We Were Liars Book Review

⭐️Overall rating: 4.5/5:

Just finished We Were Liars by E. Lockhart and… wow. 😮‍💨✨

This book had me in a CHOKEHOLD. The writing is poetic and dreamy, almost like a fairytale—but underneath it all is this dark, emotional gut punch I didn’t see coming. I’m still recovering from that twist 😭 like HOW did I not catch on sooner?!

The Sinclair family felt so real—beautiful, messy, privileged, broken. I loved the way it explored grief, secrets, and how we convince ourselves of the version of the truth we want to believe.

My only reason for docking that half star is that the writing style might not be for everyone—it’s super lyrical and abstract at times. But honestly? That’s part of what made it stand out for me.

If you haven’t read it yet, don’t look up spoilers. Just dive in blind. You’ll thank me later. 🙃

#currentread📚#booktok #bookinstagram #booktube #bookwormsoflemon8

2025/7/7 Edited to

... Read moreHey bookworms! So, my recent review of E. Lockhart's 'We Were Liars' sparked a lot of questions, and I wanted to dive deeper into some of the things you're curious about, especially since this book is still living rent-free in my head! First off, let's talk about those book covers – because honestly, they're half the mystery! The iconic cover with silhouettes in water, often bathed in summer hues, perfectly captures the eerie, dreamlike essence of the book. It hints at the secrets and tragedies hidden beneath a seemingly perfect surface. I've seen a few editions, from the original hardcover to the more recent paperbacks, and each one cleverly keeps you guessing without giving anything away. That specific cover I showed with the paw print and 'Summer' really does set the mood for the Sinclair family's island retreat, making it feel both idyllic and unsettling. It’s a masterclass in visual storytelling, drawing you in before you even read the first page. For those asking about 'We Were Liars' hardcover vs. paperback, both editions typically feature similar thematic covers, so you can't go wrong, but the tactile feel of a hardcover adds to the intensity, in my opinion! You've also been asking if 'We Were Liars' is a gripping thriller, and my answer is a resounding YES. It's not a fast-paced, action-packed thriller in the traditional sense, but it’s a psychological slow burn that builds an incredible amount of tension. The mystery surrounding what happened that fateful summer is compelling, pulling you deeper into the fragmented memories and unreliable narration. E. Lockhart is brilliant at crafting an atmosphere of unease and privilege, making you question everything and everyone. It’s less about jump scares and more about the unsettling realization of truth, which truly gives you an emotional gut punch. The narrative definitely revolves around a group whose lives become interconnected as they uncover hidden aspects of their pasts – it's all about family secrets and the lengths people go to protect their image. And for the burning question: does 'We Were Liars' have spice? While the book delves into complex relationships and a teenage romance, it is firmly a Young Adult (YA) psychological thriller. So, no, you won't find explicit or 'spicy' scenes here. The focus is much more on mental health, grief, family dynamics, and the unraveling mystery, rather than romantic encounters. If you're looking for a steamy romance, this isn't it, but if you're into deep, thought-provoking stories with a shocking twist, you're in for a treat. Lastly, I've seen some queries mentioning 'We Fell Apart a We Were Liars novel.' Just to clarify, 'We Were Liars' is a standalone novel by E. Lockhart. There isn't a direct sequel or companion novel titled 'We Fell Apart.' If you loved the author's style and want more, E. Lockhart has other fantastic books like 'Genuine Fraud' which shares a similar psychological depth, but 'We Were Liars' tells a complete story within its pages. The themes of memory, identity, and the destructive nature of secrets are perfectly contained within this single, impactful read. If you haven't picked up 'We Were Liars' yet, please, go in blind – it’s truly an unforgettable experience!

14 comments

Morgan Ray's images
Morgan Ray

the show that is out on prime did such a good job and stayed very true to the book!

See more(3)

Related posts

The image features the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart, with its cover showing people in water. Overlaid text reads 'Book Review', accompanied by a color palette, decorative flowers, and the Lemon8 logo with a username.
We were Liars Book Review 🌊🐚
I just finished reading this book yesterday and I honestly think it was pretty good . I thought the ending was a real shocker and I honestly didn’t expect it . I think I would rate this book a 8 out of 10 since it was very interesting but I just think it had a lot of chapters that could’ve been lon
Nicole Denise 🃏

Nicole Denise 🃏

6 likes

We were liars lovers🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️
#Lemon8Diary #bookrecommendation #booklemon8 #bookobsessed #BookReview
ella’s book nook📚

ella’s book nook📚

103 likes

“We Were Liars” -book review ( W T F reaction)
Okay… Without any spoilers, this was my first 2025 read and OMG, am I scared? Am I dreaming, what did I just read? This should be a movie. Is there a movie? Reading it was good, beginning wasn’t boring a lot of good context, good story telling and great POV, this is a book that you WILL
Bellarina 🎀

Bellarina 🎀

3 likes

A hand with blue glitter nail polish holds the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart against a stone wall. Text overlays highlight themes like 'Messy Family Dynamics,' 'Old Money,' 'Greed,' 'Privilege,' and 'Unreliable Narrator,' indicating a book review.
We Were Liars ☀️🌸🐚
book review | We Were Liars by E. Lockhart 🌾 my rating: ⭐️ setting: Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts 🦞 A wealthy old money family has a private island where they spend summers. A group of four cousins/siblings call themselves “The Liars”. They get sick of the adults fighting over inheritan
chelsea

chelsea

20 likes

A book cover for 'Family of Liars' by E. Lockhart, a New York Times Bestseller, is displayed against a light background. Overlaid text reads 'BOOK REVIEW' in blue and white, accompanied by white outline graphics of a heart, a smiley face, and a 'wow' expression, along with the Lemon8 logo and username.
Book Review 📖🐚
This was the sequel to another book I read called “ We were Liars “ and I think it was very good ! It took me a while to read it since I’ve been in kind of a reading slump but when I started it again I got more into it. I wouldn’t read it again though since it was kind of boring but it did have som
Nicole Denise 🃏

Nicole Denise 🃏

4 likes

Overdue review: I finished listening to the Book —
What I up with these books messin me up! This book wrecked me. It’s one of those stories that sneaks up on you quietly — soft, sunlit, and beautiful — until it crushes your heart. 💔 We Were Liars is about family, privilege, secrets, and the ways love and loss can twist together into something
Diana De Jesus

Diana De Jesus

1 like

Book Review:We Were Liars
#booksummary #lemon8challenge Read this book and lemme know what you think! I personally loved it!
Olivia💜

Olivia💜

12 likes

We Were Liars 🌊
#BookReview #wewereliars #books
allan.torres.writes_

allan.torres.writes_

0 likes

A light blue book titled 'You'd Be Home Now' by Kathleen Glasgow rests on a quilted surface. White pills are arranged on the cover, some integrated into the title. A circular sticker shows '20%' and 'Target RedCard' details. Lemon8 and @momma.hood are at the bottom left.
Book review ✨
I’m going to try to do this with no spoilers incase any of you do decide to pick this book up (I think you should) The book starts out very intense, you get attached to the characters almost immediately. The middle slows a bit as we get to watch these characters life’s play out (teen romance-ish
Bay

Bay

17 likes

If you liked We Were liars…
If you liked We Were Liars either the show or the book then these books should be your next read!! 📚 #wewereliars #booktok #book recommendations #lemon8bookclub
DBooks📚

DBooks📚

21 likes

We Were Liars 🤫📚
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 🥰🥰🥰🥰 When their daughter has an accident, family lies start to unravel. Follow this rich, beach town family while suspense arises around every corner. 🌊🫣 This book has made its way to my most unexpected book of 2025 thus far!!! I was in tears by the very end. 🥲 It’s fa
Cassidy 📚🤎☕️

Cassidy 📚🤎☕️

35 likes

🌊💔 WILD BOOK REVIEW: Family of Liars 💔🌊

I thought I was ready after We Were Liars. I was NOT. This book grabbed me by the throat, whispered “Sinclair family secrets,” and then shoved me off the dock into a storm of guilt, grief, and generational chaos. E. Lockhart said, “You want answers? Fine. But it’s going to hurt.” And oh, it hu
Diana De Jesus

Diana De Jesus

2 likes

BOOK REVIEW (no spoilers)
📖 Name of the Book: We Were Liars 💭 My Thoughts: I actually had to spoil this for myself to get myself to keep reading so I did know what happened, I was still very interested and got this done in 4 days as school was starting up. I actually really liked it and wish i didn’t spoil it for myself
A L L I E

A L L I E

9 likes

The image features the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart, a New York Times Bestseller, lying on a white, rumpled surface. The cover depicts people in water with the title. Overlays include 'Why 'We Were Liars' Blew My Mind', a book emoji, and a coffee cup emoji.
Read We Were Liars!!
The book is narrated by Cadence Sinclair, whose unreliable narration creates an air of mystery and intrigue. The fragmented, lyrical writing mirrors her mental state, pulling readers into her confusion and pain. This style keeps you engaged and leaves breadcrumbs that only make sense after the twis
Alyana Grace

Alyana Grace

5 likes

The cover of E. Lockhart's new book, 'We Fell Apart: A We Were Liars Novel,' is displayed, featuring a silhouette against a colorful background. The text 'New Book Release' is overlaid, with a glimpse of another book titled 'Little' underneath.
A hand holds the new book 'We Fell Apart' by E. Lockhart, showcasing its cover with a silhouette and colorful background. The book's spine and page edges reveal a gradient of colors.
An open book displays a detailed map titled 'MAP OF Hidden Beach WEST TISBURY, MASSACHUSETTS.' The map illustrates various locations like Pool House, Garage, Cliffside, Chalk Tower, Bone Tower, and Beach.
🚨New Book Release🚨
I totally forgot this book was coming out this month but it was a very good surprise!! If you have read or watched We Were Liars then you should probably read E. Lockhart’s new book because it is a continuation of the We Were Liars books😆 BUT this is a standalone book so you don’t have to read the
DBooks📚

DBooks📚

4 likes

marketing book review
"Building a StoryBrand" by Donald Miller provides a transformative framework for businesses to clarify their messaging and connect with customers by positioning themselves as the guide to their customers' hero journey, ultimately creating compelling brand narratives that resonate and dr
BATE by Rana

BATE by Rana

24 likes

Book Review: Not Since You
Rating: 4.5/5⭐️ Title: Not Since You Author: Dulcie Dameron Review: This was such a delightful read!! This was my very first Christian Contemporary Romance & I absolutely adored it!! The faith aspect was so refreshing to have in a romance! The mystery in this was intriguing bu
Caitri Riding

Caitri Riding

177 likes

Book Review 🏠🌊
𝐖𝐞 𝐰𝐞𝐫𝐞 𝐋𝐢𝐚𝐫𝐬 𝐛𝐲 𝐄. 𝐋𝐨𝐜𝐤𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐭 Loved this book! E. Lockhart's writing was sublime-so lyrical and haunting. At first, I thought the dialogue was a bit juvenile, but it all makes sense by the end. That twist? Chilling and unforgettable. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 #WeWereLiars #ELockhart #BookRevi
Janem91

Janem91

9 likes

Book Review
I was actually really surprised by how much I enjoyed this one given that I didn't care for We Were Liars at all. That being said, I loved the TV show but was definitely more invested in the moms and their story so I had to read this one and find out what they got up to during their own summers
shelby 📚

shelby 📚

3 likes

A hand holds the book "We Were Liars" by E. Lockhart, featuring people in water on the cover. Overlays read "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 2/5". "Lemon8 @aurorahasbooks" is at the bottom left, with a macrame hanging and plant in the background.
Tell Me What To Read - We Were Liars
Hey friends! I’ve been a little MIA on Lemon8 but it’s not because I’m ditching it, I just haven’t had time to create content, but that’s changing right now! I have a ton of ideas and am determined to spend time creating those ideas every day and making my little corner of Lemon8 a true book co
Aurora Kretsch

Aurora Kretsch

13 likes

The 100 Book Review
The 100 is a post-apocalyptic dystopian series set 300 years in the future. It follows Clarke, Bellamy, Glass, Wells, and their friends as they learn to survive on the count after spending their lives in space. There are several differences from the TV show, but the concept is the same and they
Kaitlin Graham

Kaitlin Graham

367 likes

The cover of the book "Before We Were Strangers" by Renee Carlino, featuring pink text and a silhouetted couple, with a purple-striped bookmark.
A couple brushing their teeth in a mirror, with the woman holding a camera, capturing a candid moment.
A New York City Subway map with the handwritten text "NEW YORK I HAVE SO MUCH TO THANK YOU FOR" displayed inside a subway car.
Before we were strangers book review:
This book was absolutely lovely, the characters felt realistic and I found myself really relating to each of them. The story takes an unexpected turn but is so worth it. At first the dialogue can be a bit unrealistic but once you get past the first few chapter it gets a lotttt better. 🫶🏽 I loved
nat ♡

nat ♡

5 likes

We Were Liars Series…✨
I’ve been obsessed with this series, the books are so good and I can’t wait for the 3rd book to release this year. ❤️📚 And what can I say about the “Tv. series” on Amazon Prime… It’s absolutely amazing, full of emotions and I loved every minute of it. Definitely it’s a must watch 10/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
S. Marie 🦋

S. Marie 🦋

12 likes

A family tree diagram titled 'The Sinclair Family Tree,' showing Harris Sinclair & Tipper Taft at the top, their three children (Carrie, Bess, Penny), and their respective grandchildren (Johnny, Will, Mirren, Liberty, Bonnie, Cadence), along with associated locations like Red Gate, Cuddledown, and Windemere.
A family tree diagram titled 'The Sinclair Family Tree,' detailing Harris Sinclair & Tipper Taft Sinclair, Dean Sinclair, their children (Caroline, Penelope, Elizabeth, Rosemary), and grandchildren (Johnny, Will, Cadence, Mirren, Liberty, Bonnie, Taft), plus a list of dogs in 1987.
A detailed map of Beechwood Island, Massachusetts, USA, featuring various family houses like Windemere, Cuddledown, Red Gate, and Clairmont, along with other landmarks such as Staff Dock, Boathouse, and Martha's Vineyard Harbor.
We Were Liars & Family of Liars
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: We Were Liars and Family of Liars 📖 Genre: YA psychological thriller/coming of age 💭 My Thoughts: 😵🤯 ⭐ Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5️⃣ #readreadread #reading📖 #lemon8bookclub #bookrecs #BookReview #booktok #bookclub #bookrecommendations #re
AuthorSamanthaParish

AuthorSamanthaParish

9 likes

The book cover for Maya Angelou's 'The Heart of a Woman' features a woman's silhouette and red-orange flowers on a dark background, resting on a white fluffy surface. A quote from Kirkus Reviews is visible.
Book Review
This book is absolutely amazing. Maya Angelou’s early life was truly one worth writing about. She eloquently writes of the duality of women and the lives our grandmothers were forced to live. Having a child at 17, receiving the assistance of her mother and shortly after taking full custody. May
Marlesia

Marlesia

496 likes

A hand holds a Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of the book "Things We Hide From The Light" by Lucy Score. The image is titled "Book Review" with a search bar for the book title.
Book Review | Things We Hide From The Light 🚓💋
Nash Morgan is precious and all but … I still want Knox Morgan 🥵 I’d let that man disrespect me any day of the week #bookrecommendations #booksoflemon8 #bookwormsoflemon8 #knockemoutseries #lucyscore #whatimreading #tbrlist #lemon8bookclub #bookaesthetic #kindleunlimited
Laura Sprouse

Laura Sprouse

17 likes

An open book with text visible, featuring an overlay that reads "WLW Book Review ✨💕" and glowing butterfly and flower graphics. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.
The front cover of the book "Forget Me Not" by Alyson Derrick, featuring red floral line art and a woman's profile. An overlay reads "Forget Me Not Alyson Derrick".
The back cover of the book "Forget Me Not" with red floral designs, a book blurb, ISBN, and price information. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom.
WLW Book Review ✨💕
I absolutely loved this book, This is definitely worth the read. This book definitely has plenty of cliffhangers. This was so so written. I wish I could re-read it again like it was the first time! #booktok #booktok #books #wlw #wlwbooks #queerbooks
⭐️Lainey ⭐️

⭐️Lainey ⭐️

87 likes

Book Review 💫
The whiplash from all the twists in this book was crazy! This whole read was a wild ride from start to finish. I can’t even say too much without giving something away because there's a lot going on, but just know you’re getting multiple POVs, revenge, deception, obsession… all that and then som
Courtney 📚

Courtney 📚

4 likes

A hand holds the book 'We Were Liars' by E. Lockhart, a #1 New York Times Bestselling Author. The cover shows blurred figures in water, and a blue sticker mentions 'Family of Liars'. The background is a dark green fabric.
We were liars
I hope this wrecks me just like the show did #we were liars #currentread #books #lemon8bookclub
wildflowersmama

wildflowersmama

6 likes

Before we were Innocent Review
Okay, so my caption says best book club read, here’s why: This book was SOOOO bad we vented about it for so long!!! 😂😂😂 Ella girl, what is this!!??? First, it took me about two weeks to even read the book, everytime I opened it I just could NOT connect to the book at all! Secondly, the
dreamy reader 🌱

dreamy reader 🌱

56 likes

A book titled "Honey & Spice" by Bolu Babalola, featuring two illustrated figures on the cover, lies on a fluffy white and grey rug. The image has text overlays "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and a "Reese's Book Club" sticker, indicating a book review.
Honey & Spice Book Review
For the month of April my book club read “Honey & Spice” by Bolu Babalola. I have seen so many reviews on this book and I went in with very high expectations for it and it did not disappoint! I really enjoyed this book and it was a great read. To me this book reminds me of the shows “Gro
Denny Price

Denny Price

57 likes

See more