munchies😩🧁
Y’all, I didn’t know this pop tart lineup was crazyyyy! 🥹✨I need like a lil charcuterie board of poptarts. I’ll have: 🍎Apple Jacks 🥠Sugar Cookie 🍌Banana Bread 🍨Boston Crème 🫐Unfrosted Blueberry Andddd🫠🙈 🥞Chocolate Chip Pancakes ❓Which ones y’all trying? #poptarts #summer #food
Kelly🎀✨

Kelly🎀✨

32 likes

these are DISGUSTING
I know these can't possibly be the same poptart replacements y'all have been hyping up. I'm still trying to scrub the taste out of my mouth. first of all, i know you see how disappointing that icing is. and second of all, I thought the point of most of these new hyped up protein snacks
auros

auros

367 likes

Not me trying to be cool 😂🤩
When the idea is dope but the execution fails miserably 😂🤩 #crochetersoflemon8 #crochetideas #crochetcontentcreator #crochetinspiration #poptarts
Lucy Coleman

Lucy Coleman

20 likes

Homemade Poptarts Recipe 🥧✨
These homemade poptarts are such a yummy & fun breakfast or snack! 🍓🧁 Ingredients: For the Dough: - 2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour 🥣 - 1 tbsp sugar 🍬 - 1 tsp salt 🧂 - 1 cup unsalted butter, cold and cubed 🧈 - 1/2 cup ice water 💧 For the Filling: - 1/2 cup your favorite jam or fruit p
Hadlee Potarf

Hadlee Potarf

14 likes

Strawberry Homemade Poptarts
Homemade Strawberry Pop-Tarts You can make flaky, buttery pastry filled with sweet strawberry jam and topped with a glossy icing? These homemade pop-tarts are easy, fun, and taste way better than the boxed kind. Perfect for breakfast, snacks, or dessert! Ingredients: Pastry: 2.5 cups flour
asipoftexas

asipoftexas

138 likes

Four homemade blueberry pop-tarts with a rustic blueberry glaze are arranged on a cooling rack. One pop-tart is broken, showing the fruit filling. The image has a 'blueberry poptarts' text overlay.
Four homemade blueberry pop-tarts with a rustic blueberry glaze are arranged on a cooling rack. One pop-tart is broken, showing the fruit filling.
Three unbaked, rectangular blueberry pop-tarts with crimped edges and small vent holes are ready for baking on a metal sheet, next to a rolling pin.
rustic blueberry poptarts
🌿 Homemade Blueberry Pop-Tarts These turned out so good and they’re easier than they look! Definitely something i wouldn’t mind giving my toddler for breakfast! Here’s how I made them: 🥧 Dough Mixed 2½ cups flour + 1 tbsp sugar + 1 tsp salt in my stand mixer (paddle attachment). Added 1 cup
bustosbakes

bustosbakes

78 likes

POPTARTS DID THAT🤏🏼🤏🏼🤏🏼
Poptarts + protein = my current obsession 🩷 Not every meal has to be “perfect” and “healthy”. Pairing something quick like a Pop-Tart with protein keeps me full longer, helps with energy, and honestly… makes it way more satisfying. Balance over restriction always. You got this, never settle just
Lexi Slover

Lexi Slover

6 likes

A hand holds a blue box of Pop-Tarts Ice Cream Sandwiches, Frosted Cookies & Crème flavor, featuring an image of the sandwich and a cookie. The box indicates it's a 4-pack made with real ice cream, seen in a shopping cart.
Two blue boxes of Pop-Tarts Ice Cream Sandwiches, Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon flavor, are displayed on a store shelf. Each box shows an image of the ice cream sandwich and states it's a 4-pack made with real ice cream.
Two blue boxes of Pop-Tarts Ice Cream Sandwiches, Frosted Strawberry flavor, are shown on a store shelf. Each box features an image of the ice cream sandwich and a strawberry, indicating it's a 4-pack made with real ice cream.
✨Poptart Icecream✨
#lemon8challenge #lemon8badgehunt #poptart #Lemon8
DrickaM93

DrickaM93

115 likes

Ingredients for homemade poptarts, including puff pastry, raspberry jam, cream cheese, and powdered sugar, laid out on a counter in front of a microwave.
A sheet of puff pastry dough cut into multiple rectangular pieces, ready for filling, on a baking sheet.
Rectangular puff pastry pieces filled with dollops of raspberry jam and cream cheese, prepared for assembly.
Easy homemade poptarts!
My first time making homemade poptarts. They came out so good and were so easy to make! Have you tried this recipe yet?😋 INGREDIENTS FOR POPTARTS: *puff pastry *jam of choice *cream cheese if desired *sprinkles if desired *eggs INGREDIENTS FOR ICING: * 1 cup powdered sugar * 2 tbs
In search of Destiny✨

In search of Destiny✨

44 likes

if you’re hungry 24/7 but trying to lose weight…
i’m a snacks girlie in a calorie deficit 😌 and these are my current ride or dies • the nacho cheese protein puffs taste like crunchy cheetos that lift • cheddar catalina mix is salty, crunchy, protein-packed goodness • barebells bday cake bar = literal frosting vibes i
malena ✿ wellness & habits

malena ✿ wellness & habits

111 likes

PB & J Poptarts ✨
Ok so the hubby’s fav combo is PB&J he also loves a pop-tart. Yes he’s still a kid at heart 😂 combined the two and made some PB&J Poptarts. Then I find out it’s Peanut Butter & Jelly National Day . So what a perfect day to share them . Cut my pie crust into rectangles and some squar
Apinchofirish

Apinchofirish

38 likes

See more