So I did look it up you can bake with the discard IF it has bubbled and doubled in size. Google says not to bake with the discard until day 7 or after it bubbles and doubles in size. You want a healthy starter and you don't want to bake with it to soon cause that could have bad bacteria in it. So be careful.
I did make pretzels on day 6. But I got nervous cause that's a tad too early so I wouldn't recommend doing that. But my starter has bubbled and doubled in size a few times so I knew it was healthy. So no one got sick 👍
I'm gonna wait another week to start baking with the discard and the starter in general tho just for peace of mind.
... Read moreHey fellow sourdough enthusiasts! Hitting Day 8 with your starter is such an exciting milestone, and it's totally normal to start wondering, 'Is it ready? What should it even look like?' I remember staring at mine, trying to decipher every tiny bubble!
First off, let's talk about those crucial visual cues. By Day 8, a healthy sourdough starter should definitely be showing significant activity. You'll want to see plenty of bubbles, not just a few tiny ones on the surface, but throughout the mixture. This 'foaming' indicates that the yeast and bacteria are happily chugging along, producing carbon dioxide. My starter looked like it had a fluffy, bubbly cap, almost like a sponge, after a good feed. A top-down view inside the jar often reveals a network of these bubbles, signifying it's truly active and, as the saying goes, 'HUNGRY FEED IT.'
The most important sign is consistent growth. Your starter should reliably 'bubble and double in size' within a few hours of feeding. This is where a little trick I learned comes in handy: using a rubber band to track its growth. Simply place a rubber band around your jar at the initial level of your freshly fed starter. It makes it super easy to visually confirm if it's doubled or even tripled in height. This consistent doubling is your green light for readiness, much more so than just seeing some bubbles.
Beyond the visible signs, give your starter a sniff. A healthy starter on Day 8 usually has a pleasant, tangy, slightly yeasty aroma. It shouldn't smell like nail polish remover, which can indicate it's hungry or needs a slightly different feeding ratio. The texture, when stirred, should be elastic and cohesive, not watery or separated.
So, when can you finally bake with it? While Day 7 is often cited as a general guideline, the real indicator is that consistent activity – regular doubling in size after feeding. Some people also do a 'float test': take a small spoonful of your active, bubbly starter and drop it into a glass of water. If it floats, it's generally considered ready to bake with! If it sinks, it might need another feed or two to build up more strength. I personally waited a bit longer than Day 7, just for that extra 'peace of mind,' as mentioned in the original post. It gave me confidence that my starter was robust and ready to tackle a loaf of bread.
A quick note on discard: By Day 8, you're likely generating a fair amount with each feeding. Remember the tip from my image: 'THROW DISCARD AWAY NOT DOWN THE KITCHEN SINK.' Sourdough discard, especially if it's still quite active, can easily clog pipes over time due to its sticky, dough-like consistency. Instead of tossing it, consider collecting it in a separate container in your fridge. Even if it's not quite strong enough for leavened bread, it's perfect for things like crackers, pancakes, or even quick breads that use baking soda as a leavener. This way, nothing goes to waste, and you avoid plumbing headaches!
Ultimately, patience is key. Your sourdough journey is unique, and observing your starter's behavior is the best way to understand its rhythms. Trust your senses – sight, smell, and even a little gentle stirring – to guide you. Happy baking!