Sourdough Day 4!

Not going to lie. Felt slightly discouraged today.

Have not seen any rising since the other day and it just gets soupy within a couple hours even with extra flour. Tomorrow I am switching to a new container and going to try weighing my ratios rather than by eye balling it.

#sourdoughday4 #sourdoughstarterfeeding #sourdoughforbeginners

2025/11/19 Edited to

... Read moreIt's common for new sourdough starters to face challenges around day 4, especially when the mixture becomes soupy and shows little rising activity. This typically happens due to an imbalance in the flour-to-water ratio or insufficient microbial activity. Using all-purpose flour, as noted from your 'Sourdough Vay 4' image, is a fine choice for creating a starter, but precise measurements are crucial. Weighing your ingredients rather than eyeballing them can help maintain consistency. Typically, a 1:1:1 ratio by weight of starter, flour, and water is advised to encourage fermentation. Changing containers can also have a positive effect. Switching to a clean, slightly larger container allows your starter more room to expand and reduces contamination risk. Remember, hydration levels affect texture. A soupy starter often indicates too much water relative to flour. Adjusting your flour amount can create a thicker mixture that holds bubbles and rises better. Patience is key when cultivating a sourdough starter. Environmental factors like temperature and flour brand also play roles in starter activity. Keeping your starter in a warm spot (around 75°F or 24°C) can boost yeast and bacterial growth. If you continue to experience issues, consider feeding your starter with diverse flours like whole wheat or rye, which contain more naturally occurring yeast and bacteria. They can jumpstart fermentation. Keep tracking your progress daily with notes or photos. Each starter behaves uniquely, and consistency in your feeding routine will lead to better results. Hang in there—successful sourdough baking begins with a healthy, active starter!

Related posts

Easy No Knead Sourdough Sandwich Loaf đŸĨĒ
Easy No Knead Sourdough Sandwich Loaf This is such an easy sourdough bread recipe that is great for beginners or if you want something more hands off! 👩đŸģâ€đŸŗINGREDIENTS: 65g active sourdough starter (my sourdough starter is available for purchase on Etsy if interested) 300g warm water 40g ho
Katie 👩đŸģâ€đŸŗ

Katie 👩đŸģâ€đŸŗ

1085 likes

A mason jar containing a light brown sourdough starter, with text overlays indicating it's a sourdough starter recipe and to swipe for ingredients.
Ingredients and tools for making sourdough starter, including bags of whole wheat and unbleached all-purpose flour, a mason jar, a red silicone spatula, and measuring cups.
A close-up view inside a jar showing the thick, pancake batter-like consistency of the sourdough starter being stirred with a red silicone spatula.
sourdough starter recipe 🍞đŸĨ¯
I’ve seen a lot of debate about whether or not sourdough starter is easy to make or maintain. personally, I find it to be extremely easy to make and maintain. although, I’m not a mom. I’m a student and owner of many pets - just wanted to pick up a hobby! I based my recipe off of The Clever Ca
mariangeli 🔮

mariangeli 🔮

1119 likes

Sourdough Starter 101!
Feeling intimated by your starter? Do not overthink it! If you feel like things aren’t going how you expect it I promise you, restarting is not worth it! My starter took almost a full month to establish due to environmental factors and climate. Have any other questions? Let’s chat! #My2024 #L
Starting Out Scrunchy

Starting Out Scrunchy

205 likes

Day 4 - sourdough starter from scratch
Repeating the same as day 3. Discard half 1/4 bread flour 1/4 water #sourdoughbeginner #sourdoughjourney #sourdoughstarter #sourdoughlife #sourdough
Jeni đŸŒģ

Jeni đŸŒģ

10 likes

A top-down view of a hand holding a glass jar containing a bubbly sourdough starter, with text overlay indicating "Sourdough starter Day 4".
A hand pouring thick sourdough starter from a glass jar into a copper measuring cup, with text overlay "discard 1 cup" indicating the process.
A hand discarding one cup of sourdough starter by pouring it from a copper measuring cup into an open trash can.
Day 4 sourdough starter
Don't forget to throw out a cup and feed it again. #sourdoughjourney #sourdoughlife #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughstarter #stepbystep
Momma Trick

Momma Trick

8 likes

Let’s talk sourdough starter!!
⭐Recipe on my website! Link in bio! 👋 This is Zora my sourdough starter. I named her after Aunt Zora from my favorite TV show Frasier. She's about 1 year old. Zora loves being on a schedule. She's fed twice a day with a 12 hour window between feedings. I feed Zora at 8am and 8pm ever
Dawn Belle 🩷

Dawn Belle 🩷

2382 likes

A bag of unbleached bread flour and a glass jar containing sourdough starter are on a kitchen counter. The image is captioned "let's Feed my sourdough starter," indicating the start of the feeding process for day 4.
A close-up view inside a glass jar shows a bubbly, active sourdough starter. The caption "look at those bubbles!!!" highlights the fermentation activity of the starter.
A hand holds a 1/2 cup measuring spoon filled with white bread flour. A bag of flour is visible in the background, illustrating "STEP 1 ADD 1/2C BREAD FLOUR" for feeding the starter.
let’s feed my sourdough starter day 4
Feeding my sourdough starter day 4! This was the biggest feed yet! If you want to see the other days, let me know and I can post the steps for that, next! So excited to bake!!! đŸĢ™đŸžâœ¨ #sourdoughbread #food #baking #sourdoughstarter #stepbystep
Hannah Crump

Hannah Crump

32 likes

Lets make a sourdough starter!
In a mason jar, add 1/3 cup of flour. Mix in room temperature filtered water until pancake batter consistency. Scrape the sides to the best of your ability. Cover with a paper towel. Come back for day two to learn how to feed your starter. Don't forget a name! What should we name her?
AshlynBrowning

AshlynBrowning

592 likes

A glass jar filled with an active, bubbly sourdough starter, with some overflowing from the top.
Ingredients for sourdough starter, including a bowl of flour, a measuring cup with water, and a spatula.
Two images showing the Day 1 process: a mixture of flour and water, and a bowl covered with a breathable cloth.
sourdough starter 🤍
#sourdoughideas #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughjourney #sourdoughseason #sourdoughbeginner
Winona Wickham

Winona Wickham

566 likes

Sourdough Starter Recipe
Starting a starter dough recipe the easy way! day one from scratch! The easy way no scale needed!! Ingredients Clean/filtered water unbleached flour Using a 1:1 ratio Add flour and water to a jar (not plastic) I used 1/4 cup Mixture should look like thick pancake batter Cover wit
MaMaShay

MaMaShay

277 likes

How to make a sourdough starter
Okay! Making a sourdough starter is not hard, but requires patience. Your starter will NOT be ready for 7-10 days. Do not bake bread with it before then, it will not work (speaking from experience). Materials and Ingredients: 1. Two Glass Mason Jars 2. All purpose flour 3. Filtered Water (Yes
Mikala Ryan

Mikala Ryan

618 likes

A guide titled 'Sourdough: for beginners' outlines a 6-day process for creating a sourdough starter, including daily feeding instructions and ingredient quantities. It features an illustration of a baked sourdough loaf and lists necessary ingredients like a glass jar, filtered water, bread flour, a small rubber spatula, and measuring cups.
Sourdough starter : for beginners
TIP #1 : For your first measurement, weigh the flour using a kitchen scale so you can get an idea of how the mixture should feel. Do not weigh the measuring cup! It should be like a thick paste, like peanut butter. If you need to add a little more water to incorporate the flour, that is OK too!
Brianna Morton

Brianna Morton

1023 likes

Ingredients for a Day 1 sourdough starter are displayed, including a large mason jar, a bag of unbleached all-purpose flour, a 1/2 cup of flour, and a 1/4 cup measuring cup for warm water.
A glass mason jar contains the mixed sourdough starter, with a wooden spoon inside, showing a consistency similar to pancake batter.
The sourdough starter in a mason jar is covered with a paper towel secured by a rubber band, indicating it should be left in a warm room for 24 hours.
Day 1 sourdough
Here we go on the journey of making a sourdough starter. Have you done this before? This is my second time. #sourdough #kitchen #food #bread #homemade
Momma Trick

Momma Trick

105 likes

A baking sheet holds unbaked sourdough breadsticks, seasoned with herbs and salt, ready for baking. The image has a text overlay that reads "SOUR DOUGH breadsticks Recipe" with an arrow, and a Lemon8 watermark.
This image displays the first page of a recipe for Sourdough Discard Breadsticks, detailing total time, prep time, cook time, rise time, cuisine, course, servings, and a comprehensive list of ingredients for both the breadsticks and their topping.
The second page of the Sourdough Discard Breadsticks recipe provides detailed, step-by-step instructions for preparing and baking the breadsticks, including kneading, rising, shaping, and baking times, along with keywords for the recipe.
Sourdough Breasticks
✨ Swipe for recipe! ✨ I switched out the sourdough discard & yeast and used my active sourdough starter! 👍Pros: taste amazing, little ingredients, can add whatever seasonings you’d like, made in the same day 🤔Cons: longer rise time when using active starter compared to yeast & discar
Taylor Smith

Taylor Smith

151 likes

Same day sourdough loaf
Same day sourdough recipe! * added garlic and oregano to mine but if you just want to make a plain loaf skip adding the inclusions during the shaping process* 29 Ingredients -125g active starter -363g filtered water -12g salt -500g bread flour Instructions: 1. Mix water, starter, and salt
oliviadir

oliviadir

43 likes

A glass jar containing a sourdough starter, covered with a patterned cloth and secured, sits on a kitchen counter. The image is titled 'Sourdough Starter' and indicates 'Day 1' of the process, with a lit candle in the background.
Sourdough Starter!
If you’ve considered doing a sourdough starter- let’s do it together! I got a fool proof recipe from a friend of mine, and I can’t wait to start trying new recipes with it.💗 RECIPE: ✨Day 1: Mix 1/2 cup of flour and 1/2 cup of water. You’re gonna want to mix that sucker harder than you’ve ever m
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

541 likes

Soft & Fluffy Sourdough Dinner Rolls
Thanksgiving dinner rolls. Soft, fluffy, decadent and sourdough! Sweet Stiff Starter: 40g sourdough starter 120g bread flour 50g water 20g sugar Dough: 325g bread flour 30g sugar 180g milk 1 large egg 10g salt All of the sweet stiff starter 75g butter, unsalted Instructions:
The Sourdough Lady

The Sourdough Lady

56 likes

Sourdough Starter By Scratch Day 1
1 Cup King Arthur 1 Cup Water (room temp) She doesn't have a name yet. This is also my first time doing this. Let's see what the days ahead bring. All suggestions are welcomed! #sourdoughstarter #sourdough #sourdoughbaking #day1
Jessica

Jessica

79 likes

Sourdough discard rolls
Homemade is best đŸĨ– I love making homemade goodies from my sourdough discard! Today we made so discard rolls! Recipe on last slide 🤭 #homemade #sourdough #breadrecipe #homemadebread #housewife #housewifelife #bakedgoods #Lemon8Diary #dayinmylife #sourdoughdiscard
Taylor Smith

Taylor Smith

12 likes

Sourdough Tortillas
- One of my main goals is to make all bread related products at home this year! - Today I made sourdough tortillas! - These have a corn tortilla texture but have their own yummy, fresh taste! - If you are also in your đŸĢ§ Sourdough Era đŸĢ§ I highly recommend making these! #sourdough #tortilla
Taylor Smith

Taylor Smith

51 likes

How to Make a Sourdough Starter💗
Hi guys! I found this amazing recipe from YouTuber (Farmhouse on Boone) and she shows you exactly what you need to start your sourdough starter! She also explains everything about it very well in her YouTube videos so go check her out! Here’s her sourdough link I thought I’d share with you guys😊.
Kate

Kate

231 likes

A hand holds a freshly baked, round sourdough loaf with decorative scoring and a flour-dusted crust. An overlay reads "SOURDOUGH FOR BEGINNERS" and "SWIPE FOR RECIPE."
A hand holds a large slice of sourdough bread, revealing its airy, open crumb texture. Another baked loaf is partially visible in the background on a kitchen counter.
A whole, round sourdough loaf with a golden-brown crust sits on a wooden cake stand, covered by a clear glass cloche in a kitchen setting.
Sourdough for Beginners đŸĨ–
this is NOT my recipe, I have been unable to find the original creator but it has been posted several times in a sourdough for beginners Facebook group I’m in and I figured I’d give it a shot!! It turned out so good but I will be making some adjustments next time â˜ēī¸ #sourdoughforbeginners #sourd
allison â™Ąī¸Ž

allison â™Ąī¸Ž

446 likes

My Same-Day sourdough bread
Enjoy my recipe! Hope you enjoy 😊 #samedaysourdough #bread #breadrecipe #voiceover #sourdough
Cooking_with_Lena

Cooking_with_Lena

54 likes

Sourdough Day 4!
Not going to lie. Felt slightly discouraged today. Have not seen any rising since the other day and it just gets soupy within a couple hours even with extra flour. Tomorrow I am switching to a new container and going to try weighing my ratios rather than by eye balling it. #sourdoughday4 #sou
𝙰𝚜𝚑𝚕𝚎𝚎 đŸĒŠđŸ¤ 

𝙰𝚜𝚑𝚕𝚎𝚎 đŸĒŠđŸ¤ 

3 likes

Part 2 Of Sourdough starter
On the second day of your sourdough starter it's time to feed. You might see liquid on the top of your starter, that is called hooch. Hooch is a natural byproduct of fermentation. This just means your starter needs to be fed as it has used all of its food source. Repeat the steps on the slide
AshlynBrowning

AshlynBrowning

69 likes

A bag of unbleached all-purpose flour, an empty glass jar, and a measuring scoop on a counter. The image introduces the process of making sourdough starter for days 5 through 7.
A close-up of a bubbly sourdough starter in a glass jar. Text outlines Day 5 instructions: discard, feed with flour and warm water to pancake batter consistency, and leave in a warm place.
A close-up of a bubbly and rising sourdough starter in a glass jar. Text outlines Day 6 instructions: discard, feed with flour and warm water to pancake batter consistency, noting it's 'BUBBLY AND RISING.'
🍞Sourdough Starter: Days 5-7🍞
Making Sourdough Starter: Day5-7 We’re officially bubbling and rising! By day 5, my starter had a tangy aroma and doubled in size tip: consistency is key. Daily feedings and a warm spot kept things active. By day 7, it passed the float test and smelled like fresh bread dreams! You are ready f
Shelby

Shelby

170 likes

Sourdough Day 4!
Today I will be feeding my starter for thr 5th day and I really think we will be able to make something soon! â€ĸ 🤞🤞🤞 â€ĸ #Sourdough #doucetdough #bakewithme #breadmaking
Michelle Doucet

Michelle Doucet

1 like

Chocolate sourdough pancakes!
Available in our Sourdough Breakfast Recipe Bundle — made with our rich Valrhona Chocolate Sourdough Starter! đŸĨžđŸĢ Link in bio to grab yours! â¸ģ Sourdough Chocolate Pancakes Dry Ingredients â€ĸ 2 ÂŊ cups all-purpose flour â€ĸ Âŧ cup cocoa powder â€ĸ ÂŊ cup sugar â€ĸ&
Little Ranch Family🏠đŸĒ´đŸž

Little Ranch Family🏠đŸĒ´đŸž

69 likes

🍞Sourdough Recipe🍞
I have been OBSESSED with baking bread recently. Sourdough was so intimidating and I put off trying to make it for a really long time. I was gifted some sourdough starter and decided to give it a try! I am so happy that I did. I have used many different recipes I have seen posted online. After tria
L A U R A

L A U R A

268 likes

Sourdough starter in just 7 days!
I was skeptical at first but I kept the faith and Doughy Parton is active & our second loaf is proofing now 🤠 Instructions: Day 1: In a glass jar đŸĢ™ mix together 50g whole wheat flour with 50g purified water Day 2: Love her & leave her alone 🤍 Day 3: Discard half of the starter
Shelbi Boyer

Shelbi Boyer

309 likes

Homemade Sourdough Sandwich Bread | Same Day
Same day sourdough?! You betcha! It’s super soft and very simple to make! I’ve listed the ingredients and how to below! Let me know below if you try this! Enjoy! INGREDIENTS â–ĸ 100 g Sourdough Discard unfed sourdough starter â–ĸ 250 g Water â–ĸ 500 g Bread Flour or All Purpose Flour â–ĸ 10 g Salt
Andrea

Andrea

52 likes

Easy, Healthy Sourdough Pizza Crust
Sourdough Pizza Crust 🍕 Sourdough pizza is a game changer! It is so easy, light on your gut, and you just feel so good after eating it! Plus the flavor is just chef’s kiss 😘 â€ŧī¸Be sure to like and save this recipe & follow @cookingkatielady for more easy and healthy recipes 🤗 👩đŸģâ€đŸŗING
Katie 👩đŸģâ€đŸŗ

Katie 👩đŸģâ€đŸŗ

1367 likes

Sourdough Starter - Day 4 🤩đŸĨ–
Supplies: 1 glass jar Spoon to mix Ingredients: 1/2 cup all purpose flour 1/3 cup room temperature filtered water Directions so farâ€Ļ Day 1 1. Start by adding flour & water to the jar & mix. 2. Seal the top, but not all the way. You can sit the lid on top without shuttin
Jordan

Jordan

19 likes

Sourdough Starter - Day 1 & 2
Supplies: Glass jar w lid Paper towels Spoon to mix Ingredients: 1/2 cup all purpose flour 1/3 cup room temperature filtered water Directions so far: 1. Start by adding flour & water to the jar & mix. 2. Seal the top, but not all the way. You can sit the lid on top without
Jordan

Jordan

173 likes

âŗ1 Day Sourdough Timeline
Screenshot description! Adjust to your schedule! â€ĸmake dough & cover with tea towel â€ĸrest 1hr before first set of stretch & folds â€ĸrest 30 minutes between each set of stretch & folds, covering with tea towel after each set â€ĸrest in bowl, covered with tea towel, 2hrs before first
xoxo.maddy

xoxo.maddy

25 likes

Easy Sourdough Recipe 🍞
We don’t gatekeep around here! Sourdough doesn’t have to be complicated! Try this recipe then come back and tell me how your loaf turned out!! If you want a printable version, please DM for more info! Enjoy 🤌đŸŧđŸĢļđŸŧ #sourdough #sourdoughbread #homesteadingforbeginners #homesteadi
Andrea

Andrea

28 likes

Sourdough Banana Bread Recipe
Banana bread for breakfast? Bake one day, slice and put into baggies for grab and go the next. Plus, with baggies there’s no containers to tote around. It’s the perfect make ahead option!😍 Here’s how I make it! YOU NEED: ✨DRY INGREDIENTS īģŋīģŋ2 C all-purpose flour īģŋīģŋ2 tsp baking powder īģŋ1/2 tsp b
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

75 likes

Baking with my 119 year old sourdough starter💕đŸĨš
I am so excited to be back baking! Stay tuned for all the new recipes coming your way; and in the meantime, since I still get asked this 1,000 times a day and wish I could respond to all of you-here is my famous sourdough chocolate cake recipe! I highly recommend this cake for your Valentine’s Day
Little Ranch Family🏠đŸĒ´đŸž

Little Ranch Family🏠đŸĒ´đŸž

22 likes

A freshly baked, sliced loaf of sourdough sandwich bread rests on a wire cooling rack, showcasing its golden crust and airy interior. A torn paper graphic overlays the image with the text "RECIPE SOURDOUGH SANDWICH BREAD".
đŸžđŸ¯ SAME DAY Honey Sourdough Sandwich Bread Recipe
I feed my starter twice a day at 8am and 8pm and I start this recipe at 11am - 12pm. Completed by 12pm - 1pm ready for bulk fermentation on the counter top. *Your starter should be double in size by 12pm if you fed at 8 am. This means the starter is strong enough to produce a loaf. I typically
Dawn Belle 🩷

Dawn Belle 🩷

74 likes

Same day sourdough focaccia
Ingredients: 400g filtered water 150g active sourdough starter, 1/2 cup + 2 tbs 1 tbs honey 500g bread flour, 3 2/3 cup 10g sea salt, 1 1/2 tsp 4 tbs olive oil, divided Flaky salt -start by feeding you starter 1:1:1 ratio meaning 1 part starter 1 part all purpose flour 1 part filtered w
thevibrantapron

thevibrantapron

10 likes

Sourdough Flatbread Easy Recipe
#lemon8challenge #whatieatinaday @Lemon8 Food @Lemon8 Food #lemon8partner
Tim Clowers

Tim Clowers

106 likes

Sourdough Pancakes | super easy breakfast
These sourdough pancakes are SO good. They’re the best recipe I’ve tried so far, and a family favorite. Technically it’s best if you mix the dry ingredients and the wet ones separately, but I’m lazy and just do it all together lol. INGREDIENTS: 190 g flour 24 g sugar 1 tsp baking soda 2 tsp
AmberDavis

AmberDavis

50 likes

A close-up of golden-brown sourdough garlic knots, brushed with garlic sauce and sprinkled with herbs, on a baking sheet. The image has text overlay "Sourdough Garlic Knots Beginner Friendly! SWIPE Yum" and "lemon8 @tn.mama20".
A white bowl containing a shaggy, unrisen sourdough dough, with flour visible around the edges. A paper note overlay says "FIRST RISE (5 HOURS)".
A white bowl containing a smooth, risen sourdough dough that has expanded to fill the bowl. A paper note overlay says "AFTER.".
Sourdough Garlic Knots Recipe
I made these for our Mother’s Day lunch and it didn’t disappoint!😋 YOU NEED: BREAD: 1/2 C water 1/3 C +1Tbs Active starter, at the peak 1 1/4-1/2 C flour, until shaggy dough forms 2 tsp salt 3 Tbs butter GARLIC SAUCE: 2 Tbs olive oil 3 Tbs minced garlic 5 Tbs butter salt to your liking
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

179 likes

A glass jar containing a sourdough starter, covered with a white coffee filter secured by a metal ring, sits on a wooden surface. The jar features an embossed rooster design. Overlay text reads "SOUR DOUGH TIME," with a Lemon8 logo and a stylized flower icon.
Simple Sourdough Starter Recipe
I am creating my Sourdough Starter recipe to share with you because I wish I had all of this information at the beginning when i began mine. It took time and digging to learn everything I have on creating my own sourdough starter. Below, I have the recipe I use daily, unless I want to bake a specif
Vikkilee23

Vikkilee23

25 likes

EASY SOURDOUGH | JALEPENO CHEDDAR
This is one of my personal favorite sourdough inclusions! The jalepeÃąo and cheddar compliment each other so well. I just posted a recipe for the dough itself on my page the other day. It’s basically foolproof at this point. #sourdough bread #lemon8food @Lemon8 Food
AmberDavis

AmberDavis

29 likes

See more