How to make your own coffee creamer

2025/12/14 Edited to

... Read moreMaking your own coffee creamer at home offers a fantastic way to control what goes into your coffee and avoid the artificial flavors and preservatives found in many store-bought creamers. A popular homemade recipe involves using half & half as a creamy base, organic maple syrup for natural sweetness, and a splash of pure vanilla extract for that rich, comforting aroma. Start by pouring your desired amount of half & half into a clean container. The amount you use will depend on how light or creamy you like your coffee. Next, add a small splash of vanilla extract—be careful not to overdo it, as too much vanilla can create a harsh flavor. Then, sweeten your creamer naturally with organic maple syrup, adjusting to your preferred level of sweetness. Mix these ingredients well until combined, and keep your homemade creamer refrigerated. When serving, add it to your coffee after you've sweetened your drink, as per your taste. This method not only delivers a fresh, wholesome creamer but also allows you to experiment with variations such as adding cinnamon, matcha powder, or other flavorings to suit your coffee aesthetic. Using natural ingredients such as organic maple syrup and pure vanilla ensures your coffee creamer is free from artificial additives and unnecessary sugars, making it a healthier choice. Plus, crafting your own creamer is cost-effective and fun, giving you full control over freshness and flavor intensity. Enjoy your coffee with the satisfaction of knowing exactly what you’re putting into your cup every morning!

Related posts

Homemade Coffee Creamer
I also added 1/2c water that I didn’t record! #coffeecreamerrecipes #coffeecreamer #homesteading #coffee
Cheyenne🌵

Cheyenne🌵

1033 likes

Pumpkin Spice Creamer Homemade
☕️ 🎃 I love all things pumpkin spiced flavored 🧡 This is how I make my creamer: 1 can- sweetened condensed milk 1 cup- pumpkin puree 3 cups- milk (you can add less) 1 tsp- pumpkin pie spice 1 tsp- nutmeg 1 tsp- vanilla extract - I mix it all together well and store it in the fridge. T
Lucy | Jesus & Lifestyle ✞ ❀

Lucy | Jesus & Lifestyle ✞ ❀

1933 likes

3 ingredients coffee creamer
#homemade #coffeecreamerrecipe #coffeeathome
Emily Drew

Emily Drew

2066 likes

Crème Brûlée Coffee Creamer Recipe☕️
I am alll about those vanilla/caramel vibe coffees and if you are too- I’ve got a recipe for you!😋☕️ YOU NEED: 1 12oz can evaporated milk 1/2 C brown sugar 1 1/2 C milk Vanilla extract, to taste RECIPE: 1. In a small pot bring brown sugar and evaporated milk to medium heat, stirring until su
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

1175 likes

A glass jar of tiramisu coffee creamer sits on a kitchen counter next to a coffee mug and coffee maker, with text overlay 'Tiramisu Coffee Creamer' and 'swipe'.
Sweetened condensed milk is poured from a can into a saucepan containing half and half, illustrating the first step of combining ingredients over medium heat.
Espresso powder and cocoa powder are shown in a bowl with a small amount of warmed milk mixture, ready to be mixed until smooth as part of the recipe.
Tiramisu Coffee Creamer Recipe☕️
Who doesn’t love a good tiramisu?😋 This creamer brings all those rich, creamy flavors right into your morning cup of coffee.☕️ 🤍YOU NEED: 2 C half and half 1/2 C sweetened condensed milk 1 Tbsp instant espresso powder 1 Tbsp cocoa powder 1 tsp vanilla extract 1/2 tsp almond extract Pinch of
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

1201 likes

Caramel coffee creamer
Caramel coffee creamer ✨ • pint size mason jar • 1/2 cup sweetened condensed milk • 1 tsp vanilla • 1 cup caramel sauce • 1/2 tsp cinnamon • fill the rest of the jar with your choice of milk lasts in the fridge for up to 2 weeks ☕️ . . . #iced caramel coffee #groceryessentials #
Lex 🦋

Lex 🦋

1274 likes

A mason jar filled with s'more's coffee creamer on a speckled countertop, with text 'S'more's Coffee Creamer' and a 'SWIPE' arrow, indicating a recipe guide.
A pot containing sweetened condensed milk, cocoa powder, and ground cinnamon, with a spatula, illustrating the initial mixing step for the s'more's coffee creamer.
Half and half and vanilla extract being poured into a pot with the chocolate-cinnamon mixture, showing the next step in making the s'more's coffee creamer.
S’more’s Coffee Creamer Recipe
Fall is the season for s’mores, so naturally.. let’s add it in our coffee.☕️🥰 YOU NEED: 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk 2 Tbsp cocoa powder 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon 1 1/2 cups half and half or milk 1 tsp vanilla extract 1/2 cup mini marshmallows RECIPE: 1. In a pot over medium
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

1026 likes

Homemade Pumpkin Spice Creamer
Making your own dreamers at home saves on additives. I cannot wait till pumpkin season so I can cook my own pumpkins down for this! I live this recipe sooo much and it is in my fridge year round!! #pumpkinspice #coffeecreamer #homemade #coffer #coffeerecipe
✨️Wanderer TTC✨️

✨️Wanderer TTC✨️

312 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer
Homemade Coffee Creamer! So easy to make and way better than store bought! 🫙1 can of sweetened condense milk 🫙Fill the rest of the jar with your choice of milk! 🫙Roughly 1tbs of vanilla (more or less whatever you prefer) 🫙A dash of cinnamon 🫙Put your lid on and shake! What’s your favorit
Jasmine F

Jasmine F

881 likes

Homemade Vanilla Bean Coffee Creamer
It’s so simple to make your own creamer and this vanilla bean creamer just changed my coffee ☕✨ Smooth, rich, and perfectly sweet, it’s the easiest way to upgrade your cup without doing too much. Definitely staying in rotation. ✨ Save this for your next coffee moment. What you’ll need:
TheUrbanHomemakerMama

TheUrbanHomemakerMama

242 likes

HomemadeCoffee creamer
Brown sugar and cinnamon coffee creamer 10/10 Recipe: • 1 cup brown sugar • 1 cup water • 1 cup heavy whipping cream Warm this on the stove in a small saucepan over medium heat till brown sugar is dissolved Then add 1 tsp salt I personally added 2 tbsp of cinnamon and 2 tbsp of vani
Rach🍋

Rach🍋

2486 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer 🌾
#homemadecoffeevibes #homemadecoffee
Gwin |momma

Gwin |momma

226 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer.Clean,Simple & Intentional
Making your own coffee creamer is so much easier than most people think and the best part? ✨ No chemicals ✨ No artificial flavors ✨ Just real, nourishing ingredients made with intention The base is always simple: 🥛 Milk 🥛 Half & half 🥛 Condensed milk From there, you can mix and matc
De Romero Wellness

De Romero Wellness

58 likes

Coffee creamer
Did you know coffee creamer has VEGETABLE OIL as one of the first few ingredients? 🤮 In four easy steps.. make a more tasty coffee creamer at home! Step one: pour out that nasty store bought container and rinse it well. ( save container ! - you’ll need it! ) Step two: take a can of sweet co
Jennmadethat

Jennmadethat

776 likes

Ingredients for homemade coffee creamer are displayed on a white wooden surface, including milk in a measuring cup, an open can of sweetened condensed milk, and vanilla extract in a small white bowl.
making your own coffee creamer
Homemade coffee creamers can last up to a week in the fridge if stored in an airtight container - 1 (14 ounce) can sweetened condensed milk - 1 ¾ cups skim milk (or almond milk!!) - 2 teaspoons vanilla extract #coffee #coffeeaesthetic #coffeerecipe #homemaderecipes #homemade #
Alex Caster

Alex Caster

117 likes

Homemade coffee creamer 😋
Just three ingredients and it’s delicious! I use a 1 Quart Mason jar- ▫️Pour 1 can sweetened condensed milk into the 1 quart jar- I prefer the blue can but my store was out. ▫️Fill the rest of the mason jar up with milk- any type of milk will work. ▫️Pure vanilla extract- measured with your
Nicole

Nicole

1350 likes

Banana Bread Creamer
This is so delicious! 🤤 I used banana extract because I don’t want to worry about it going bad super fast. But you can sub 1/2 banana. 1 cup milk 1/2 cup heavy cream 1/4 cup brown sugar 1/2 tsp vanilla extract 1/2 tsp banana extract 1/2 tsp nutmeg 1/2 tsp cinnamon Combine it al
Stephanie Ford

Stephanie Ford

492 likes

Homemade coffee creamer made simple ☕️✨
Super simple and fast recipe for coffee creamer! #homemadecoffeecreamer #coffeeathome #cleaneatingrecipe
Beth|4R Homestead

Beth|4R Homestead

51 likes

Two Mason jars on a kitchen counter, one filled with light-colored homemade coffee creamer and the other with a darker liquid. The image features the text "I threw away my coffee creamer And why I think you should, too."
I threw away my coffee creamer
Two words: vegetable oil. I knew it was in there… I just kept choosing to ignore it. But why?? I don’t want to drink vegetable oil every morning. I don’t think you should, either. Plus, making your own coffee creamer is inexpensive, easy, and naturally pretty long lasting. Recipe: 1 (14oz
Shannon🪽 🤍

Shannon🪽 🤍

903 likes

New coffee creamer!
Omg I came across some new coffee creamers at Kroger. I ended up buying the Chocolate Covered Strawberry 🍓 Which one have you tried? And which one is your go to creamer? #coffeelover #coffeecreamer #chobani #coffeetime☕
SelengeZ

SelengeZ

2089 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer with Milk & Half and Half
I’ve been skipping the store-bought creamers and making my own with just milk, half & half, a little maple syrup, and vanilla. It’s cozy, simple, and mama-approved. No artificial stuff, just a smooth and creamy blend that makes my morning cup feel a little more special. You can switch up the fl
Chande Outen

Chande Outen

975 likes

Home Made Sweetened Vanilla Coffee Creamer (32oz)
Thank me later!!! I purchased a 32oz jar (You can use any size jar that you would like, I wanted less sugar) I added: ✔️14oz of Sweetened Condensed milk ✔️18oz of unsweetened Coconut milk (If you want it sweeter you can just put the contents in a smaller jar) ✔️1/2 teaspoon of organic
Kyti Joi

Kyti Joi

1659 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer
Homemade caramel brûlée creamer ✨ .5c brown sugar 1c water 1 can (14oz) condensed milk 🤍 bring it all to a simmer 🤍 remove from heat + add : 2tsp vanilla 1tsp salt .5c milk Keep in fridge drink it before the due date on your milk. 🧚‍♀️ • Making your own creamer is so easy
organicallybree

organicallybree

190 likes

2 Ingredient Natural Tea & Coffee Creamer
#naturalcreamer #healthycreamer #coffeelovers #tealovers #homemadecreamer
Seun.scott

Seun.scott

635 likes

Homemade Salted Caramel Coffee Creamer
I haven’t bought store bought coffee creamer since making this!!! 🤤🤎 CARAMEL: 5 tbs butter 1 cup brown sugar 1/2 cup heavy cream 1/2 tsp salt Melt butter over medium heat Add brown sugar Let come to a slight boil Add heavy cream Mix until smooth Remove from heat & add salt CREAM
Casey Enlow

Casey Enlow

78 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer✨
Make homemade sugar cookie coffee creamer with me ✨ #homemade coffee #coffeesyrup #coffeecreamer #coffeeaesthetic #homemadecreamer
CourtneyChris

CourtneyChris

1140 likes

Homemade coffee creamer
This takes under 5 minutes to make! & it’s delicious. This is the first recipe I’ve tried so I plan to try more and find a sugar free version. #coffee #homemade coffee #coffee creamer #recipesideas
MariahR

MariahR

28 likes

A hand holds a mason jar filled with frothy, light brown peanut butter mocha coffee creamer. The jar is embossed with 'golden harvest' and an emblem. Spice jars, including one labeled 'McCormick', are visible in the background.
Peanut butter mocha coffee creamer
2 cups heavy cream 1/2 can of sweetened condensed milk 2 tbsp peanut butter 2 tbsp unsweetened cocoa powder 1 tsp vanilla extract — mix everything but the vanilla in a medium sauce pan on medium heat — stir for 5-7 minutes until incorporated — take off heat, stir in vanilla — let cool
Lex 🦋

Lex 🦋

337 likes

Homemade coffee Creamer
I used almond milk in mine but feel free to use your choice of milk! #homemade coffee #coffeecreamer #coffeerecipe #homemadecreamer #coffee
Lizzie Marie

Lizzie Marie

108 likes

You need this creamer hack!
Ditch the oils and chemicals in store bought coffee creamer and make your own! ☕️ WHAT YOU NEED: ✨ Half & Half (or your milk of choice) ✨ Sweetener (I love brown sugar!) ✨EXTRA✨ Add a small splash of vanilla 🤤 #coffeecreamer #coffee #coffeecreamrecipe #brownsugar #homemadecoff
airelmcgee

airelmcgee

93 likes

Homemade coffee creamer
Dunkin extra extra copycat recipe! #homemade coffee #homemade #dunkincoffee #copycatrecipes
Kristen Michael ☕️📚

Kristen Michael ☕️📚

43 likes

A mason jar of homemade cinnamon roll coffee creamer sits next to a mug of coffee with the creamer, showcasing the finished product. The image is overlaid with the text "Cinnamon Roll Coffee Creamer".
All the ingredients for homemade cinnamon roll coffee creamer are displayed: half and half, sweetened condensed milk, vanilla extract, ground cinnamon, and an empty mason jar. The image is labeled "Ingredients".
A mason jar contains half and half, condensed milk, and vanilla, with ground cinnamon added on top, ready for mixing. The image includes the instruction "Add all ingredients to a container."
Cinnamon Roll Coffee Creamer Recipe
I’m on a mission to make my own coffee creamers weekly, and I’m thinking this may be a Thursday thing from now on.😋 First up- Cinnamon Roll Coffee Creamer! It didn’t disappoint, sipping some right now as I type this.👩‍🍳💋 YOU NEED: 2 C half and half 14 oz can of condensed milk +- 1 Heaping Tbs
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

517 likes

Homemade Vanilla Bean Coffee Creamer
Combined these ingredients today until everything is incorporated and enjoy you made your own coffee creamer. P.S you can create any flavor you want Caramel (caramel sauce) Chocolate (coco powder) Peppermint (peppermint extract) Birthday Cake (almond extract or birthday cake syrup) Etc. #h
Melly Melz

Melly Melz

80 likes

How to make your own coffee
#coffeediy #coffeemaking #homemade coffee #make coffee #coffeeathome what coffee I drink daily: Home Edition ☕️
𝒥𝑒𝓃𝓃𝓎ꨄ︎

𝒥𝑒𝓃𝓃𝓎ꨄ︎

27 likes

Make your own coffee creamer!
Easy, tasty, vegan 📍Location: my kitchen #vegancoffeehacks #homemade coffee #homemadeproducts
susan

susan

38 likes

Stop buying Non-Dairy Creamer! Make this instead!
As a Functional Wellness Practitioner, I run labs on my clients. And….I am ALWAYS my first client. After receiving the results of my MRT food sensitivity blood test - cow dairy came up HIGH. Little did I know that even the smallest bit of half and half in my morning coffee caused an onslaught o
AgingGraceful

AgingGraceful

13 likes

✨☕️ Homemade Coffee Creamer ☕️✨
So in 2024 I started making my own bread, granola, and a few other things because I was wanted to be more health conscious. One of which is coffee creamer! Have you ever taken a peep 👀 at the ingredients that are in the store bought ones 😖? You should! ✨ Here’s what you need: ✨ • 4 tbsp of fla
Peyton 🐘

Peyton 🐘

40 likes

Sweet cream coffee creamer recipe
I feel like it’s inhumane to change people coffee routine without giving them proper notice. And finding out it’s discontinued when you’re on the aisle looking for it should be criminal. #coffee #recipeideas #coffeerecipe #coffeelover
Ari💚

Ari💚

224 likes

Homemade coffee creamer
#lemon8diarychallenge #homemadecoffeecreamer #Lemon8Diary #healthylifestyle2024 #cleaneating
Lori Griffith

Lori Griffith

31 likes

Homemade coffee creamer is the best!
Yes, making coffee creamer at home takes time but, it really doesn’t take that long! This recipe only took me 20 minutes (which is way less time than I would spend in the store, let’s be honest 😂) and it tastes WAY better than any store bought creamer I’ve found! Did I mention that this recipe is t
Rachel Foster

Rachel Foster

23 likes

HomemadeCreamer
Skip the store-bought creamer 🤎 Making my own coffee creamer has saved money, cut down on ingredients I can’t pronounce, and honestly tastes so much better. This homemade vanilla creamer takes just a few minutes to make and turns my morning coffee into a little moment of peace before the chao
Dakota 🩷

Dakota 🩷

12 likes

A mug of coffee with brown sugar creamer and a mason jar of creamer on a counter. The image features the title 'Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer' and 'blessed A series, PT. 5'.
A pot containing half and half, brown sugar, vanilla, and cinnamon, ready to be mixed for the creamer. The image lists the ingredients for the recipe.
The brown sugar coffee creamer mixture being stirred in a pot on medium heat until the sugar is completely dissolved. The text overlay provides this instruction.
Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer Recipe
Top 3 Faves so far!✨ The brown sugar just gives a nice rich flavor, definitely a must try!😋 Peep the flowers my girlie brought me in from outside.🥰 YOU NEED: 2 C half and half 1/2 C brown sugar dash of vanilla Maybe a 1/2 tsp cinnamon, if that- to tastes RECIPE: Put all ingredients into a p
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

295 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer
From Scratch Sugar: Melt 1 cup sugar in a saucepan until golden brown, then carefully whisk in 1 cup heavy cream and 1 tsp vanilla. Cool, then whisk into 2 cups hot milk. This yields about 32 servings and requires constant refrigeration. Brown Sugar Simmer: Boil 3/4 cup brown sugar with 3/4 cup w
LeAnn

LeAnn

3 likes

Vanilla coffee creamer
#coffeeathome #coffeecreamerrecipes #homemaking
Shay Shay

Shay Shay

1865 likes

Homemade Creamer Made Simple ☕️✨
Why buy store-bought when you can make your own creamer in minutes? All you need is condensed milk, your favorite milk, and a splash of coffee syrup for the perfect flavor. Customize it to your taste and take your morning coffee to the next level! 🥛☕ #HomemadeCreamer #DIYRecipes #coffeelover
Aulaura wfh mom of 4

Aulaura wfh mom of 4

47 likes

Homemade coffee creamer
The best homemade coffee creamer with 3 simple ingredients 😍 Ingredients: 1 3/4 cups Half and half, or equal parts milk and heavy cream 14 oz Sweetened condensed milk, or add to taste 1 Tbsp real vanilla extract Directions: Combine half and half, sweetened condensed milk and vanilla ext
Sprinkle Me Syd

Sprinkle Me Syd

57 likes

Pumpkin spice coffee creamer
☕️PUMPKIN SPICE COFFEE CREAMER ☕️ ..:follow @likeavirgil_ for all the fall recipes! Did you know you can make your own coffee creamers at home with a few simple ingredients? Save money and lots of unnecessary additives. Ingredients: 1 cup half and half 2 tbsp pumpkin puree 2-3 tbsp maple
likeavirgil_

likeavirgil_

15 likes

FallCoffee Creamer
Tested out making my own coffee creamer today. Perfect for Fall, no Pumpkin Spice but could easily be turned into it! 🍁 1 cup brown sugar 1 cup water 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg 1/2 tsp cinnamon 1 cup heavy cream 1 cup almond milk 1 tbsp vanilla extract Stir brown sugar and water unti
Stephanie Ford

Stephanie Ford

64 likes

See more