my book rating scale✨📖

★ Same rating scale, 𝚗𝚎𝚠 YEAR :) ★

I do give half star ⭐️ratings too, just depends how I feel the books falls in between the ratings!

*pinch screen to zoom in

I usually wouldn’t finish a book if it was 1 star but say maybe you are reading a book in a buddy read or book club or for a class and have to finish it lol

QOTD:

Do you rate your books a certain way?? Lmk! ⬇️

#books #canva #design #edit #Lemon8Diary #reading #rating #bookrecommendations #BookReview #bookstagram

2024/1/20 Edited to

... Read moreYou know that feeling when you finish an amazing book, or one that just didn't click? Having a solid book rating scale is such a game-changer for me! It helps me make sense of my reading experiences, articulate my thoughts for reviews, and even helps me recommend books to friends more accurately. I've personally found a 1-5 star book rating scale to be the most intuitive for my reading journey. My personal rating system, which I like to think of as my own 'reading rating scale chart,' isn't just about a number; it's about the whole experience. So, what defines each star and that crucial 'DNF' (Did Not Finish)? 5 Stars: AMAZING! This is reserved for books that absolutely blew me away. They're unforgettable, thought-provoking, beautifully written, and left a lasting impact. I couldn’t put it down, and I’m probably still thinking about it weeks later. These are the books I'll shout about from the rooftops and reread without hesitation. 4 Stars: I loved this book! It was fantastic, highly enjoyable, and I’d definitely recommend it. Maybe there was a tiny element that kept it from being a 5-star, or it didn't quite resonate with me on that deepest, most impactful level. Still, a truly excellent read! 3 Stars: This is a solid, good read. I enjoyed my time with it, but it might have had some minor flaws, felt a bit forgettable, or just didn't stand out from the crowd. It was a perfectly fine way to pass the time, and I don't regret reading it, but I probably won't be raving about it. 2 Stars: I struggled with this one. I didn't particularly enjoy it, but I powered through and finished it. Perhaps it had some redeeming qualities or an interesting premise that kept me going, but overall, it wasn't for me. It might be a book I finished out of obligation for a book club or if I was buddy reading. 1 Star: BADDDDDD. This book was a real miss. I actively disliked it, found it frustrating, poorly executed, or problematic. It’s rare for me to finish a book that falls into this category, but if I do, it’s usually because I had to for some external reason. Otherwise, this is often a candidate for DNF. Speaking of DNF – sometimes a book just isn't working, and that's okay! My 'DNF' rating means I literally 'Did Not Finish' the book. This isn't a reflection of the book's quality necessarily, but more about my personal engagement with it. If I'm not connecting with the characters, finding the plot slow, or the writing style just isn't for me, I give myself permission to put it down. Life's too short to read books you're not enjoying! Having a consistent 'how to rate something' system isn't just for books. The principles can apply to movies, games, or anything you want to critically evaluate. For books, it really helps me track my preferences over time and refine my taste. While I stick to a 1-5 star scale, I know some people prefer a 'book rating scale 1-10' for more granularity, or even a 'rating love scale' for more emotional connection to their reads. Whatever system you choose, the goal is to make your reading experience more meaningful and easier to share!

14 comments

Shanika Hastie's images
Shanika Hastie

Love your ratings. I haven’t figured out how to rate. Just started really reading books this year. So I’m still a newbie

See more(2)
Franklyfrances's images
Franklyfrances

definitely use the five-star system ❤️🍋

Related posts

Book and spice rating
Chat gbt for the win! Gonna start using this to rate my books! #chatgbt #bookratingscale
LifeWithShell💜

LifeWithShell💜

4 likes

A book titled "Iron Flame" by Rebecca Yarros is on a shelf next to a plant. Overlay text reads: "A BOOK SO SMUTTY i HAD TO TAKE BREAKS."
Unhinged Book Read
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ I don’t even know how to begin about this book. I’ve read a lot of books and I can confidently say that I have never read anything like this yet. The spice in this is unmatched and let me put it two words: THE CLAW.. ( iykyk 😉 ), and I think it bro
moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

moodreadswithnicole 📚💭

12.6K likes

Three books, 'Love Redesigned,' 'Powerless,' and 'Promises and Pomegranates,' are displayed on a white textured surface, with pink text overlay stating 'how I rate my books.'
my book rating scale 🌟
this is how I rate my books! I also do a lot of .5’s in goodreads, therefore those get rounded up. if I have something rated a 3.5 it will show as a 4 star, but at the beginning of my review it will say “3.5 ⭐️s rounded up.” #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchallenge #books #book #boo
kalees reads

kalees reads

37 likes

A hand holds several books, with text overlay 'ENEMIES TO LOVERS BOOKS' and a chili pepper emoji, indicating a list of romance novels. The Lemon8 logo and username are visible at the bottom.
The book 'Powerless' by Lauren Roberts is shown, highlighted with keywords like 'FANTASY ROMANCE', 'FORBIDDEN LOVE', 'ENEMIES TO LOVERS', and 'SLOW BURN', along with a summary of its plot.
The book 'A Court of Mist and Fury' by Sarah J. Maas is displayed, featuring keywords such as 'SECOND CHANCE', 'FANTASY', 'TRAUMA BONDING', and 'EMOTIONAL', accompanied by a plot summary.
Rating Viral Enemies to Lovers Books 🥵
🔥Looking for books with the enemies to lovers trope, but they REALLY hate each other?! You’ve found just the right post 👀 1️⃣ Powerless by Lauren Roberts After being forced to work for her sworn enemy, the powerful and ruthless CEO, a strong-willed woman finds herself entangled in a dangerous g
irianna

irianna

1242 likes

A collage of Freida McFadden book covers with the text overlay "FREIDA MCFADDEN Book Ranking" in white, set against a dark background.
A hand holding Freida McFadden's book "The Teacher," rated 3.7 stars, with keywords including "Teacher & Student Relationship," "Cheating," and "A shoe obsession."
A hand holding Freida McFadden's book "The Locked Door," rated 3.9 stars, featuring keywords "Prominent Surgeon" and "Serial Killers."
Freida McFadden Book Rating 💡
Freida McFadden is literally my favorite Author! Her books are fast-paced and binge worthy 📚 #thecookbook #reading📖 #embracevulnerability #booksoflemon8 #books #reading #friedamcfadden #reading📚 #books #book
Katie May

Katie May

714 likes

My spice rating scale for books
How spicy do you like your books? 👀 #spiciestbooks #bookratings #books #reading #spicybooks
Alliegator

Alliegator

38 likes

A hand holds a clear phone case with various stickers over a book, with text overlayed saying 'How I Rate my books' and 'MY STAR SYSTEM' on a pink background with star outlines.
Five solid pink stars represent a 5-star book rating, described as 'absolute perfection!' with text detailing why the book was highly recommended and reread multiple times.
Four solid pink stars and one outline star represent a 4-star book rating, described as 'I pulled a couple all-nighters' with text explaining it was a good book despite minor flaws.
my book rating scale ⭐️
everyone’s book rating scale is so different, but this is how i do it! should i post my spice scale as well? 🔥 #bookratingsystem #bookratings #bookwormsoflemon8 #booktok #starrating #bookstagram #howiratebooks #romancereader
victoria 🩰

victoria 🩰

17 likes

BOOK RATING!!
#book #rating #haunting adeline #zademeadows #lemon8bookclub #ratingbooks #opinion #honest i dont even know where to begin with this book. it does romanticize sexual abuse, but then again the author does privide trigger warnings unlike some authors *colleen hoover*. this book wa
ℒ ʚ❤︎ɞ

ℒ ʚ❤︎ɞ

348 likes

A stack of horror books, including 'The September House', 'Leech', 'Dead Silence', 'The Troop', 'Parasite', 'Tender Is The Flesh', 'Where He Can't Find You', 'Uzumaki', and 'Mary', held by a person in a white sweater and black glove.
The book 'Where He Can't Find You' by Darcy Coates, rated 2.5/10 for body horror, with text indicating mostly intact bodies and the author's use of mannequins as horror.
The book 'Mary' by Nat Cassidy, rated 3/10 for body horror, with text describing some bodily unease and self-transformation, but nothing extreme.
VISCERAL HORROR:BODY HORROR INTENSITY SCALE📉➡️📈
⚠️The ratings are body horror based not overall for the book itself 🩸I keep forgetting Lemon8 only allows 10 photos. 🩸I ranked "The September House" 2/10. Almost no physical degradation 🩸My scale maxes out at 9.5 rating. I know what a 10 would be and which book(genre). 🩸But I w
⛓⛓YÉE⛓⛓

⛓⛓YÉE⛓⛓

78 likes

A pink graphic titled "Spice rating" with faint heart outlines in the background. It lists five levels of book spice, each represented by 1 to 5 red chili peppers, describing content from kissing to explicit kinks and trigger warnings.
Spicy rating scale
These ratings are based on my own personal scale. If there is no rating or a 🫑 then no spice is included in the book. QOTD: Do you guys like knowing the spice scale?? #lemon8diarychallenge #booksmut #darkromance #morallygreymen #lemon8bookclubchallenge #lemon8darkromance #sp
CanieshiaPowell

CanieshiaPowell

491 likes

Teen Book recommendations and my rating!
These books are a MUST read! I personally loved them so if you’re a mystery,drama, and fantasy lover these are definitely for you. Would you guys like to see more book recommendations or have any? If so comment below #AskLemon8 #book #books 🫶🏼 DISCLAIMER Most of these books contain deat
Avarie

Avarie

29 likes

Book recs based on my spice scale🌶️
Always check triggers before you read! As you can tell I prefer some spice in my books so I apologize there are not a ton of 1🌶️ recs Make sure you keep an eye out on my reviews I always include the 🌶️ ratings #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge #letschat #readersoflemon8 #spicesc
CanieshiaPowell

CanieshiaPowell

103 likes

A book cover for Aron Beauregard's 'Playground' is centered on a background of colorful plastic balls. The cover shows a girl on a slide covered in blood. Overlays read 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW', 'Rating: 4.25/5', and 'Lemon8 @itskacijo'.
Rating: 4.25/5
It’s been a little while since I finished Playground by Aron Beauregard, but instead of sitting down to do this review, I read 3 more books. It would be a disservice to this book and author if I didn’t finish telling you all my thoughts about it. So, here we go. I really enjoyed it. I would have
Kaci Jo

Kaci Jo

438 likes

The Ultimate Book Tracker
This journal is part tracker, part challenge, part celebration of my love for books 📚💖 From genres and page counts to publication dates, alphabet challenges, and even monthly reading grids—this is how I turn my TBR chaos into something that actually makes sense (and looks cute doing it). Shouto
Cannin Plannin

Cannin Plannin

19 likes

rating every book I read in September
September was a pretty slow month for me as I was juggling school with my new teaching schedule. But I did manage to read these three books, one of which is probably my favorite I've read this year. Can you guess which one?? Let me know in the comments your favorite book so far this year! #le
bookrvws

bookrvws

30 likes

My rating is a 100/10✨✨✨✨🌶️🌶️🌶️
So this book is hella good and if u read Icebreaker and u liked it u will most likely like this one! This book is about a girl named Kendall (a shy introverted bookworm girl)and a guy named Vincent(a popular star basketball player) meet each other and yk one thing leads to another 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️that ha
Orchid_🌺🌺

Orchid_🌺🌺

1388 likes

A book review for 'God of Malice' by Rina Kent, showing the dark cover with a skull mask, rated 4/5 for the book and 5/5 for spice with five chili peppers, set against an ornate background.
A text overlay describes the plot of 'God of Malice' about an art student and a dangerous medical student, accompanied by a collage of a person painting, an open book, and medical texts.
Text describes Glyndon's attraction to Killian's enigmatic presence and his dark secrets, featuring quotes like 'Too bad you got the villain' and 'You being mine. I'll give you the world in return.'
Rating: 4/5
My Current Read 📖 Name of the Book: “God Of Malice” 📄 Plot: Glyndon King, an art student with dark fantasies, who becomes entangled with Killian Carson, a mysterious and potentially dangerous medical student. Their intense, obsessive relationship is fueled by power struggles, control, and hidden
Oliviahunttt

Oliviahunttt

77 likes

A hand holds two Emily Henry books, "Beach Read" and "Book Lovers," against a light wall with sunbeams. Text reads "rating every Emily Henry book I've read." Icons for books and reading are in the top right corner.
A hand holds Emily Henry's "Book Lovers" with a 4.5-star rating. Text describes it as "my personal fav!" and highlights "enemies to lovers," "small town romance," and being "for fans of 'The Proposal'."
A hand holds Emily Henry's "Beach Read" with a 4-star rating. Text says "really enjoyed! would recommend still" and mentions "grumpy sunshine dynamic," "complicated parent-child relationship," and "second chance romance."
rating Emily Henry books
Emily Henry’s next book “Funny Story” comes out in April this year so I thought I’d give my ratings on her books I’ve read so far! I’m not normally a romance reader but I do really love the way she writes dialogue and her female characters. Have you read any of these books? #lemon8partner #le
bookrvws

bookrvws

35 likes

• 40 DAYS OF BOOKSTA CONTENT •
I know some days, it’s hard coming up with content ideas. Here are 40 days worth! I hope these are helpful for you and get those creative juices flowing! #Lemon8Diary #books #booktok #booksoflemon8 #bookstagram #contentideas #contentcreator #lifestyle #readersoflemon8 #reading
devin.reads

devin.reads

358 likes

A hand holds the 'Wedding Hacks' book, featuring a light blue cover with gold and blue illustrations, in front of a bookshelf. The image has text overlays 'RATING WEDDING BOOKS ON A SCALE OF 1-10' and a Lemon8 watermark.
A hand holds 'The Wedding A to Z' book with a bright pink cover. An overlay rates it 4 stars, calling it helpful and less dated, noting it contains tips found online but is preferred over many tabs.
An open page from 'The Wedding A to Z' book displays a '911 WHAT SHOULD YOU HAVE IN YOUR EMERGENCY KIT?' checklist. An overlay highlights this as one of many helpful pages, listing items like zip ties and stain remover.
book recs for future brides!!!! 📚💐👰‍♀
hey friends! i get married in three months, and i wanted to share the more (and less) helpful books i've read about the subject. i only have 5 still checked out from the library, so i'll just share about those! (Also, HUGE typo on that cover photo. I'm ranking them on 1-5 stars, n
Grace Anne

Grace Anne

58 likes

Rating: 5/5
Book Review Book name: One by One Author: Freida McFadden Genre: Fiction, suspense, thriller My rating: 5/5 My review: This book was an easy read. I love how I’m always wrong on what I think will happen. The ending definitely had my jaw dropping. If you haven’t read it yet, please add this
Katie

Katie

84 likes

rating tampons for vaginal health
Tampons play a role into vaginal health due to the ingredients. Tampons are in contact with your vaginal skin for hours. Your vaginal wall has direct contact to your blood stream so whatever chemical pesticides, plastics or other ingredients are in the tampon can easily be transferred to your blood
rachel

rachel

182 likes

A white bookshelf filled with various books, with pink text overlays reading "Rating my top 10 Books." A small decorated Christmas tree stands to the right.
The book cover for "Love on the Brain" by Ali Hazelwood, featuring an illustrated couple. Overlaid text describes it as a cute enemies-to-lovers story, rated #10.
The book cover for "The Cellar" by Natasha Preston, showing stairs with a pink flower. Overlaid text describes it as a good thriller/horror story with a good ending, rated #9.
Rating my top 10 books
My favorite books I’ve read! Book Review #books 🫶🏼 #favoriteread #lemon8bookclub #booklover
June

June

648 likes

Rating McFadden 📚
#bookwormsoflemon8 #lemon8challenge -the last book is my favorite McFadden book! -need to read The Crash next. -cannot wait for the movie of the Housemaid!
𝚂𝚊𝚖𝚊𝚗𝚝𝚑𝚊🍒

𝚂𝚊𝚖𝚊𝚗𝚝𝚑𝚊🍒

289 likes

Rating my recent book 📖
#recentbook #reading📚 #newbookreview #bookrec #bookreccomendation
Amanda 💋

Amanda 💋

19 likes

Rating twisted series honestly
Book review💜💜 king of sins series nexttt #twisted lies #twisted love #twistedhate #twisted games #twistedseries
Luv.Jen

Luv.Jen

472 likes

A white book titled "A Love Letter to Whiskey" by Kandi Steiner, 5th Anniversary Edition, rests on a dark textured blanket. Overlay text reads "MY HONEST BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 4.5⭐️", indicating a book review.
Rating A Love Letter to Whiskey 🥃 ⭐️
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️ A Love Letter to Whiskey follows B Kennedy and Jamie over the span of a decade. They meet in high school where Jamie dates B’s best friend. Despite their relationship, B and Jamie build a best friend bond theirselves. As the years go by there are times when fate brings them togeth
BookishWitLani ✨

BookishWitLani ✨

535 likes

Two dark romance books, 'Once You're Mine' and 'Now You're Mine' by Morgan Bridges, are displayed with intricate butterfly and skull designs on their covers. The image is captioned 'BOOK RATING !!'.
The book 'Possessing Her Book 1: Once You're Mine' by Morgan Bridges is shown. Text overlays indicate a rating of '8/10 -story' and '7/10- spicy scenes' for the dark romance novel.
The book 'Possessing Her Book 2: Now You're Mine' by Morgan Bridges is featured. Text overlays provide ratings of '9/10 -story' and '9/10- spicy scenes' for this dark romance book.
rating once you’re mine series !!
this book series was actually really interesting for me! I loved the mmc hayden. there were a few scenes in this book that made me mad tho but not enough to make me want to stop reading it🤭🤭!! #darkromance #darkromancereads🖤🖤🖤 #booktok
𖣠𝚓𝚓 ݈݇⎼ ݈݇⎼

𖣠𝚓𝚓 ݈݇⎼ ݈݇⎼

109 likes

A Kindle e-reader displaying "Captivated by Danger" rests on a textured blanket next to a tablet. The tablet shows a detailed book review for "Captivated by Danger," including star ratings, spice level, favorite moments, a soundtrack suggestion, and a written review mentioning characters Diesel and Greysen.
Book Review ✨ Captivated By Danger
📖 Name of the Book: Captivated by Danger 📄 Plot: Diesel Danger is a man who is described as having a ‘god complex’ by those close to him. He’s used to getting what he wants from women, when and how he wants it, with no pushback— until he runs into Greysen McCree. 📖 Genre: Romance ⭐ Star Rating
SheCozy&Lit

SheCozy&Lit

37 likes

Finished book rating!
📚: BETTER THAN THE MOVIES 📖: LYNN PAINTER RATING?: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ DESC. In this rom-com about rom-coms, in the spirit of Kasie West and Jenn Bennett, a hopeless romantic teen attempts to secure a happily-ever-after moment with her forever crush, but finds herself reluctantly drawn to the boy next
sky🫶🏼

sky🫶🏼

10 likes

A book review for 'Darling Girls' by Sally Hepworth, rated 5/5, is displayed against a sunset landscape. The review highlights a twist at the end, mystery genre, and short chapters, with the book cover featuring a swimming pool and house.
Book Rating: 5/5
Lovedddd the short chapters of this one and all the POV with flashbacks! Def check TW on this one but it kept me engaged. At first I thought it was predictable and then the twist at the end I was like yaaaaaaaaaaas. I’ll def be reading another one from Sally Hepworth! #BookReview #thrillerbooks
MorganNicola

MorganNicola

19 likes

Book Rating
I give this read 5/5 ⭐️ Highly recommend! 💯 #book #bookratings #bookreccomendation #butcherandblackbird #brynneweaver
pagesandlatteswithsarah

pagesandlatteswithsarah

6 likes

rating books I’ve read this week
I guess you can say I love a good thriller 🔪 #thrillerbookrecommendations #thrillerreaderreview #thrillerbooksaddict #booktok
Sammy 💕

Sammy 💕

96 likes

Books ive read and my rating of them ⭐️
#reading📖 #books 🫶🏼 #read📚 #reading📚 #fallloobook #readreadread #loves to read 📚 #a book 😭 #musthavesthisfall #Lemon8Diary
avery ☆

avery ☆

43 likes

The image introduces a rating of the ACOTAR series by each book, featuring the cover of "A Court of Thorns and Roses" by Sarah J. Maas.
The image displays "A Court of Thorns and Roses" by Sarah J. Maas, rated 8/10, with a review mentioning being hooked but disliking Tamlin's actions.
The image features "A Court of Mist and Fury" by Sarah J. Maas, rated 7/10, highlighting a slow start but praising the romance between Rhysand and Feyre.
rating the ACOTAR series by each book
TOG is next… #acotar #books #fyp
a.steidl

a.steidl

154 likes

Book Rating
A little rating on an audiobook I listened to and absolutely loved! Very much recommended #booktok #bookratings #darkromance #darkromancebooks #maskedmen
elle.3x3

elle.3x3

3 likes

A black spiral-bound sketchbook with various stickers on its cover, including a raccoon, a fantasy scene, and a bat. Overlay text reads 'Rating pages in my current sketch book!'.
A detailed black and white sketch of a female character with long, wavy hair, wearing a dress and platform shoes. A smaller head sketch is in the upper right. Text rates it '9/10'.
A pencil sketch of a person in a flowing dress, with arms raised, possibly dancing. The drawing is rated '8/10' with additional text about needing work.
Rating pages in my current sketch book!
There’s obviously more but I just picked a couple. I’m thinking of doing a colored version of the first one. I might add more to the second one. Idk this was fun #sketchbook #art #drawing #Lemon8Diary
Shroollie

Shroollie

36 likes

A book review graphic featuring a dark-skinned man in a suit, with text 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and the title 'PROMISED TO A Street King' by Tatum James. It displays a 5/5 rating with a star and a spice level indicated by three chili peppers.
Book rating: 5⭐️ spice: 3🌶️
This book is the third book in the Dark Reign series. Lovely enemies to lovers book. A lot of drama and some spice. Bishop maybe my new book boyfriend. Love me a thick chocolate man. Bishop and Lourdes kept the drama going. It’s a good read for some spice and to get you out of a little reading slum
Sunnishyne 🌻

Sunnishyne 🌻

14 likes

Rating Every Book in the ACOTAR Series 🤌 Pt. 1
#booksummary #lemon8challenge Book Rating 📚 One of my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE series! I finished it a few weeks ago and decided I’d rate each book for this lemon8 challenge. Comment/Follow if you read this book or if you’d like to see a part two 💕 #reading #books #acotar #series
Nailah ੈ✩‧₊˚

Nailah ੈ✩‧₊˚

21 likes

Rating Booktok Books
Some of these are worth it, some of them are not. All of the books listed are pretty quick read aside from credence. Have any of you read these books, what were your thoughts? #booktok #books #BookReview #bookwormsoflemon8
Jade

Jade

11 likes

Rating books i’ve read this week pt.1
#books 🫶🏼 #recentbook #recentread #augustreadreview ⭐️Overall rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️ 3.5/5: The Seven Year Slip This book was super cute and fun, I just wish there was more to it. But, if you love a YA book that feels very warm, this is it. ⭐️ 1/5: The Priest This one just wasnt it fo
shay🪐🎧 📚🌷

shay🪐🎧 📚🌷

106 likes

My Book Rating System!
I feel like everyone rates their books a little differently so here’s what my star ratings look like and what it means for me! ⭐️ = I should have DNF’d. ⭐️⭐️ = It was fine, odds are it would have been DNF’d if there wasn’t some solid enough spice. ⭐️⭐️⭐️ = I liked it. Probably sits in the m
Aurora Kretsch

Aurora Kretsch

27 likes

A flat lay displays six B.pure Hydrating Hand Sanitizers from Dollar Tree in various scents, including Watermelon, Cucumber Mint, Salted Caramel, Caramel Apple, Frosted Coconut, and Vanilla Sugar Cookie. The image indicates a scent rating on a 1-10 scale.
RATING MY DOLLAR TREE HAND SANITIZERS 🔥
My favorite is Watermelon 🍉 and my least favorite is Frosted vanilla cookie 😕 Which one is your favorite? Let me know in the comments! Please like, share, and interact with me for more budget friendly finds 🥰 #dollartreefindgoals #dollartreegoals #shoppingatdollartree #itsteddi
Teddi Marie

Teddi Marie

403 likes

See more