Just finished reading

This was one of my most anticipated reads and it really let me down. This book felt bloated to me, easily could have been 200+ pages shorter. The number of typos, basic grammar mistakes, and a misspelling of a real personโ€™s name grated on me after a while.

I also donโ€™t read many books by men bc I find their depictions of female characters empty. This was no exception. Every girl/woman in the same age group as the main character was inexplicably โ€œhopelessly devotedโ€ to him. There was one female character who was literally described as perfect constantly. It was exhausting.

The story went on for so long it seemed to lose itself along the way. Timelines stopped making sense, characters were described in inconsistent ways that struck me as mistakes as opposed to natural human variations.

I kept reading simply because I wanted to know what happened with 2 specific characters. I wish I hadnโ€™t bothered, honestly.

2024/12/16 Edited to

... Read moreAs a passionate reader, I know the thrill of picking up a highly anticipated new release, especially from an author like Chris Whitaker. When I finally delved into 'The Colors of the Dark,' I was hoping for an immersive experience, but sometimes, even the most promising stories can fall short. My original review touched on several points of disappointment, and I wanted to expand a bit on why these aspects can truly impact a reader's journey. First, let's talk about pacing and length. When a book feels 'bloated,' it's not just about the page count; it's about whether every chapter, every scene, every paragraph truly serves the narrative. A well-paced novel keeps you hooked, driving the story forward. If parts feel redundant or descriptions meander without purpose, it can make even the most intriguing plot feel like a chore to get through. For 'The Colors of the Dark,' I found myself longing for a tighter edit that would have sharpened the narrative focus and kept the momentum going. Then there's the crucial element of editing. As a reader, encountering numerous typos, basic grammatical errors, or even misspellings of names can be incredibly jarring. It pulls you right out of the story, reminding you that you're reading a book, rather than living within its pages. These details, though seemingly small, can accumulate and seriously diminish the overall quality and professionalism of a published work, impacting the credibility of the narrative itself. It makes you wonder about the care taken in its production, which is a shame, especially for a book that likely had a lot of effort put into its creation. Another significant point for me, and something many readers resonate with, is character development. When female characters are consistently depicted as one-dimensional or solely existing in relation to a male protagonist, it often signals a missed opportunity for richer storytelling. In 'The Colors of the Dark,' the portrayal felt disappointingly shallow, with women often described in idealized, almost unbelievable terms or as inexplicably devoted to the main character. Authentic, complex female voices are vital in literature, reflecting the diverse experiences of women in the real world. When they're absent, it can leave a substantial void for many readers who seek relatable and nuanced characters. Finally, narrative consistency is the backbone of any compelling story. When timelines become muddled, or characters behave in ways that contradict their established personalities without clear narrative reason, it can shatter the reader's trust in the author's vision. A story needs an internal logic, even in fantasy or speculative fiction. Inconsistent character arcs or plot holes can make it difficult to suspend disbelief, leaving you feeling confused rather than captivated. While my experience with 'The Colors of the Dark' was largely disappointing, I always encourage fellow book lovers to consider various perspectives. If you're someone who prioritizes plot over character depth, or can overlook minor editorial issues for a unique premise, your mileage might vary. Every book finds its audience, and perhaps some will find elements to appreciate that I couldn't. However, for those who value tight editing, consistent storytelling, and well-rounded character portrayals, especially for female roles, it might be worth proceeding with caution or looking for other titles by Chris Whitaker that might align more with your reading preferences.

Related posts

Just finished reading
Iโ€™ve been procrastinating reading the Jah book. I decided to read something else instead ๐Ÿคญ Iโ€™ll have to give this one 5.5 out of 10. At least I understand the characters from another series of hers that I read now! #book #blackauthors #reading #kindle
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

9 likes

๐Ÿ“– just finished reading
โญ๏ธ Rating: 5/5 i could not put this book down!! ๐Ÿ˜ณ a real - who done it - until the very last chapter ๐Ÿคฏ i checked this out at my local library ๐Ÿ’š Woodstock Library #bookrecommendations #booktok #library #reading #book recommendations
๐‘›๐‘Ž๐‘ก๐‘Ž๐‘™๐‘–๐‘’ ๐Ÿงธเพ€เฝฒ

๐‘›๐‘Ž๐‘ก๐‘Ž๐‘™๐‘–๐‘’ ๐Ÿงธเพ€เฝฒ

2 likes

A stack of five dark-covered books by H.D. Carlton, featuring titles like "Satan's Affair," "Haunting Adeline," "Hunting Adeline," "Where's Molly," and "Phantom." The image is titled "Adeline COLLECTION" and "The Order To Read Them."
The Adeline Reading Order
Okay, Iโ€™ll admit itโ€ฆ I read these out of order! 1. Haunting Adeline 2. Hunting Adeline 3. Whereโ€™s Molly 4. Satanโ€™s Affair (Currently Reading) 5. Phantom (TBR) Hereโ€™s why I am okay with itโ€ฆ First reason being I didnโ€™t have Satanโ€™s Affair or Phantom in the beginning. In Haunting Adeline,
Caroline ๐Ÿ“š๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ“š

Caroline ๐Ÿ“š๐Ÿ–ค๐Ÿ“š

2011 likes

An open Bible with handwritten notes and sticky notes, overlaid with the text "HOW TO START READING THE BIBLE for beginners," indicating a guide for new readers.
An open Bible with notes and an iPad displaying prayer notes, overlaid with the text "START WITH THE GOSPELS" and listing "MATTHEW MARK LUKE JOHN."
A close-up of an open Bible page with highlighted text, overlaid with the text "PAIR PSALMS & PROVERBS TO LEARN THE HEART AND WISDOM OF GOD."
How to Begin Reading Your Bible: A Simple Guide
Starting your Bible-reading journey can feel overwhelming, but it doesnโ€™t have to be! Hereโ€™s a step-by-step guide to help you dive into Scripture and truly connect with Godโ€™s Word: ๐Ÿ’› Start with the Gospels (John First!) The Gospels are all about the life, teachings, death, and resurrection of
ModistyAmethyst

ModistyAmethyst

8643 likes

Just finished reading:
Mel did it again. I think this book was really good, the FMC was a nerdy little goer. She could hold her own but wasnt with all the drama. Loโ€™ak was a lover boy but in the streets NOT for the streets though. I also loved how Mel brought up Jahquel, just like Jah mentioned Mel in Don. Found that to
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

26 likes

A hand holds the book 'Beautiful Little Fools' by Jillian Cantor, featuring a 1920s-style woman on the cover. A grey cat is visible in the background, with the text 'just finished reading' overlaid.
๐Ÿ“– just finished reading
๐Ÿธ My oldest daughter & I watched The Great Gatsby recently & it made me want to read something similar. After doing some research (& seeing what my library had available right then) I picked this book. ๐Ÿธ Absolutely decadent!! If youโ€™ve ever wondered what might be going on in the wom
๐‘›๐‘Ž๐‘ก๐‘Ž๐‘™๐‘–๐‘’ ๐Ÿงธเพ€เฝฒ

๐‘›๐‘Ž๐‘ก๐‘Ž๐‘™๐‘–๐‘’ ๐Ÿงธเพ€เฝฒ

3 likes

Just finished reading
I just finished reading as good as dead. Now i want to read a romance so tell me which one out of these should i read next. The book that has the most comments will be my next book.
Meagan Young

Meagan Young

2 likes

A hand holds the book 'Fairest: The Lunar Chronicles, Levana's Story' by Marissa Meyer, featuring a red cover with illustrations of two women. A cross-stitched bookmark with 'Karley' is tucked into the book. The text 'BOOK REVIEW' is overlaid on the image, along with 'Lemon8 @iampapakarl'.
Just finished reading Fairest.
Ahhhh she just wanted to be LOVED ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ But she evil evil. This book made me genuinely wonder how Cinder ended up being so good despite her evil family lineage. Queen Channary was an absolute jerk too ๐Ÿคฃ a good and quick read. Adds a lot of context to Levana. #cinderlunarchronicles #fairest
Karl

Karl

8 likes

Just finished reading!๐Ÿซถ๐Ÿผ
This was book 3 of 2025 for me! I listened to this one and it was soo interesting to hear about the shows that I grew up watching! Have you read this one??๐Ÿค #whatimreading #2025books #reading๐Ÿ“– #booklemon8 #bookrecommendations
kaycee | SAHM + travel agentโœจ

kaycee | SAHM + travel agentโœจ

6 likes

A book titled "The Lies That Bind" by Emily Giffin, with a pink and white cover featuring a cityscape silhouette, is displayed on a plaid blanket. A "BOOK REVIEW" overlay is at the top. A Lemon8 BookClub ticket provides a 3-star rating and notes: "Slow start, quick burning romance. The ending surprised me."
just finished readingโ€ฆ
I wasnโ€™t sure what to expect when I read this book, being born and raised in #newyork , having an uncle who has retired from FDNY post 9/11 and witnessed the second tower fall- itโ€™s always hard to get into books about 9/11. Overall, I would recommend this to someone for a quick in-between read! #
Gabryela

Gabryela

3 likes

JUST FINISHED & CURRENT READ ๐Ÿ“–
Hello from vacation up in upstate New York! ๐Ÿ‘‹๐Ÿผ ๐ŸŒฒ ๐Ÿฅพ I just finished Malibu Rising by Taylor Jenkins Reid. Excited to started This Summer Will Be Different by Carley Fortune. Do you read on vacation? #currentlyreading #currentread #lemon8bookclub #lemon8books #lemon8review #books #bo
amanda โœจ ๐Ÿ“– ๐Ÿญ ๐Ÿ’…๐Ÿผ

amanda โœจ ๐Ÿ“– ๐Ÿญ ๐Ÿ’…๐Ÿผ

21 likes

A hand holds a Kindle e-reader outdoors, displaying the cover of 'A Bargain With The Fae King' by Megan Van Dyke. Overlays read 'Currently Reading' and 'Worth the Hype', with a Lemon8 watermark.
A Kindle e-reader displays a page of text from a book, with a sentence highlighted about wanting someone to hold a hand. The screen shows options 'Back to page 350' and 'Stay here', resting on a patterned blanket.
A Kindle e-reader displays a page of text from a book, with a sentence highlighted about a magical vow made for the character's benefit. The screen shows '1 min left in book' and '96%', resting on a patterned blanket.
Just finished reading
#booksummary #lemon8challenge Just finished this last night! My Current Read ๐Ÿ“– Name of the Book: A Bargain With The Fae King ๐Ÿ“„ Plot: must save her sister from the enemy ๐Ÿ“– Genre: fantasy ๐Ÿ’ญ My Thoughts: I really enjoyed it, I felt like the main character was a little whiny but overal
lauren partlow

lauren partlow

6 likes

Just finished reading
WOW JUST WOW! I took a bit longer to read this because life and other books but I canโ€™t stop thinking it all over. My jaw dropped SO MANY times. MFC has DID?! Multiple POVs, mystery and thrills happen inside and outside of the mind?! I knew I was in for a thriller but I didnโ€™t realize just how e
mamawavyreads

mamawavyreads

38 likes

The colorful cover of the fantasy novel "This Princess Kills Monsters" by Ry Herman, featuring a castle, dragons, and a bridge over water. A hand holds the book, which is the subject of the review.
Just Finished Reading ๐Ÿ“š
At exactly 5:31pm on August 8, 2025 I finally finished reading This Princess Kills Monsters By, Ry Herman. My 9th book I've read of the year. Without spoiling the entire book the best way I can summarize everything would go likeย  this ... This is a fantasy, romance book mixed with fairytale
KimberlyโœŒ๐Ÿป

KimberlyโœŒ๐Ÿป

8 likes

Just Finished Reading โœ”๏ธ
Just finished reading The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up: The Japanese Art of Decluttering and Organizing by Marie Kondล I was sooo excited to read this one because Iโ€™m a chronic tidying up person. I feel like it fell short for me. I love how she is a firm believer in her ways, I just donโ€™t see
Boo

Boo

1 like

Just finished reading
The series was pretty good. I would recommend it, BUT FOR ME PERSONALLY? It wasnโ€™t all that, thatโ€™s my opinion and canโ€™t nobody tell me otherwise. I mean the flashbacks, the over explanations, the repeated comments & quotes. It was like โ€œdid I already read this chapterโ€ moments for me because o
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

10 likes

Just finished reading
Another great read ! Creed gets what Creed wants. Never taking no for an answer, cocky big olโ€™ intense self. #bookrecommendations #blackauthors #read #kindle #tbrlist
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

28 likes

just finished readingโ€ฆ
WILD EYES by Elsie Silver *banter & spice *friends to lovers *single dad *slow burn like the plot the spice was a little silly to me it just felt a little awkward at times #elsie silver #wild eyes #romancebooks #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookworm
hhgruver

hhgruver

1 like

JUST FINISHED READING
This one was better than the first book! Dare I say, as much as I loved Creed(I love Riot more)! This book was so juicy so many twist and turns. Havoc really pissed me off so did that cousin! Oh and the random 6โ€™5 brother at the end ?! I just know hes about to be added to the book zaddddy lis
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

10 likes

Just finished reading
LOVED this book, cannot wait for book 3. I am obsessed with the entire plot it keeps getting better and Iโ€™ve yet to predict anything correctly. The twist and turns of it all kept me on the edge of my seat. Beautifully written, I really recommend this book for anyone who has read it yet! Book one ha
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

9 likes

Just finished reading
Stolen Love- by Aubry J 10/10 read. The twist and turns of it all omgosh ๐Ÿ™ƒ. Amethyst ?! Lord. Krude was hilarious per usual, I had to put the book down so many times to calm myself down. I just need someone to talk about this book with ๐Ÿ˜ญ the cliffhanger?! I need the next book ASAP ! #justfinish
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

15 likes

The cover of the book 'Wildfire: A Maple Hills Novel' by Hannah Grace, featuring an illustration of a man and a woman in a summer camp setting, with trees and a campfire in the background.
An open book page displaying a dedication that reads: 'For younger me, who wanted to be his first choice.'
An open book page titled 'Playlist,' listing various song titles and artists, including 'Sparks Fly (Taylor's Version)' by Taylor Swift and 'Wildfire' by Seafret.
Finished Reading ๐Ÿ“šโš ๏ธ Spoiler Alert
At exactly 12:48pm on September 8, 2025 I finished reading Wildfire By, Hannah Grace. The second book out of 3 books in the Maple Hills series. My 13th book I've read of the year. Without spoiling the entire book the best way to summarize everything would go like this ... -Romance book
KimberlyโœŒ๐Ÿป

KimberlyโœŒ๐Ÿป

8 likes

The book cover for 'The Vanishing of Class 3B' by Jackie Kabler, featuring a yellow school bus driving away on a road under a green sky. An overlay reads 'Just finished' with three golden stars, and 'USA TODAY BESTSELLER' is visible at the bottom.
Just finished Reading
This was the pick for book club for February. This book started out so good, it pulled me in right away, I thought it was going to be great! Then the middle of the book was long and drawn out and the ending was disappointing. Iโ€™m so glad itโ€™s over. 3/5 Stars #lemon8bookclub #lemon8challenge
Angie

Angie

5 likes

Just finished reading
The tears Iโ€™ve cried .. the amount of times I had to stop reading because WTH ?! Omgosh. #justfinishedreading #abook๐Ÿ˜ญ #kindlepaperwhite #blackauthors
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

16 likes

A book review graphic featuring the cover of 'The Midnight Feast' by Lucy Foley, showing glowing lanterns. It displays 'Finished Reading' at the top and four out of five stars, indicating a rating. Lemon8 branding is visible at the bottom.
Finished Reading!
4/5 Such a good read. I actually finished it in one night because I had to know what was going to happen. Told from different perspectives that make it such a fast pace. #justfinishedreading #recentread #revengestory
Sydney Hampton

Sydney Hampton

7 likes

An open Bible displays pages 1736-1737 with highlighted text from Ephesians 4. An overlay prominently features the verse 'BE COMPLETELY HUMBLE AND GENTLE, BE PATIENT, BEARING WITH ONE ANOTHER IN LOVE' from Ephesians 4:2 (NIV), with a Lemon8 user handle.
Just finished reading Ephesians 4 ๐Ÿค
Whewโ€ฆ this chapter got me together in the best way. Itโ€™s all about unity, growth, and letting go of the old version of yourself so you can walk like someone who truly knows God. The verse that really stuck with me was: โ€œBe completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in lo
Bloom Babe ๐ŸŒผ

Bloom Babe ๐ŸŒผ

4 likes

A hand holds a Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of the book 'Obsessive Love' by National Bestselling Author Aubry J., subtitled 'Fable & Pyrite's story'. The cover features a black and white cityscape reflected in water, with 'JUST FINISHED READING' overlaid at the top.
Just finished reading
First of all ?! This book was so good and hilarious! I loved seeing things from their POV ! Especially when they all jumped that lady, and Mary whooped on that raggedy mama a little more. & all the moms had on ski masks ๐Ÿ˜‚. Pyrite is so unhinged literally Fable didnโ€™t stand a chance ! Im ready t
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

9 likes

just finished & currently reading ๐Ÿ“–
Onto book 3 of the throne of glass series ๐Ÿคฉ so exciting!! The series definitely picked up for me with Crown of Midnight โ€” itโ€™s my fave so far. Do you have a fave book? #throneofglass #throneofglassseries #fantasybooks #books #booksoflemon8 #lemon8bookclub #lemon8bookchalleng
amanda โœจ ๐Ÿ“– ๐Ÿญ ๐Ÿ’…๐Ÿผ

amanda โœจ ๐Ÿ“– ๐Ÿญ ๐Ÿ’…๐Ÿผ

23 likes

Just finished reading and current read
Been slacking a little bit but here are my just finished reading and my current read! Whereโ€™s Molly - took me a little bit to finish but Iโ€™m glad I did! This is apart of H.D. Carltonโ€™s cat and mouse series and it comes after hunting Adeline and I think it wouldโ€™ve helped if I read it in the righ
Kassidie Freeman

Kassidie Freeman

11 likes

A digital reading journal displayed on a tablet, showing a 'MY LIBRARY' page with various book covers, titles, authors, and star ratings. The image has a text overlay 'UPDATE MY READING JOURNAL With me'.
A tablet screen displaying an empty digital reading journal library page with placeholders for book covers, titles, authors, and star ratings. A text overlay says 'Let's click on an empty Entry in the library'.
A tablet screen showing a blank 'BOOK REVIEW' template in a digital reading journal, with fields for title, author, genre, format, dates, summary, review, and quotes. A text overlay instructs to 'fill everything in'.
โœจUpdate My Reading journal with me โœจ
Hey yโ€™all! This is my digital reading journal, and I usually update almost every book I read on here, especially if I enjoyed it. It has 120 log entries plus series tracker. I also complete the challenges which Iโ€™ll post later at some point. Anyways, I just finished reading the Teacher by Freddieโ€™
Byaombe โ€ขโ€ขโ€ข

Byaombe โ€ขโ€ขโ€ข

547 likes

A hand with a red fingernail holds an e-reader displaying the cover of 'Secure In The Arms Of A Thug 2' by Tatum James, presented by B. Love. The cover features a man's face. Overlay text says 'Just finished reading'.
Just finished reading
Okay Tatum ! Book 2 was just as good as the first one. 5 โญ๏ธ #read #kindle #blackauthors #a book ๐Ÿ˜ญ #bookseriesrecs
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

15 likes

Just Finished Reading ๐Ÿ“š
At exactly 4:59pm on July 19, 2025 I finished reading A Million Junes By, Emily Henry. My 7th book I've read of the year. Without spoiling the entire book the best way to describe it would be a tale like Romeo & Juliet, Fantasy, Magical, mysterious. It was very really written. I would d
KimberlyโœŒ๐Ÿป

KimberlyโœŒ๐Ÿป

3 likes

Just Finished Reading..
Book Review Book name: Deep End Author: Ali Hazelwood Genre: Contemporary Romance My rating: 4/5 Spice Level: 4/5
BSweeney403

BSweeney403

5 likes

An e-reader displays the cover of 'Where Love Blooms: A Jareau Family Novel' by Kimberly Brown, featuring a couple embracing. A red heart keychain is visible next to the e-reader, which rests on a textured surface. The text 'Just finished reading' is overlaid on the image.
Just finished reading
Where love blooms was such a beautiful story. Jamison Jareau , the older levelheaded brother. The single father/ widow. The doctor whoโ€™s closed off to love. Aleviyah the patient loving nanny, whose heaven sent aura restores the love and joy back into this family. Definitely a must read in my opinio
Cami Jay

Cami Jay

6 likes

Just Finished Reading
Plus Size Player by Danielle Allen. Is the best book Iโ€™ve read so far this summer. Nina was known for having a roster until Russell Long came along. Loved the representation in book. Russell has officially been add to the book husband list. He stepped down as CEO for his women. Go read this book. I
Duasianรจ

Duasianรจ

30 likes

Just finished reading...
โ€œFools rush in where angels fear to tread." "What shapes us is not always our achievements but our omissions. Not lies; simply the truths we donโ€™t tell." "For who are we if not the sum of our experiences, the things that we gather and collect in life? Once you strip those away
Beth Ford

Beth Ford

3 likes

See more