Book Review: Not Another Love Song

Wow?! I can't believe I waited this long to read this.

This book has one of my favorite types of MMC, one I've seen in lots of Ali Hazelwood-type books. You start the book believing he hates the FMC, but, *MILD SPOILER* he was interested or into her the entire time. Julie Soto does a good job of this here.

That scene when they first hang out... you know the one. INSANE. I was not expecting that, and my jaw was on the floor. One of my favorite scenes in a contemporary romance, ever.

I lost a star for the ending. It wasn't poorly written or even unrealistic. I just didn't enjoy it, and that feeling was strong enough that I am deducting a star. I don't know if I could come back from that ending, but I do think our MMC has started that journey to forgiveness. I definitely understand his reasons, but I don't think it really excuses the behavior.

#notanotherlovesong #spicyromance #BookReview

2025/7/29 Edited to

... Read moreWhen I picked up Julie Soto's 'Not Another Love Song,' I was immediately drawn to its beautiful illustrated cover, featuring a man and a woman with a cello—a perfect hint at the rival musicians theme that unfolds within. This book delivers on so many fronts, and after finishing it, I just had to share more insights, especially for those wondering what makes it truly special. First off, let's talk about the burning question: Is 'Not Another Love Song' spicy? Absolutely, yes! The original review hinted at an "insane" scene, and believe me, it lives up to the hype. Julie Soto masterfully builds the tension and chemistry, making the spicy moments feel earned and incredibly satisfying. It's not just thrown in for shock value; it's an integral part of the characters' passionate connection, elevating the romance beyond typical fluff. If you're into romance novels that don't shy away from heat, this one should definitely be on your radar. The slow burn combined with explosive moments truly left my jaw on the floor, as the original review mentioned! Another aspect that really shines in this book is the 'second act romance' element. While I won't give away specifics, the dynamic between the main characters certainly feels like a second chance or a new beginning after a period of development, both personally and professionally. This trope can be incredibly compelling, as it often involves characters who have grown, learned from past mistakes, and are now ready for a more mature and profound love. It adds layers of depth to their relationship, making their journey to forgiveness and understanding even more impactful. It's not just a straightforward enemies-to-lovers; there's a delicious complexity that makes you root for them even when you're frustrated. The book's cover, depicting the two musicians, perfectly encapsulates the essence of the story—a tale of rival musicians battling it out, not just in their careers but also in their hearts. It's visually appealing and hints at the artistic and competitive world the characters inhabit. Speaking of musical themes, while there isn't a direct 'maybe someday soundtrack' for this book, the way music is woven into the narrative is incredibly evocative, almost making you hear the melodies as you read. Fans of other music-centric romances, like those by Elle Kennedy (if you've ever looked up 'Love Song Elle Kennedy book cover,' you know the vibe), will appreciate the dedication to the craft and passion that permeates every page of 'Not Another Love Song.' Overall, despite my personal feelings about the ending—which, as the original review stated, wasn't poorly written but just hit me in a particular way—this novel remains a fantastic read. The journey the MMC embarks on towards forgiveness is compelling, and Soto does an excellent job of exploring complex emotions and motivations. If you're searching for a romance that combines a genuinely spicy plot, a captivating second act dynamic, and memorable characters set against a backdrop of competitive music, then 'Not Another Love Song' by Julie Soto is a must-add to your reading list. My 4/5 rating reflects how much I enjoyed the ride, even with its bittersweet conclusion.

Related posts

The image displays the front cover of the psychological thriller novel "Behind Closed Doors" by B.A. Paris, featuring the title in red and a dark keyhole design. Overlay text indicates "BOOK REVIEW" and a "10/10" rating.
Book Review✨🖤 Psychological Thriller
Book Review 🪻🌾✨ Book name: Behind Closed Doors Author: B.A Paris Genre: Psychological Thriller My rating: honestly.. 10/10, I’m hoping to find this thrill in another book. My review: I had no idea going into this book exactly what I was getting into. The words and details used made me picture
RM

RM

639 likes

An e-reader screen displays the cover of the book 'NOT ANOTHER LOVE SONG' by Julie Soto. The cover features a grayscale illustration of a man embracing a woman who is holding a cello. The author's name and title are prominent.
NOT ANOTHER LOVE SONG BOOK REVIEW:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.75 🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶 I got this as an ARC from Netgalley. Thank you to Netgalley and Forever publishing for letting me get an E-ARC. I ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS BOOK!! This has become one of my top 5 reads of the year! Gwen Jackson is a violinist and had been in the Manhattan Pops for four ye
Zoe

Zoe

3 likes

The book cover for 'The Coldest Hoe Ever' by Cornellia Smith features a close-up of a person's face with dark skin, dark glittery lipstick, and smoke emanating from their mouth. The title is in prominent pink and purple text, with the author's name below. A dark cityscape is visible in the background, and a Lemon8 logo is at the bottom left.
Book Review: The Coldest Hoe Ever By Cornellia Smith 🥶❄️😥
The Coldest Hoe Ever By Cornellia Smith ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5 Stars) Okayyyy Miss Cornelia Smith… let’s talk about it 😮‍🔥 When i first started writing this review, I wasn’t even all the way done with this book and was already yelling like—find a new friend?? Slap that hoe!! Because baby… this book wa
Readingwitvee

Readingwitvee

417 likes

A hand holds the book 'Not Another Love Song' by Julie Soto. The cover features an illustration of a man and a woman, with the woman playing a cello. A quote from Ali Hazelwood is visible on the cover.
not another love song review
4.5/5 Julie Soto does it again. This book was so good. I did an audio/physical read. I really thought the narrators were a good choice. They really brought the story to life. You could really feel the chemistry between Alex and Gwen. I loved their relationship and was stressed towards the en
Mary 📚🫶🏻

Mary 📚🫶🏻

9 likes

An open book, "Pack Darling 1&2" by Lola Rock, is shown with a bookmark that reads "A Reader lives a THOUSAND Lives." A small card notes the book's title, author, and the comment "My first Omegaverse read." Pink page flags are visible on the book's pages.
Various book-related items are displayed, including an "Annotation Key" for "Pack Darling" by Lola Rock, with categories like "Lilah" and "Grovel." Stickers include "falling for fictional characters," "DON'T ROCK THE BOAT," and a gummy bear with "EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE OF A F***ING GUMMY BEAR."
A hand holds the light pink cover of the book "PACK DARLING COMPLETE DUOLOGY" by Lola Rock, featuring ornate designs of buildings and toothbrushes. Numerous pink and white page flags are visible along the edges of the book's pages.
Dark Romance Book Review 🌷✨🔪
I am back with another romance book review😁 So first things first I can’t lie to yall🫣 I received this book back in November through PS bookclub. At first glance I thought this was a wolf shifter book🐺 but brother was I wrong😮‍💨 I had never heard of omegaverse, but I obviously knew the term omeg
Jayde 💫🍒🪩

Jayde 💫🍒🪩

12 likes

A book review graphic featuring the cover of Darcy Coates' 'The Haunting of Blackwood House' against a dark background. The book cover depicts a spooky, mist-shrouded house. The words 'Book Review' are at the top, and several lit candles are at the bottom, with the Lemon8 logo and username '@litwithlaney' visible.
HAUNTED HOUSE 👻 Book Review 📚
⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 Genre: Mild Horror/Thriller This was a very classic haunted house story in my opinion. I appreciated how the book got right into it and didn’t have many slow points. I enjoyed the creepy ghosts and flashbacks to another time very much! I found the FMC, Mara, to be very annoying
DeLaney 🌞

DeLaney 🌞

43 likes

The book cover for "Men We Reaped: A Memoir" by Jesmyn Ward, featuring an old photograph of two young Black children, rests on a white fluffy surface. The cover includes a quote from The New York Times Book Review and the author's name. A Lemon8 watermark is visible at the bottom left.
Book Review 📚
If you are easily triggered, this may not be a book you would want to read. In order to go out into society and experience others without judgement, we have to know where they came from. The author perfectly illustrates the lives of four young, Black men who died very young. Their tragic deaths sho
Marlesia

Marlesia

265 likes

A hand holds Natasha Preston's 'The Island' book, featuring a cover with an abandoned roller coaster on an island, pink water lilies, and a moody sky. A 'book review' graphic and Lemon8 watermark are visible.
This Thriller Had Me Shook 😳 | Book Review
Book Review: The Island by Natasha Preston ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I finally see what the hype was about — and wow, it did not disappoint. This book was phenomenal! Natasha Preston has officially earned a spot on my must-read author list. 👏🏽 The plot of The Island is gripping, fast-paced, and everything
settleherewellwithtee

settleherewellwithtee

112 likes

The book cover for 'You and Me Forever' by Francis and Lisa Chan, featuring green and orange handprints. Overlay text reads 'Lemon8 Book Club', 'IN A MARRIAGE? THINKING ABOUT MARRIAGE? READ THIS', and 'Review in caption', with a Lemon8 logo and wedding rings.
A book page with highlighted text discussing biblical roles in marriage, emphasizing that loving a spouse as Christ loved the church is challenging and requires sacrificial love, not just words.
A book page with highlighted text stating that love for God should be in a different category and far beyond love for family. It shows two lists, contrasting a typical order of affections with a biblical mandate placing God first.
Book Review: You and Me Forever 💛
It’s time for another review! 🤓 Written by Francis and Lisa Chan, “You and Me Forever: Marriage in the Light of Eternity” is a short but compelling read for any Christian considering marriage. Admittedly, I don’t know very much about Francis Chan, but I think it’s awesome that he was able to collab
Study w Cathy 🤍

Study w Cathy 🤍

125 likes

A person holds a Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of the murder mystery book "Last Day Alive" by Jeneva Rose, featuring two figures in a field. The image, set by a pool, is a book review for the Lemon8 Book Club, with "BOOK REVIEW" text overlaid.
MURDER MYSTERY BOOK REVIEW!
this book is a part two to another book I read last year! it involves a detective searching for a missing little girl in town and only a few days later does her only friend end up missing as well. little does the detective know that the ones closest and most important in the girls lives are the one
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

46 likes

Mid- Year Book Review
All the books I’ve read since January including 2 I didn’t finish… 4.5 stars / THE SONG OF ACHILLES Retelling of the Greek tale of Achilles and Patroclus. Beautifully written and intriguing. A great read for Pride.A heartbreaking romance but it didn’t destroy me like I excepted it too after h
Cas

Cas

9 likes

A person holds the book 'JACKAL' by Erin E. Adams, featuring a dark silhouette of a face against a starry night sky and trees on a red background. Text overlays read 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and 'Rating: 4/5', with small white heart icons. A color palette is visible on the left.
Mini Book Review,Rating: 4/5
This was a great read in my opinion, I haven't heard many people talking bout this book I got this book based on the cover and what I read on the back. This book is mainly about black girls going missing once a year around the same time of the year by someone in the woods and someone who is
Tymara

Tymara

20 likes

Just Another Missing Person — BOOK REVIEW
I recently finished Just Another Missing Person by Gillian McAllister! This was my first book by this author. 🍋 A B O U T 🍋 The story, told from multiple POVs, follows a detective as they try to solve a missing person’s case. Only, the missing person walks into a dead end ally never to be seen
lexi :) :(

lexi :) :(

10 likes

A hand holds the book "Frientimacy" by Shasta Nelson, with the subtitle "How to Deepen Friendships for Lifelong Health and Happiness." The image is overlaid with "1st Book Review of 2024."
An open book displays a section on "How the Frientimacy Triangle Works," featuring a triangle diagram with P, C, V, representing Positivity, Consistency, and Vulnerability. The text explains these three requirements for healthy friendships.
An open book shows a page detailing "The Eight Vital Friend's Roles," listing descriptions for roles like Builders, Champions, Collaborators, Companions, Connectors, Energizers, Mind-Openers, and Navigators. The "Energizers" role is highlighted.
1st Book Review of 2024 ✨
Frientimacy by Shasta Nelson Genre: self-help Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Review: I started reading Frientimacy after seeing the book discussed on TikTok and feeling like it would help me develop greater intimacy with my female friends. Understanding the frientimacy triangle which includes positivi
Alex Davis

Alex Davis

591 likes

A dark, eerie illustration of an old, multi-story house with glowing windows, a large bare tree, and a woman in historical attire near a river. Text overlays read "Book REVIEW" and "Genre: Horror," with an arrow pointing to "MORE ON THE OTHER SIDE."
The book cover for "1689" by Amy Cross, featuring a dark, imposing house with illuminated windows. The cover is set against a spooky landscape with a bare tree and a covered wagon. Text indicates it is "1 in a 13 SERIES."
An open book displays a two-star review, highlighting "SPELLING ERRORS" and "ONLY A COUPLE OF GOOD PARTS." The background depicts a dark, atmospheric scene with an old house, a large bare tree, and historical figures in a rural setting.
Book Review - 1689 by Amy Cross👻
Book name: 1689 📖✨ Author: Amy Cross Genre: Horror / Ghost Fiction 👻 My rating: ⭐️⭐️ My review: Had really high hopes for this book (and series) because the covers alone had me really wanting to dive in. There are many spelling and grammar errors throughout the book. Even on a specific part it
tbrwithchelsea✨

tbrwithchelsea✨

24 likes

A stack of books, including thrillers and mysteries, leans against a white door frame, with a pink 'Book review' overlay. Titles like 'The Silent Patient' and 'Good Girl, Bad Blood' are visible, along with a Lemon8 watermark.
A close-up of 'The Silent Patient' by Alex Michaelides, described as a #1 New York Times Bestseller, mystery/psychological thriller, addictive, jaw-dropping, and a good read. A Lemon8 watermark is at the bottom left.
A close-up of 'She's Gone' by David Bell, described as unpredictable, addictive, a YA thriller with a plot twist, and a good read. The cover features white text on a black background. A Lemon8 watermark is present.
Book review
The silent patient~ so good! I definitely recommend. It is a page turner! I seriously loved it! My jaw was on the floor at the end She’s gone~ Another page turner I read it in a day, it is addictive. My jaw was on the floor at the end. Something Happened To Ali Greenleaf~ so good, eye opener. It
Aubrie📖🩷

Aubrie📖🩷

140 likes

A hand holds the book 'You Made a Fool of Death with Your Beauty' by Akwaeke Emezi, a New York Times bestselling author, against a green background. 'Book Review' text and book emojis are overlaid, with 'lemon8' and '@bookedandbusy_brynnd' at the bottom.
Book Review 📚
Book Review 📚 You Made a Fool of Death with your beauty by Akeaeke Emezi Genre: Shady Romance 🫢 Rating: 5 ⭐️’s Listen, I know a lot of yall disliked this book, but hear me out. Is it possible that you didn’t catch the overall message of the story? 👀 Not the shady crap FEYI was on… bec
_BrynnD

_BrynnD

16 likes

A book cover for "Where Sleeping Girls Lie" by Faridah Àbíkẹ́-Íyímídé is displayed on a light background. Text overlays read "BOOK WTF?!" and "REVIEW." A heart icon, "Lemon8 @nii.colleee," and a Lemon8 color palette are also visible.
Where Sleeping Girl Lie Book Review 🤎🐀
Honestly this book was sooo good like when I started I couldn’t even put it down . It had so many plot twist,emotion, and drama ! I finished the book in 3 days and I can’t wait to get another book by this author ! Definitely recommend reading this one 🤗 #booktok #lemon8challenge #booksoflemon
Nicole Denise 🃏

Nicole Denise 🃏

139 likes

Book Review: Even If the Sky is Falling
Let’s talk about my first anthology series in a long time. I’m not a big fan of short stories or anthologies. Do I think short stories can be amazing, smart, and beautifully written? Absolutely! There is so much talent in being able to pull so much elegance and feeling out of so little words. Even
Coco J

Coco J

51 likes

𝔹𝕆𝕆𝕂 ℝ𝔼𝕍𝕀𝔼𝕎 ♾️⭐️
This book had me in a CHOKËHØLD, y’all! I thought I loved Beautiful Fiend, but Heartless Beloved was just on another level for me. I finished it on audio last year ( I know, I’m so behind 😅🤷🏻‍♀️) and @corvin.king & @heatherfirthnarrator absolutely KILLED IT! AGAIN!! But of course they did. They
Renita🖤Bookstagram

Renita🖤Bookstagram

13 likes

A book cover for "The Merciless" by Danielle Vega, featuring a pink background with a gold pentagram. Overlaid text reads "My Honest BOOK REVIEW" and "Rating: 5/5". The bottom left corner shows "Lemon8 @taylortequilalockhart".
Book Review: The Merciless by Danielle Vega
This is the first book in The Merciless series. The Merciless follows Sofia Flores, a teenage girl starting at a new school. She quickly makes friends with the popular girls who share her faith in religion but things take an unexpected turn for the worse when they suspect another student is poss
Taylor Tequila

Taylor Tequila

15 likes

Book Review 📖
Another book review for the girls, this time we got a sports romance from the lovely Brittainy Cherry. TPWP was a surprise for me since I was expecting the usual sports romance but this is a contender for my “Favorite Reads of 2024” List. Avery and Nathan are each other’s first loves who cross
Simone Umba

Simone Umba

25 likes

A book cover for 'Black Girls Must Be Magic' by Jayne Allen is displayed on a white fluffy surface. Text overlays read 'My Honest BOOK REVIEW' and 'Rating: 8/10', indicating a review of the book.
“Black Girls Must Be Magic: Book Review”
I’m back with another book review ya’ll !! For the month of June my book club read “Black Girls Must Be Magic” by Jayne Allen. This is the second book in her “Black Girls Must Die Exhausted” series. The books follow the main character Tabitha Walker as she navigates the ups and downs of life as
Denny Price

Denny Price

50 likes

A close-up of the book cover for 'Dopamine Nation' by Anna Lembke, MD. The cover features a colorful watercolor design in red, orange, and yellow, with the title and subtitle 'Finding Balance in the Age of Indulgence'. It's a New York Times Bestseller, with a Lemon8 watermark.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Star Book Review - Dopamine Nation
Dr. Anna Lembke’s Dopamine Nation was one of those books that didn’t just teach me something—it held up a mirror. It helped me understand my own relationship with pleasure, motivation, and the constant chase for “just one more” hit of satisfaction. 🌿 What I Loved Lembke’s writing is a blend o
Kae

Kae

12 likes

A Kindle e-reader displaying the cover of "Just For the Summer" by Abby Jimenez, resting on a red checkered case on light bedding, next to a cup of coffee with latte art, depicting a cozy reading scene.
The title page of the physical book "Just For the Summer" by Abby Jimenez, showing the author and publisher "FOREVER New York Boston," with an embosser tool beside it on light bedding.
A person holding the colorful physical book "Just For the Summer" by Abby Jimenez and a striped paper plate with a s'more, enjoying an outdoor evening by a fire pit.
BOOK REVIEW- Just For the Summer by Abby Jimenez
BOOK REVIEW- Just For the Summer by Abby Jimenez Five Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Every time I think that I’ve found my favorite book, Abby Jimenez writes another and it immediately goes to the top of my list. Abby has such an incredible talent of telling a story in a way that will steal your heart, ha
Jess VB

Jess VB

34 likes

The book cover for "Maybe I Can Be The Cure" by Caprice J., presented by K.C. Mills. It features a tattooed man, a woman, dollar bills, and a city street background, with the title prominently displayed.
Book Review: Maybe I can be the cure!!
Book Review: Maybe I Can Be the Cure by Caprice J. Rating: ★★★★★ (8/5 stars) Maybe I Can Be the Cure by Caprice J. is hands-down one of the most captivating books I’ve ever read, and without a doubt, it's now sitting comfortably in my top five books of all time. From the very first page,
Readingwitvee

Readingwitvee

43 likes

See more