What to Read Next After ‘If We Were Villains’: Bookmas and BookTok Recommendations

8 followers

Follow

Follow

Follow

1/4

0 saved

finished ‘If We Were Villains’ today… what should i read next?

#winterbooksvibes #bookmas #booktok #happyholidays

2025/12/7 Edited to

If you recently finished 'If We Were Villains' and are wondering what to read next, you're not alone! Many readers find themselves craving a similarly immersive and atmospheric story after finishing this captivating novel. Since this post references #Bookmas and #BookTok, popular reading communities that highlight seasonal and trendy book picks, here are some recommendations that align well with the cozy, dramatic vibe of 'If We Were Villains.' A highly recommended read for those who love literary fiction with intricate character dynamics is 'Pachinko' by Min Jin Lee. This multi-generational saga delves into themes of family, identity, and perseverance across Korean immigrant lives in Japan. It’s a powerful story that combines rich historical context with compelling character arcs, much like the deep characterization in 'If We Were Villains.' Plus, the post references "day three Bookmas & Pachinko Min Jin Lee," indicating it’s a festive season favorite. For fans of dark academia or character-driven fiction similar to 'If We Were Villains,' consider diving into books like 'The Secret History' by Donna Tartt or 'Never Let Me Go' by Kazuo Ishiguro. These novels explore complex friendships and moral ambiguity in beautifully haunting narratives. Since you’re browsing #winterbooksvibes and #happyholidays, you might also enjoy a mix of heartwarming and engaging reads that celebrate the spirit of the season. Look for contemporary fiction or literary mysteries with rich atmosphere and emotional depth. Don’t forget to engage with the vibrant BookTok and Bookmas communities online—they offer fresh picks, honest reviews, and seasonal reading challenges that can inspire your next book choice. Happy reading and enjoy your holiday literary adventures!

Related posts

They Thought We Were Finished💀

💀 They thought the squad was finished… then everything changed. 🔥 Watch MstrComms live on YouTube for clutch Apex Legends moments, hilarious comms, and insane wins. Subscribe and join the stream! #mstrcomms #apexlegends #apexclips #gamingshorts #shorts

0 likes

A special edition of 'If We Were Villains' by M.L. Rio, featuring a dark blue and gold cover. Text overlays highlight themes of 'DARK ACADEMIA,' 'MURDER MYSTERY,' and 'SHAKESPEARE,' indicating the book's genre and influences.

An open book displaying a detailed, dark illustration of a moonlit landscape with a wooden pier, a small house, and figures. The image emphasizes that this is a 'SPECIAL EDITION W/ ILLUSTRATIONS.'

A worn copy of 'If We Were Villains' with a black cover and white text. Text overlays point out 'MY FIRST COPY,' a 'ROMANCE SUB-PLOT,' and 'THEATER COLLEGE STUDENTS,' describing key aspects of the book's content.

If We Were Villains

my rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/ 5 this is one of my favorite books of all time. i’ve read it multiple times and as seen in the pictures have multiple copies if you read and love The Secret History chances are you’ll love this one. book traits: switches between present and past, murder amongst a group o

25 likes

books i finished

#books #reading #romance #mysterybooks #thrillerbooks #youngadultbooks

315 likes

An open copy of 'If We Were Villains' by M.L. Rio, featuring a sword bookmark, a lit candle, and a 'BOOK CLUB' tin. Text overlays read 'annotating if we were villains' and 'It's time to Read'.

An open book with colorful sticky tabs marking sections like 'quotes/lines I LIKE', 'Important could be clues?', 'Women!', 'add a little bit of spice', and 'Oh Sh*t'. A sword bookmark is also visible.

A close-up of a book page from 'If We Were Villains' with a pink sticky note. A sentence describing 'a wild, savage blow' is underlined, and 'girl boss!' is handwritten in the margin.

if we were villains

my annotations for if we were villains . hoping that i can use this app to find people who love to read #ifwewerevillains #booktok #book #readersoflemon8 #reading #annotation #quotes

6 likes

A person's hand holds a physical copy of the book "Haunted Love" by Sheridan Anne, featuring a moth on its dark cover. Overlaid text reads "Finished Read w/ Annotations."

A digital page displays detailed annotations and notes about the book "Haunted Love," with its cover art featuring a moth embedded. Text highlights specific plot points and character interactions.

This image shows more digital annotations for the book "Haunted Love," including plot summaries and character reactions, with the book's moth-adorned cover embedded within the text.

Finished read: Haunted Love 📚

#smutbooks #smutt #smutreader

11 likes

We Were Mothers by Katie Sise

We Were Mothers by Katie Sise is a compelling, emotional read that will especially resonate with readers who love character driven suspense. What I loved most was how emotionally layered the characters felt. No one was entirely right or wrong, and each woman was carrying secrets, regrets, and impo

20 likes

A person sits on a concrete block, pointing, surrounded by space-themed doodles like planets, stars, and a rocket. Text overlays include "Recent finished projects" and inspirational quotes, all set against a cloudy sky background.

A collage featuring a person with curly hair, with close-ups of their eyes and lips. Decorative elements include a butterfly and color swatches. Text overlays read "may the flowers remind us why the rain was so necessary," "Art has no rules," and "promise me this love is forever."

A dark-themed collage featuring a person in a pink tracksuit, a skull, and various text snippets like "MY PROBLEM IS THAT I WOULD RATHER HEAR YOUR VOICE THAN HEAR MY FAVORITE SONG" and "love love love love." Newspaper clippings and a butterfly are also included.

Recent finished projects

For some reason I’ve been obsessed with doing this, I don’t even know what exactly it’s called or if it’s even a hobby. But it’s fun and keeps me occupied for hours. How am I doing so far? Any notes or advice for me? I use Pics Art, ibis Paint X and Canva. #sharemyart #COLLAGE #myart🎨 #Lemon

4 likes

A hand holds the extreme horror novel "Playground" by Aaron Beauregard. The cover features a young girl on a blood-soaked slide in a dark, stone-walled setting, with the title in colorful balloon letters. A quote from Brian Keene describes it as a "genuinely chilling, uncomfortable novel."

Just Finished Playground 🛝

Just finished Playground by Aaron Beauregard and I genuinely need to go touch grass, hug a baby, and bleach my brain. This book didn’t just cross a line — it straight-up spit on it, shit on it, and set it on fire while laughing in my face. I feel violated in ways I didn’t know were possible.

631 likes

A wide shot of a finished baby girl's nursery featuring a white crib, a white display cabinet, and a changing table. The room has two-toned pink walls, wood-look flooring, and natural light from a window.

A close-up of a white baby crib with a patterned sheet, a beige blanket, and decorative pillows. A baby monitor is mounted on the two-toned pink wall above the crib.

A white dresser serving as a changing table with a beige changing pad, a white diffuser, and a framed photo. Above it, a round mirror, a starburst decoration, and a circular shelf with essential oils and a cross are on the wall.

Finished Nursery Tour ✨🎀

If you saw some of my older posts, my husband and I bought a house in January and after some hard work and dedication, we renovated the upstairs to help turn it into our dream house. Before we finished the nursery, it was an unsettling shade of blue and the floors were covered in some pretty yucky

33 likes

A hand holds the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart, featuring silhouettes in water on the cover. Overlays include 'BOOK REVIEW', a paw print, a smiling book icon, 'Summer', and 'Lemon8 @knicoled13'.

We Were Liars Book Review

⭐️Overall rating: 4.5/5: Just finished We Were Liars by E. Lockhart and… wow. 😮‍💨✨ This book had me in a CHOKEHOLD. The writing is poetic and dreamy, almost like a fairytale—but underneath it all is this dark, emotional gut punch I didn’t see coming. I’m still recovering from that twist 😭 like

5 likes

An open Bible page displaying 1 Samuel 31, detailing Saul's death. The text is highlighted in various colors, and handwritten notes in the margins offer spiritual reflections on themes like humility, disobedience, pride, and grace. A watermark for 'lemon8 @mychristwalk' is visible at the bottom.

Finished 1 Samuel! Bible notes: 1 Samuel 31 💕

Finished 1 Samuel! Bible notes: 1 Samuel 31 💕

43 likes

A hand holds the book "I Am Not Your Perfect Mexican Daughter" by Erika L. Sánchez, featuring a girl with a braid on the cover. Overlays describe it as an "Emotional Contemporary YA BESTSELLER" and indicate a "Swipe" action.

An open book page displays highlighted text about a conversation regarding making tortillas. An overlay reads, "I laughed. I too had this type of conversation with my mom," reflecting a relatable experience.

An open book page shows text discussing career aspirations, specifically wanting to be a writer versus working in an office. An overlay states, "This felt too close to home," indicating a personal connection to the content.

Finished in a day read

Book Review~ but I never really gave a book review so yee :3 My review: At first I was getting annoyed, but then I began to connect to some things as a Hispanic girlie. I was unsure first reading this but it made me rethink a lot giving me a bit more appreciation to my parents. Julia goes up

8 likes

Finished the “IF LOVE” series…📚

Just got done with reading the IF LOVE series by Ana Huang 🥹 I loved each and every last story just like the ones in the TWISTED series 🥹🫶🏾 Whatever Ana Huang writes, I’ll most definitely read 🩷 Next series for me to finish is the King of Sin series 😩 #booksoflemon8 #bookrecs

37 likes

A stack of white books on a blue blanket with the text "Books I finished In 24 hours or less Romance Edition with ratings ;)" and a five-star rating.

A hand holding the book "Done and Dusted" by Lyla Sage, featuring a cowboy and cowgirl kissing on the cover, with a four-star rating and the text "obsessed w this couple."

A hand holding the book "Betting On You" by Lynn Painter, featuring illustrated scenes of couples on a pink background, with a three-star rating and the text "might be my fav Lynn Painter book."

Books I finished in 24 hrs OR LESS>>>

I’ll admit, a few I finished just because they were shorter books. But none of them I could put down! 🐎 DONE AND DUSTED by Lyla Sage: Western romance that stars a girl who falls for her brothers best friend (psa, he falls first and HARDER). 🍕BETTING ON YOU by Lynn Painter: A boy makes a bet

1577 likes

Just finished the essay, it was tough 🥲

Hmu if need some tips on how to write a great paper💯 #collegelife #college #help #lemon8creator #fyp

6 likes

We Were Liars — A Beautifully Heartbreaking Summer

I just finished We Were Liars by E. Lockhart, and wow — I’m still processing 😭. This was a 6 Star book 1000% I cried and wasn't ready to finish the book I didn't want it to and I didn't want Cady to remember her members just yet I wish she still had more time with them and to jump i

6 likes

📖 Just Finished the Introduction to All About Love

I just finished the introduction of All About Love by bell hooks, and one thing already stands out: We talk about love all the time, but many of us were never taught what love actually is. Not how to recognize it. Not how to practice it. Not how to give it to ourselves. I’m realizing tha

1 like

Finished reading Regretting you by Colleen Hoover♥️

#kindleunlimited #kindleaesthetic #colleen hoover book #regrettingyoucolleenhoover

36 likes

A book cover for 'The Ballad of Falling Dragons' by Sarah A. Parker, featuring black dragons on a light blue background with a yellow lightning bolt icon. User rating is 5 stars, and the Fable Community rating is 3.5 stars.

A review for 'The Ballad of Falling Dragons' with a 5-star user rating. The text describes the book as action-packed with multiple POVs, love, friendship, and heartbreak, calling it a favorite fantasy. A small book cover is in the corner.

A book cover for 'The Replacement' by Liv Constantine, featuring a woman's face with red lipstick and a lightbulb icon. User rating is 3.5 stars, and the Fable Community rating is 2.5 stars.

Just finished these

The Ballard of the Falling Dragons, so good, from beginning to end. Multiple POV. The Replacement, nice short story about karma, last month short story from Amazon Prime First Reads, The Safe Room, this month short stfeom Amazon Prime First Read, which it was longer. And last mint pick from Amzon P

0 likes

A hand holds the book 'Hide N' Seek' by Eden Emory & Ashley Pines, featuring a masked figure on the cover. The image is annotated 'Finished Read w/ annotations' and includes the Lemon8 handle.

The book 'Hide N' Seek' is surrounded by annotations detailing plot points like three games (Hide and Seek, Truth or Dare, Rat Race), character relationships, and a 'Hunger Games' vibe.

Annotations around the 'Hide N' Seek' book cover reveal character backstories, including Kohl being a trans-man, Vic's past with Dylan, and family secrets involving Kohl's father and Vic's dad's death.

Finished read 🏳️‍⚧️

#smut #smuttbooks #darkromance #dystopianbooks

8 likes

Finished Skulls

Crochet update! I finished the skulls squares I needed and started on the ghosts. The skulls were surprisingly hard (I'm a beginner), and I've been having a possible Crohns flare so there's been lots of joint pain in my wrist/knuckles/elbow/shoulder. It's a slow go, but I'm maki

8 likes

An outdoor scene at sunset with a car in the foreground and a house in the background. Text overlay reads: 'I FINISHED EPHESIANS AND I'M SO SO PROUD OF MYSELF!! I JUST WANTED TO SHARE HOW I DID MY BIBLE NOTES AS A BEGINNER!!'

An open Bible showing the book of Ephesians with highlighted sections and handwritten notes. A yellow sticky note with 'finished' is visible at the top.

An open Bible displaying Ephesians chapter 1, featuring extensive highlighting, sticky notes with handwritten reflections like 'gods plan > mine', and colorful tabs marking sections.

i finished Ephesians and i’m so so proud of myself

i did use Pinterest to help me with my notes. #youngchristian #biblestudies✝️ #beginnerchristian #KJV #✝️

7 likes

The cover of the book "Hush, Hush" by Becca Fitzpatrick, featuring two dark winged figures and falling feathers. The cover has a red "Finished" overlay and colorful page tabs on the right side. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.

A black background with the word "Thoughts" in yellow. Text below indicates a 4-star rating and a positive review point about the characters feeling like real teenagers. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.

A black background with the word "Thoughts" in yellow. Text lists positive review points about the book's mystery keeping the reader entertained and the author's vivid setting descriptions. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.

⭐️Overall rating: 4/5 #books #bookwormsoflemon8 #bookrecommendations #yabooks #hushhush

3 likes

finished my first semester of fashion school!

started going to the fashion institute of technology this year! can’t believe i already finished my first semester, here’s some of the work i did from drawing to draping and a fashion show my clothes were selected for :) let me know if you guys wanna see more in depth posts about it <3 #fas

23 likes

We Were Liars 🤫📚

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 🥰🥰🥰🥰 When their daughter has an accident, family lies start to unravel. Follow this rich, beach town family while suspense arises around every corner. 🌊🫣 This book has made its way to my most unexpected book of 2025 thus far!!! I was in tears by the very end. 🥲 It’s fa

35 likes

The book cover for 'The Cellar' by Natasha Preston, featuring dark steps with a pink flower, and the author's name. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.

A close-up side view of 'The Cellar' book, showing numerous colorful annotation tabs in purple, orange, red, and green, marking various sections.

A page from 'The Cellar' book with text discussing characters Lewis and Clover, and a green annotation tab marking the page. A Lemon8 watermark is visible.

I finished this book and…

⭐️ 5/5 stars This book was truly something else. it really is something that you have to read slowly to be able to take in exactly what is happening because it is not very good. It switches perspectives between 🪷Summer/Lily and how she’s handling being kidnapped tortured and trapped. 🍀Colin

7 likes

Finished read w/ Annotations

#smutbooks #smutt #smutreads

23 likes

Finished this alongside a tutorial✨

Field with flowers and bubbles (bubbles we're my own touch and its all kind of in my own style). Tutorial by: Creatively Me With Bri on YouTube ⭐️ Rating: 10/10 would highly recommend to anybody just starting on landscapes and flowers. She makes it easy. Was it easy? For the most part, there

5 likes

The front cover of Freida McFadden's thriller 'The Coworker,' featuring a red high-heeled shoe. Overlays highlight it's a story from two perspectives about coworkers with a shared past and office secrets.

The back cover of 'The Coworker' by Freida McFadden, detailing the plot about Dawn Schiff and Natalie Farrell, a mystery/thriller of 320 pages involving a cat and mouse game.

An open book displaying pages 140 and 141 of 'The Coworker,' showing the text content of the novel, held open by a hand, with an 'OMG!' overlay.

I finished this book in three days?!?

When starting this book I did think It has a slow start. I also feel as if the Freida did a good job building up the story to where I always had questions about something. I do feel like there is a lot of plot twists and things that I just utterly did not expect to happen. ⭐️Overall rating: 4/5

8 likes

Her BF is finished

#standup #comedian #hilarious #dating #fyp

3 likes

Just Finished Another Round of LIIFT4!

Another round of LIIFT4 in the books! This program never fails to challenge me, push me, and remind me what consistency can do. From the heavy lifts to the intense HIIT, every workout tested my limits—but that’s exactly why I keep coming back. There were days I didn’t feel like showing up. Days

2 likes

The book cover for 'Alchemised' by SenLinYu features a dark, gothic castle and gnarled trees with a cracked texture. A small figure in a red cloak walks towards a glowing orb. The title 'ALCHEMISED' is in yellow, with '#1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER' below it.

Alchemised was a different from what I normally read. It’s a tragic and dark book but wonderfully written (in my opinion). There were some parts that I had to skim because it was very detailed and gruesome for me. Overall, I would recommend! #alchemised #darkromantasy #standalonebokk He

34 likes

Just Finished Season 3 of Ginny & Georgia…

Just finished season 3 of Ginny & Georgia and… yeah we need to talk. I started watching this on a random day thanks to TikTok recs, and I didn’t expect to actually like it this much 😭 Season 1 & 2 were mad cringey ngl—but this season?? They actually listened to the feedback, toned it dow

945 likes

Recently finished! 🤍🎀💭 🌟🌟🌟/5

Recently finished! 🤍🎀💭 🌟🌟🌟/5 This book is a 3 star for me because there were some parts that were boring for me and hard to get through. I wa salía on this book for way to long as well, in some parts felt dragged out ( or I was just ready to be done). Towards the end it speed up and I found it

3 likes

A Bible page open to Exodus 37, with highlighted text and handwritten notes emphasizing God's presence, the importance of obedience, and the symbolic meaning of the Ark and Table of Showbread, linking them to purity, permanence, provision, and fellowship.

A Bible page open to Exodus 37-38, featuring highlighted verses and notes on the Tabernacle's elements. It highlights the Lampstand as light, the Altar of Incense for holiness, the Burnt Offering Altar for forgiveness, and the Basin for Washing as purity, all central to worship.

A Bible page open to Exodus 38-39, showing highlighted text and notes on the Tabernacle's courtyard and materials. Themes include worship requiring sacrifice, God calling people to holiness, craftsmen using skills for God's glory, and the integrity and faithfulness required in handling resources.

✨Exodus Ch 37-40 Bible Notes ✨ Finished 🫶

📖 Exodus 37 – Bezalel makes the Ark, table, lampstand, and altar exactly as God commanded → God cares about details in worship (37:1). 📖 Exodus 38 – The altar and courtyard are built; women serve at the Tabernacle → All God’s people can contribute (38:8). 📖 Exodus 39 – Priestly garments are c

4 likes

An open Bible displays pages 1736-1737 with highlighted text from Ephesians 4. An overlay prominently features the verse 'BE COMPLETELY HUMBLE AND GENTLE, BE PATIENT, BEARING WITH ONE ANOTHER IN LOVE' from Ephesians 4:2 (NIV), with a Lemon8 user handle.

Just finished reading Ephesians 4 🤍

Whew… this chapter got me together in the best way. It’s all about unity, growth, and letting go of the old version of yourself so you can walk like someone who truly knows God. The verse that really stuck with me was: “Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in lo

4 likes

My finished project!

0 likes

How I actually finished 75 Hard without burning ou

1️⃣ The Help Corner I didn’t just plan for the good days — I had a game plan for the bad ones too. 💯 Energy? Go all in. 💪 80%? Shift priorities. 😮‍💨 60%? Do your best. 🫠 40% or less? Just the essentials — that’s still progress. 2️⃣ Imagine Worst-Case Days I trained my brain for hard da

49 likes

✨ He’s not finished with you yet ✨

He who began a good work in you will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus.” – Philippians 1:6 💛 Feeling behind? Unworthy? Like you’re not enough? Let this verse remind you: God doesn’t give up on His masterpieces. 🙌 He started something beautiful in you—and He will finish it.

4 likes

The image features the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart, a New York Times Bestseller, lying on a white, rumpled surface. The cover depicts people in water with the title. Overlays include 'Why 'We Were Liars' Blew My Mind', a book emoji, and a coffee cup emoji.

Read We Were Liars!!

The book is narrated by Cadence Sinclair, whose unreliable narration creates an air of mystery and intrigue. The fragmented, lyrical writing mirrors her mental state, pulling readers into her confusion and pain. This style keeps you engaged and leaves breadcrumbs that only make sense after the twis

5 likes

Finished Acts 💕

0 likes

Finished Echoes of the End 😌😌

We finished Echoes of the End the other day live on Twitch I gave it a 9/10 ONLY because the combat felt repetitive and simple but omg the visuals and story were great I got some good screenshots on photo mode too I definitely recommend it ❤️❤️ #fyp #gaming #playstation #twitchstreamer

0 likes

The cover of Riley Sager's thriller "Survive the Night" featuring a car with bright headlights on a dark road. Overlays mention "Finished in 24 hours BOOK SUMMARY" and "BONE-CHILLING," with a red kiss mark and a B&N discount sticker.

The book "Survive the Night" by Riley Sager, open to reveal many colorful page markers. Overlays highlight "Lemon8 Book Club," "Unreliable Narrator," and "Short Chapters," indicating key aspects of the book's review.

An open page from "Survive the Night" (page 178) with text discussing Charlie's thoughts. Handwritten notes include "YES QUEEN" and an orange heart, with colorful page markers visible on the left edge.

FINISHED A BOOK 1 HOUR BEFORE SUMMARY FINAL TIME

"Survive the Night" by Riley Sager is a rollercoaster of a psychological thriller that had me hooked from the very beginning. I think it might be one of my fav thrillers I’ve read in a while!! I literally read it in 24 hours hahaa! I am literally writing this 1 hour before midnight 😂 Thi

14 likes

An overhead shot displaying a collection of finished ceramic pieces, including red tomatoes, blue blueberries, green leaf dishes, slug-like forms, frog-like bud vases with fluffy tops, and a lemon-shaped trinket tray. The text "MY FINISHED CERAMICS" is overlaid.

Three iridescent ceramic slug-shaped bud vases are displayed on a white surface. Each slug has a small opening for a bud and a speckled base. The text "Slug bud vases" is overlaid.

A ceramic red tomato with a smiling face and green stem sits in the foreground, with several other red ceramic tomatoes partially visible in a green mesh bag behind it. The text "Tomato friends" is overlaid.

Ceramics I finished this month! 🍃🐛🍅

I was SO happy with all of the things I made out of clay recently, this batch was a fun one! It's my garden collection including tomatoes, blueberries, slug & frog bud vases, worm leaf trays, and geese ring holders. The silly geese were my most popular item when I brought them to my recent

616 likes

An embroidery hoop displays three crosses on textured hills with the words "It is finished" stitched on light fabric, resting on a wooden stand. A floral pattern is visible in the blurred background.

A hand holds an embroidery hoop featuring three crosses on textured hills and the words "It is finished" stitched on light fabric, set against a blurred background of yellow and orange flowers.

An Easter-themed display includes the embroidered hoop with crosses and "It is finished," alongside decorative eggs, a floral framed picture, a fabric bunny, and letter tiles spelling "HE IS RISEN."

It Is Finished!! ✝️

Today our Savior died on a cross and shed His blood to save humanity. And He did it for everyone, every single person throughout all of history, no matter who they were, even if they never got the chance to live, He still died for them! He died for you! There is no act of love that was bigger tha

66 likes

Book that I finished vs books that finished me

Have you read any of these books? Which one was your favorite? ❤️ #unfiltered #Lemon8 #lemon8bookclub #booktok #bookrecommendation

5 likes

See more