Cookies At Midnight: Nutella Stuffed

Welcome back to Cookies at Midnight — where we turn our crash-outs into cookies.

Like I said, my mental health is droopy, and the most productive thing I can do is make something. Creating instead of spiraling gives me a tiny sense of control, and if I can make something delicious in the middle of chaos, then maybe I’m gonna be okay.

Why cookies? Why not. I may look like I have a sweet tooth, but I really don’t — half the time I barely eat them. Cookies were the one thing I always struggled with, so now the challenge is the therapy. And trust me, my friends and family do not complain about being the beneficiaries of my coping mechanisms.

Tonight’s adventure: a Nutella-stuffed cookie that had me questioning my “I don’t like sweets” identity. She is delicious, she is soft, she is crispy, she is gooey, and she keeps well. Yes, I used generic Nutella — I am not paying three extra dollars for the same taste.

Another twist: I swapped regular chocolate for a milk chocolate hazelnut bar and WOW. Also, these silicone molds? I am feral over them. I want to stuff everything inside something else. Cookies, herbs, garlic — I’m unhinged in the best domestic way.

The recipe is the same base as my last two cookies. If you want, I can make a recipe card for the base and post it since it’s the one I use the most. #cookies #cookie #nutella #crashouts #mentalhealth

2025/12/6 Edited to

... Read moreBaking can be a powerful form of self-care, especially when life feels overwhelming. The idea of creating Nutella-stuffed cookies resonates beyond just the dessert—it's about finding a moment of calm and control amidst chaos. Using a milk chocolate hazelnut bar in place of regular chocolate offers a delightful flavor upgrade, enhancing the richness while complementing the gooey Nutella center. Silicone molds, like the ones mentioned, are game-changers for cookie making, allowing you to get creative by stuffing not only sweets but also herbs or garlic for savory experiments. Generic Nutella spread works just as well as branded alternatives, making this recipe budget-friendly without sacrificing taste. The cookies' texture balance—soft on the inside, slightly crispy outside—adds to the overall satisfaction of each bite. Storing these cookies properly ensures they keep well, so you can enjoy them over several days, which is great for sharing with family and friends. This recipe is more than just a treat; it symbolizes turning challenges into creative wins. Such homemade baked goods can serve as a reminder that sometimes, small acts like making cookies can uplift moods and strengthen mental health. Whether you struggle with a sweet tooth or not, trying out this Nutella-stuffed cookie delivers comfort in both flavor and sentiment, making it a perfect indulgence during stressful times.

Related posts

Oreo Nutella Stuffed Cookies 🍪
Ingredients: 4 dollops Nutella hazelnut spread 4 oreo double stuf chocolate sandwich cookies 4 slices pillsbury chocolate chip cookie dough Instructions: On a parchment lined baking sheet, place 4 dollops of Nutella spread, top each with 1 chocolate sandwich cookie, and freeze for 30-60 minu
Tai__RD 🖤

Tai__RD 🖤

29.7K likes

Chocolate stuffed cookies🍫🍪
Ingredients Refrigerated • 2 Eggs, large Condiments • 8 tbsp Chocolate hazelnut spread Baking & Spices • 21/4 cup All purpose flour • 2 tsp Baking powder • 1 tsp Baking soda • 3/4 cup Brown sugar, light • 2 cups Chocolate chips, semisweet • 1 tsp Cornstarch • 1/4 cup Granulated suga
Rose Martinez

Rose Martinez

3915 likes

4-Ingredient S’mores stuffed cookies
Looking for a fun, over-the-top (and best of all EASY) dessert for your summer cookouts and this Memorial Day weekend? These Stuffed S’more Chocolate Chip Cookies are just the sweet treat you are looking for. This is a recipe that kids and adults will love, although just a few bites may be enoug
Mallory Austin

Mallory Austin

7442 likes

Stuffed cookies 🍪
Cookie Monster🍪 Fruity pebbles 🍓🍒 Red velvet cheese cake 🍰 Reese’s peanut butter 🍫🥜
__amberkaye__

__amberkaye__

2997 likes

Nutella stuffed cookies
🎊🌈✨ Nutella stuffed sugar cookie recipe ⬇️ Ingredients: — 1/2 cup (1 stick) softened butter — 3/4 cup white sugar — 1 egg — 1 tsp vanilla — 1/2 tsp almond extract — 2 cups flour — 1 1/2 tsp baking powder — 1/2 tsp baking soda — pinch of salt — sprinkles — nutella how-to
Madison

Madison

1871 likes

Nutella Stuffed Cookies 🍪😮‍💨
Full Recipe⬇️🍪 Makes 6-8 cookies depending on the size you'd like. (Freeze 6-8 balls of nutella I used a heaped tsp of nutella) Batter Caster sugar 60g Light brown sugar 120g Browned unsalted butter 125g (leave to cool) *use about 160g of unmelted to achieve this. Plain flour 22
TooGoodNotTo

TooGoodNotTo

3254 likes

Valentine Nutella Stuffed Pastry Puff Hearts
If you haven’t seen my prior post this is a twist to my stuffed pastry bunnies that I made last Easter! Obviously everyone knows the number one seller on Valentine’s Day is chocolate covered strawberries, but this is something different that is super easy to make. Here's the recipe for t
Lauren Wegrzyn

Lauren Wegrzyn

6873 likes

CHEESECAKE STUFFED COOKIES
the best decision at 12am 🍪 #Cheesecake #cheesecakecookies #cheesecakestuffed #chocolatechipcheesecake #cookies @pillsbury
KATELYN

KATELYN

3748 likes

NUTELLA STUFFED BANANA MUFFINS
literally life changing! can’t have banana muffins no other way now! #nutella muffin #nutellamuffin #bananabread #banananutmuffin #bakingrecipe
KATELYN

KATELYN

30 likes

🍪 THE BEST Nutella Stuffed Cookie Pie!
This will be your new favourite dessert — the gooey Nutella centre is CRAZY. Follow to see more easy bakes! 🍫👇 Ingredients: Butter, brown sugar, egg, vanilla, flour, bicarb, chocolate chips, Nutella. Method: Cream → mix → fold → press → fill with Nutella → cover → bake 160°C / 30 min. H
Sauced & Social

Sauced & Social

4712 likes

Nutella stuffed cookies 🍪
#cookies🍪 #bakingrecipes #baking #bakingfromscratch
Briana Welch

Briana Welch

58 likes

A plate of milk chocolate stuffed jack-o'-lantern cookies, with two broken open to reveal gooey chocolate filling. The cookies are orange-brown with carved faces. Overlaid text describes them as 'Easy to make', 'Fun to make', 'Milk Chocolate STUFFED Jack-o'-lantern Spookies'.
🎃🍪 Milk Chocolate Stuffed Jack-O-Lantern Cookies 🍪
🎃🍪 Milk Chocolate-Stuffed Jack-O'-Lantern Cookies 🍪🎃 Get into the Halloween spirit with these adorable milk chocolate-stuffed jack-o'-lantern cookies! These festive treats are soft, chewy, and filled with gooey milk chocolate, making them perfect for celebrating the season. 🎃👻 You will ne
Rozalynn Fisher

Rozalynn Fisher

1602 likes

Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups
Nutella Stuffed Cookie Cups make the best dessert, brunch, or after-school snack! These fun cookie cups are baked in a ramekin and filled with Nutella for the absolute best crunch. Everyone will love these easy chocolate chips cookie cups.
Kay Creations

Kay Creations

414 likes

Six golden-brown chocolate chip cookies are baked in a muffin tin. One cookie on the bottom right has a bite taken out, revealing a darker center, consistent with an Oreo stuffing.
Six freshly baked, thick golden-brown chocolate chip cookies are arranged in a metal muffin tin, appearing round and full, suggesting they are stuffed.
Four large, golden-brown chocolate chip cookies are presented on white parchment paper. One cookie is broken open, clearly showing a dark Oreo cookie inside.
Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies 🍪
I used the Nestle brand of the chocolate chip dough roll and any Oreos of your choosing. They were a hit at my job. Wish I would’ve made more. #cookiesforlife #unfiltered #oreocookies #chocolatechipcookies #delicious
idalis_ottissa

idalis_ottissa

1040 likes

Brown butter Nutella Stuffed Cookies
Recipe 1 stick unsalted butter 1/4 cup white sugar 1/2 cup packed brown sugar 1 egg 1 tsp vanilla 1 1/2 cup flour 1 tsp salt 1 tsp baking powder 1/2 cup chocolate chips kosher salt for topping bake at 350° for 12 to 14 minutes I measured out about a tbs of Nutella and froze it
Tyti 💕

Tyti 💕

17 likes

Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies
Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies! Crispy on the edges, soft and chewy in the center, stuffed with delicious Nutella chocolate. Ingredients 1/2 cup (1 stick) salted softened butter 1 Egg 1 cup brown sugar 2 tsp baking powder 1 tsp vanilla extract 1 1/3 cup flour Add-ins: •&
Lila 🌸

Lila 🌸

96 likes

Dubai stuffed cookies new obsession 💚💚🤎🤎💚💚🤎🤎💚💚🤎🤎
Recipe: 1 stick butter (melted & browned) 3/4 cup brown sugar (packed) 1/2 cup granulated sugar 1 large egg • 1 tsp vanilla paste 11/3 cup all-purpose flour 1/2 tsp baking soda Pinch of salt 1 cup chopped semisweet chocolate (or any chocolate of choice) Flaky sea salt (for garnish)
🌮💄🎧🍕

🌮💄🎧🍕

868 likes

A stack of peanut butter stuffed cookies, some cut in half to reveal the creamy peanut butter filling. The image has text overlays: 'PEANUT BUTTER STUFFED COOKIES STEP BY STEP' and three blue arrow emojis.
A clear glass bowl containing peanut butter and powdered sugar, with a white spatula. The text overlay instructs to 'Add 1 cup peanut butter and 1/2 cup powdered sugar to a bowl and mix'.
Small, scooped dollops of peanut butter arranged on parchment paper. The text overlay instructs to 'Use a small cookie scoop to scoop small dollops of Peanut butter Freeze for at least 2-4 hours'.
✨Make Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies with me✨
Step by step stuffed peanut butter cookies! The peanut butter filling in the center is so creamy! Follow me for more recipes! 😊😊 full recipe at link in bio! #peanutbuttercookies #peanutbutter #cookiesrecipe #cookies #recipes
Zesty Lemon Bakery

Zesty Lemon Bakery

199 likes

A light blue box contains six gourmet stuffed cookies with various toppings. Flavors include chocolate, chocolate chip, peanut butter, sprinkles, cookies and cream, and one with a rectangular pastry topping.
The interior of a cookie store features a counter with a "Gourmet STUFFED COOKIES" sign. A menu board displays classic and weekly special cookies. A "Dirty Dough" logo is visible on the floor mat.
A prominent white "Dirty Dough" logo is displayed on a light blue wall. The wall features a subtle pattern of city buildings and various baked goods.
stuffed cookies😋
DIRTY DOUGH! This place is honestly amazing🥰 , i feel like you don’t like crumbl cookie you’ll probably love this place. The thing is they have a consistent menu but one different cookie weekly! give it try ☺️ #cookiecrumble #dirtydough #crumble cookies 🍪 #like for a cookie 🍪 #viral
nadine 💎

nadine 💎

844 likes

Dubai Stuffed Chocolate Cookies 🍪
Stuffed with Dubai filling and added on top! How can you not love this ? #chocolatedubai #dubaichocolate #cookies🍪 #dubaichocolate🍫 #fyp
Stacy Kowalski

Stacy Kowalski

83 likes

Stuffed Oreo Cookies 🤎🤍🤎
✨Make Oreo Stuffed Cookies with me✨ so much fun to make! Find the full recipe in my bio. #oreocookies #recipeideas #baking #cookies #cookieideas
Zesty Lemon Bakery

Zesty Lemon Bakery

806 likes

A close-up of baked stuffed peanut butter cookies, with one broken open to show the gooey peanut butter filling. A stack of three cookies is in the background, along with other cookies scattered around.
Hands pulling apart a warm stuffed peanut butter cookie, revealing the stretchy, gooey peanut butter filling inside. Other cookies are blurred in the background.
Unbaked peanut butter cookie dough balls, coated in sugar, arranged on a parchment-lined baking sheet, ready to be baked into stuffed cookies.
🥜Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies 🥜
These peanut butter cookies are stuffed with gooey peanut butter. They’re so yummy and easy to make! Ingredients: Peanut Butter Filling -1 cup creamy peanut butter -1/2 cup powdered sugar Cookie Dough -1/2 cup unsalted butter (1 stick) at room temperature. -1/2 cup brown sugar -1/4 cup
Zesty Lemon Bakery

Zesty Lemon Bakery

47 likes

Stuffed S’mores Cookies with Graham Cracker Base 🔥
I tried making stuffed s’mores cookies and yeah… these came out crazy 😭 There’s a graham cracker on the bottom, marshmallow in the middle, then chocolate chip cookie dough baked over top so everything melts together. It’s soft, gooey, and honestly tastes like a full s’more but better. The mar
Vaneche ❤️

Vaneche ❤️

145 likes

Nutella Stuffed Cookies
Chocolate cake mix cookies stuffed with Nutella is one of the easiest recipes and tastes absolutely amazing! #chocolate #cookies #recipes #easyrecipes #cookiesrecipe #Chocolatecookies #Recipe #lemon8food #baking #dessert @Lemon8 Food
Shanice

Shanice

304 likes

Cookie butter stuffed peanut butter cookies 🤤
6 scoops of cookie butter (you can also use Nutella) 1 cup of creamy peanut butter 1 egg I cup of sugar You put 6 scoops of whatever you choose to use on parchment paper. Put it in it the freezer for 30-40 mins You mix together the peanut butter, the egg and the sugar until a dough forms.
NikkiKhalifa🧡💋

NikkiKhalifa🧡💋

20 likes

Reese's Stuffed S'mores Cookies 🍪
Reese's Stuffed S'mores Cookies 🍪 Follow me for more ‼️‼️‼️ #cookies 🍪 #fresh baked cookies 🍪 #sweettooth #peanutbuttercookies #reeses 💌 Brand: @HERSHEY’S ✨Super Viral Cookie Recipe You Should Never Miss‼️ Chicago
MaliBsKitchen1

MaliBsKitchen1

468 likes

🍪🔥 S’mores Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies
What you need: • Your favorite chocolate chip cookie dough • 1 box Graham crackers, broken into rectangle pieces • Hershey bar (one bar will make 12 cookies) ⸻ 👩‍🍳 Instructions 1️⃣ Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C). Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. 2️⃣ Take a palm piece of c
Socially Tasty

Socially Tasty

407 likes

Caramel stuffed pumpkin cookies
Now these cookies have PUMPKIN to talk about!🎃⁠ ⁠ You’ll need: 1 box of Yellow Cake Mix⁠ ½ cup of pumpkin puree⁠ ⅓ cup of oil⁠ 2 tsp. pumpkin pie spice⁠ 2 cups chopped pecans⁠ Caramel candies⁠ ⁠ To Make:⁠ 1. Preheat oven to 350° F and mix together the cake mix, pumpkin puree, oil and spi
Sprinkle Me Syd

Sprinkle Me Syd

61 likes

choc chip stuffed cream chesse cookies
heatherhamilton992

heatherhamilton992

582 likes

nutella stuffed chocolate chip cookies 🍪
#cookinwitxzwts
xenia 💋

xenia 💋

8 likes

Stuffed cookies 🍪
#baking #cake #homemade #food #dessert #foodie #foodporn #yummy #instafood #chocolate #bakery #cakes #foodphotography #delicious #cookies #cakedecorating #cooking #cupcakes #cakesofinstagram #baker #sweet #pastry #birthdaycake #bake #love #bread #cakestagram #foodstagram #desserts #b
baking channel 🎂

baking channel 🎂

45 likes

A close-up of baked Biscoff Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies, featuring a Biscoff cookie and crunchy Biscoff cookie butter on top, with text overlays identifying the components.
A four-panel collage showing the cookie-making process: wet ingredients, dry ingredients, mixing flour into wet ingredients, adding chocolate chips and crumbled Biscoff to dough, and a baked cookie.
A close-up of a baked Biscoff Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie on a cooling rack, and a broken cookie revealing its gooey Biscoff center.
Brown Butter Biscoff Stuffed Cookies
My kind of therapy comes with a whisk, a little butter, and a sweet ending. Brown Butter Biscoff Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies 🍪🤎 Ingredients * 1 cup unsalted butter (browned) * 1 cup brown sugar * ½ cup granulated sugar * 2 eggs * 1 tbsp vanilla extract * 2 ½ cups all-purpose flour *
Roe

Roe

2080 likes

cookies and llcream chocolate chip Nutella stuffed
🍪🍫 Nutella-Stuffed Oreo Chocolate Chip Cookies Makes: 14–16 large cookies # 🍫 Nutella Centers (Do First) Scoop: * 14–16 tsp Nutella onto parchment-lined plate or tray. Freeze: * 30–45 minutes until firm. This keeps the centers gooey instead of leaking everywhere. # 🍪 Cookie Dough * 1 cu
Baked daily

Baked daily

3 likes

See more