Healthier Oreo Protein Shake

An Oreo protein shake that tastes similar to a milkshake but without all the calories and sugar! It's creamy, thick and packed with Oreo flavor. Try this for a healthier snack or dessert. This recipe makes one 16-18 ounce shake.

INGREDIENTS

3-4 Oreo sandwich cookies, plus more for garnish

1 scoop vanilla, chocolate, or unflavored protein powder I used Optimum Nutrition Vanilla Ice Cream Protein Powder

1/2 cup milk of choice (I used skim milk)

1/2 cup water or use more milk for a less foamy shake

5-6 ice cubes

Whipped cream (optional)

INSTRUCTIONS

Add all ingredients into a blender and blend at high speed for about 10 seconds. Blending the protein shake for too long will result in a foamy top layer.

Top with whipped cream and crushed Oreos. Enjoy!

Nutrition:

334 calories, 28.7 grams of protein, 35.5 grams of carbohydrates, 19.5 grams of total sugars

For more healthy recipes & nutrition for moms content, visit link in bio or:

www.moderatelymessyRD.com

#proteinsmoothierecipes #proteinshake #oreocookies #oreomilkshake

2025/8/1 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so you've tried the basic recipe for this amazing healthier Oreo protein shake, and I bet you're loving it! But let me tell you, there are so many ways to make this even better and perfectly customized to your taste and health goals. As someone who's always looking for delicious yet nutritious options, I've experimented quite a bit to truly elevate this healthy Oreo protein shake experience. First off, let's talk about why this 'healthier' version is such a game-changer compared to a traditional Oreo milkshake. We're cutting down significantly on sugar and unnecessary calories while boosting your protein intake – essential for feeling full, supporting muscle recovery, and managing weight. It’s a win-win! If you're curious about specific calorie comparisons, let me just say, this recipe dramatically slashes the numbers without sacrificing that indulgent taste. Think of it as your guilt-free dessert or a fantastic post-workout recovery drink. Now, for those who love to tweak recipes, here are some of my favorite tips and variations: For the Perfect Texture: You know how the recipe mentions not blending too long to avoid foam? That’s super important! I've found that using a high-speed blender for just 10-15 seconds gives you that ideal creamy, thick consistency without excess froth. If you prefer it even thicker, reduce the amount of water or use all milk (dairy or non-dairy like almond or oat milk work great!). For a thinner shake, just add a splash more liquid. And don't skimp on the ice cubes – they are key to that frosty, milkshake-like chill and body. I always serve mine in a tall glass with some extra ice cubes for that authentic 'cookies and cream protein shake glass' look and feel. Flavor Boosts & Variations: While the classic Oreo flavor is divine, sometimes I like to mix things up! Chocolate Lover's Dream: Instead of vanilla protein, try a chocolate protein powder for an even richer chocolate Oreo protein shake. You can also add a teaspoon of unsweetened cocoa powder. Peanut Butter Twist: Craving something extra? Add a tablespoon of natural peanut butter or almond butter. This makes it an 'oreo peanut butter milkshake' protein style! It adds healthy fats and even more protein, making it incredibly satisfying. Minty Fresh: A tiny drop of food-grade peppermint extract can transform this into a mint Oreo delight. Extra Creaminess: A quarter of a frozen banana or a few tablespoons of Greek yogurt can add extra creaminess and nutrients without overpowering the Oreo taste. Making it Even Healthier: If you want to reduce sugars even further, opt for sugar-free Oreo cookies or a similar sugar-free chocolate sandwich cookie. You can also use unsweetened almond milk and a naturally sweetened protein powder. The goal is to enjoy that incredible taste while being mindful of your dietary needs. Ultimately, this healthier Oreo protein shake is incredibly versatile. It's become my favorite way to enjoy a sweet treat without derailing my health goals. Give these tips and variations a try – I promise you won't be disappointed!

Related posts

High protein treats!
I've rounded up 20 of my favorite nourishing desserts that all packed at least 10grams of protein per serving! Now you really can have your cake and eat it too! 🤩 My FAVORITE clean ingredient protein powder from Just Ingredients brand is on sale now through March 2! Code colleenF10 saves
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

12.6K likes

Cookie Monster Protein Shake 🍪
Protein shake of the day 🙌🏻 Ingredients: - 2 Oreo cookies (110 cals) - 1-2 chips ahoy cookies (I used 3 minis which equals 1 regular size, 85 cals) - 40g nonfat plain yogurt (21 cal, 3.5g protein) - one scoop vanilla or cookies and cream protein powder ( mine has 135 cal per scoop, 32g protei
IvannaCarolina

IvannaCarolina

1315 likes

Cowboy Soup (healthier version)
Ingredients: • 1 lb extra-lean ground beef (95% lean) or ground turkey breast • 1 small onion, diced • 3 cloves garlic, minced • 1 can (14.5 oz) diced tomatoes, no salt added • 1 can (15 oz) tomato sauce, no salt added • 4 cups low-sodium
LaDonna Barr

LaDonna Barr

369 likes

Viral Protein Muffins 🧑‍🍳
Stole this recipe from @Jessica Barstow . Couldnt find the SF cake mix at my store, but these were delish for a “healthier” option & toddler approved. 😋 #proteinmuffins #muffinrecipe #fairlife #oikosproproteinyogurt @
S Y D N E Y 🤍

S Y D N E Y 🤍

1686 likes

Cherry Ice Cream - 20 gr protein 🍨
HEALTHIER CHERRY ICE CREAM (serves 1): 1 cup frozen cherries 1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt 1/4 cup cottage cheese 4 drops stevia (or 1-2 tsp raw honey or maple syrup), to taste See the link in my profile for recipes 🍨 @Lemon8 Food #holidayrecipe #highproteindessert #proteindessertrec
Zehra Hub Spot

Zehra Hub Spot

2310 likes

High Protein Oreo Pudding
I am obsessed with these high protein pudding desserts! I made a strawberry banana one last week & today I made this Oreo one. I got the recipe from the creator “trainwithshay” on TikTok. She posts a lot of healthy high protein recipes that actually taste like the real thing! ❤️ Mix 1 bottl
Megs 🖤🗡️📚

Megs 🖤🗡️📚

2994 likes

High Protein Oreo Cheesecakes
here is my version of the higher protein individual cheesecakes! The video is a double recipe. Original recipe from @ganjagwyn on tiktok I’m not saying this is healthy. This is a healthIER alternative with higher protein than a slice of cheesecake, and still tastes great. if you use the prem
alli✨

alli✨

92 likes

No bake protein cookies 🍪😋🍫✨Recipe!!
These are so delicious and fast to make!! If you are trying to eat healthier and consume more protein but have a sweet tooth, these are for you!! Ingredients listed on second slide 😊 #nobakerecipe #healthycookies #proteincookies #proteinsnacks #healthybreakfast #fastmeals #desse
Michelle 🤍

Michelle 🤍

3107 likes

Protein Oreo dessert✨
This stuff is my weakness but that’s okay because it’s helping me hit my goals! 42g of protein! Ingredients: 42g fairlife corepower protein (I use vanilla but chocolate will be good too) zero sugar vanilla pudding mix Zero sugar small tub of cool whip 4-5 Oreos Mix your protein shake and
Jess 🫧🦋

Jess 🫧🦋

632 likes

A classic made healthier! ✨
What if I told you this mac & cheese has 27 g of protein in a cup? And that’s without adding any meat, protein powder, etc. It’s creamy, cheesy, and so so easy, but is a healthier, nutrient dense option when you want your mac & cheese fixed. Perfect to bring to a summer cookout or just enjo
Jacklin

Jacklin

6401 likes

Healthier low cal dessert
Air fry a honeycrisp apple covered in cinnamon and honey at 350 for about 15 minutes (depending on the size) then add low cal high protein ice cream or vanilla Greek yogurt with some more honey and granola :)
AllenxSpeigner

AllenxSpeigner

2237 likes

A healthier summer treat✨
I whipped up these lightened up s’mores ice cream sandwiches and they’re so good! 🤩 They’re lower in sugar and higher in protein than a traditional ice cream sandwich, and they taste amaaaazing. Lower calorie and weight watchers friendly! Get the details below: Ingredients: * 6 Graham crackers,
Jacklin

Jacklin

5072 likes

Healthier Junk Food Swaps 🍪
I love some chips and cookies every so often but they always make me feel crappy… These are some common “junk food” snacks that I like to swap for a “healthier” alternative. I honestly love the alternative so much more than the original. My go to brands are usually Siete and Simple Mills
Jade Mesquita

Jade Mesquita

2797 likes

High protein chocolate muffins anyone?!🍫🙌🏻
You will need: •1 box of any sugar free cake mix (this works with brownie mix as well)✅ •any bottled protein shake✅ •any container of Greek yogurt✅ Combine all 3 ingredients together in a large mixing bowl and mix until smooth. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Place evenly in a cupcake dish. Bak
Kota💗

Kota💗

1334 likes

A hand dips a Chick-fil-A nugget into sauce, with a cup and nugget box in the background, illustrating "Chick-Fil-A Hacks for Weight Loss."
Displays four Chick-fil-A breakfast hacks for weight loss, including an Egg White Grill, Spicy Chicken Biscuit, Hash Brown Scramble Bowl, and Breakfast Protein, with calorie and protein information.
Features four Chick-fil-A entree favorites for weight loss, including Grilled Chicken Cool Wrap, Grilled Chicken Club, Chicken Sandwich, and Spicy Chicken Sandwich, with calorie and protein details.
Healthier chick fil-a orders 🍽️
#lemon8partner #chickfila #food #healthyfood #foodie
Amy Deschaine

Amy Deschaine

1142 likes

A blurred mirror selfie of a person in a black sports bra and blue shorts, with the text 'How To Control your DIET' and a dashed arrow pointing right.
An infographic titled '80/20 Rule For FAT LOSS' showing a weekly breakdown of food choices, illustrating how to maintain an 80% whole food intake with some treats.
A close-up of a meal featuring sliced steak, roasted green beans, and white rice, with the text 'PROTEIN CALORIES VEGGIES REPEAT' overlaid.
How to eat HEALTHIER (CHECK CAPTION)
Eating healthy can be hard. It takes a bunch of time and effort to push yourself to avoid sugars, fats, sodium, etc. I’m going to show you guys what I personally do to eat healthier and cleaner!. 80/20 RULE: As I went in my other post the 80/20 rule is really important, it allows you to eat heal
Alijah

Alijah

2301 likes

A store aisle displaying various high-protein snacks, including protein chips, cookies, muffins, and numerous protein shakes in different flavors and brands. Text overlays indicate "HIGH-PROTEIN SNACKS" and "Repeat buys."
A hand holding a 4-pack of cake batter flavored protein shakes, highlighting 30g protein, 160 calories, and 1g sugar per serving, with immune health support.
A hand holding a box of chocolate cake flavored frosted protein cookies, noting 5g protein and 1g net carbs per serving, described as soft baked and gluten-free.
High protein snacks ✨
Here’s a few of my tried and true high protein snack options… quest is really doing it the right way in my opinion I enjoy their shakes and the variety but also indulge in their cookies and bars for a “healthier” treat option when I’m trying to ward off sweet cravings 🌸 My 10 year old loves the
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

1208 likes

Morning Habits for a Healthier You in Your 40s ✨
A healthy morning routine in your 40s should focus on energy, mobility, hydration, and mental clarity while setting a strong foundation for the day. Here’s a well-balanced routine to help you thrive: 1. Wake Up Early (Consistently) • Aim for 7–9 hours of quality sleep and wake up at th
Ty 😍✨✌🏽

Ty 😍✨✌🏽

2350 likes

A shopping cart filled with groceries, including rice crisps, protein drinks, cranberry juice, chocolate chips, whipped topping, pudding mix, and fresh produce like pineapple. Overlay text highlights it as a snack for sweet cravings.
A close-up of ingredients for a sweet treat: a container of zero sugar whipped topping, a box of chocolate pudding mix, and a bag of semi-sweet chocolate morsels. Text notes the pudding mix is usually zero sugar and that more whipped topping makes it thicker.
A pink measuring cup filled with a chocolate-flavored creamy mixture, placed next to a clear container of fresh, sliced strawberries. The image is captioned "Perfect sweet treat!".
A healthier option!
For all my peeps trying to lose weight but have a sweet tooth like me! Here’s an easy and not super expensive option! #snacksforweightloss #foodideas #healthysnackidea #Lemon8Diary
E.B. Dugish✨

E.B. Dugish✨

3135 likes

Homemade Healthier Cotton Candy Ice Cream!
No artificial colors or refined sugars! This creamy homemade Ice cream is flavorful and gorgeous! Takes you right down memory lane! The first time I this I made it completely vegan! It can also be made with a mix of my original ingredients and cottage cheese for a protein rich treat! Recipe
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

2298 likes

A grocery store shelf displays various low-calorie and low-sugar sauces, including options like zero-calorie teriyaki, sesame ginger, and sweet chili. Many bottles are labeled gluten-free or organic, offering healthier choices for flavoring meals.
A hand holds a green bottle of KA'ME Zero Calorie Sesame Ginger Sauce & Marinade, highlighted for being low sodium and sugar-free, making it a healthier flavor option.
A hand holds an orange bottle of KA'ME Zero Calorie Sweet Chili Sauce & Marinade, noted for being low sodium and sugar-free, providing a healthier alternative for meal flavoring.
Healthier swaps for my sauce girlies
Low-calorie, low-sugar sauces are a healthier choice for flavoring meals without extra calories or sugar spikes. Unlike high-calorie sauces, they won’t add hidden fats or sugars to your plate, helping you stay on track with your goals. Look for options like salsa, vinegar-based dressings, or homema
Ava

Ava

736 likes

✨ Pillowy-Soft Healthier Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls
Made with pumpkin puree, Greek yogurt, and cozy spices! 🧡 Ingredients – Dough: • 2 ¾ cups all-purpose flour (or half white whole wheat) • 2 ¼ tsp instant yeast • ½ tsp salt • ½ tsp cinnamon • ¼ tsp nutmeg • ¼ cup coconut sugar (or brown
Maria | Dietitian | Mom of 3💚

Maria | Dietitian | Mom of 3💚

458 likes

A hand holds a glass bowl filled with a high-protein breakfast or snack, featuring creamy yogurt, chopped red strawberries, and crunchy granola, with a spoon inside. Text overlays read 'high PROTEIN BREAKFAST snack idea' and 'Lemon8'.
strawberry crunch protein snack
Easy protein snack for 🍓ON THE GO 🍓 - 4 tablespoons of Chobani Greek yogurt - add granola as desired - chop strawberries in pieces - THEN ENJOY :) Great snack for the girlies trying to eat healthier and or loose body fat while building muscle 💪🏻 #healthylifestyle2024 #healthysna
Emily

Emily

7643 likes

Healthier Ice-cream Picks
Craving ice cream but want a healthier option? These low calorie, high protein and dairy free choices lets you enjoy your sweet treat guilt free. Here are some of the best healthy ice-creams you can grab on your next grocery run. Halo Top (Low-Cal, High-Protein) Around 280-360 calories per pin
Beauty

Beauty

1788 likes

Healthier Starbucks order 🥰✨
I have been trying to come up with healthier Starbucks orders to help me from drinking my calories😂 I love Starbucks as much as the next girl but hate drinking over 500 cal in 1 cup, so I am on a mission to come up with several different healthy combos and try them so you don’t have too🥰❤️ #lowc
Chey Wynn

Chey Wynn

2263 likes

Healthy Fudgey Oreo Brownies- Only 71 Calories
These are a healthier Oreo cheesecake brownie that still has that Fudgy center! These come out to be about 71 calories per brownie!! They taste so good you wouldn’t even be able to tell that they are a healthier recipe! These are one of my healthy go-to desserts now! You can even add a spoonful of
Cookingwithhals

Cookingwithhals

97 likes

“Healthier” Snacks you maybe didn’t know about 😋
#snacksforweightloss #healthsnacks #snackingishealthy #snacksss #snacks are a must
jada🩵

jada🩵

970 likes

Healthier Alternatives for Sweets Cravings🍭🍦
Healthy Alternatives for Sugar Cravings (PMS Edition) Because the cravings are real—and we deserve sweet things that don’t wreck our progress. I’ve been hit with serious sweet tooth vibes lately (PMS, I see you), so I wanted to share the sugar-friendly finds I grabbed during my last grocery run
Anna🫶🏼

Anna🫶🏼

1346 likes

Healthy Oreo Protein Shake
This Oreo protein shake is thick, creamy, and tastes just like a milkshake – but it’s healthier! With just 5 simple ingredients, it’s a quick and delicious snack or treat with 28 grams of protein. As someone who doesn’t always love the taste of protein shakes – this might be my exception. WHY I
Alex, MS, RD | Nutrition

Alex, MS, RD | Nutrition

8 likes

Make a yummy protein shake w me!
If you’re anything like me, then you have a SWEET TOOTH. I have been working hard to eat healthier but every night I find myself CRAVING something sweet. Ice cream is a big weakness of mine, but i have found my saving grace!! This protein shake is SO yummy and it tastes like a peanut butter m
Kenedi <3

Kenedi <3

141 likes

Healthier snacks that actually taste good 🫶
I have many more recommendations but here are a few ! #snacksforweightloss #healthy #summerbod #fyp #bodytransformation United States California Southern California Huntington Beach Gold's Gym
funkho

funkho

1334 likes

Cookies & Cream Protein Shake
Creamy, indulgent, and packed with protein — a smooth vanilla base blended with crushed cookies for a dessert-style shake that supports recovery while satisfying sweet cravings. #quickrecipes #fyp #food #protein #healthy
FitBiteNutrition

FitBiteNutrition

370 likes

A bowl of high-protein chicken alfredo pasta, topped with sliced chicken and parsley, is presented on a wooden plate. Text overlays indicate it's a high-protein dish with 543 calories and 66g protein per serving.
Various ingredients for high-protein chicken alfredo are displayed on a dark surface, including chicken breast, Banza pasta, cottage cheese, parmesan, milk, garlic, parsley, and seasonings.
A raw chicken breast seasoned with cajun, paprika, garlic herb, pepper, garlic salt, and olive oil is shown in a white bowl, illustrating the first step of the recipe.
HIGH PROTEIN CHICKEN ALFREDO ⭐️
When dieting or trying to make healthier choices, it can be hard to balance foods you really enjoy while also maintaining a healthy diet that is high in protein and within your calorie intake, which is why I absolutely love this creamy chicken alfredo recipe! • some side notes I like to include
Denise Hamdan 🤍

Denise Hamdan 🤍

7728 likes

Protein Packed Oreo Cheesecake milkshake 💪🏼 ✨
Here is my recipe for a delicious protein Oreo cheesecake Milkshake. This is my fave go to when I’m craving something sweet, definitely worth a try ! 🥤🍰 Ingredients : Fairlife 2 % milk 1 cup Oreo Protein Powder 1 scoop Oikos triple zero yogurt 1 container Jello cheesecake mix 7 g #prote
Landon

Landon

319 likes

Healthier dessert ideas! 💌
#healthydessertideas #healthydessert #HelloLemon8 #embracevulnerability
McKenzii

McKenzii

61 likes

A layered protein shake in a clear plastic cup, featuring a light brown top layer, white creamy middle, and dark crumbly base. Overlaid text reads 'PEANUT BUTTER OREO PROTEIN SHAKE'.
Protein Shake
#herbalife #herbalifenutrition #peanutbutter #oreo #nutritionbythelake
Ashley Nicole

Ashley Nicole

185 likes

A blender container filled with frozen pineapple chunks and mixed berries, ready for a protein shake. Yellow text reads "A protein shake a day" and white text says "ON A #CALORIE DEFICIT," promoting a healthy, calorie-conscious routine.
Daily Protein Shake for Wellness 🍓🍍
Building healthy habits doesn’t have to be complicated. Each morning, I kickstart my day with a quick protein shake packed with fruits and nutrients! 🍓🍍🍇 This small, daily ritual is part of my wellness journey, keeping me energized and on track. ✨ What I Use: A handful of frozen berries, pineapp
branDi.

branDi.

16 likes

27g protein chips and dip alternative
Let me put yall on be cause this combo is 🔥 Ive lost 39 pounds by finding healthier alternatives for food i eat Im a girl that loves a crunchy savory snack But my days of eating half a bag of lays in one sitting are over The amount of protein in this snack leaves me feeling full and satisf
Alli 🐊

Alli 🐊

662 likes

Healthier Peanut Butter Pie!!
High protein, gluten free, refined sugar free, velvety smooth peanut butter pie!! With homemade dark chocolate peanut butter cups to top 🤌🏻 This creamy desert will satisfy all your sweet tooth cravings, without the heavy feeling after! #peanutbutter #proteindessert #peanutbutterpie #he
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

32 likes

Lower carb higher protien healthier crab cakes 🦀
Makes 3 serving 2 crab cakes per serving! 58 grams of protein for just the crab cake serving 71 with the sauce 🥰 For the sauce i mix nonfat plain greek yogurt Mustard pickle juice Hotsauce Lemonjuice Dill Salt/ pepper ****while these are lower carb than traditional crab cakes these a
Alli 🐊

Alli 🐊

3631 likes

An overhead view of multiple clear meal prep containers filled with alternating portions of cubed cheese and sliced pepperoni, with text overlay about healthier lifestyle staples.
An image showcasing Boar's Head Sweet Chili Garlic Hummus, Quaker Lightly Salted Rice Cakes, and Publix Reduced Fat Wheat Snacks, suggesting hummus as a dip or spread.
Three bottles of salad dressing: Bolthouse Farms Classic Ranch, Bolthouse Farms Creamy Caesar Yogurt Dressing, and Marzetti Simply Creamy Caesar Dressing, labeled as go-to options.
Healthier lifestyle grocery list must haves 🤩
These are all my must have can't live without staples in my house. A big part of eating healthier is finding healthy alternatives that don't leave you just craving the real thing. Finding things that have good nutrition labels is a game changer! I never feel guilty about snacking because I&
Jess | Eat What You Crave

Jess | Eat What You Crave

697 likes

High Protein Oreo Fluff
I’m actually obsessed with this dessert and will be making different variations of it, so please give me topping ideas! I’m thinking berries or nut butters?! I’ve seen people use cool whip to make “healthier” desserts before, but this recipe was inspired by @Emmabfitnhealthy My sweet toot
Gracey

Gracey

361 likes

Healthier Caramel Filled Klondike Bars!
Homemade Klondike bars! Gluten free, refined sugar free, and with a protein boost! The Ice cream itself is incredibly smooth & creamy, with a gooey yet wholesome caramel filling, perfectly complimented with a rich, dark chocolate coating 🤌🏻 Recipe in bio! You absolutely won't regret add
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

1494 likes

High Protein Snack Ideas (build muscle!) 💪🏼💗
Here are some of my FAV go to protein finds at Target (but I am sure you can find the same or similar at your grocery store too). ‼️ Eating a decent amount of protein each day is important for muscle growth, fat loss and overall wellness. But I am not going to lie, it can be tricky to get enough
carlyroese

carlyroese

1646 likes

See more