SNACK REVIEW: Sugar Cookie Reese’s 🎄🍪🍫

Besties, you gotta give this one a try! Okayyy these are dangerously good. The filling has actual sugar cookie bits mixed in and it tastes like the perfect mix of holiday sweetness + classic Reese’s. If you love sugar cookies AND peanut butter cups, this is literally both in one bite.

Super creamy, super festive, super addictive.

I’m giving this a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 for the holidays — would buy again immediately.

Have you tried this flavor yet? Would you?? 👀💬

#snackreview #snacks #reeses #chocolate #snack

@Lemon8 Food

2025/11/19 Edited to

... Read moreWow, you guys, I'm still thinking about how delicious these Sugar Cookie Reese's Big Cups are! When I first saw them, I was a little skeptical – sugar cookie and peanut butter? But let me tell you, Reese's really hit it out of the park with this one. First off, let's talk about those 'sugar cookie bits' the original post mentioned. They're not just a subtle hint; they're actual tiny, crunchy pieces of sugar cookie dough (or at least that's what it feels like!) mixed right into the creamy peanut butter filling. It adds this incredible texture dimension that you don't get with regular Reese's. It's not just smooth; you get that delightful crunch that really elevates the whole experience. It truly feels like two desserts in one bite – the classic milk chocolate and peanut butter combo, plus the festive sweetness and slight grittiness of a sugar cookie. It's a genius move! The fact that it's a 'BIG CUP' (as the packaging clearly states!) also makes a difference. You get a generous 2.6 oz of pure holiday joy, perfect for savoring or even sharing... if you can resist! For a single piece, it clocks in at around 180 calories, which, for such an indulgent and satisfying treat, feels pretty reasonable for a festive splurge. It's definitely a substantial snack, not just a bite-sized chocolate. Compared to other seasonal Reese's offerings, like the pumpkins or eggs, this one stands out because of the unique flavor addition. While I love the classic shapes, the Sugar Cookie Reese's offers a completely new taste profile that truly screams 'holiday' without being overtly spiced like gingerbread. It’s that comforting, sweet, familiar taste of a sugar cookie that makes it so special this time of year. I found mine at my local grocery store, but I've also heard they pop up at most major retailers during the holiday season. They're definitely a limited-time holiday item, so if you're curious, I highly recommend grabbing them before they disappear! Stock up if you love them, because who knows when they'll be back? For the ultimate holiday experience, I love pairing my Sugar Cookie Reese's Big Cup with a warm mug of hot cocoa or a festive coffee. The melted chocolate and the cool, creamy peanut butter with those cookie bits create a symphony of flavors and textures. You could even crumble a piece over a scoop of vanilla ice cream for an instant holiday dessert upgrade! Have you ever tried to recreate a Reese's flavor at home, or do you stick to store-bought? What’s your favorite holiday candy that you look forward to every year? Let me know in the comments – I'm always looking for new festive treats to try!

1 comment

Ross 💎's images
Ross 💎

ive had this too and it was bomb 🔥

Related posts

A Walmart aisle displaying shelves stocked with various protein bars, protein cookies, protein muffins, and protein shakes, with text overlays indicating a 'Healthy Snack Haul Walmart Edition!!'.
A hand holding a box of Built Puffs protein bars in 'Cookie Dough Chunk' flavor, featuring an image of a chocolate-drizzled cookie dough scoop. The box highlights 15g protein, 160 calories, and collagen.
A hand holding a bag of Catalina Crunch Dark Chocolate Cereal, showing a bowl of cereal with raspberries. The packaging indicates 0g sugar, 11g protein, and 9g fiber.
Walmart Snack Haul (Healthy Alternatives!)🛒💓
POV: You’re on a health journey but still crave actual good snacks 🍬 I went to Walmart to find the best high-protein, low-sugar alternatives that won’t make me feel deprived. Here’s what I picked up! ⬇️ 🌟 Built Puffs (Chocolate Cookie Dough) 🍪🍫 💪 15g protein | 160 cal + collagen ☁️ A protein b
Anna🫶🏼

Anna🫶🏼

3375 likes

Peach Cobbler Cookie Boats🍑🤭
#peachcobbler #sugarcookies #bigbacksnack #chefbae #Lemon8PhotoStudio #Lemon8 #foodie #dessert #baking #lemon8food United States
Chef Bae Sherri Smith

Chef Bae Sherri Smith

4583 likes

A plate of golden-brown Reese's Cheesecake Pinwheels, drizzled with chocolate sauce, is shown from an overhead view. The text 'REESE'S CHEESECAKE PINWHEELS SWIPE' is overlaid on the image.
Hands are shown preparing a tortilla, spreading peanut butter and sprinkling chocolate chips over a layer of cream cheese. The text outlines steps 1-4 of the recipe, including laying out the tortilla and adding fillings.
Hands are shown carefully slicing a rolled tortilla, brushed with butter and sugar, into individual pinwheels using a sharp knife. The text describes steps 5-7 of the recipe, focusing on rolling and slicing.
Reese’s Cheesecake Pinwheels
Perfect quick air fryer dessert #chocolate #snack #airfryerrecipes #sweets #food
Lex

Lex

843 likes

An image titled "This not That! CALORIE DEFICIT SNACK ALTERNATIVES" surrounded by various snack items like macaroni and cheese, peanut butter cups, an energy drink, smoked sausages, crunchy cheese snacks, and gummy candies, with arrows pointing to "CHECK THIS OUT."
Two comparisons of snacks: spicy crunchy cheese snacks (160 Calories) versus sweet and spicy chili rice crisps (130 Calories), and potato chips with onion dip (300+ Calories, 4g Protein) versus hummus and pretzels (370 Calories, 10g Protein).
Two comparisons of snacks: a package of smoked sausages (140 Calories) versus beef mini sticks (40 Calories, 4g Protein), and chocolate-dipped almonds (160 Calories) versus chocolate-covered almonds (140 Calories, 4g Sugar).
Calorie Deficit Snack Alternatives! 🍽️
Calorie Deficit Snack Alternatives! 🍽️ Looking to satisfy your cravings while staying in a calorie deficit? Here are some of my go-to snacks that won’t break your calorie bank. Tips and Tricks for Snacking Smart: •Not all “healthy” snacks are as healthy as they seem! 🧐 Just because someth
Hal- Mad Cook

Hal- Mad Cook

4268 likes

My quick, healthier “no-bake cookie” snack!
I picked this up when I was breastfeeding to boost my supply, and it just kinda stuck. Quick, easy stir and done!If I want to throw a quick snack together- this is it!😋 YOU NEED: 1/3 C oats 3 Tbs peanut butter Chocolate syrup to tastes, I’d say maybe 1 1/2 Tbs RECIPE: Add ingredients to a bowl
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

505 likes

A hand holds an apple slice dipped into a protein cookie dip with chocolate shavings in a clear bowl, illustrating a healthy snack idea.
A clear bowl contains separate portions of Greek yogurt, brown sugar, and vanilla extract, showing the base ingredients for the protein cookie dip.
A clear bowl holds a creamy dip base topped with a generous amount of chopped chocolate, indicating an optional ingredient for the protein cookie dip.
Healthy Snack Idea | Protein Cookie Dip with Apple
Snack idea! Here’s an easy way to incorporate more fruit and protein into your diet. Ingredients: • Greek yogurt • Vanilla extract • Brown sugar • (optional) vanilla flavored protein powder • (optional) chopped chocolate / m&ms / chopped white chocolate, etc This is SO good with ap
Abby

Abby

216 likes

Protein Snack Finds
Little pricey! I buy in bulk so it is cheaper 🤞 #costcofinds #proteinhaul #weightloss #questchips #proteinsnacks #gatoradezero #proteinshake #proteingoal #mealprep #gymgirl
Laney Calagui

Laney Calagui

1511 likes

HEALTHY COPYCAT REESE'S CUPS
On the Litely app that I’ve been fasting with and using to lose weight, I found a copycat Reese’s cup recipe and I couldn’t wait to try it! I’ve always been a huge fan of Reese's cups - that peanut butter and chocolate combo is just unbeatable, right? But let's be real, the sugar in them ca
Lushie Club 💖

Lushie Club 💖

188 likes

Reese’s cup at home 😍
HOMEMADE REESE’s PEANUT BUTTER CUPS 🍫🥜 This was fun dessert/snack to try. These peanut butter cups came out 10x better than the ones in the store. The perfect sweetness & creaminess. I used all organic brands when making these. And these required very few ingredients. Ingredients use
Kendall

Kendall

296 likes

🍪🍦 Entenmann’s Soft Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream by Turkey Hill
✨✨If you were the kid who cracked open that Entenmann’s box before anyone else even touched it, this collab is about to hit you right in the nostalgia. Turkey Hill took that soft, buttery chocolate chip cookie magic and turned it into a creamy frozen treat that tastes like comfort straight from the
Kamisha’s BigBackSnackShack

Kamisha’s BigBackSnackShack

39 likes

🍫 Protein Reese’s Cups: A Guilt-Free
Protein series: 4 SAVE RECIPE ⬇️ & try it this week 🔥 INGREDIENTS (FULL BATCH): • 100g sugar-free chocolate chips • 2 tbsp PB2 • 100g vanilla Greek yogurt • 1 scoop vanilla Muscle Milk protein • 1/2 tsp stevia • Splash of vanilla extract TOTAL MACROS (ENTIRE BATCH): • Calories: 6
Pedro

Pedro

93 likes

every reese’s lover needs to try these‼️🍫
Every Reese’s lover needs to try these!! ‼️🍫 As a Reese’s lover I knew I had to try the new Big Cups and the caramel version is officially a new favorite. The marshmallow is a solid 7/10, but that caramel and salty peanut butter combo is just unmatched. 🤤 Rating Breakdown: • Marshmallow: 7/1
Myra 💞

Myra 💞

31 likes

My Favorite Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Recipe
These Reese’s peanut butter cups were SO GOOD! I’m exited to make them again, these also serve as great appetizers. 👉🏿1/2 cup peanut butter or any nut butter like almond butter (125g) 👉🏿1 Tbsp. of softened butter optional (15g) 👉🏿1 cup powdered sugar added gradually, may need a little more or
Safeezygal

Safeezygal

237 likes

Three Snif body spray bottles, 'Hazel Split,' 'Berry Styles,' and 'Extra Whip,' are displayed on a counter. The image has text overlays: 'Snif BODY SPRAYS Full Honest Review' and 'Spoiler: Two Of Them Are Delicious!' A woman's face watermark is visible.
A hand holds the 'Extra Whip' Snif body mist bottle. Text describes it as a light vanilla scent with too much musk, rated 3.5/10. Top notes include sugar and aldehydes, middle notes whipped cream, and base notes sandalwood, vanilla, and musk.
A hand holds the 'Berry Styles' Snif body mist bottle. Text describes it as a fruity, juicy, and slightly powdery scent, like sugary bubblegum, rated 9/10. Top notes include raspberry, blueberry, and lime, middle notes freesia, and base notes vanilla.
Smell Like A Snack With The New Snif Body Sprays!
Okay Lemon Loves, most of you babes know that I personally feel so-so when it comes to Snif. I’ll be honest and say the only full bottle perfume that I would actually own from them at this point is Sweet Ash- (keep in mind, I haven’t smelled everything from them yet.) With that being said, I love t
Court.Charisse

Court.Charisse

126 likes

My fave low calorie snack on a sugar crave🍭
I have a huuuge sweet tooth but I’m trying to eat less sugar/lower fat foods to start my summer shredding! GUILT FREE 😌 Dates with peanut butter, chocolate, and a sprinkle of salt that is cooled in the freezer = Reeces Peanut Butter Cup DUPE!!! Dates have so many great benefits! They are good
teresse nunez

teresse nunez

81 likes

A square Monster Lactation Cookie Bar, rich with oats, dark chocolate chips, milk chocolate chips, and peanut butter chips, sits in a clear glass baking dish. Pink text overlay reads "MONSTER COOKIE BAR For Lactation," with "Lemon8 @kakamama11" in the bottom left.
Favorite Lactation Snack🥛🍪
This is my favorite lactation snack that I consume on the regular. I have a huge sweet tooth, so this just really speaks to me. It's called a Monster Lactation Cookie Bar. it's absolutely delicious. It tastes exactly like a cookie but gives your body a boost in producing milk. It's e
Shanxox

Shanxox

15 likes

SMELL LIKE A SNACK FOR $3.75! 🍬✨
Want to smell like Brown Sugar & Cashmere? 🍯☁️ ​I am officially in my "Budget Gourmand" era! I found the ultimate cozy scent combo at Dollar Tree, and I had to share. ​The Layering Routine: 1️⃣ Base: Apply the Pro Silk Creamy Cashmere lotion. It’s thick, moisturizing, and has that
Amari Yarber

Amari Yarber

17 likes

Christmas Tree Cookie Dippers ✨
The easiest festive treat you’ll make all season — and they’re almost too cute to eat! 🎅🏼 These Christmas Tree Cookie Dippers take just 5 minutes, and they’re perfect for dunking into hot cocoa or wrapping up for sweet little gifts. 🎁 Trust me, these disappear fast — so maybe double the batch
LetsBeBestieBoos

LetsBeBestieBoos

902 likes

A hand holds a large orange bag of Reese's Frozen Fruit Banana Slices, featuring sliced bananas enrobed in milk chocolate and peanut butter chips. The image has overlaid text that says "Snack Review" and a "Swipe" icon.
I tried the Reese’s bananas at Costco🍌🥜🍫
#whatieatinaday #lemon8challenge These are pretty good I wish they had more peanut butter because I’m a peanut butter girl but I would recommend them as a little treat (I do think if you have the energy you could probably make them better at home to be honest but they’re not a bad snack
Ghouly

Ghouly

282 likes

A smiling woman holds two large baking sheets filled with a chocolate and peanut butter snack mix, featuring cereal, peanuts, and mini peanut butter cups, in a kitchen setting.
Various ingredients for the snack mix are displayed on a counter, including boxes of Corn Chex, Chocolate Chex, Chocolate Cheerios, jars of dry roasted peanuts, and bags of Reese's peanut butter cups and chips, and Butterfinger bits.
A large clear plastic bowl is filled with the completed Buckeye Snack Mix, showing a mixture of Chex cereal, chocolate-coated clusters, peanuts, and mini peanut butter cups.
Amazing Buckeye Snack Mix
This snack mix was absolutely amazing. So I was told.! I’m on keto so I can’t eat it, but I made several bowls of it and everybody ate it to the last crumb. Buckeye Snack Mix Recipe: Ingredients: One box of chocolate peanut butter Cheerios One box of chocolate Chex cereal One box of rice
JusttheBells10

JusttheBells10

82 likes

A hand holds a clear container filled with red grapes coated in white powder, labeled as "2 INGREDIENT HEALTHY CANDY GRAPES NO ADDED SUGAR."
A clear glass dish contains white powder, with text indicating to "USE SUGAR FREE JELLO POWDER OR DRINK MIX POWDER" for the recipe.
Several red grapes, coated in a reddish powder, are shown in a ceramic bowl, with instructions to "ROLL WASHED GRAPES IN THE POWDER" while they are still moist.
My favorite 2 ingredient sweet snack! 🍇
Here’s how to make healthy candy grapes with just 2 ingredients! They’re so easy and don’t have any added sugars. If you’re looking for something easy, healthy, and either sweet or sour, this is a 5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Ingredients: • grapes • jello or drink mix powder (sugar free) Directions:
Abby

Abby

108 likes

A collection of Reese's brand snacks, including a box for Peanut Butter Crème Pie, a box for Peanut Butter Flavored Cupcakes, a bag of Reese's Popcorn, and a resealable bag of Reese's candy, displayed together.
reese’s snack haul 🥜🍫
The best passenger princess 🥜 #reeses #snack #peanutbutter #candy #dessert
Morgan Chomps

Morgan Chomps

205 likes

HEALTHY SNACK
#sugarfree #wafers #healthylifestyle2024 #health #guthealth #healthysnack #groceryessentials
Crystal Reese💍🫶🏽

Crystal Reese💍🫶🏽

16 likes

Drizzilicious Gluten Free Snack Review
#drizzilicious #glutenfree #snack #healthjourney
Melissa

Melissa

37 likes

✨2 ingredient Reese’s cookie cups✨
#cookies #baking #snack #yummy #peanutbutter
Brooklynams

Brooklynams

21 likes

GLP-1 Friendly Snack That Doesn't Taste Like Diet
Legendary Foods Mini Protein Donuts (Chocolate Dipped): 20g protein, only 5g net carbs, and it actually tastes like a donut. The chocolate coating is rich and it doesn't have that weird protein aftertaste. This one genuinely surprised me. Fit Treats Guiltless Cookies (Chocolate Chip): Made w
Kelsi_Z

Kelsi_Z

25 likes

Yummy protein snack😋🥰
Taste just like a Reese’s PB cup! So good! Also a great protein snack 👏🏻🤌🏻 #favoriteproteinsnack #proteinpackedsnacks #protein #snackideas #summerbod
Samantha Payne

Samantha Payne

61 likes

A hand holds a package of OREO BTS Brown Sugar Pancake Flavor Creme sandwich cookies, featuring purple packaging with blue text and an image of a purple cookie.
The back of the OREO BTS cookie package, detailing the Brown Sugar Pancake flavor, its inspiration from Hotteok, and a call to collect 13 unique cookie designs.
Three purple OREO BTS cookies held in a hand, displaying different designs: one with BTS member names, one with 'BTS,' and another with 'THE BIGGEST LOVE BTS ARMY.'
New BTS OREO Brown Sugar Pancake Review!
These are inspired by “hotteok,” a classic Korean-style pancake filled with melted brown sugar. This the first ever purple-colored oreo cookie. They smell is overwhelmingly maple, almost butterscotch to me, but the taste is giving brown sugar maple creme filling, between two graham cookies. I g
Texas Grocery Finds

Texas Grocery Finds

7 likes

A shopping cart filled with various zero sugar candies, including Reese's, Lily's chocolate bars, Hershey's, and Jolly Rancher, with overlay text questioning if they are truly zero sugar.
A hand holding a bag of Zero Sugar Jolly Rancher Hard Candy, sweetened with isomalt, priced at $9.15. The image highlights its similarity to the original and shows its nutrition facts panel.
A hand holding a bag of Hershey's Zero Sugar chocolate candy, sweetened with maltitol, priced at $6.34. The image describes it as classic chocolate but less rich, with its nutrition facts visible.
Walmart Zero Sugar Candy… Worth It? 👀🍫
zero sugar candy sounds fake… so I looked into it😛 If you’re trying to cut back on sugar, these are everywhere right now, BUTTT the sweetener matters way more than the label!!! 🩷 stevia / monk fruit = no sugar but can taste a little off 🤍 allulose = closest to real sugar 🩷 suga
Brooke˚₊‧♡ ‧₊˚

Brooke˚₊‧♡ ‧₊˚

97 likes

Healthy Snack Idea 💡
Half Baked PB&J Bars 🥜🫐🍓 👉 Feel free to mix in protein to the bottom layer for a high protein version! Gluten Free | Grain Free | Dairy Free | Refined Sugar Free 👩🏻‍🍳INGREDIENTS: For the bottom layer: 1 large organic egg 1/3 cup peanut butter 1 tsp vanilla extract 2 tbsp organic m
Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

Katie 👩🏻‍🍳

87 likes

CRUMBL COOKIES REVIEW
Nothing better than this week’s @crumbl COOKIES LINEUP!!! I got all of them because this lineup looks absolutely amazing!! So glad CRUMBL brought back the S’mores Cookie!! Anyways take a look to see how good this week’s CRUMBL LINEUP is!! Cheers to MONDAY!! #crumblcookies
Ava Rose

Ava Rose

0 likes

A hand holds a single purple Oreo cookie with the classic Oreo design. Overlay text reads "I Was Ready To Hate These..." with star ratings above.
A hand holds a single purple Oreo cookie, showing the reverse side embossed with the text "LEADS TO US" within a hexagonal design.
A single dark-colored package of Oreo BTS sandwich cookies is shown, featuring the "OREO BTS" logo and text indicating "Brown Sugar Pancake Flavor Creme."
🔥 Brown Sugar Pancake Oreos?! Hear Me Out… 🍪
@Lemon8 Food 🍪💜 I was 100% prepared to hate these. The second I saw "Brown Sugar Pancake Oreos," I knew somebody was playing in my face. 😭 Then I opened the pack... First thing I noticed? The smell. It gives cotton candy vibes, which immediately made me nervous because I d
Life W/ Leshia

Life W/ Leshia

214 likes

Healthy Low Cal “Reese’s” for Valentine’s Day 🫶
Healthy, lower calorie and higher protein resee’s chocolate just in time for Valentine’s Day. This came out amazing and it’s exactly the kind of snack or dessert that will help you satisfy your sweet cravings and stay on track. Each piece has 68 cal and 5g of protein, total for the recipe is 406cal
IvannaCarolina

IvannaCarolina

30 likes

✨COMING SOON✨REESE’S x OREOS!✨
Oreo has collabed with Reese's to bring two iconic flavors in one! A Reese’s & Oreo lover’s dream mash up! ✨Oreo Reese’s Cookie✨ Filled with Reese’s Peanut Butter & Oreo crumbs. ✨REESE'S OREO Cups✨ Milk Chocolate filled with Reese’s Peanut Butter & Oreo Cookie crumbs.
Kamisha’s BigBackSnackShack

Kamisha’s BigBackSnackShack

419 likes

December Vanilla Review
December Vanilla | Paris Corner First of all, who doesn't want to smell like a queen in snack form? This is delectable royalty. A sweet and spicy boozy dessert with a sugary whipped cream on top. Rum, vanilla, brown sugar, creme brulee? A gourmand lovers dream! This is a powerhouse fragranc
Feel_Good_Tingz

Feel_Good_Tingz

43 likes

Snack Haul 🍒
Last day of school for the kiddos is tomorrow so I loaded up on the snacks! Swimming in the pool makes these girls hungry, hungry, hungry! ☀️ #snackhaul #walmartgroceries #walmartfinds #foodie #snackideasforkids
Yasi

Yasi

483 likes

New Walmart Snack 🍫
7/10, they were good but I wouldn’t get them again #walmartsnacks #walmartfinds #groceryessentials #lemon8review #dessertideas
Ce’Yonna Black

Ce’Yonna Black

151 likes

A hand holds two snack packages: a blue Oreo Reese's Peanut Buttery Creme cookie pack (4 cookies, 2.04 oz) and an orange Reese's Oreo King Size peanut butter cups pack (4 cups, 2.8 oz). The image has a 'Yay or nay #8' text overlay.
✨Oreo & Reese’s✨
I was gifted these for my birthday. I believe they got them from Walmart! I have finally tried both. I say absolutely yay for both!! The Oreos are perfect. I have never tried a peanut butter Oreo, so I can’t compare… but you can definitely tell they partnered with Reese’s! The Reese’s are e
Summer 🍴🍔

Summer 🍴🍔

96 likes

CRUMBL COOKIES REVIEW
Nothing better than this week’s @crumbl COOKIES LINEUP!!! I got all of them because this lineup looks absolutely amazing!! So glad CRUMBL released the Peanut Butter Cup Brownie Ft. Reese’s, and also they had An encore of the Dubai Chocolate Cookie!! Anyways take a look to see how good this week’s C
Ava Rose

Ava Rose

17 likes

Halo Top cookies review 🍪✨
i am absolutely obsessed with these guilt-free treats! sweet and packed with protein & WAY lower in calories than my other fav cookies. making them my go-to snack for satisfying my sweet tooth without the guilt 😙🤌🏽 absolute chefs kiss 10/10 #healthyfood #healthylifestyle2024 #snack #s
hi! im reis 🤍

hi! im reis 🤍

223 likes

A hand holds a white chocolate Reese's cup above a large blue Oreo Reese's collaboration box, while another hand holds a smaller king-size package. The box advertises "Reese's Peanut Buttery Creme with Oreo Cookie Crumbs" as a limited edition.
A close-up of the Reese's Oreo wrapper, featuring a repeating pattern of orange Reese's and blue Oreo circles. The wrapper also displays allergy information: "CONTAINS: PEANUT, WHEAT, SOY."
An open box reveals rows of Reese's Oreo cookies, stacked neatly in their foil packaging. The image includes a rating of "9.5/10" overlaid on the bottom right corner.
Oreo/Reeses Collab Review!!🧡💙
#oreocookies #reesespeanutbuttercup #Lemon8 #snacks #food
Heather🌸💕

Heather🌸💕

8 likes

See more