My boyfriend of 8+ years won’t marry me

I’ve been with my boyfriend for 8.5 years, living together for 5. We love each other, we communicate well, he’s supported me through school, and honestly our life together feels like marriage already… except it’s not.

I’ve always dreamed of being a bride, having that celebration with family and friends, and making it official. He doesn’t shut me down when I bring it up, but he also hasn’t proposed. Every year that passes, every time someone asks “when’s the wedding?” I feel more stuck.

I don’t want to waste more years waiting for something he’ll never do… but I also can’t imagine leaving someone who treats me so well.

Do you think I should give him a real deadline, or accept that marriage might never happen with him?

#AskLemon8 #LetsChat #RelationshipTalk

2025/9/20 Edited to

57 comments

Doww Jones's images
Doww Jones

Marriage isn't some magical thing, its a complete waste of money just to fulfill your fairytale dream. If you guys get alone and love each other, just be happy and live your life.

Jayne's images
Jayne

Okay hun, what you need to do is sit down with him and tell him how much you love him, how happy he makes you but you need to know if he ever wants to marry you. Because that's something that's important to you. Then you'll know exactly what his opinion on marriage is. Don't put it off because you'll end up resenting him at a certain point in the near future.

See more comments

Related posts

A woman in a long, light-colored dress with black trim takes a mirror selfie. The image features a large text overlay that reads '100 Questions To ask your boyfriend', indicating the article's topic.
A couple looks at each other affectionately in what appears to be a bathroom. A text overlay lists questions 1-10 for boyfriends, including 'What did you first notice about me?' and 'Where do you see us in 5 years?'.
A man stands with his back to the camera, looking up at a vibrant purple light installation. A text overlay presents questions 11-20, such as 'Where would be your dream honeymoon?' and 'What career goals do you have?'.
100 questions to ask your boyfriend 🫶
Ask these!! It can be a fun little date night to ask eachother questions or just to have a general chat about the topics above - what other questions can you think of? #lemon8partner #relationships #relationshipadvice
Eva Hansen

Eva Hansen

8518 likes

Two hands, one wearing a ring, gently hold a small white and yellow flower. The image has text overlays including "Things me and my Boyfriend do as 18yo dating to marry" and a pink heart icon.
A hand's shadow forms a heart shape on a wall, with a vintage green rotary phone icon in the corner. The text overlay reads "We talk every night" and describes their daily ritual.
A nighttime view of a balcony with a small table and chairs, overlooking apartment buildings. Two red heart balloons with "Love" written on them float above. The text overlay is "We alternate date nights."
Things me and my boyfriend do as 18yo❤️
#boyfriend #boyfriendideas #youngcouples #him💍 #bf
Lauren :)

Lauren :)

1448 likes

Marry Me Chicken Orzo
Ingredients: -1 1/2lbs boneless, skinless chicken breasts, cut into cubes -2 tbsp olive oil -minced garlic -3/4 cup sun dried tomatoes in oil, drained -2 tsp Italian seasoning -2 tsp paprika -1/2 tsp salt -1 tsp pepper -1 cup orzo -2 1/2 cups chicken broth -3/4 cups heavy whipping cream
Megan

Megan

4168 likes

A close-up of a person's arm and hand resting on a car's center console, with a light green Stanley cup visible. The image features the title '100 QUESTIONS to ask your boyfriend' and the Lemon8 username.
A scenic image of a field with trees and power lines against a sunset sky. Overlayed text presents '10 QUESTIONS personality' followed by a list of questions about personal traits and preferences.
A colorful field of cosmos flowers in various shades of pink, purple, and orange under a blue sky. Overlayed text displays '10 QUESTIONS dreams / goals' and a list of related questions.
100 questions to ask your boyfriend
10 QUESTIONS: random❤️‍🔥 If you could master any skill instantly, what would it be? What’s the most random fact you know? What’s one thing on your bucket list you still want to do? What’s your favorite holiday and why? If you could switch lives with anyone for a day, who would it be? What’s s
Zoey Rofkahr

Zoey Rofkahr

5697 likes

10 QUESTIONS to ASK the PERSON you want to MARRY🤍💍
It doesn’t matter if you’ve been in a relationship with your partner for 1 year or 10 years… It doesn’t matter HOW WELL you might think you know your partner after many years together. Even if you’ve spent years together… there are still some very valid questions that you should be asking a p
Sarah Bispy

Sarah Bispy

4735 likes

A close-up of two gold wedding rings, one with a diamond, resting on soft pink flower petals. The image features the title "Part 1 BEFORE YOU MARRY HIM !!!!" and the Lemon8 logo with the user handle.
A pink background with text introducing the importance of open conversations before marriage. It states, "Here are some essential questions you might want to ask your boyfriend:" and includes the Lemon8 logo.
A pink background displaying the first category of pre-marriage questions: "1. Family and Relationships." Bullet points cover topics like family involvement, conflict resolution, children, and balancing family, work, and couple time.
Before you marry him !!!
Before saying 'I do,' here are the important questions to ask and the conversations to have because love is built on understanding, trust, and shared dreams. #marriage #engagement #questions #letschat #embracevulnerability
Kaay Love

Kaay Love

6637 likes

18 years of loving you, hallelujah 💗
18 years ago, we were simply scene partners in Grease. He as Kenickie and myself as Cha Cha. He drove me crazy being mischievous, failing at attempts to serenade me with the song “Bad the Bone,” and dropping the romantic line, “Does your Momma let you date? “ 🙄 I didn’t want to give him the time
kendallmariah

kendallmariah

0 likes

TikTok Viral Marry Me Chicken🤩
Spread the love Marry Me Chicken is creamy, juicy, and full of flavor! It's said that this chicken dinner is so good that if you cook it for your partner, he will propose to you! Yes, it's THAT amazing! Funny name, but probably the best chicken recipe ever! Marry Me Chicken is creamy, j
Kate

Kate

1696 likes

A split image shows Big Sean with Naya Rivera on the left, labeled "Engaged in 3 Months" with a ring emoji, and Big Sean with Jhené Aiko on the right, labeled "Refused To Marry" with a ring and shrugging emoji. Both couples are smiling, with event backdrops.
Broke Up After 10 Years 😩💔
Big Sean absolutely refused to marry Jhene. After being with her for 10 years and literally having a child with her. Yet, proposed to Naya in line 3 months. He said he loves the idea of marriage but didn’t want to let “societal issues” pressure him. PLEASE SAVE IT 😭😭 Also, Jhene got a whole port
L a n a i s Li 🧚🏽‍♀️

L a n a i s Li 🧚🏽‍♀️

1092 likes

A couple laughing and embracing on a couch, with text overlay asking "Is He From God? Or A Lesson? Find out" to introduce the article's theme.
A list titled "THINGS TO CONSIDER BEFORE COMMITTING..." detailing questions about aligning values, schedules, future desires, trust, lifestyle, conflict resolution, views, sexual preferences, finances, and feeling safe.
A list titled "Attributes of a Good Man" describing qualities such as loving you as you are, being sensitive, spending time, being attentive, reliable, protective, honest, resilient, appreciative, supportive, and respectful.
How To Know God Brought You The One?🤨
How do you know if he’s the one God has for you? How do you know if you should marry him? After spending years being single and praying for God to bring you your future husband, you think this guy could be the one. Here are some signs to know if He Is The One For YOU: 1) God Has Confirmed He’s t
Angelina

Angelina

1466 likes

A pink graphic with the text "letters for your boyfriend" and an envelope emoji, set against a white lined paper background. It features "XOXO" at the top, a fuzzy pink heart, and a small pink bow character, indicating a romantic theme.
A handwritten letter on pink lined paper, addressed to a boyfriend, expressing deep love and support. The letter is adorned with several red lipstick kiss marks, emphasizing its romantic and personal nature.
A bullet journal page titled "my favourite," listing numerous reasons why the author loves her boyfriend. Each point, such as "when he holds my hand" or "his compliments," is marked with a red heart emoji, highlighting cherished moments and qualities.
letters for your boyfriend 💌
#Lemon8Diary #Valentine #pinterest #boyfriend
Rachiel

Rachiel

8086 likes

“Letting a man smack your booty for FREE will not make a man marry you.”
abellewis2026

abellewis2026

111 likes

8 lessons I learned in 8 years of marriage
1️⃣ Before correcting my husband, I learned to bring my frustrations to the Lord first. Asking the Holy Spirit for wisdom on when to speak and when to be quiet. And if I do speak, that my words would reach his heart. 2️⃣ Marriage reveals what God still wants to refine in us. Our marriage is only
Ana Silva

Ana Silva

106 likes

A desert landscape with cacti under a blue sky, featuring the shadows of a couple on the sand. Overlaying text reads: 'My boyfriend is asking me to marry him, but I am fed up of his anger issues.'
Would you marry someone if you were already scared
I’ve been with my boyfriend for 6 months, and now he’s asking me to marry him. The problem? His anger issues. In the beginning, I told myself I’d just put up with it until we eventually split, but I never told him that. When his parents started pushing him toward an arranged marriage, he propose
Ula

Ula

155 likes

A couple embraces in an autumn forest, with text 'Boyfriend Gift Ideas homemade edition' and 'lemon8 @reinakjohnson' overlaid, serving as the cover for homemade gift ideas.
A collection of heart-shaped or lip-print notes with handwritten messages, labeled 'Kiss love notes', expressing affection and personal thoughts for a boyfriend.
An open 'floral love letter' featuring dried flowers tied with a ribbon, adorned with lip prints, and a handwritten note about hand-picked flowers and perfume.
Boyfriend gift ideas
#boyfriend #boyfriendgirlfriend #boyfriendandgirlfriend #boyfriendgiftideas #boyfriendgift #relationshipideas #relationshipchallenge #coupleideas #Lemon8MadeMeBuyIt i’m #relationshiptips
Reina Johnson

Reina Johnson

24.5K likes

A young couple, a blonde male in a black shirt and a dark-haired female in a pink dress, stand outdoors, looking at each other. The female has her arm around the male's waist. Text overlay reads 'cute messages from my boyfriend' and 'lemon8 @zoekristinaa'.
A screenshot of a text message showing 'Goodnight wifeyyy' with a red heart emoji. Above it, a 'Tap and hold to super react' prompt displays various emojis. Below, options like 'Reply', 'Forward', and 'Copy' are visible.
A screenshot of a text message bubble saying 'I wanna see you'. Above it, reaction icons including a heart, thumbs up, and 'HA HA' are shown. Below, a menu offers 'Reply', 'Add Sticker', 'Copy', 'Translate', and 'More...'.
cute messages from my boyfriend 🫶🏾
just a few cute messages sent from my boyfriend 🥰🥰 im the luckiest ❤️ #textswithmybf #bf #love #dating #boyfriend #promphotography #him❤️💍♾️✨ #boyfriend💖
zoe 💐

zoe 💐

3267 likes

I think i’m gonna marry him
Los Angeles
tanna

tanna

1230 likes

18 years of loving you, hallelujah 💗
18 years ago, we were simply scene partners in Grease. He as Kenickie and myself as Cha Cha. He drove me crazy being mischievous, failing at attempts to serenade me with the song “Bad the Bone,” and dropping the romantic line, “Does your Momma let you date? “ 🙄 I didn’t want to give him the time
kendallmariah

kendallmariah

3 likes

ja rule actually wanted to marry Ashanti
because he felt they just had a strong bond in connection over the years that they was dating and this is probably why Nelly is so jealous because Nelly don't have no chemistry with Ashanti you know ja rule he did a lot for Ashanti he made her feel like a queen appreciate it and he always appre
Aaliyah my wife loves me

Aaliyah my wife loves me

21 likes

Should I delete these from my social media?
Originally I was very excited to post because I thought I looked good and I guess get more follows and likes.. But now I hate that I posted these. Not many people are even liking the post.. My sister said it’s too provocative and that married men are interacting with these with there own desires
Therachis0

Therachis0

491 likes

Why you SHOULD’NT marry an unbeliever
Additionally, the Bible doesn't just limit this passage to marriage, but all forms of being "yolked together". This may include going into business with someone as well.
Angelina Maria☀️

Angelina Maria☀️

151 likes

A couple embraces on a bridge overlooking a city skyline at dusk, with the text "Meet my boyfriend!" above them, introducing the man.
A couple stands at an outdoor event, looking at each other, with text stating they met on Snapchat when he was 15 and she was 14.
A couple poses in a grassy field next to a red barn, with the man playfully touching the woman's head. Text describes their professions: he is an operator, and she is a CNA studying to be a nurse.
I stole my boyfriend from a friend 😞🤍
I met my boyfriend on snapchat when I was 14, and he was 15. He was dating a girl off my travel softball team ( she was also my friend) at the time. She had posted him and tagged him, and I was messy and thought he was cute so I added him. He immediately added me back, and we had an instant connect
a.c

a.c

1295 likes

Should I just marry him? ❤️
MemoryCuube

MemoryCuube

37 likes

5 years of no social media & 6 things I learned➡️
There’s more written in the pics, but here’s a very small snippet of what I learned: 1. You are what you eat - what you consume virtually is what your mind is going to be operating from. High stress shows=high stress brain 2. It’s easy to spot a Phony!- people are very regular in real life! Once
Tori

Tori

94 likes

He’s a 10 but…. (Book Boyfriend Edition)
1. Done & Dusted by Lyla Sage - The first installment follows Clementine “Emmy” Ryder after she returns home following a horse riding accident. There, she runs into Luke Brooks, the town's bad boy and her brother's best friend. However, Luke has changed a lot since Emmy has last seen hi
paigesofsmut

paigesofsmut

129 likes

A baby in a white bonnet and pink outfit sleeps on an adult's lap in a car. The text 'THIS IS THE SECOND TIME HE'S CHEATED' is overlaid, emphasizing the article's theme of infidelity. Lemon8 branding is visible.
My husband cheated on me 1 day before the wedding
In high school, 3 or 4 months into dating, he strayed with his ex. Now I’ve learned he cheated the day before our wedding with a coworker at work. He claims it was a one-time thing, years ago, but they’re still close. How did he marry me with that? Look me and our child in the eye daily? I am absol
Zoe💌

Zoe💌

1153 likes

6 years down the drain
the sad part is i had no idea what he was going through bc he didn’t tell me
kenzi.ecreates

kenzi.ecreates

7 likes

Before you marry him !!
Since you all loved Part 1 of Before You Marry Him !! Here’s Part 2 with even more essential topics to discuss before saying ‘I do’! Comment down below your opinions ⬇️⬇️ #marryme #questionstoask #letschat #marriage #lemon8challenge
Kaay Love

Kaay Love

20 likes

Marry Me Dip + Garlic Bread
This is the kind of appetizer that starts conversations and disappears fast. Creamy chicken dip with sun-dried tomatoes + homemade garlic bread dippers…the second you smell this coming out of the oven you’ll understand 😭💛 Perfect for: • Date night • Thanksgiving leftovers • Holiday parties •
A Dose Of Love

A Dose Of Love

35 likes

Yes, I’m 31 years old and I play Sims 4.
Me: Hi, I’m Tamara I’m 31 years old and I play Sims 4. Other Sim lovers: Hi Tamara. Growing up my parents could not afford to get me Sims, back then there was just the original Sims. I had this one friend who had a laptop, a sidekick , iPod mini, and even a Nintendo ds! So I only would get to
Mara

Mara

1844 likes

won’t reach that 20k after 3 years 🙂‍↕️
Join my series where I help you travel and study abroad easily and affordably! #college #tuition #tuition reimbursement #studenttips #studyabroad
ʙʀʏ ᴍᴀʏʙᴇʀʀʏ ☆゚.*・。゚

ʙʀʏ ᴍᴀʏʙᴇʀʀʏ ☆゚.*・。゚

354 likes

Gift ideas for Boyfriend💕
Simple gift ideas whether your flat broke or got money 💰 to use . Make your boyfriend ✨ᶠᴱᴱᴸ✨ your love on VDay❤️ 👍Pros: He marry you😳😮‍💨😻 🤔Cons: He Leave You 🤦🏽‍♀️🥺 Like this post for good luck ! Leave a follow for more relatable woman Content 💋 #boyfriendgifts #valentineinspo #Lemon8
Ms.No Face

Ms.No Face

627 likes

making a scrapbook for my boyfriend 💕
Part 1🎀 I know it’s not perfect but I put so much thought and love into this I couldn’t even keep it a secret I had to show him my progress🤭 I’m no where near done so give me ideas for future pages! #scrapbookideas #scrapbookpage #scrapbookwithme #scrapbookjournal #boyfriend
Jayleee🍰❤️

Jayleee🍰❤️

112 likes

WHY DO MEN NEVER MARRY THE WOMAN THEY STRUNG ALONG
#sheraseven
sprinklesprinkle

sprinklesprinkle

39 likes

4 years in, he says he’ll never marry
My man and I have been together 4 years. We split rent, share pets, do holidays with each other’s families. I thought we were just taking our time and not skipping marriage entirely. I’d bring it up gently now and then, but he’d say, “Not yet” or “It’s not everything.” Then last month, he said it c
Sophia☘️

Sophia☘️

18 likes

Marry Me Chicken (Creamy Tuscan Chicken)
This delicious Creamy Keto Tuscan Chicken Recipe (also know as Marry Me Chicken) is made with perfectly seasoned and pan-seared chicken breasts, simmered in a velvety sauce made with sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, garlic, red onions, heavy cream and parmesan cheese. Best of all, this dish only dirties
KyndraHolley

KyndraHolley

23.2K likes

19 years and counting 🥰
#bestfriends
F❤️E Family

F❤️E Family

11 likes

Marry your Middle School Sweetheart 🥰
I met my soulmate in a choir class in the 6th grade, and I couldn’t think of anyone else to spend the rest of my life with ♥️🥰 #andyandlogan #couples #love #middleschoolsweethearts #marriedlife
❤️Andy & Logan❤️

❤️Andy & Logan❤️

16 likes

Could you love someone who won’t marry?
We were having dessert when he casually said, “I don’t really believe in marriage.” I froze. Not because I didn’t expect honesty but because I realized how differently we see the future. Part of me respected him for being upfront instead of pretending. But another part of me felt a quiet heartbre
Nikki🍋

Nikki🍋

86 likes

A vibrant collage of colorful plastic links forms the background for the text 'THE EARLY YEARS OF 2000', evoking nostalgia for early 2000s childhood memories.
A collage of nostalgic 2000s locations including a Toys R Us store, a bookstore, a wooden playground, a merry-go-round, a McDonald's play place, and a Build-A-Bearville game screenshot.
A collage of popular 2000s candies and gum, featuring Hubba Bubba Guch, Hubba Bubba Max, Hershey's Kissables, Wonka Shockers, assorted bubble gum, and Hubba Bubba bubble liquid.
The early years of 2000’s 👾
Don’t you wish you can just rewind time to experience your childhood again 🥺, as i get older i miss the little things about being a kid and all the amazing things we had our kids won’t get to experience:( The early 2000s was a year to be alive 😩 #2000s #nostalgic #childhoodmemories
Andrnique

Andrnique

1717 likes

I believe Kobe he would have marry Mya
because Maya had a crush on Kobe Bryant she loved that man I truly believe these two could have gotten married because they was dating each other and Kobe Bryant was still playing basketball at the age of 19 years old like Kobe Bryant had a real chemistry in connection with Maya Maya had a career K
Aaliyah my wife loves me

Aaliyah my wife loves me

160 likes

Marry The Blind Billionaire, Be His Container
From his pregnancy container to his soul mate…
NovelFlow

NovelFlow

3 likes

Would you marry the demon?
They never expected the demon they sacrificed her to fall in love but that’s exactly what happens in the cozy dark romantasy That Time I Took Down A Cult by Rebel Carter My name is Buffy Martinez and I’ve spent my entire life training to be a wife, but when a cult is the one leading me down the
rebelcarterwrites

rebelcarterwrites

109 likes

See more